What do you think?
Rate this book
ベイビーポップ [Baby Pop] #1
Baby Pop Volume 1
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 4 of 4 reviews
May 15, 2017
Father and daughter relationship. Not smut for pete's sake.
May 24, 2012
Originally posted here.
The only reason I read this manga is because I love Tramps Like Us (Kimi Wa Petto), one of Yayoi Ogawa's other manga. This one held no other appeal for me. The cover and the subject is wholly unappealing. I hoped that there might be a similar charm to this series, but no such luck.
Baby Pop is about a girl stuck living with her stepfather after the death of her mother. I spent the whole manga worrying that this would turn out to be a romance between the two. This seemed a definite possibility given the character of Ryunosuke and the fact that Tramps Like Us is about a relationship with an age gap. Thankfully, this turned out not to be the case, or, at least, it didn't happen during these two volumes. Either way, my enjoyment was colored by that possibility. I was just creeped out all the way through.
The manga also isn't well-constructed. To some degree, this may be because of its brevity. Plot lines come and go (like a random kidnapping...is it possible to write a manga without a kidnapping scene? who knows?!) without ever really seeming to flow, and the ending just sort of happens. That's why I'm not sure if it was supposed to be trying to set the daughter and stepfather up for a romantic relationship. I was really surprised when I got to the end, because there was no resolution. I really don't know what the point of that was.
Nagisa is a strong girl, not emotional and definitely more under control than Ryo. However, I didn't connect with her at all, because she was so reserved. She seemed to be largely without a personality. I can see, I think, what she was trying to do. I suppose this was meant to be a sweet tale of Nagisa and Ryu forming a strong family bond despite the awkward circumstances in which they are left together. However, his manga was really just a fail. Give this one a pass.
The only reason I read this manga is because I love Tramps Like Us (Kimi Wa Petto), one of Yayoi Ogawa's other manga. This one held no other appeal for me. The cover and the subject is wholly unappealing. I hoped that there might be a similar charm to this series, but no such luck.
Baby Pop is about a girl stuck living with her stepfather after the death of her mother. I spent the whole manga worrying that this would turn out to be a romance between the two. This seemed a definite possibility given the character of Ryunosuke and the fact that Tramps Like Us is about a relationship with an age gap. Thankfully, this turned out not to be the case, or, at least, it didn't happen during these two volumes. Either way, my enjoyment was colored by that possibility. I was just creeped out all the way through.
The manga also isn't well-constructed. To some degree, this may be because of its brevity. Plot lines come and go (like a random kidnapping...is it possible to write a manga without a kidnapping scene? who knows?!) without ever really seeming to flow, and the ending just sort of happens. That's why I'm not sure if it was supposed to be trying to set the daughter and stepfather up for a romantic relationship. I was really surprised when I got to the end, because there was no resolution. I really don't know what the point of that was.
Nagisa is a strong girl, not emotional and definitely more under control than Ryo. However, I didn't connect with her at all, because she was so reserved. She seemed to be largely without a personality. I can see, I think, what she was trying to do. I suppose this was meant to be a sweet tale of Nagisa and Ryu forming a strong family bond despite the awkward circumstances in which they are left together. However, his manga was really just a fail. Give this one a pass.
June 3, 2012
Very irritating story about a girl and her stepfather. I feared there would be any explecit sex between those two involved, but thank God, nothing like that happened. I also didn't really like the style, or how there was no real foreshadowing.. It was all so straight-forward and in the end the only character who had some personality was stepdad-san, whose name I have already forgotten.. Ryo? Hm.
February 28, 2010
This is about an interesting father-daughter relationship, josei style. An interesting take on their family, but its inconclusive. I would like it better if it had a solid ending.
Displaying 1 - 4 of 4 reviews