Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read.
Start by marking “Holy Cow: An Indian Adventure” as Want to Read:
Holy Cow: An Indian Adventure
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating
Open Preview

Holy Cow: An Indian Adventure

3.53  ·  Rating details ·  17,271 ratings  ·  1,291 reviews
In her twenties, journalist Sarah Macdonald backpacked around India and came away with a lasting impression of heat, pollution and poverty. So when an airport beggar read her palm and told her she would return to India—and for love—she screamed, “Never!” and gave the country, and him, the finger.

But eleven years later, the prophecy comes true. When the love of Sarah’s life
Paperback, First Broadway Books Trade Paperback Edition, 291 pages
Published 2003 by Broadway Books (first published January 1st 2002)
More Details... Edit Details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Reader Q&A

To ask other readers questions about Holy Cow, please sign up.

Be the first to ask a question about Holy Cow

Community Reviews

Showing 1-30
Average rating 3.53  · 
Rating details
 ·  17,271 ratings  ·  1,291 reviews

More filters
Sort order
Start your review of Holy Cow: An Indian Adventure
I have to admit that I decided to read this book because it has a great cover. I should have peeked a bit inside, though, because the cliched chapter titles would have kept me away: Insane in the Membrane, Birds of a Feather Become Extinct Together, etc.

Basically, this is the memoir of a selfish Australian woman's year in India. She sees India as a filthy place full of disgusting people with intolerable cultural habits. And she spends her free time (while her husband is working in other cities o
Nov 25, 2007 rated it did not like it
"Holy Cow" by Sarah Macdonald is the author's condescending account of time she spent in India. Her descriptions of what is actually a beautiful, rich, varied culture are narrow-minded and written in a tone that makes it clear she considers herself superior to India and Indian people. It's a shame that she didn't learn anything useful from her travels or absorb any of admirable values of Indian/Hindu culture such as acceptance, open-mindedness and respect for all beings.

Last but not least, the c
Petra has a cold and is hoping its just that
India as a giant spiritual supermarket! Sarah Macdonald peruses the aisles and samples the product. Jainism here, Judaism there, Hindus, Parsis, Buddhists, Sufis and Christians she samples all their wares. And the book is just about as superficial as it sounds. It is not about these religions (although Sarah does try for some depth) but about her experiences of them with some rather wacky people. Both the 'magical' gurus and the hippie-types who sit at their feet and swoon.

Sarah, like the advent
Amit Chawla
Jan 01, 2013 rated it did not like it
Shelves: trash
I read the book while holidaying in Northern NSW. The reason I read this book was because it was on the bookshelf in the holiday home we had for the week. Also because it was supposed to talk about India from a Westerners perspective.

Let me put it out there: this book is not a travelogue. It is a miserable portrayal of a difficult to understand country by a selfish Australian woman. A lot of what she passes off in the book is exaggeration. In other words, fiction. Do NOT use this book as a deci
Aug 22, 2008 rated it really liked it
If you have a lingering, romanticized desire to travel to India, this book will cure it.

Krishna! Does this woman tell it like it is: the pollution, trash, urine, feces and dismembered body parts clogging up the Indian landscape and water ways. Impossible traffic and hoards of desperate people pressing in on you from all sides, limping zombie lepers chasing you through dark alleys begging for coins, Indian men aggressively groping western women in public because they think all white women are slu
Jan 09, 2008 rated it did not like it
If I could give a book negative stars, it would be this one. This girl seemed to complain about everything she was experiencing in India. I think I yelled at the book every chapter, "GO HOME!" I read the whole thing hoping to witness her enlightenment and was highly disappointed. If you want a book which will give you more insight about India, read Motiba's Tattoos! ...more
René Edde
Jan 21, 2008 rated it it was amazing
India with humor, the only way to take the country in stride. This book captured the heart and the essence of India and its vast array of religions and cultures, all from the outsiders perspective. I have read this book a few times and know I will read it again. But, for a bigger treat, check out the audiobook. A take on India and its many accents all with the drawl of an Australian accident. This book made me laugh so hard while driving to assignments that I nearly wet my pants.

Perfect read fo
Nenia ✨ I yeet my books back and forth ✨ Campbell

Instagram || Twitter || Facebook || Amazon || Pinterest

I have very mixed feelings about HOLY COW. On the one hand, it's a memoir about a place I am unlikely to go and it was interesting to see a journalist's take on the people and the culture, since if I can't travel somewhere, it's fun to enjoy it vicariously. But on the other hand, this memoir is very dated (published in 2002) with some very outmoded views towards people of color and she takes a decidedly Western slant when talking about s
Corey Fry
Dec 15, 2008 rated it liked it
A good book that no one should take too seriously. She actually starts off a selfish, egocentric woman aghast at the quality of Indian life and grows into a spiritual investigative journalist of sorts.

I traveled to India this past year and her accounts from a western perspective are accurate. But with time, the beauty of India reveals itself to travelers and she shares this with readers.

It's a funny memoir that gives a cursory background of the spiritual-religious forces existent in modern India
OK first up - I haven't read this book and neither do I intend to. The simple reason being that everything a westerner (or an easterner for that matter) had to say about the dichotomy of modern India, has been magnificently captured and related by Shantaram by Gregory David Roberts and any book by William Dalrymple.

That's it. Done. You won't need anything else.

But the reason why I am writing this "review" is just one : The issues Indians on this discussion board have with the book's cover.

What is so strange/weird/unacce
Mar 09, 2016 rated it did not like it
Shelves: ugh-hate-ed-it
I wish I could give this book zero stars. What a condescending, racist piece of garbage. Why write about going to India if you didn't even like it? I saw this book sold in stores everywhere in India and I wish they would take it off the shelves. Sarah MacDonald is a peddler of lies about this truly phenomenal country. Please don't read it. ...more
Feb 20, 2013 rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
I first read ‘Holy Cow’ in 2006 or 2007. It was interesting to look at Indian diversity and idiosyncrasies through the eyes of an outsider who wanted to make sense of the chaos. I loved it. But in order to appreciate this book, you must have the ability to laugh at India’s eccentricities. It is one of the very few books which I have re-read and enjoyed.

Sarah Macdonald, an Australian journalist, broadcaster and presenter, did not like India on her first visit and never wanted to return. But she r
I enjoy books exploring the different cultures and customs of the world. I enjoy a well-written memoir exploring those discoveries, but I finally put this one aside about 3/4 of the way through it. I tried, I truly tried to finish it, but with so many wonderful books out there waiting to be read, I couldn't justify spending another minute listening to this poor, lost woman attempt to "find herself" or the meaning of life that she was so desperately seeking.

I had read reviews mentioning that ther
I'm actually surprised I disliked this book as much as I did! I expected an hilarious account of a girl travelling to India, a place where she'd been to previously but never wanted to return to. Well, she did and she did do some travelling but it wasn't hilarious by any stretch of the imagination... She used to be a radio host in Sydney, so I figured I'd really relate to her humour but hm, there just wasn't much of that.

Since I listened to the audiobook, read by the author, what I must credit to
Jun 22, 2021 marked it as will-not-read
are you serious? the blurb sounds so condescending. Fuck you, author.
Finished. 5 stars from me. Review to come.

So cold here at the moment I needed to read something about a warm place. India is on my list of places to visit before I die so till then I can't get enough books to whet my appetite. It was a pleasant surprise to find out Sarah Macdonald is Jonathan Harley's other half. He wrote "Lost in Transmission" which I liked tremendously. Harley writes about his time as ABC reporter in India & the east generally and Macdonald quit her job at Triple J & went over
Feb 19, 2012 rated it did not like it
After reading first chapter, I realized what I am heading to, but continued to read, as a bestseller should have some salt. And, indeed it was there, just in the name of crass Ozzie sense of humor she kept on rubbing on, Indian wounds.

Though her depiction of situation of civic situations in India and obscurity of religions is very true. But, when it becomes continuous ranting and predictable, it becomes derogatory and prejudiced. When she is deriding india she gets very detailed and elaborate, b
The first third of the book is fantastical poverty porn and reads like slumdog Borat attends Ripley's! There are lepers begging at the airport, ash-smeared naked aghoris at traffic signals in central Delhi, earthquakes that claimed hundreds and yet 'hardly is in the news' because it's common in India, Apollo is 'the only good hospital in New Delhi' but is 'half a city away' and has a 'For Poor People' special entrance, her boyfriend has to stay with her in her hospital room since rapes are very ...more
Christine Zibas
Feb 09, 2016 rated it it was amazing
As one might guess from the title, this Indian voyage is not for the serious-minded or those likely to take offense easily. For those with a sense of humor and adventure, however, this book is a delight. Australian Sarah Macdonald, backpacking the world at aged 21, could not wait to get out of a country beset by poverty, pollution, and chaos. At the airport, a beggar predicts that she will return to India one day for love.

Clearly, Macdonald had no intention of returning, yet 11 years later just
Aug 07, 2008 rated it it was ok
As far as I could tell, this was supposed to be a true story. The problem started when some of Sarah's anecdotes were just too fantastic, and clearly written in such a way as to convince her audience of jaded Westerners that the possibility of magic still exists in India. Additionally, some events were reworked to increase their impact (I would run some passages by my Indian friends to see if such claims were possible, such as a toilet cleaner calling a palm reading a "hand job"; the unanimous a ...more
Sep 28, 2007 rated it liked it
Shelves: travel
I enjoyed it and felt a little ashamed for enjoying it so much. The best chapter is the one about the Vipassana ten-day meditation boot-camp. I've done that, and she nailed it. The tone of the book bothers me, though. It's written from a position of comfortable privilege: an American middle-class woman survives the hardships of travel in India. I think the author genuinely responds viscerally and spiritually to India, but I'd rather read a less-mediated version of India from, say, Arundhati Roy, ...more
Jun 23, 2021 marked it as might-read
Not sure whether to read this lol. I don't know...the description is a bit questionable. I might give it a try some time though? ...more
Last winter, during my Rajasthan tour, I came across a small bookstore in Jaisalmer and, I kid you not, copies of this book were more than half of the total books that the store had to offer. Surprised I asked, "Why?" "Foreigners love this book, Sir. I sell 10-15 of this every month," was the smiling response from the seller. An interesting title, an attention grabbing cover and an excitement to read about my idiosyncratic country from a visiting foreigner's perspective motivated me to grab a co ...more
Daniel Roy
May 03, 2011 rated it really liked it
Shelves: non-fiction, travel
I loved this book once I finished it; however, the cover, title and back cover are misleading.

I expected a humorous romp through India, but this book really explores serious themes and real-life situations, albeit with humor. I wanted a light-hearted introduction to India as I was headed there - what I got instead was a hard look at some of the good and not-so-good about India.

I found the beginning of the book hard to take, bordering on xenophobic; the tone changes as the author begins to "under
Jul 27, 2016 added it
There are no stars because it didn't deserve one!
Holy Cow: An Indian Adventure by Sarah MacDonald
-1 ★'s

From The Book:
In her twenties, journalist Sarah MacDonald backpacked around India and came away with a lasting impression of heat, pollution and poverty. So when an airport beggar read her palm and told her she would return to India—and for love—she screamed, “Never!” and gave the country, and him, the finger.

But eleven years later, the prophecy comes true. When the love of Sarah’s life is post
Jan 01, 2013 rated it really liked it
Holy Cow: An Indian Adventure by Sarah Macdonald
3.5 stars

'In India I’ve travelled a soul’s journey: from hedonism to sickness, from silence to song, from violence to peace and from learning to die to celebrating life.'

The above passage beautifully encapsulates this entertaining and thought-provoking travel memoir. I decided to read Holy Cow so I could kill two birds with one stone: to gain more knowledge about India before my upcoming trip, and to kick off the Australian Women Writers’ Challenge
Marcel Patrick
Sep 06, 2015 rated it really liked it
All the reviews that give this book a low rating makes me wonder if they're missing the point! This was a heart opening book aptly conveying the challenge of living within a culture that brings all of ones judgement, criticism and shadow side to the fore.

Kudos to the author for her ongoing quest in her development of compassion and the process of striving to bring more peace both to her life and others. The spiritual journey is always a contradiction as after all we are only human and she does
I've read some bad reviews of this book, and therefore have put it off. But I decided I should finally give it a go. And it started off as bad as I expected. An entitled, white, Australian heading to India and bitching and moaning the whole way.

I missed Sarah on radio, as I was at school while her program was on Triple J. So I caught every other show on radio, except the 9am-12pm slot. Maybe that would have endeared me to her before reading this book, because she needs all the help she can get
Will Byrnes
Oct 05, 2008 rated it liked it
Shelves: nonfiction
Macdonald was a TV journalist in Australia. She leaves the comforts of home for true love, joining her boyfriend, also a reporter, in India. This book recounts her experiences and observations there as she attempts to sample the many forms of religion that India has to offer, including Christianity and Judaism. She is a young woman, without a strong background in religious study, so functions as an everyman, or in this case, an everywoman. She describes her experiences in an engaging manner, not ...more
Sep 03, 2016 rated it did not like it
While living in USA, I continuously miss my home country India; thus, I thought of reading a book based on India expecting it to refresh my memories. I opted for “A Holy Cow”, but soon I realized I have made a wrong choice. Her description of India is as if someone is visiting a poor’s house and making a mockery of his poverty. Since I’m an Indian my review might be considered a biased one, but my intention is just to be logical. After reading the initial few pages it appeared as if the writer i ...more
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 next »
There are no discussion topics on this book yet. Be the first to start one »

Readers also enjoyed

  • Almost French: Love and a New Life in Paris
  • Shantaram
  • Able: Gold Medals, Grand Slams and Smashing Glass Ceilings
  • The Beach
  • Through Sand & Snow: a man, a bicycle, and a 43,000-mile journey to adulthood via the ends of the Earth
  • Picnic, Lightning
  • Himalaya
  • The Sex Lives of Cannibals: Adrift in the Equatorial Pacific
  • Paper Towns: by John Green -- Sidekick
  • One Bright Moon
  • The Silver Metal Lover (Silver Metal Lover, #1)
  • City of Djinns: A Year in Delhi
  • The Mountain People
  • Lost on Planet China: The Strange and True Story of One Man's Attempt to Understand the World's Most Mystifying Nation, or How He Became Comfortable Eating Live Squid
  • Fresh Air Fiend: Travel Writings
  • Islands in the Sky
  • Biggles Flies East
  • The Malice of Unnatural Death (Knights Templar, #22)
See similar books…
See top shelves…
Sarah Macdonald is an Australian journalist, author and radio presenter.

After completing a cadetship at ABC NewsRadio, Macdonald worked as Triple J's political correspondent in Canberra, later hosting its morning show. She has worked in television on programs such as Recovery, Race Around the World and Two Shot, and presented on radio station 702 ABC in Sydney. In 1999 Macdonald left Triple J, to

Related Articles

Need another excuse to treat yourself to a new book this week? We've got you covered with the buzziest new releases of the day. To create our...
35 likes · 5 comments
“The cycle of violence needs extreme love to break it.” 16 likes
“India is beyond statement, for anything you say, the opposite is also true. It's rich and poor, spiritual and material, cruel and kind, angry but peaceful, ugly and beautiful, and smart but stupid. It's all the extremes.” 13 likes
More quotes…