Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read.
Start by marking “Tales of the Madman Underground” as Want to Read:
Tales of the Madman Underground
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating
Open Preview

Tales of the Madman Underground

3.94  ·  Rating details ·  3,250 ratings  ·  399 reviews
Wednesday, September 5, 1973: The first day of Karl Shoemaker's senior year in stifling Lightsburg, Ohio. For years, Karl's been part of what he calls "the Madman Underground" - a group of kids forced (for no apparent reason) to attend group therapy during school hours. Karl has decided that senior year is going to be different. He is going to get out of the Madman Undergr ...more
Hardcover, 532 pages
Published June 25th 2009 by Viking Books for Young Readers
More Details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Community Reviews

Showing 1-30
3.94  · 
Rating details
 ·  3,250 ratings  ·  399 reviews

More filters
Sort order
Dec 29, 2011 rated it really liked it
Recommends it for: fans of "Spectacular Now," "Sorta Like a Rockstar," Gary D. Schmidt
Recommended to Tatiana by: Thomas Tomato
Shelves: ya, 2012, printz
As seen on The Readventurer

At first, this books is hilarious, then it is sad, heartbreaking and scary and later it is inspiring. To think of it, my favorite kind of book.

Karl Shoemaker is determined to start his senior of high school being completely "normal." After spending years in mandatory group therapy with other madmen (abused, traumatized and plain crazy kids) after a disturbing rabbit killing incident, Karl for once wants to separate himself from the mad group and be a part of the "norm
Emily May
Jan 17, 2012 rated it really liked it
Recommended to Emily May by: Tatiana
Shelves: 2012, young-adult

This book is a real melting pot of emotions. It reminded me very much of another favourite of mine - Sorta Like a Rock Star - in the way it created such a detailed, sad and often amusing picture of a teenager's life and how it pretty much just sucks a lot of the time.

I like teen problem novels that know how to be funny but still make the desired emotional impact as well. Karl Shoemaker lives with his alcoholic mother who steals his hard-earned money and sometimes even locks him out of the house
Have you ever watched the show How I Met Your Mother? The show features Ted, a hopeless romantic, as he is telling his teenage kids the story of how he met their mother. Cute, right? Only he tells his kids the entire story, starting with the moment when he realized that he was looking for a long-term relationship, marriage and kids. So we, the viewers, follow Ted's stories of dating woes, drinking with his friends and all of the fun shenanigan's which follow. Because, as Ted puts it, all of his ...more
Katie Fitzgerald
It has been three days since I finished the last chapter of Tales of the Madman Underground, and I am still thinking about Karl Shoemaker. Honest, humorous, foul-mouthed, masculine, resourceful, and wounded, Karl is definitely the kind of protagonist you want to spend 500 pages with, and whose plights you sympathize with so greatly, you honestly lose yourself in the book, and in the five days during September 1973 that is the backdrop of his story.

Karl's father, the former mayor of their hometo
4.5 I could say that not a whole lot of plot happens in this book. I could say it's too long and that at times it veered toward After School Special--albeit with no language censor--territory. I could say that no teenager has ever been able to verbally express themselves like the kids do in this book. But none of that would matter in the end because any bumps in the road are completely obliterated by the sheer charismatic force of the protagonist. Karl Shoemaker won me over pretty quickly just b ...more
Mar 25, 2011 rated it really liked it
This is Karl's story, summed up in one week that might be the turning point for him. Since his father died of cancer, his mother has turned into a paranoid alcoholic that hoards cats and steals Karl's money to buy drugs. The Madman Underground of the title is his therapy group at school, a group of kids at least as messed up as he is who make up his friends and only real support group.

This is quite a chunk of a book (530 pages in hardcover). The one thing that keeps it going is Karl's voice. He
High Plains Library District
Jan 10, 2015 rated it it was amazing
Shelves: teen, meagan
Sometimes I pick up a book out of some misplaced sense of obligation, and I don’t think I’m alone in that. Books make their way onto my reading list because they’re being named “important,” or winning awards, or landing on Best of the Year lists. (I’m especially prone to this around the end of the year, when I realize how few of the “IT” books of the year I've read.) Usually these books don’t sound particularly appealing to me, and usually I give myself permission to try them and abandon them if ...more
Jennifer Wardrip
Reviewed by Dianna Geers for

Karl has a plan for his senior year. It's to be normal. Or at least to appear to be normal. Forever he has been known as slightly crazy and a target of harassment.

There are a ton of obstacles that will make it difficult to pull of the "normal" appearance. First of all, he has to avoid his very best friend in the world. Not to mention the fact that he has to work endless hours to help support his mother and himself. (She has been off the deep end ever
Oct 01, 2009 rated it it was amazing
Shelves: young-adult
Tired of his affiliation with the madmen, a group of students bound together during the school year by their shared visits to the school psychologist, Karl Shoemaker starts his senior year by deploying operation “be f***ing normal.” Yet try as he may to break from the madmen and distance himself from their shared injustices, he is just too good of a friend. He also can’t escape his own rap as possibly psychopathic, after a misunderstanding involving the death of one or more cats. Told over six d ...more
Andrew Hicks
Jul 17, 2014 rated it it was amazing
Shelves: ya, favorites
I read Tales of the Madman Underground during a Printz Award alumni binge that included Kit’s Wilderness, American Born Chinese and In Darkness. Madman was possibly the wordiest YA novel I’ve read so far, but I never tired of it. Madman is set in small-town Ohio in 1973, and it’s the first YA I’ve read that was structured as a few sequential days in the everyday life of the protagonist, wake to sleep. Five days of home, work, school and social life at the very start of protag Karl Shoema ...more
Stuti (Turmeric isn't your friend. It will fly your ship


This book is everything I wanted the perks of being a wallflower to be. Now, I won't go on and make any comparisons lest I soil my good mood.

Tales of the Madman Underground is less of a book and more like a potpourri of emotions and feelings, ranging from those rare stolen moments of happiness to sweet-as-coffee-bitterness to black-hole-in-my-gut-horror and disgust. And performing the role of quintessential salt was constant sadness, even till the very end when all things finally come togethe
Jan 19, 2010 rated it really liked it
Recommends it for: everyone NC17
When asked if the Madmen protect each other, Karl replies: "No. Usually we can't do a f**king thing for each other, come to admit it. We're a little group of mental-case high school students, not the f**kin' X-Men, you know? But we know each other's stories, and we do try to watch each other's backs, when we can."

I was 200 pages in before I noticed the writing was a bit shaky and at that point I couldn't care less. The narrative voice is like a magnet- it pulls hard and makes an immediate connec
Sep 25, 2010 rated it it was amazing
Shelves: ya
I wasn't crazy about the end of this book, but overall I loved it. If I had been on the Printz committe, I think I would have been backing this, although it would have been a tough fight between this and Going Bovine.

Favorite passage, page 354:

She opened the waffle iron up and dumped out two perfect waffles. "How do you know when they're ready?" I asked.

She grinned. "Ancient secret, Tiger Sweetie. You get married very young. You get a waffle iron as a wedding present and you have a husband that
Oct 28, 2009 rated it really liked it
Karl Shoemaker has "gotten a ticket" every year since middle school--an invitation he can't refuse--to take part in a therapy group for kids who are disturbed, maltreated at home, or just plain weird. For his 1973 senior year, Karl just wants to try to be normal even though he works five jobs and has to hide his earnings all over the house so his inattentive barfly, UFO conspiracy fan, "super, super lady" mother doesn't steal yet another one. He just wants to try to be normal even though his mot ...more
Jan 18, 2010 rated it it was amazing
This is a book that I added to my TBR list solely based on the fact that it was a Printz Honor book. It sounded interesting enough, and it gets consistently high marks on GoodReads, but for some reason I went into it giving myself an exit. Fifty pages, I said, and then I could quit. I'll have given it a shot, and that's all I can ask for.

Stupid me. I loved this book. The characters and their situations sucked me in so thoroughly that at one point I was so afraid of how I might react to a charact
ugh. i couldn't handle the tone of this book. it was all "awww shucks" cheese-o-riffic and full of dopey jokes and gratuitous cursing. (you wouldn't think the two would mesh well, right? right. they don't.) the characters were always saying corny things to each other that i can't imagine coming out of *any* teen's mouth, 1970s or not. i couldn't keep any of the characters straight, in fact, because they all talked EXACTLY THE SAME.

moreover, it was pompously, ludicrously, ridiculously, egotistic
Pei Pei
Apr 21, 2010 rated it it was ok
I love Huck Finn. I love Catcher in the Rye. I understand the inspiration. However, both those novels are amazingly slim and yet pack enormous punch. They move at lightning speed, no wasted words. Unfortunately, the same cannot be said for this bloated, derivative novel in which nothing really happens and characters spew more pointless and expository dialogue than would be permitted in a college writing workshop. Maybe even a high school writing workshop.

Two stars because it was occasionally fu
Jun 16, 2009 rated it really liked it
This is a truly great guy book, and what King Dork strove to be. But it succeeds. And, I can say this despite the fact that multiple cats die. It's truly funny, truly male, and not made irrelevant by its 1970s setting. It also reads faster than it looks. Plenty of sex and bad language if you're squeamish, but, well it's coming from the brain of a 17 year old boy. Delightful!

As long as I'm causing trouble, maybe I should also say it's the book that Staying Fat for Sarah Byrnes tried to be? With
Jan 31, 2016 rated it it was amazing
Shelves: favorites, read-2016
Wow, this book has so much packed into it. And somehow I loved all of it...? Yeah, wow.

This is the type of YA contemporary I actually like. It's gritty, raw, honest, and makes you feel every feeling the author wants you to feel. John Barnes is a magician. Enough said.
May 02, 2012 rated it liked it
I think my cat read this b/c after I finished it she threw up on my bed. Charming.
May 14, 2019 rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
What can I say? Something about teenage problem stories just gets to me. I generally enjoy this type of narrative tone which is just very blunt and honest and appropriate for teenagers. Tales of the Madmen Underground delivers this tone with just the right kind and amount of humour which just made it more intriguing and relatable. I liked how the book was set in Ohio in the 70s because it felt like a rather unusual setting for such a story but only the story only benefitted from it.
However, I do
LA Ayers
Sep 03, 2018 rated it did not like it
Shelves: dnf
DNF at page 68

This book is fucking awful. I'm not even sure what it's supposed to be about, other than the little shit who's the protagonist that I want to shove off a cliff. If you're into whiney, self-absorbed, piggish, sociopathic douchewad teenagers, then you'll love this.

I was bored to tears. What the hell was supposed to be happening!? And it's so edgy because every other word is "fuck." Don't get me wrong, I think "fuck" is a great word, but you could probably shave off 100 pages if you o
Kate Stericker
This book has a lot of compelling detail and unconventional plotlines that are easy to get engaged in; I particularly enjoyed the way the unexpectedly hopeful ending brought so many elements together. However, I'm not convinced that this story needed to be told over 532 pages. On the whole, I feel "Tales of the Madman Underground" was well worth the time it took to read, but it wouldn't hurt if that time had been a little shorter.

(The author is also prone to using slurs like 'r*tard' and making
Mar 13, 2019 rated it really liked it
Man, I loved this book!! I wish I could give it a 5-star review, but cussing and inappropriate language were everywhere. Even so, I fell in love with the characters. The writing was great. Great read on human character and community. Makes me think about what love really looks like. How would I respond to situations like this? How would Jesus? Why is the Church always painted as full of hypocrites who lie through their smiles?
Really interesting.

Funny, witty, brash, awkward, touching, sad, bemusing -- quite apart from having the best title ever, Tales of the Madman Underground runs rings around any preconceptions I might have had of what it was going to be. I'm all for snarky heroes, and Karl Shoemaker is probably the most authentic snark I've come across; there's nothing pretentious about him, he's refreshingly honest and probably the most chatty narrator in the world.

It wasn't an easy story. Underneath the running current of self-dep
Ruth Ann
I absolutely love Karl Shoemaker's honest, youthful, brave, foul-mouthed, caring voice.
From laughter to tears, this book takes us through Karl's first six days of senior year high school, this tale of fierce friendship in 1973. Much more interesting than any days of my senior year!
Karl's dad was the mayor of Lightsburg, OH and there's a street in town named for the family. Karl's mother is a widow, an alcoholic who steals Karl's hard earned money to drink not only at home, but in local bars so s
Oct 02, 2012 rated it it was amazing
When I finished this book and closed the cover, I felt like I was saying goodbye to a really good friend. Karl Shoemaker is the friend everyone should be lucky enough to have at least once in a lifetime. He's brave, sensitive, tough, hard, soft, gentle, firm, honest and kind. He's got a complicated life for sure and he does his best to be everything he can for everyone he loves. He attends in-school therapy with a bunch that call themselves the "Madmen Underground." He has a great bunch of quirk ...more
Jul 19, 2012 rated it did not like it
Recommends it for: People who like blatant Catcher in the Rye rip-offs
This book was like wading through a river of shit. It's a great concept - basically nice high school kid with emotional issues tries to make his way through therapy with a bunch of other similar kids a Toledo, Ohio suburb in the 70s. But.... epic fail. This story was basically the Catcher in the Rye in Ohio in the 70s. Except in this one Holden Caulfield has friends whose existence you don't somewhat doubt. I wanted to like this book. I loved Catcher in the Rye, which I guess is why I don't see ...more
This is a big book - figuratively and literally - and it's hard to know where to start. It's one of those books where you completely buy into the world of the story - it's character driven, and you never doubt for a moment that this is how they would act or think. But because it feels so real, it's that much more difficult to read. Each of the high schoolers is so painfully messed up, each family has so many issues. It never reads like a problem novel, partly because it's so well crafted and par ...more
Feb 23, 2010 rated it it was amazing
Wow! This is a great book, full of characters so real you want to call them up and share your day with them. I didn't want it to end. Loved the narrator and his crazy hectic life of juggling multiple part-time jobs, cat poop duty and coping with his often-drunk and stoned mother, all with a super sense of humor and way of looking at the world even when it's really beating him down. The Madman Underground is the nickname Karl gives to his group of outcast friends, who all spend time in therapy fo ...more
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 next »
topics  posts  views  last activity   
By way of announcement ... 7 40 Mar 04, 2012 04:14PM  

Readers also enjoyed

  • Punkzilla
  • Heart to Heart: New Poems Inspired by Twentieth-Century American Art
  • One Whole and Perfect Day
  • John Lennon: All I Want is the Truth
  • Surrender
  • Freewill
  • A Wreath for Emmett Till
  • Your Own, Sylvia: A Verse Portrait of Sylvia Plath
  • Many Stones
  • The Last Summer of the Death Warriors
  • Flash Burnout
  • The White Bicycle (Wild Orchard, #3)
  • Black Juice
  • Repossessed
  • The Kingdom on the Waves (The Astonishing Life of Octavian Nothing, Traitor to the Nation, #2)
  • Chanda's Secrets (Chanda, #1)
  • Postcards from No Man's Land
  • The Orange Houses
See similar books…
John Barnes (born 1957) is an American science fiction author, whose stories often explore questions of individual moral responsibility within a larger social context. Social criticism is woven throughout his plots. The four novels in his Thousand Cultures series pose serious questions about the effects of globalization on isolated societies. Barnes holds a doctorate in theatre and for several yea ...more
“So we fell asleep holding hands. If married couples got to do this all the time, shit if I could understand how there were ever divorces, or even fights.” 42 likes
“I think everyone always has time to suffer.” 25 likes
More quotes…