Sidney Crosby has already been hailed as the NHL's next saviour. Young, bright, photgenic, personable and a media darling, the only question that remained was whether he could handle the big time. From an international advertising deal with Reebok to a season that seems to go from triumph to triumph, Sid the Kid has proven that he alreasdy is the man. In the tradition of A Season on the Brink and Peter Gzowksi's The Game of Our Lives, Shawna Richer has had the exclusive assignment of chronicling Sidney Crosby's incredible rookie season. Beginning with the NHL entry draft that alwmost never was, Richer follows Crosby to Pittsburgh, where he is greeted as the team's saviour and moves in with living legend Mario Lemieux. From there it's onto the ice, where the team's youngest player proves to be its best player day in and day out, staying on pace to se rookie scoring records while the team loses and is forced to first it's coach.
Very good account of Sidney Crosby's rookie season with the Pittsburgh Penguins in 2005-2006. I'm pretty sure that any use of the phrase "beestung lips" is too many - this book used it three times! As a Pens' fan, it was fascinating to discover the origin of the much-repeated taunt about Crosby diving (blame the Flyers) and disheartening to realize that several of the things Crosby knew he needed to work on during his rookie season (such as letting rival teams get him wound up to put him off his game) remain problems for him today.
The writing was a little weird at times, as Richer would gloss over a specific time-like the Olympics or something-and then come back a few paragraphs later and explain it in detail, which could get a bit confusing, but it was still interesting. As someone who grew up reading biographies of the "greats" that had retired (many of which are mentioned in this book) it felt a little funny to read about a player that began playing just a few years after I was born, and who is still playing. Of course, it is a hockey biographies, so there are a few (1-2) mentions of taking the Lord's name in vain, several mentions of hockey players being fluent in profanity, whether they were French or English, mentions of injuries (mostly non-detailed), mentions of the rookie being allowed to have girls over to the Lemieux house, but not being able to have them sleep over. Honestly, for a secular book about hockey players, it felt much cleaner than the Wayne Gretzky I read the other year. But that book was written by two men, and this one by a woman, which probably makes a difference in having less mentions of the locker room things.
Genuinely think this book reads best in hindsight. I’m sure it was still great and engaging in 2006, but it’s way more fun to read about Sid being left off the ‘06 Olympics roster and what he might do in 2010 when you know the answer is as good as it is. The same is true for all the hypotheticals posed in here about his and the Penguins’ future.
This was just a fun read, which really speaks to Richer’s ability to hone her narrative considering how disappointing the 05-06 season was overall. Problem after problem arises, but you never want to quit on the book or on the team. It really makes you appreciate how insane it was that he ended the season with 102 points. How insane it was that this 18 year old boy, already with more media pressure than a FOA had ever dealt with, was often the only player available to the media after countless horrible losses. Well. 60 horrible losses.
I could probably talk about this book for way longer than anyone should have to tolerate, so I’ll leave off here:
It’s not a perfect book, and I think it may “objectively” be a 4 star read, but Richer points out “to be objective in the literal sense would be to remove all emotion from the coverage, and sportswriting at its best can only be worthwhile by embracing and exposing emotion and all things that fuel it.” So. 5 stars. To me.
Loved all the quotes and the day-by-day perspective.
Reading this in 2021, we know it all worked out! The Penguins stayed in Pittsburgh, Mario kept the team until just this month, the Penguins went to the Stanley Cup finals in 2008 and won 3 times, Sid won gold with Canada at the 2010 and 2014 Olympics, etc.
great behind-the-scenes access to a team that comes out of the NHL lockout with great hopes but watches them crumble ... A season that saw the retirement of a legend (Mario Lemieux), the retirement of an enigma (Ziggy Palffy) and the firing of a coach (Eddi Olczyk) also saw Sidney Crosby prove himself in the NHL. The writing could have been a bit stronger, but the access and anecdotes are worth the price.
In a properly run world, more women would be writing about sports. Richer balances her hockey expertise with an eye for human nature to craft a fascinating book out of a single hockey season. She writes with humanity yet detachment, and never follows the party line like male reporters. I began with neutral feelings about Crosby, but by the end, I was cheering him on.
Quite a good read if you like hockey and even better if you are a fan of Sidney Crosby. The book talk about the NHl's tranistion into a faster pace. Another thing the book talks about is the new and upcoming star Sidney Crosby, more precisly how Sidney Crosby got to the NHL.
It's a good record of events for people who didn't follow the team, but a lot of what was written could've been gleaned from the local newspapers. It's decent for what it is, but not great.
Outstanding sports book! (If anyone knows of any other other good Hockey books, please drop me a line!). Highly recommend this book to any Hockey fan or Sports fan.
A few repeated anecdotes, but all in all, a compelling and engaging read. It's a bit hagiographic, but since Crosby tends to attract either hagiography or hatred, I'll be satisfied with the former.
My obsession with Sidney Crosby is officially off the rails. Still though, it was a super interesting read, it never got dull or overly technical and it was pretty insightful.
Decent. Crosby is basically LeBron James, but I just don't care enough about hockey to get gripped by a story that lacked intense drama. The account of Philly sports fans acting psycho was well-put.