Sadly this book was a disappointment for me. I have to start by saying that I loved the first book and was eager to continue this story. I also want to say that the writing is very good, without a doubt the author knows her ways around words. My problem is with the story itself, with the rhythm it has and how it completely departs from the previous book.
I knew that the story had to take a different turn after the end of the previous book and that this part would have more Valentine's views to discover his side of the story. And here my problems begin.
I liked that Valentine's story was different from what was expected and not just a boy who always lived in the system, that part seemed interesting to me. My biggest problem is the justification for the initial behavior of him towards Nova, for me it has neither weight, nor sense and it feels forced. The expectation that it reminded him of someone was fine, it was the connection itself, it seemed weak and far-fetched. Like forcing him to connect it with Nova. I think that something simpler here would have been more justified (we already knew that Nova didn't act in the best way at times).
To continue with Valentine's line, another thing that I didn't like is that his character simply seems different, obviously I didn't expect his behavior to be the same for Nova after what happened but since we never had even glimpses of the "real" him in the previous book this radical change in his personality unsettled me. I expected more of a sweet and sassy mix but for me it was just boring and a little lam. I was just thinking "Ok, crawl but mischievously" since that was part of his charm in the last book.
I also liked that they put scenes from the last book from his point of view but these didn't meet my expectations either, I prefert the mystery from Nova's point of view (I don't know if this was, as I said, because his actions seemed hardly justifiable or if they just picked the wrong scenes that allowed to see more of him )
On the other hand, although I appreciate the direction that the author decided to give Nova in treating her condition so seriously and showing us her way with therapy, it seemed to me, I don't know how to put it, perhaps too overexplained? I don't know. At a certain point the first book gave me the impression of being more NA (even though his characters were still in high school) and this feels VERY YA. Which in itself is not a bad thing but I come back to the same thing that it just seem like two totally different stories.
Now focusing on the story, as I said, I was simply not convinced. To start the times slots, everything feels a lot for the time that passed, when the characters say that only 2 weeks have passed since Valentine arrived and without having really seen why there have such strong feelings (not only between Valentine and Nova, also from Valentine and his foster family) I just don't buy it. But well, since you are there, take the opportunity to show me or build that, but not the story take twists and turns in other things that don't build any of the relationships (or at least not deeply).
And don't make me talk about "the mystery of who did that to Nova". This wouldn't have bothered me if they wouldn't have given it so much importance. That is to say, discovering who this person was was everything to Valentine, it was his way of making Nova forgive him as well as his friends and redeem his name. And when they brought it up over and over and over again I started to say "Well, it better be good. Let it be the super revelation, let it be a huge plot-twist . It has to be worth it." And even though since it happened I was clear who it had been, with so much expectation I began to doubt and even wished it was someone unimaginable like Nova's Brother wanting to make her reaction or something. But obviously that didn't happen and it was the only person who could be and so much drama about it seemed like a waste of time.
Since I mentioned Nova's brother, something I had enjoyed in the first book was her relationship whit him and whit the other scions, but in this book it was to much. Don't get me wrong, I still think that Nova's relationship with his whole family is wonderful, but I feel like they over-saturated me and although it's nice to wish having that at a certain point, it seemed unreal to me.
The end felt very lazy for me, after Valentine said over and over again that he needed Nova back he leave and months go by without them seeing each other and that she has to forgive him again when he decides to return (because she looks for him in the first place, I should be said) it was already a lot for a relationship that felt so weak. At this point I didn't understand the fasination of one with the other more than physical attraction and the idealization of the other person in their heads, because to be honest there was no time for them to really get to know each other.
I think I would give the stories of the other characters a chance when their books come out but I don't have high expectations about it.