Here is my review of Fir Lodge
Immersion: 4 of 5
There is a monstrous amount of time travel. Thankfully there are date/time tags at the start of each chapter to orient yourself with what day it is… and how many times its been that date. While some jumps in time broke my immersion (mine, not necessarily yours), I was re-immersed quickly.
Now… with that critique out of the way, I was very invested in the story, emotionally!
I felt Hal and Kara’s: happiness, fears, sadness, despair, and much more.
I felt everything!
It’s one thing to write a story, it’s another to make your reader feel emotions at every turn!
Though I have finished the story, I’m still feeling everything, it sunk in deep.
I can’t say that about a lot of books.
Characters: 5 of 5
There are a lot of characters, which may have also factored into my immersion
“Who is this guy again?”
That said, Hal and Kara! My goodness. I feel like I know them.
I felt their friendship grow throughout their long journey.
I understood them both, how they were going to react to situations.
They had sweet, funny, cringy (good kind), emotional moments.
I honestly was shipping them halfway through, then I stopped myself.
Why? This is the kind of friendship that doesn’t need to turn romantic.
Not quite the same, but I felt it was a Frodo & Sam kind of friendship.
Anytime you make me think LoTR’s, you’re on a solid path
Ending: 5 of 5
No spoilers…
It definitely sets up for a sequel
(which I knew going into this 😉)
Overall, I’m happy with the ending
It’s satisfying while also answering the question
“What happens next?”
Storyline: 5 of 5
This was masterful!
I’m not going to write a wall of text, simply put, this story was thought out and plan to a T
Every “What if” I could think of was answered in a dramatic life or death fashion
The stakes were high, and I was with Hal & Kara at every discovery
This is storytelling done right!
Personal Enjoyment: 5 of 5
I loved this book!
Author Sean McMahon, I can see why other authors have sited you as their inspiration
Your work is inspiring!
I enjoyed every up and down, twist and turn.
Potential reader
If you have any reservations whether to buy this book
I am here to tell you to dash them
You will enjoy this book as I have
Final Score: 24 out of 25
4.8 Stars!