Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read.
Start by marking “Did America Have a Christian Founding?: Separating Modern Myth from Historical Truth” as Want to Read:
Did America Have a Christian Founding?: Separating Modern Myth from Historical Truth
by
A distinguished professor debunks the assertion that America's Founders were deists who desired the strict separation of church and state and instead shows that their political ideas were profoundly influenced by their Christian convictions.
In 2010, David Mark Hall gave a lecture at the Heritage Foundation entitled "Did America Have a Christian Founding?" His balanced and ...more
In 2010, David Mark Hall gave a lecture at the Heritage Foundation entitled "Did America Have a Christian Founding?" His balanced and ...more
Get A Copy
Hardcover, 240 pages
Published
October 29th 2019
by Thomas Nelson
Friend Reviews
To see what your friends thought of this book,
please sign up.
Reader Q&A
To ask other readers questions about
Did America Have a Christian Founding?,
please sign up.
Be the first to ask a question about Did America Have a Christian Founding?
This book is not yet featured on Listopia.
Add this book to your favorite list »
Community Reviews
Showing 1-30
Start your review of Did America Have a Christian Founding?: Separating Modern Myth from Historical Truth
For me, the issue was settled back in 1975 when I first started reading about the Calvinistic influence on American history. There was a history professor at our local community college who was the most scholarly teacher on staff and a thorough-going Calvinist. A friend told me to take his class because "he teaches the Five Points of Calvinism, and you need to know that for American literature." She was right, for American literature is a tug of war between Calvinists (beginning with the Puritan
...more
With Did America Have a Christian Founding?, Mark David Hall has written a book that is as useful as it should be unnecessary. To anyone approaching the American founding (apologies to Russell Kirk) without ideological blinders, the religious faith of the founding generation is patently obvious. This is not to deny that there were varying levels of commitment to the Christian faith among that generation, nor that some prominent members of it held less orthodox views. But it cannot seriously be q
...more
It is a dangerous proposition to critique a “distinguished professor” but I do so as a practicing historian in both public and academic worlds who also holds a Ph.D. in American History. Mark David Hall has attempted a history of the founding generation of America to prove that it had a Christian founding. My finding is Hall had ignored better research to satisfy the groups supporting Christian Nationalism. Coming from an evangelical and Christian nationalist background myself, I understand how
...more
Hall makes the briefest definitive case establishing America was founded by Christians and a few non-Christians happy to see Christianity voluntarily flourish. His discussion reveals how free speech, freedom of religion and more are part of a Christian founding. These values and freedoms are eroding as Christ and the church are marginalized.
The evidence is so abundantly clear that Christianity had a direct influence on this nation. If we are to remain in denial its either by willful ignorance or deep commitments to revisionist history.
The author does an excellent evidence based job to display this historical reality. What really should be common knowledge based on primary historical sources.
Did our founders create a "theocracy?" Absolutely not. Did a Christianized people create this nation....no doubt about it. When John Adams sa ...more
The author does an excellent evidence based job to display this historical reality. What really should be common knowledge based on primary historical sources.
Did our founders create a "theocracy?" Absolutely not. Did a Christianized people create this nation....no doubt about it. When John Adams sa ...more
Hall speaks briefly about the tendency of the founders to speak about God with terms such as "Supreme Being" or "Divine Creator" without getting into the important history of deism and enlightenment Christianity that these terms often denote. Of course the founders were Christians in many ways - it is the SORT of Christian that they were that matters. Many Enlightenment Christians had very warm feelings about a sort of "rational religion," a mental process by which they accomplished in their min
...more
This is an excellent primer that pushes back on the idea of a deistic founding. It’s not meant to be a deep scholarly book. It’s written for laypeople. While I might quibble with a couple things here and there, Dr. Hall makes a great case that the Founders were in many ways convincingly Christian. I’m perhaps not as convinced they were particularly “interested” in religion, but to Dr Hall’s credit he states very clearly his aim is to show that the Founding was not deistic or secular. In that, he
...more
Yes, America had a Christian founding. Hall does a wonderful job defending and explaining it. He pulls out lots of key quotes and sources to support his argument. This is a key work for American Christians to read in order to understand our own country better and then work to maintain the liberties that we love: religious freedom, etc. Written interview with author here: https://crosspolitic.com/did-america-...
...more
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it,
click here.
Depends on how you use the word "Christian" when speaking of a "Christian" founding. If you're using the narrow concept of a nation with an established national, Christian church, then no. If you're talking about a country where everyone is apart of social, cultural Christianity, then no. If you're talking about a country where everyone is a regenerated, evangelical, then no.
However, if you're talking about a country where the basic presupposition of many major founders was that of a Christian w ...more
However, if you're talking about a country where the basic presupposition of many major founders was that of a Christian w ...more
A fascinating historical retrospective, Did America Have a Christian Founding? challenges the modern conception that the Founding Fathers were deists that intended to create a secular state. Author Mark David Hall looks at the lives of the Founders that are often cited as deists and sees if they actually fit that definition. He also examines who and what actually influenced the writing and passage of the United States Constitution and Bill of Rights. Additionally, Hall analyzes the actions of th
...more
Hall contends "that an excellent case can be made that Christianity had a profound influence on the founding generation" (xxii). This is true beyond any reasonable doubt, and this book helpfully pulls together some of the evidence and presents it in a very readable manner. At the same time, however, the book doesn't really wrestle with key concepts. What counts as Christianity? What is religion? What is liberty? What is morality? It is one thing to say that the founders were influenced by Christ
...more
In an age of growing public questioning about the degree to which America was founded upon Christian principles, this book is a timely rebuttal. Recent academic circles positing that the founding fathers were not Christian, but deists who believed that God did not intervene in the matters of men, and who argued for the strict separation of church and state, are refuted throughout this book by Mark David Hall, whose primary theses include attempts to debunk these myths.
As a prerequisite bias that ...more
As a prerequisite bias that ...more
I read this book because I’ve increasingly heard that America is not a Christian nation, that the founders weren’t Christians, and that government should play no role whatsoever in the promotion of religion.
Like everyone else in my generation, I’ve heard the constant reiteration of Jefferson’s ‘wall between church and state’ and therefore any slight symbol of religion (Christianity) put forth by government, state or federal, should not be tolerated.
I’ve also heard that a majority of the key foun ...more
Like everyone else in my generation, I’ve heard the constant reiteration of Jefferson’s ‘wall between church and state’ and therefore any slight symbol of religion (Christianity) put forth by government, state or federal, should not be tolerated.
I’ve also heard that a majority of the key foun ...more
Hall has provided a good corrective to the foundation for key political and religious decisions in our day that are based on a skewed view of early American history. He shows that a Christian worldview was very much a part of our Nation’s founding.
However, two weaknesses of his work are his minimal attention to the Declaration of Independence and to the Treaty of Tripoli. Scholars pressing for a broad Deist view of the founding pounce on the Treaty of Tripoli as evidence of their view. The Treat ...more
However, two weaknesses of his work are his minimal attention to the Declaration of Independence and to the Treaty of Tripoli. Scholars pressing for a broad Deist view of the founding pounce on the Treaty of Tripoli as evidence of their view. The Treat ...more
His answer to the title was a pretty resounding YES! if you think of it as being influenced by Christian values and not as our founders necessarily having true faith in Jesus. This book is particularly a response to those who say our founders were mostly deists. He asserts that only one or two were.
Growing up I was exposed to the opposite: all our founders were Godly men, which I think is also exaggerated. I was thinking the book was going to deal with that misrepresentation so I struggled some ...more
Growing up I was exposed to the opposite: all our founders were Godly men, which I think is also exaggerated. I was thinking the book was going to deal with that misrepresentation so I struggled some ...more
A relevant book
A good book that refreshes the origin of the foundation of America and its Christian’ principles. The book gains points by not trying to preach or to sell religion, but historically acknowledging the influence of Christian principles in the foundation of America and, in special, that came mainly from Christians the idea of separation of Church and State and that it does not mean, but actually reinforce, that the influence Christianity is present in, for example, how the Constituti ...more
A good book that refreshes the origin of the foundation of America and its Christian’ principles. The book gains points by not trying to preach or to sell religion, but historically acknowledging the influence of Christian principles in the foundation of America and, in special, that came mainly from Christians the idea of separation of Church and State and that it does not mean, but actually reinforce, that the influence Christianity is present in, for example, how the Constituti ...more
Mark David Hall gives an amazing historical look into this issue in a time when feelings and shallow ideas rule. Addressing the idea that one cannot define an entire time period by quick glimpses at a few people Hall lays out a well supported case based on historical facts and analysis.
The greatest sign of Halls credibility on this issue is how fair he is with every premise put forth by both sides of the issue. Hall calls out faulty logic on each side of the issue sticking to facts and logical d ...more
The greatest sign of Halls credibility on this issue is how fair he is with every premise put forth by both sides of the issue. Hall calls out faulty logic on each side of the issue sticking to facts and logical d ...more
Fascinating, easy read. The author dismantles the arguments typical of secular contemporaries who want to re-write the founders as enlightenment minded deists who denied orthodox christian principles. In reality, they were in large part (not in every case) faithful, pious Christians who sought to maintain their biblical convictions and reflect those convictions by setting up what they believed to be a just, fair, and religiously tolerant government.
Excellent, well-researched, clear.
This book is very well-researched and clearly examines the actual writings and practices of the founders to evince as false the common claim that the founders were deists. I particularly like the sections toward the beginning on Jefferson, especially the seal that he proposed with God leading the Israelites out of Egypt and the motto, "Rebellion to tyrants is obedience to God." I would recommend this book to every history teacher, lawyer, and general Christian. ...more
This book is very well-researched and clearly examines the actual writings and practices of the founders to evince as false the common claim that the founders were deists. I particularly like the sections toward the beginning on Jefferson, especially the seal that he proposed with God leading the Israelites out of Egypt and the motto, "Rebellion to tyrants is obedience to God." I would recommend this book to every history teacher, lawyer, and general Christian. ...more
The next time I hear someone argue “but Jefferson wanted a wall between church and state!”, this is the book I will throw at...erm, kindly ask them to read.
Hall does an excellent job of undressing the most common arguments against a Christian founding and repudiating them in easy-to-understand terms. He uses the Founders’ own words and writings to make his points, which makes his points pretty indisputable. And it’s a short, digestible read, so well worth it.
Hall does an excellent job of undressing the most common arguments against a Christian founding and repudiating them in easy-to-understand terms. He uses the Founders’ own words and writings to make his points, which makes his points pretty indisputable. And it’s a short, digestible read, so well worth it.
My first Audible Audiobook and a solid work of historical scholarship. My favorite part was Hall's repetition of the need to actually have evidence to make a historical claim. Hall does a good job amassing real evidence for his claims.
...more
Yes, it did. The book is relatively short since the thesis isn't difficult.
...more
There are no discussion topics on this book yet.
Be the first to start one »
News & Interviews
Sally Thorne, author of The Hating Game and 99 Percent Mine, explores what it means to take risks for love, and for yourself, in her newest...
101 likes · 11 comments
No trivia or quizzes yet. Add some now »











