Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read.
Start by marking “Candy Hearts (So Over the Holidays, #2)” as Want to Read:
Candy Hearts (So Over the Holidays, #2)
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating
Open Preview

Candy Hearts

(So Over the Holidays #2)

4.08  ·  Rating details ·  396 ratings  ·  148 reviews
Mechanic Benji Holiday is so over Valentine’s Day and men who don’t get him. A weekend getaway with friends to escape the holiday hubbub is exactly what he needs. But William O’Dare—a stern and silent nightclub owner with “Be My Valentine” practically stamped on his forehead—throws a wrench into Benji’s plans.

William has spent years focused on his career, and it has cost h
Kindle Edition, 1st edition, 209 pages
Published February 3rd 2020 by Erin McLellan
More Details... Edit Details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Reader Q&A

To ask other readers questions about Candy Hearts, please sign up.

Be the first to ask a question about Candy Hearts

Community Reviews

Showing 1-30
Average rating 4.08  · 
Rating details
 ·  396 ratings  ·  148 reviews

More filters
Sort order
Start your review of Candy Hearts (So Over the Holidays, #2)
On hold.

Never a good sign when a book’s been on your ‘currently reading’ shelf and you’re just not interested in going back to it.

(I’m a bit grumpy atm-nothing is doing much for me)
Heather K (dentist in my spare time)
*2.5 stars*

I don't know what it is about this series, but I am not digging them, though I would think they would be right up my alley.

Who doesn't love a good opposites attract story, plus lingerie?! I SHOULD have loved this, but, alas, it was a bit slow and hard for me to get through.

I thought the fake Valentine's thing was cute, and I enjoyed the sex positive message, but I thought the romance got a bit lost with all of the side characters. It started off strong and then got muddled part way
Feb 02, 2020 rated it really liked it
That was very cute.

I liked the humour, the incredibly sexy encounters, the emotional highs and lows and the friendship bonds between a group of disparate characters who've occasionally lost their way in recent years.

The fake Valentine's angle was fun, the close proximity plotline worked well to advance the narrative and I loved the way both Benji and William got over their fears together.

It was short but still managed to feel like a complete story.

#ARC kindly received from the author in return f
michaela ⚘
Jan 14, 2020 rated it really liked it
Shelves: 2020, arc, hot, m-m, holiday-rm
Benji is over Valentine’s Day and is content to just let it pass on by but an invite from his sister to be it with some friends may be exactly what he needs. What he doesn’t expect is William -- a silent, stern workaholic who may just be everything Benji is looking for. But, is Benji what William is looking for?

Everything about Candy Hearts was scorching hot. The chemistry between the two MCs outside and inside the bedroom was another level of steamy -- especially when the satin, lace and sexy t
Jess Gabriel
I. LOVED. THIS. BOOK. These characters were so well developed, especially for a novella. I loved that Benji was a large, muscled man (not a twink) that secretly loved lingerie. It really added another layer of sexiness to the story. The author really went for it with the sex (Thank you, Erin!) and these guys had INSANE chemistry. Most of all, the intimacy and tenderness that they found in each other within the snark and banter was just perfect.

This definitely goes right on my re-readable shelf.
Mar 19, 2020 rated it really liked it
Shelves: lgbtqiap, 2020
Back in December I was absolutely obsessed with Stocking Stuffers, the first book in this holiday romance novella series. I just assumed that the rest of the books would be Christmas themed as well and I wasn’t expecting another one until next winter. So I was super surprised when I just realized that a Valentine’s Day novella was released last month.

This story follows Benji, the brother of Sasha from the first novella, as he accidentally shows up to William’s Valentine’s Day party a day early.
True Loveislovereview
Feb 10, 2020 rated it really liked it
Shelves: 2020, lgbtq
Fasten your seatbelts and let Benji’s charms pull you in. His sweet candy smell and unfiltered mouth.

A party to escape all Valentine's fuss, that's where Benji was going, he ended up in a big dark house with a sweet man.
William is, at first sight, a bit of a grumpy professor, buried in paperwork and books. Owner of more than one nightclub, he is a rich and busy man.
But when he becomes enthralled by Benji, a mechanic, and when he gets to know what Benji has under his clothes, William is very atte
DNF 69%. I got bored. I wasn't really into the man-lingerie or armpit sex. Both William and Benji seemed like interesting characters, but the plot was getting kind of boring for me. Maybe I'll pick up on this one day, but I'm really dying to move on to more interesting books. ...more
Jan 29, 2020 rated it really liked it
Erin McLellan keeps delighting me with these queer holiday romance novellas. Candy Hearts is perfect for those who maybe kind of hate to love Valentine's Day but would absolutely embrace it with their own sexy "fake Valentine" like Benji and William. I loved the stuck together in a power outage situation that brought our two lovers together, as well as the found family celebration. Benji's love of lingerie is also very endearing and used to great sexy effect.

I learned a new sex move term and als
Joyfully Jay
Feb 03, 2020 rated it really liked it
Shelves: jay
A Joyfully Jay review.

4.25 stars

First off, let’s be clear. There is a whole lot of sex in this story. I’m going to go with “sex romp” to describe it. The guys spend a lot of time in bed sexing it up, including playing with toys and enjoying Benji’s sexy lingerie. So expect a lot of heat and intensity, but with a nice, playful side.

What I think makes this story work so well, however, is that there is more to it than just the heat. We have William, a man who is successful but lonely, and who is f
Roberta Blablanski
Hot guys in lacy underthings is my kryptonite, and Candy Hearts slayed me.

Benji is a buff mechanic who likes to wear delicate lingerie. William is uptight and career-focused.

These two are HOTT together once William warms up to Benji. After that, it's fire everywhere. Which is a good thing because they are stuck without power in the middle of winter. The ways they find to stay warm and cozy will make you sweat.

I also enjoyed the cast of friends (including Sasha, Benji's sister, from Stocking Stu
4 1/2 STARS! Quick and dirty V-Day fun. Lingerie, candy, toys, and stormed-in? Yes, please!
Jan 08, 2020 rated it really liked it
Thanks to the author and publisher for granting me a complimentary copy via A Novel Take for an honest review.

I love the concept of this series. With all the couples around, who isn't so over these holidays that make a person who's single feel inadequate?

Benji is a real mixture of contrasts. I liked that he was a big strong fully capable mechanic, but had a softer side. William, with his workaholic tendencies is also adorable in his insecurities about being in the dating world again.

I really l
Loved this one! Full review to come.

I received an e-ARC of Candy Hearts by Erin McLellan in exchange for an honest review.

I read the first book in this series, Stocking Stuffers, and loved it so I was super excited for the chance to review this book. I have been in a bit of a reading slump and haven’t been able to handle more than quick novellas. This hot, sexy novella was just what I needed.

This is the story of Benji, the young mechanic with a love for lingerie, and William, the older workaholi
Alex (HEABookNerd)
Series: So Over the Holidays #2
Rating: 4 stars - really enjoyable

One Sentence Summary: Benji Holiday is done with changing himself for the men he dates, so when William O’Dare accepts every part of Benji, he worries it's too perfect to be true.

CANDY HEARTS was a really cute story about two people who have struggled with the relationships in their life, both friends and lovers. Enjoying a weekend as secret Valentines is what each of them are looking for but neither expects it to become more. Wi
Nadine Bookaholic
This was a HOT quick read that I devoured in one afternoon! I Loved Benji and his love for lacy, silky, sexy undergarments as well as sex toys, and he was the perfect opposite of William which made things so interesting. William is a total workaholic and he's finally realized that he's at a place in his life where he feels comfortable enough to step back a bit from his business and start dating, what he doesn't expect is for the perfect person to knock on his door during a power outage.

Read my f
Jessica Alcazar
I've had a MONDAY so I'm gonna tell you guys about this book tomorrow but go #oneclick now if you like ;)

Clearly, I am enthusiastic about this story LOL It’s not the next Great American Novel but it’s not supposed to be. It is exactly what it is supposed to be. A little escape for a reader. It’s not unrealistic but it is definitely fiction LOL I loved the cuteness that surrounded the story at all time. It is 100% sexually driven and *fans self* I enjoyed that very very much! And believe it or no
Barb ~rede-2-read~
I loved this story! First and foremost: manties! And then, wham! The story was even better than the manties. I loved Benji, the big good-looking auto mechanic with the penchant so feminine undergarments, and William, the successful business man with his list of qualifications for the perfect man, a list that turns out to be a carbon copy of his own assets.

But opposites attract, and a little boost from the Valentine spirit made this story just great. If I had any complaint at all, it would be th
I highlighted the holy heck out of this freaking amazing book.

Eloquent, I know, but damn. Erin McLellan's Candy Hearts sent me into a sugar high with how much I loved it! My recommendation? Read it.

I can be more than one thing.

Benji never receives the call that the V-Day party has been postponed, so he finds himself standing in front of a stranger's house greeting the hot as hell, bespectacled, older man of the house in question with no electricity, Benji's lack of filter, and a hot and heavy at
Sexy and good. My only concern is I don't have the warmest feelings towards the heroine of the first book after reading it? It's strange how reading order can really matter sometimes. (My issue is less the very mean thing she said to the person whose home she was in, and more the setting her brother up. That's rude, don't do that.) Will definitely pick up the other two books at some point, though. ...more
Jenn (not Lily)
Feb 10, 2020 rated it really liked it
Shelves: ku
Very fun, with some great sexy times and also a little bit of heartwarming tenderness. I'll be putting the first of the series onto my TBR and looking forward to book three this summer! ...more
Mar 13, 2020 rated it really liked it
This was cute and sweet with pretty much no angst. I liked the two MCs quite a bit and the secondary characters were interesting as well.
*Received A Copy To Review From The Author*

Loved this one so much! It's freaking adorable and will just make you happy. The way this romance developed over basically a weekend was actually believable and works. It doesn't feel rushed or shallow. There's still depth in the connection forged. The circle of friends was fun. I normally am not a "Grand Gesture" person, but I think this one is respectable because it's kind of more about self celebration and Benji owning and being okay with who he is a
Victoria (Eve's Alexandria)
2nd read - April 2020
I am doing a lot of rereading at the moment, seeking out soft and comfy places to spend time. I wasn't sure how this would hold up a second time but it surprised me and I'd probably bump my rating to 5 stars now. It showcases stellar communication and consent between the MCs in a caring, natural way, and walks a perfect line between soft and silly and mad sexy. If you want something quick, sweet and dirty, this is a lovely retreat.

1st read - February 2020
An extremely sweet
Christina Wade - BFD Book Blog
Full disclosure time…I signed up to read this book because I wanted a light, fluffy, sexy read after reading something heavy. I’ve never read anything by this author, so I went in a bit blind but figured I was safe with a novella. I didn’t read book one for a couple of reasons: 1) I only read MF books from trusted authors and 2) I’ve had bad luck with stories involving characters who sell sex toys. After reading this book, I’m considering going back to read it as well as the next book when it co ...more
Ruthie Taylor
Feb 01, 2020 rated it really liked it
~~I received a free copy of this book to read and review for Wicked Reads ~~

This is the second book in the series, and whilst you could read it as a standalone, Stocking Stuffers is a lot of fun and introduces us to Benji's sister Sasha. We get to meet her and Perry again here, which is fun.

There is a lot of fun, sex and some home truths being dished out in the anti-Valentine's party weekend. William has finally stood back from his workaholic life to host the weekend with his dearest friends,
Feb 02, 2020 rated it it was amazing
Shelves: blog
Sweet but oh so hot!

Candy Hearts is the first book I've read by Erin McLellan and what a great introduction to her writing. This book was all kinds of steamy, sexy, hot and yet really sweet. Both Benji and William have confidence problems and neither of them is really looking for a relationship.

Benji is a really great character (so is William) and I love all of his quirks and how unapologetic he is about what he likes. While he's kept his love of naughty lingerie mostly to himself, he opens up t
Leigh Kramer
This was such a fun Valentine’s Day novella! There’s a great found family element with a group of friends who gather for a house party every Valentine’s Day. This time around, Benji’s sister invites him to attend, only she forgets to let him know about a power outage that means everyone else is arriving a day later. Cue awkward meet-cute when he arrives at William’s house and no one else is there!

I adored these two together. William is a great buttoned up hero who has been so consumed with work
Benji is over with dating guys. Despite his “manly” job as a mechanic, despite his size as a big guy, Benji is a romantic at heart, and romance doesn’t like him, so Benji decides to quit love. He agrees to join his sisters and their friends for a holiday escape in the cabin of a friend of them William.
Candy Heart by Erin McLellan is my first book by this author. I loved it, I really loved it.
Benji is a big guy with a “manly” job who inside is a real sweetheart. Benji also has little secrets, thi
Feb 01, 2020 rated it it was amazing
Shelves: fantastic, lgbtq
Fake valentines. Secret kinky fake valentines! I had a lot of fun reading Candy Hearts. Benji and William are both men with a stretch of bad relationships. Benji is tired of faking, and so done with pretending to be someone else for the sake of his boyfriends. But with William he doesn't have to. William accepts him.

William and Benji are smoking hot together. And the chemistry is off the charts. Benji is so amazing! A big strong mechanic who loves lingerie? A study in contrast! William and Benji
« previous 1 3 4 5 next »
There are no discussion topics on this book yet. Be the first to start one »

Readers also enjoyed

  • The Naughty List
  • Work-Love Balance (Out & About, #1)
  • Daddy Crush
  • Boyfriend With Benefits
  • The Traitor and the Fighter (Seeking Asylum, #2)
  • A Husband for Santa
  • My Dad's Best Friend (A Touch of Taboo #3)
  • Lights, Camera, Christmas!
  • He's Come Undone: A Romance Anthology
  • Honeymoon Sweet (Out & About, #2)
  • The Alpha's Warlock (Mismatched Mates #1)
  • Daiquiris and Dreams (Hearts of Snow Lake, #7)
  • The One Decent Thing
  • His Beauty
  • Feel My Pain
  • A Kaleidoscope of Butterflies
  • Snowfall and Romance
  • Liberating Love (Interlocking Fragments, #3)
See similar books…
Erin McLellan is the author of the Farm College, So Over the Holidays, and Storm Chasers series. She enjoys writing happily ever afters that are earthy, emotional, quirky, humorous, and very sexy. Originally from Oklahoma, she currently lives in Alaska and spends her time dreaming up queer contemporary romances. She is a lover of chocolate, college sports, antiquing, Dr Pepper, and binge-worthy TV ...more

Other books in the series

So Over the Holidays (4 books)
  • Stocking Stuffers (So Over the Holidays, #1)
  • Bottle Rocket (So Over the Holidays #3)
  • Party Favors (So Over the Holidays #4)

News & Interviews

The idea for The Gilded Ones came to author Namina Forna in a dream. The recurring image was one of a young girl in armor walking up a...
76 likes · 7 comments
“I think your house is haunted. By sex fairies. Or horny little cupids. There’s no reason it should be this good.” 0 likes
“Please date me for real, Benji. I like you like you. Stay with me. Give me sunshine and excitement and unexpected laughter and you. Give me you.” 0 likes
More quotes…