Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read.
Start by marking “The Body in Question” as Want to Read:
The Body in Question
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating
Open Preview

The Body in Question

3.58  ·  Rating details ·  7,061 ratings  ·  958 reviews
A spare, masterful novel about a shocking murder trial, a sequestered jury, and an affair between two of the jurors--the woman, in free fall in her life and marriage to a much older man.

The place: central Florida. The situation: a sensational murder trial involving a rich, white teenage girl--a twin--on trial for the horrific murder of her toddler brother, and the sequeste
Hardcover, 174 pages
Published June 11th 2019 by Pantheon Books
More Details... Edit Details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Reader Q&A

To ask other readers questions about The Body in Question, please sign up.
Popular Answered Questions
Bas I was confused by this as well.
I finally decided to interpret it to mean that, although their "marital relations" had changed physically due to the hu…more
I was confused by this as well.
I finally decided to interpret it to mean that, although their "marital relations" had changed physically due to the husband's advanced age (he was 86 and she was 52), the emotion behind the act continued to have a profound impact on her, specifically when she thought about his life force that continued to seek out intimacy with her, and that was when she felt "slayed." (less)

Community Reviews

Showing 1-30
Average rating 3.58  · 
Rating details
 ·  7,061 ratings  ·  958 reviews

More filters
Sort order
Start your review of The Body in Question
The Body in Question by Jill Ciment is a 2019 Pantheon Books publication.

An unvarnished but addictive legal drama!

The jury has been selected for a sensational criminal trial where a teenage girl is accused of murdering her younger brother. The story follows the shocking developments of the trial, but the primary focus is on the jury, which has been sequestered. The spotlight zeroes in on juror C- 2, a 52- year old photographer, and F-17 – a 41- year old anatomy professor who forge a complicated
Elyse Walters
Jun 13, 2019 rated it it was amazing

...READ IT...


Magnificent & Brilliant!!!!

One sitting read for most readers. You won’t be able to put it down!!!

A few small excerpts- but no spoilers in this review:

“The point of no return is the moment when continuing a journey becomes less dangerous than turning back”......

“What else but guilt”, asks the defense counsel, “would cause an innocent person to confess?”

“You either photograph what you know, or photograph what you want to know. Bu
Jun 23, 2019 rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
A tense court drama, superbly written, that focuses on the jury rather than the defendant. A teenage girl is accused of killing her toddler brother and the jury of 6 are tasked with giving the verdict. Sounds familiar? Yes, quite, but I was surprised by the Author who, apart from unravelling the story of the tragic death of a baby, tells a story of an unexpected relationship between two jury members, and how jurors relate to one another. Still familiar? I can assure you that the narration makes ...more
Spoiler-free review:
Far more than a simple courtroom drama, this book puts the sequestered jury as the focus. We learn details of the trial of a wealthy teenager accused of murdering her toddler brother only through their eyes, or, more specifically, through juror C-2’s eyes (we learn her name only in the last half). Her observations, her thoughts, her notes, and her relationship with juror F-17 are what drives this story and makes it so fascinating. The first half of this book deals with the ti
Jun 20, 2019 rated it it was amazing
Wow! I resented the time I had to take away from this book due to family obligations... seriously an addictive and riveting story, a real page turner!
A murder trial, a sequestered jury.... things happen...
Thank you Elyse for bringing this to my attention!
Aug 21, 2019 rated it really liked it
Shelves: mystery
I almost think this should be called the anatomy of a body. A crime takes place and a jury is selected. However, in this clever narrative, characters are only known by their jury number.
The jurors are sequestered. An affair begins between C-2, in what she believes to be her last fling at 52 and married to an aging husband, and F-17 an anatomy professor.
When the trial is over, an unravelling of character begins.
There is a sacred beauty depicted in the dissection of a body donated to science. It’
Jul 26, 2019 rated it liked it  ·  review of another edition
Shelves: c-w-mars
A teen girl, a twin that is on the spectrum, has been accused of murdering her 18 month old brother. A jury is chosen. We follow along with the jury.

Two of the jurors (which are only referred to by their juror #'s rather than names) C-2, a 52 yr old photographer that is married to a much older man, and F-17, a 41 yr old anatomy professor decide to carry on an affair while being sequestered at the Econo Lodge. When it comes time for the jury to deliberate C-2 can't believe that F-17 is on the op
Holly  B
What a different novel with so many elements that I enjoy...

courtroom drama, the behind the scenes jury discussions/happenings, deliberations, a side affair, complications at home, controversy and so much more!

Thanks to Elyse for her review that prompted me to pick this one up (library loan). Would be a good buddy read or book club discussion.

There is so much to think about... even after finishing...

Although some may question the ending, I was satisfied.

Look forward to her next novel!
Marialyce (absltmom, yaya)
There are times when a short little book can pack in a lot of very strong feelings, excellent writing, and encourage a taste for information, discussion, and awareness. Jan and I found this little book packed with a plethora of questions, ones we often struggled to comprehend, and yet this story is powerful and timely.

For what seems to be a very long time, courtroom drama has become a voyeuristic look into the workings of our legal system. Spurred on by the now famous OJ Simpson trial followed
May 02, 2019 rated it it was amazing
A sensational murder trial would soon commence in Central Florida. A six-person jury would be selected. Potential jurors C-2 and F-17 flirt while waiting to be interviewed. The jury box chosen consists of five women and one man with one alternate, if needed. C-2 and F-17 are both chosen to serve on the jury. The trial, requiring sequestration, will last for approximately three weeks.

Juror C-2 is a former portrait photographer for Rolling Stone Magazine. Uninterested in working in this capacity,
Dec 29, 2019 rated it really liked it
Shelves: dec-2019-reads
This was a superb, little novel that served as my last read of 2019. I was shocked when I went back and read the Goodreads summary that it gives so much away. I think it serves a person considering this as their next read well to completely ignore the summary and know one thing: This is not a typical courtroom drama. The drama surrounds the jury; particularly jurors C-2 and F-17. The case itself takes a backseat to the lives of our two main jurors, their affair and the outcome that affair has on ...more
Kelly (and the Book Boar)
Find all of my reviews at: http://52bookminimum.blogspot.com/

2.5 Stars

I picked up The Body In Question after reading JanB’s amazing review (proving once again that Goodreads has some seriously talented bookpushers in its midst). I followed her suggestion and went in blind, but fully admit I had presuppositions (is that the word I’m looking for? probably not) since this was a book that focused on the jury rather than the accused, victim or attorney parties that it would be a bit . . . .

If I
Mar 20, 2020 rated it it was ok
Was this about a murder trial? An elicit affair to while away the hours in between the trial? Dealing with end of life issues? There is too much and also not enough.

This author and I are not a good fit. I read a previous book, Heroic Measures, and I had the same feelings of detachment from the story and characters turning the last page and asking myself…and the point was?

There are many glowing reviews, I’m definitely in the minority on this jury, but my verdict is guilty by reason of inconsequen
Jessica Woodbury
You know all those fancy literary novels where you read hundreds of pages of beautiful prose but nothing happens? This is not that. This is a fancy literary novel, but at its center is a whole lot of plot. It is still Literary Fiction, so of course there are well-off middle-aged white people and double of course there is marital infidelity. But there is also a high-profile trial where a teenage girl is accused of murder. (Note: this involves the death of a child, and it's rather gruesome if that ...more
Jun 18, 2019 rated it it was amazing  ·  review of another edition
5 Stars. Loved it! Thank you Elyse...
Thought I would like this but didn't. Should have more to say but don't. ...more
Sep 23, 2019 rated it really liked it
Do human impulses need reasons? A hard hitting novel that explores the potential damages of infidelity. Almost unrelenting tension builds towards an emotionally satisfying ending. You may want to set some uninterrupted time aside for this. Once you start you likely won’t want to stop.
Jun 06, 2019 rated it it was amazing
From the first page of The Body in Question, there was no question: this was going to be a riveting read. I picked it up mid-afternoon and by nightfall, the house could have fallen down on me and I would not have even noticed. That’s how good this book is.

The book centers around a sensationalistic trial in Central Florida – think something like Casey Anderson. The defendant: a wealthy teenage girl who may be on the spectrum who is accused of a heinous murder. Jurors are chosen and sequestered, a
In central Florida, a photographer is called to jury duty. The trial is sensational, high-profile stuff: a teenage girl is accused of murdering her 18-month-old brother by way of arson. During sequestration, the photographer begins an affair with another juror, an anatomy professor. Throughout the trial, we only know the photographer and her lover by their court aliases, C-2 and F-17. Only much later are we told what they're really called; it's funny how those real names never quite seem to fit. ...more
Nov 09, 2019 rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
3.5 stars

I wouldn’t have chosen this one, but I read it for a book club. The Body in Question is an odd little novel. It seems a bit disjointed, with lots of plot strands that eventually come together at the end. Hannah is in her 50s, married to a man in his late 70s. She is called for jury duty, for a horrendous murder trial. The story focuses on the relationship between the jurors, Hannah’s relationship with her husband, and the family at the centre of the murder trial. It’s not a mystery, but
Cathrine ☯️
Nov 26, 2019 rated it really liked it
4✚ 🚬 🚬 🚬 🚬
This is a short and smart intoxicating read. Just like the six jurors have to discuss and deliberate their verdict, so too the reader will wish (s)he has an in person book club to mull this one over. The acts of judging others and self-indulgence with all accompanying consequences are all over the pages and will remain in your brain for a while after completion.
Caution: this one may make you want to take up smoking or start again if you've quit. Once the smoke clears you're not sure a
Jun 18, 2019 rated it really liked it
4.5 stars and my second enthralling modern read within one week. Unheard of!

This one is short and like a flaming arrow hitting a target 100 yards away within 2 inches of the bulls' eye in the end zone. It's adult and starkly real. And the first 2/3rds didn't at all lead me to believe what the last 1/3rd ending entailed at all. And I'm a fairly good guesser.

Jill Clement has gotten the mundane reality of jury duty even within homicide trials of wide acclaim/ media exposure. Plus she has another HU
Aug 15, 2019 rated it liked it  ·  review of another edition
It was a mistake not reviewing this book immediately upon finishing it. After a week long beach vacation, this book seems just out of mental reach. It is a quick read that presents the jury in an interesting light. Different, but forgettable for me.
♥ Sandi ❣
4 stars Thank you to Penguins First to Read and Pantheon for allowing me to read and review this ARC. Publishes June 11, 2019.

This was a story within a story. While sitting on a jury, two of the jurors started an affair. Juror C-2 and Juror F-17, as they are known throughout most of the novel, are sneaking around and quickly falling in love. C-2 is married to an older man. F-17 is a single anatomy professor.

The trial the jurors become sequestered for involves a set of twin girls, one of whom se
Dec 10, 2019 rated it it was ok
This is a tiny little book, barely five hours to listen to the whole thing. If it had been much longer, I don’t know if I would have stuck with it. The story just didn’t land with me, and I never really connected with any of the characters. I was mildly entertained enough, but just never really invested enough to care too much about what was happening.

And, yes, some pretty wild things happen! There is a horrific murder which brings these jurors together, but even that felt flat to me. The trial
luce (currently recovering from a hiatus)
| | blog | tumblr | ko-fi | |

3.25 stars

“A flirtation would make the sequestered nights more interesting. ”

This was an interesting novella that reminded me of some short stories by Joyce Carol Oates. There is this sense of unease which permeates the narrative as well as a growing sense of foreboding. The writing style is intentionally detached, for instance addressing two of the main character as C-2 and F-17, and the other jurors by nicknames (deriving from their profession or some physical a
May 13, 2019 rated it it was amazing  ·  review of another edition
A teenage girl has been accused of murdering her toddler brother in a horrific way. The jury for her murder trial has been chosen and sequestered in an Econo Lodge. Jurist Hannah, known in much of the book as juror C-2, is a 52-year old married well-known photographer. She’s married to a much-older man, an 85-year-old Pulitzer Prize winner. She finds that she’s very attracted to one of the jurists, Graham (known as juror F-17), who is a 41-year-old anatomy professor. Hannah and Graham find ways ...more
Jul 09, 2019 rated it it was ok
Shelves: fiction
I was initially drawn to this book because of it's basic description - two people called to jury duty, sequestered for a few weeks as a high profile murder trial plays out, who begin an affair with one another and possibly fumble their roles as jury members because of it. It sounded like a new, slightly provocative take on the legal thriller genre. Turns out, everything from the plotlines to the style of storytelling were way too remote and cold for my liking.

C-2 and F-17 (the two jurors) were n
5.0 Stars — The Body in question is part court/jury procedural, part contemporary- light-drama & perhaps part mystery. The important thing, is that it’s bloody brilliant!!!

Full review to come, more cogitative thought required to permeate my language here..
Tamar...playing hooky for a few hours today
I don’t like to give a bad review so this will be short. I wish C-2 had been an unreliable character, I might have found something nice to say.
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 next »
topics  posts  views  last activity   
The Ending? 3 44 Feb 28, 2020 07:37PM  

Readers also enjoyed

  • The Body Double
  • A Good Man
  • Buried Beneath the Baobab Tree
  • Maybe You Should Talk to Someone
  • Ghost Lover
  • Beijing Payback
  • Stay and Fight
  • Pursuit
  • Devotion
  • Agent Running in the Field
  • Never Look Back
  • The Sentence is Death (Hawthorne and Horowitz Mystery, #2)
  • Biloxi
  • City of Girls
  • Afternoon of a Faun
  • Recursion
  • The Travelers
  • Dual Citizens
See similar books…
See top shelves…
Jill Ciment was born in Montreal, Canada. She is the author of Small Claims, a collection of short stories and novellas; The Law of Falling Bodies, Teeth of the Dog, The Tattoo Artist, and Heroic Measures, novels; and Half a Life, a memoir. She has been awarded a National Endowment for the Arts, a NEA Japan Fellowship Prize, two New York State Fellowships for the Arts, the Janet Heidinger Kafka Pr ...more

Related Articles

Here at Goodreads World Headquarters, we like to encourage an informal, lateral-thinking approach to reading. If you’ve never tried it, themed...
152 likes · 21 comments
“Grief doesn’t feel as if a rug has been pulled out from under her. There is no rug. There is no floor on which to lay a rug. There is no ground on which to build a floor to lay a rug.” 1 likes
“The stars are beautiful—diamonds, twinkles, something you can wish upon. The space in between the stars is the sublime—cold, black, and infinite, something that inspires awe and fear.” 0 likes
More quotes…