Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read.

Start by marking “Ways of Hearing” as Want to Read:

Other editions

Enlarge cover

Rate this book

Clear rating

1 of 5 stars 2 of 5 stars 3 of 5 stars 4 of 5 stars 5 of 5 stars

Open Preview

Ways of Hearing

Damon Krukowski,

Emily Thompson (Foreword)

3.78 · Rating details · 129 ratings · 29 reviews

A writer-musician examines how the switch from analog to digital audio is changing our perceptions of time, space, love, money, and power.Our voices carry farther than ever before, thanks to digital media. But how are they being heard? In this book, Damon Krukowski examines how the switch from analog to digital audio is changing our perceptions of time, space, love, money, ...more

Get A Copy

Paperback, 136 pages

Published April 9th 2019 by MIT Press

More Details... Edit Details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Reader Q&A

To ask other readers questions about Ways of Hearing, please sign up.

Be the first to ask a question about Ways of Hearing

Lists with This Book

This book is not yet featured on Listopia. Add this book to your favorite list »

Community Reviews

Showing 1-30

Average rating 3.78 ·

Rating details

· 129 ratings · 29 reviews

More filters

Sort order

Start your review of Ways of Hearing

Jul 21, 2019 Rob Smith rated it did not like it

Shelves: music

I think it's kind of ironic for a book obsessed with the downsides of sleek digital music production, it's actually just the transcript from a sleek, digital NPR podcast.

That's all it literally is, and it's pretty okay. I should have figured given the marketing and publishing parallels to John Berger's Ways of Seeing that this would also have been something like a podcast. But unlike Berger's book, this one's a straight up transcript of the podcast episodes, complete with listing the music cues I think it's kind of ironic for a book obsessed with the downsides of sleek digital music production, it's actually just the transcript from a sleek, digital NPR podcast.

That's all it literally is, and it's pretty okay. I should have figured given the marketing and publishing parallels to John Berger's Ways of Seeing that this would also have been something like a podcast. But unlike Berger's book, this one's a straight up transcript of the podcast episodes, complete with listing the music cues and sound effects.

I like the book but; it has a couple problems. Straight-up, the book has a "old man yells at cloud" vibe. Damon Krukowski talks a lot about how music has changed in the switch from analog to digital, and while he likes digital I'm not sure he does. Gotta be honest, you talk to someone in a local music scene that's well into their 30s and you'll fine a lot of the same opinions here. Digital means you can delete all the noise and acquire pefect signal, record shops/bookstores are dying but are great for curation, and big digital corps are predicting what we want.

And what I find is... well who cares? A lot of the interviews and quotes are also from people who remember the music world before the advent of digital. There's no one prominent in the book who is below the age of what, 30, 40, 45? I'd like to see the perspective as someone who grew up with digital. I'm old enough to have a decent-sized collection of physical media. I love buying books, blu-rays, actual video games discs, and well into my 20s I was buying CDs.

But my problem is... take away all this digital-ness and the music world kinda sucks. My local radio stations are garbage, unless you're in NYC it's almost gonna be impossible to signed, let alone honest-to-God radio play. The competition between noise and signal will still exist... because ya know. People still go to live shows. But if I don't have to lug my CD collection around or burn a CD or choose which songs I want on my iPod/Phone storage (and man we forget how easy - and quick - it is to fill those things up) then sign me up for Spotify forever.

And I know it's based off a podcast. But that's no reason for it to shallow in it's topics. Krokowski touches on some great topics in music, but that's all he does: he just touches on it. My favorite chapter is probably the one where he defends bookstores and record shops as places of curation, where you don't shop for a particular item but you discover something you never knew existed. That part's great, that's something I do in my local indie shops all the time.

But there's no depth. See, what makes of Ways of Seeing stand on it's own as a book, is that Berger just didn't transcribe the documentary series in a book. He used the book, an entirely different medium, with an entirely different sense of time to expand on some of the issues he talks about in the documentary. There are two essays entirely made up of pictures of paintings. Berger uses Ways of Seeing to talk about our ideas of art, of the male gaze/female representation in art, of art as status symbol for the monied classes etc.

Krokowski could have talked about the ingrained sexism in certain music industries and local scenes. He could have fucking talked about local music scenes and how they're thriving and that smaller artists actually benefit more from the internet unmooring us from rich NYC publishing gatekeepers. He could have actually talked about the fucked legal status of music and songs a la Lou Reed getting all of a Tribe Called Quest's royalties because they sampled one of his songs.

What's more, for a guy talking about in a lot of ways how digital has downsides he never once acknowledges that the ultimate irony of talking about all of this while communicating it in the style of one of those NPR-style, sleek well produced podcasts. Most of the podcasts I listen to have some production, but they're never strictly scripted. They're just a bunch of people around a mic talking free style about a subject they've chosen. I've never heard of the terms in the glossary used anywhere but a sleek radio production.

I'm probably being harder on the book than I need to be, mostly because of the pains it takes to compare itself to Ways of Seeing: in advertisement, in format as well. The book is about the dimensions of Ways of Seeing, and laid out a little like his too, complete with the first page also being on the cover. I'm also annoyed because I just paid 20 bucks to read a monied professional podcast script that comes off as a shallow freshman term paper.

He had a different medium, something which he acknowledges in the text is different, and he doesn't fully utilize the medium. Three stars for some of the information, but honestly there are better books on music. ...more

flag 3 likes · Like · see review

May 29, 2019 Kevin rated it really liked it

Shelves: nonfiction-or-memoir

An interesting, fun, and thoughtful look at sound, both ambient and musical.

flag 3 likes · Like · see review

Oct 19, 2019 Mark Mulvey rated it really liked it

“Damon reminds us that our senses’ most fundamental task is not simply to entertain or distract us, but to situate ourselves within our surroundings. By enabling each of us to understand where we are, our senses allow us to understand who we are, as individuals located within networks of physical and social connections. Just as John Berger’s popular television series ‘Ways of Seeing’ showed viewers back in the 1970’s how to understand art—and the vision that art materializes—as a tool for locati ...more

flag 1 like · Like · see review

Nov 02, 2019 Jeff rated it really liked it

Shelves: music-writing

undertaken as a podcast & turned into a book, putatively on the model of Berger's Ways of Seeing though that's just a smokescreen -- books are silent but not invisible. The analogy Krukowski may have liked is not-and-never-will-be exact. That said, there are intriguing things here, namely about connoisseurship and the mystical in any audio-philia. I have not yet returned to listen to the podcast, which could well have been done with more love than this meta commentary. At some point I will -- ...more

flag 1 like · Like · see review

May 08, 2019 Sue rated it really liked it

This is a cool book -- a speedy diversion into what it is to hear and to listen in the digital world. It's nostalgic, yes... but also inventive.

This book is the script to a podcast -- which I'm currently listening to. I'm one to tolerate repetition, and enjoy thinking on what each medium -- print and audio -- bring to this story; and how I experience the story through each medium a little differently.

Reading -- or the solo experience of turning down the exterior world to internalize a story -- r ...more

flag 1 like · Like · see review

Aug 25, 2019 Geoff rated it liked it

Shelves: essays, history, nonfiction, read-2019, science

It’s sort of weird reading a transcript of a podcast series, but that actually worked for me the same way reading a play works. The actual argument about digital sound was less convincing. It’s clear that digital recording and all of its consequences have changed how we listen to, buy, and interact with music (& the world around us). I’m just not convinced that that change has been bad.

flag 1 like · Like · see review

Aug 14, 2019 Patrick rated it it was ok

As other reviewers have noted, aside from the addition of an introduction by Emily Thompson, and pictures, this is essentially just a transcript of Krukowski's podcast. It's not uninteresting, but, if you've thought at all about sound or music in the past 30 years, it's nothing new, and it only touches the surface of the issues raised.

I do have a couple of beefs with Krukowski's discussion of copyright and artist's rights generally. In Episode 4, "Money", pp. 78-79 Krukowski appears to claim tha As other reviewers have noted, aside from the addition of an introduction by Emily Thompson, and pictures, this is essentially just a transcript of Krukowski's podcast. It's not uninteresting, but, if you've thought at all about sound or music in the past 30 years, it's nothing new, and it only touches the surface of the issues raised.

I do have a couple of beefs with Krukowski's discussion of copyright and artist's rights generally. In Episode 4, "Money", pp. 78-79 Krukowski appears to claim that there is no copyright in "music". ("What Napster did that was so damaging to the industry, was to separate music - which doesn't have a price attached to it - from the technology that delivers it, which does.") This is simply false. Any fixed expression which has a minimal degree of creativity is subject to copyright. Whether you notate the composition on a piece of paper or sing it into your phone, the music is subject to copyright and as such, pirating by the tech industry aside, has the price the copyright owner (or the government) puts on it. The technology of how the sound recording is distributed may change, from, say, a vinyl LP to a CD shipped to a store, to a digital download or stream (which is actually a download which is deleted from your device after playing), but that doesn't remove the copyright in the composition or the recording.

Krukowski also seems to support artists' rights, but blithely dismisses concerns about wholesale copyright violation and devaluation enabled by the internet, instead focusing on a band called Downtown Boys, whom he characterizes as seeing their rights as artists as a labor issue. Obviously, labor - how musicians are treated and compensated for their performances - is important (and musicians are generally treated poorly by club owners and promoters), but the value of musicians and other artists, and the concomitant wealth generated for them by it, was greatly expanded by the introduction of copyright - that is, by granting property rights to the fixed expression of that labor. Prior to copyright, artists were almost wholly dependent on the patronage of the wealthy or institutions like the church to survive. For a couple of hundred years since the advent of copyright, composers were able to support themselves from the distribution of their works to the masses, and once sound recordings were possible, musicians also benefited from sound recording copyright. Digitization of work and distribution via the internet stripped that support away, enabling a massive transfer of wealth from artists to ISPs, computer and device manufacturers, and tech companies (Google, Facebook, Spotify, etc., as well as owners and enablers of pirating sites like Kim Dotcom) by either ignoring copyright entirely and refusing to pay composers and musicians, or by only paying them compensation which is nominal (and virtually non-existent) for all but the most popular of artists. The result is the end of a middle class career for many musicians. To ignore this in a book/podcast about the effects of digitization of music is to refuse to discuss the elephant in the room. ...more

flag Like · see review

Aug 21, 2019 Ollie rated it really liked it

There is no doubt that Damon Krukowski is the right guy to be talking about music. He understands it at an intimate level where I either wished I could talk about it the same way, or that I could spend a couple hours picking his brain over a cup of coffee. Ways of Hearing is a curious book that doesn’t really have a thesis and is more of a work-in-progress. It discusses different aspects of music and noise. Really, it tries to distinguish between the two because even though this book is mostly a There is no doubt that Damon Krukowski is the right guy to be talking about music. He understands it at an intimate level where I either wished I could talk about it the same way, or that I could spend a couple hours picking his brain over a cup of coffee. Ways of Hearing is a curious book that doesn’t really have a thesis and is more of a work-in-progress. It discusses different aspects of music and noise. Really, it tries to distinguish between the two because even though this book is mostly about music, it’s also a lot about how we hear it, and as such has to deal with how it is that we hear noise in general.

Right off the bat I knew I’d be in good hands with Krukowski’s book because the first thing he discusses is the metronome, or clicktrack, and how our switch from analog to digital has complicated its use because with digital music., there is a small fraction of time that’s needed for a computer to process analog sound into digital signal, and this causes a delay. The smaller picture is that the approach to using a metronome has to be changed since the beat we’re recording isn’t the same as the one we’re playing along with on our instruments (something I’ve dealt with myself). The larger picture is that this is a shift in the way we hear things because, when dealing with digital recording or broadcasting, nothing is happening in real time, but delayed by microseconds. Is that the end of the world? Not really, but it is a change that has occurred right in front of us that we haven’t even noticed.

It’s topics like this, and many others, that Ways of Hearing explores. Like how the space we inhabit affects the sounds in our life, how technology can be used to manipulate the qualities of the things we hear, and how our purchasing experience affects what music we play. In the latter, imagine two people looking for a particular song. One finds and purchases the song on Amazon as an MP3. The other goes to a record store, browses the bins for the record that has the song they want, purchases that record (along with the other songs it contains), and that other record they happened to come across in that same visit which had a striking cover but contained music they would otherwise never listen to. These two hypothetical people were looking for the same song but ended up with different music. It’s these beautiful little things in our lives that Ways of Hearing makes us aware of.

Now, the format of this book is something entirely different, as it’s made up basically of transcripts of Krukowski’s podcast, right down to the guests he interviews. There’s even photos of the subjects or artists discussed and indications of which song was playing when Krokowski dictated his parts. So, it’s an easy read and super short, but kind of feels unnecessary if you already listen to the podcast. I don’t, so I dug this.

Ways of Hearing is an oddly formatted book with some truly wonderful ideas. It makes you ponder the world around you and makes you appreciate it more. As a music fan, I highly recommend it.
...more

flag Like · see review

Jun 29, 2019 John rated it it was amazing

Shelves: reviewed-by-me, rock-books

This is an engaging and delightful book about how we experience the world. The key examples in this book, which is essentially a transcription of the author's podcast, Ways of Hearing, come from music and sounds. [Full disclosure: I went to grad school with Damon and was at the first show his band Galaxie 500 played in a bar.]

The chapters are on Time, Space, Love, Money, Power, and Signal & Noise. Damon helps us understand how music means something different when recorded and played via analog v This is an engaging and delightful book about how we experience the world. The key examples in this book, which is essentially a transcription of the author's podcast, Ways of Hearing, come from music and sounds. [Full disclosure: I went to grad school with Damon and was at the first show his band Galaxie 500 played in a bar.]

The chapters are on Time, Space, Love, Money, Power, and Signal & Noise. Damon helps us understand how music means something different when recorded and played via analog vs digital means. But it goes a lot farther than that: Our music companies and institutions have been able to seize control of the medium by emphasizing the technological control over signal.

In a tour de force but brief final chapter, Damon tells us that our world is impoverished without noise. Noise provides the opportunity to turn one's attention to other signals -- the conversation across the room, the digital fingerprints captured during an analog recording session. But our culture's ceaseless obsession with making everything available for profit-taking is all about reducing noise in favor of presenting us with choices that satisfy our conscious desires, not leaving much room for the random play of opportunities to experience everything else (and all of those things that are being pushed out of the digital channel). If this book doesn't make you start being your own historian or ethnographer at used record stores, book stores, and live performance, I don't know what will. A funny irony for me reading the book is that in passing Damon suggests that people reading the book have heard the podcast; I didn't! I like books and randomness, and in fact the book was a gift from my friend Jaimie. So I think there are ways to increase the opportunity to grab noise instead of a coroporately-curated signal.

The book is clearly an artifact from the podcast, and Damon doesn't go into a lot of detail with his argument -- the book is really about the examples and conversation, I think. I expect we would find that in his longer book, The New Analog: Listening and Reconnecting in a Digital World, which I'll be putting on my list. ...more

flag Like · see review

Jun 22, 2019 Andrew rated it really liked it

This book is actually (at least in part) a transcipted version of a podcast. Much of its content is a comparison between digital and analog methods of recording, and the characteristic distinctions between the two. Many music lovers notice something missing in digital sound; Krukowski digs into the specifics of what that/those something(s) is/are. For example, noise (as in "signal-to-noise" rather than loud clangor), room ambience, the spaces between things.

Really fascinating stuff; recommended ...more

flag Like · see review

Jun 09, 2019 Steev Hise rated it it was amazing

Shelves: art, politics, own-it

This is a really great book. As soon as I saw it I knew I had to get it and read it ASAP. But YMMV. I'm a sound/noise/music/art guy, so am definitely biased.

Anyway, it's about way more than sound and music. It's about what the internet and the digital world we're in now has done to us and our culture and our society.

The design of the book reminds me of McLuhan's The Medium is the Massage. The title is a nod to John Berger, and the book does a good job of aspiring to, but isn't quite get up to th ...more

flag Like · see review

Jan 15, 2020 David Ashley rated it really liked it

A transcription of Damon's 6 part Ways of Hearing podcast series. A very light and relaxing but also interesting read, definitely has that easy going podcast vibe to it which works surprisingly well in book format.

It's very loosely based around the change from an analog to digital world and what that does for sound in its many forms. It's a lot warmer and relatable than it sounds! The design of the book is great with interesting formatting and images throughout although I wish it was physically ...more

flag Like · see review

Jun 18, 2019 Michael Chojnacki rated it really liked it

A (blog turned into a) book that explores what happens when we move from an analogue to a digital music world. The author considers the technical, economical, sentimental aspects of that shift concluding that : removing 'noise' from 'signal' changes the nature of sound leaving behind lot behind we find near and dear. I have read this book while listening to the podcast, going back and forth. A few very valid points made by a the author/musical. ...more

flag Like · see review

Jul 06, 2019 Claudia Skelton rated it liked it

This book focuses on how digital culture has changed the making and listening to our music. The author is a musician, author, and professor. Based on a podcast, this book summarizes how the shift from analog to digital audio has changed our perceptions of time, space, noise, and more. It also is about an aspect of how the digital world has changed our culture and society. (I may consider listening to the podcast.)

flag Like · see review

Nov 16, 2019 Jieying Zhang rated it liked it

One star for the pictures, one star for some key points that I can relate, and one last star for making me curious enough to listen to the podcast that I ended up enjoying (much more that the book). It's usually good to make a paper book audible but the other way round doesn't seem to work.. at least in this case. ...more

flag Like · see review

Sep 13, 2019 Cate rated it liked it

This is a print rendition of a podcast on sound and hearing, signal and noise. Not being familiar with the podcast, I literally took it at its printed word. Krukowski raises interesting questions about what it means to have constant access to sound and constant exposure to noise. I also was fascinated to learn that digital time is not good at syncing with itself. Huh.

flag Like · see review

Sep 02, 2019 Jeremy Hatch rated it liked it

The content is fine. I’m giving it three stars because the book, as such, is simply a transcript of a freely available podcast — albeit in an engagingly designed format filled with illustrations. But those two things add little of value to the podcast itself. I found the best use of the book was to read along while listening to the podcast. Other than that, not really worth the spend.

flag Like · see review

Jun 25, 2019 Davide rated it it was amazing

Shelves: audio, music, sound

It is hard to convert a podcast into a book. Still, I believe the author and the graphic designer did an amazing job in this case. They converted the audio interludes into illustrations, plus they were also able to convey some sound effects by clever use of typography and fonts. The result is a book that is very easy to read as well as very beautiful to look at.

flag Like · see review

Jan 18, 2020 Scott Holstad rated it liked it

Shelves: music

This topic is of great interest to me, but I think his The New Analog: Listening and Reconnecting in a Digital World from just a couple of years ago was quite a bit better. I just sort of left me feeling somewhat unfulfilled. If interested in the topic, I'd start with his previous one. ...more

flag Like · see review

Sep 27, 2019 Jehnie rated it really liked it

Shelves: music

Interesting to read the transcript of a podcast about sound without being able to hear the audio track. A lot of good food for thought that makes me think about sound and noise differently, but the sound is relevant to the argument.

flag Like · see review

Jun 27, 2019 Sammy Williams rated it liked it

Shelves: 2019-books

I think I would have better enjoyed the podcast. Although he brought up interesting points, I don't feel like they were explored deeply enough. Sections about cell phones and digital elimination of noise were the most informative. ...more

flag Like · see review

May 10, 2019 Vuk Trifkovic rated it liked it

Nice book - both graphically and in content. Lot of the stuff is interesting but bit artificial. Would totally read a 300-450 page expanded version.

flag Like · see review

Apr 25, 2019 dimwig rated it liked it

Shelves: music

This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it, click here.

flag Like · see review

Jan 09, 2020 Kat rated it really liked it

This is good but the podcast was better

flag Like · see review

Jun 05, 2019 Scott Schneider rated it it was ok

I'm not sure it was a good idea to translate a podcast about sound into print. It probably works much better in audio form. Maybe I should get the audiobook version of this podcast book. ...more

flag Like · see review

May 07, 2020 Kbuxton rated it liked it

I liked the podcast version better

flag Like · see review

May 14, 2020 April rated it liked it

I read this for my Audio Culture and Digital Sound Production class, and we got to have a Zoom call with Damon at the end!

flag Like · see review

Jul 23, 2019 Herb rated it liked it

Shelves: req, 2019, libr, male

A very good book that’s really a better podcast.

Damon Krukowski is very smart about how digital and analog audio are different NOT just as applies to contemporary recording of music, but also in how modern listeners interact with what they hear in non-musical contexts. The podcast, as an audible object, uses many techniques and opportunities for the listener to hear the points that Krukowski and his guests are making.

In book form, all the spoken text is there, with one or two additions (primar ...more

flag Like · see review

May 26, 2019 Gabby rated it liked it

It’s fine. Listen to the podcast too for the full experience.

flag Like · see review

Mike rated it really liked it
Jun 03, 2019

« previous 1 2 3 4 5 next »

new topic
Discuss This Book

There are no discussion topics on this book yet. Be the first to start one »

Recommend It | Stats | Recent Status Updates

Readers also enjoyed

See similar books…

Genres

Music

23 users

Nonfiction

8 users

Writing > Essays

4 users

Philosophy > Theory

2 users

Science

2 users

Art

2 users

See top shelves…

About Damon Krukowski

Damon Krukowski

12 followers

Damon Krukowski is a writer and musician. Author of The New Analog: Listening and Reconnecting in a Digital World, he has taught writing and sound (and writing about sound) at Harvard University. He was in the indie rock band Galaxie 500 and is currently one half of the folk-rock duo Damon & Naomi. He lives in Cambridge, Massachusetts.