Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read.
Start by marking “Mistletoe Magic” as Want to Read:
Mistletoe Magic
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating
Open Preview

Mistletoe Magic

(A Holiday Romance Novel #2)

4.41  ·  Rating details ·  87 ratings  ·  61 reviews
This is an ACE of ASIN:B076C9374Z Mistletoe Magic

A mistletoe. A kiss. This just might be the start of a beautiful Christmas.

Theresa might not make the best pot of coffee in town, but people still flock to the diner for a cup, even Officer Crowl, who rarely displays a smile since his fiancé died. She’ll never be able to win his heart, but it’s hard to resist him, especially
Kindle Edition
Published December 1st 2017
More Details... Edit Details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Reader Q&A

To ask other readers questions about Mistletoe Magic, please sign up.

Be the first to ask a question about Mistletoe Magic

This book is not yet featured on Listopia. Add this book to your favorite list »

Community Reviews

Showing 1-30
Average rating 4.41  · 
Rating details
 ·  87 ratings  ·  61 reviews

More filters
Sort order
Start your review of Mistletoe Magic
Can you imagine having people bet on how bad your coffee will be? Sure, it has become the town joke, and people even buy Theresa’s coffee often just to see if it can get worse, but no one gets her attention like Officer Crowl, should rhyme with Growl, the sober-faced man who has secretly stolen her heart. It isn’t the coffee that has him so dour, it is the death of his fiancé and Theresa would do anything to be the one who puts a smile back on the handsome officer’s face, guess he would have to ...more
Sherry Fundin
Mistletoe Magic by Amanda Siegrist is a very appropriate title, but I won’t spoil the surprise for you. It may be predictable but there are some special moments that put a smile on my face and a happy ever after in their future.

Theresa works at the diner and is known for making the worst cup of coffee, but Officer Aiden Crowl comes every day for his cuppa. The precinct even has a bet on whether or not she will every make a good pot. She has always had a crush on him, going back to high school, a
Oct 27, 2017 rated it it was amazing
What a sweet story Mistletoe Magic was! I was not sure at first how I felt about Officer Aiden Crowl because he was quite a jerk. I loved Theresa Brennen’s character though. She was a sweet small-town girl who may not have had the best of opportunities but she made do with what she had. Despite growing up on the wrong side of town she was not jaded and was satisfied with her life for the most part. She did of course wish for someone to share her life with but so far that had not been in the card ...more
Sexy opposites attract Christmas read with a bit of angst that will leave you with a warmth in your heart

Mistletoe Magic is a sexy opposites attract romance between a brooding cop and a barista who can’t make a decent coffee with secret feelings. Despite being slightly angsty and suspenseful, this is a cute Christmas read that will leave you with a warmth in your heart.

Theresa and Aidan, who tell the book through dual perspective, have a simmering chemistry that is nicely built up after a litt
Sharing My
Oct 22, 2020 rated it it was amazing  ·  review of another edition
A sweet and heartwarming story! I loved Theresa, and loved her positive attitude. No matter how little she had, or how long she has pined for Aiden l, she always had a positive attitude. Aiden, however, didn't have much of a positive attitude. Every since his fiance died, he has felt guilt, and he felt that he didn't deserve to be happy. He did look forward to seeing Theresa every day and drinking her horrible coffee. One mistletoe kiss has Aiden thinking more and more about Theresa. Will Aiden ...more
Dec 08, 2017 rated it really liked it
Mistletoe Magic - 3.5 stars

This is one of those books that I sat with before reviewing. I really wanted to like it because its got a hot cop in a small town and it's Christmas. Those three things are winners in my book.

While the characters were quickly developed and we learned their quirks early on, it took FOREVER for them to get their act together and figure out how to navigate the path of least resistance when pursing a relationship.

She is a waitress who makes horrible coffee yet everyone sti
Dec 23, 2017 rated it liked it
Shelves: romance
pretty cute little story
Brandy Thornton
Oct 28, 2017 rated it it was amazing
So there were several moments I wanted to smack Aiden for being an ass. But he totally redeemed himself. And quickly. I totally understood why he blamed himself for things that happened in the past, being the stand up guy he is and all. But we can't control everything in life, something I have trouble with myself. Hence why I understood Aiden, but again I still wanted to shake him. And Theresa amazed me. She works her tail off, even if her coffee sucks big time, she still gives 110% with everyth ...more
Bobbi Wagner
Dec 01, 2017 rated it it was amazing
Mistletoe Magic (A Holiday Romance Novel Book 2) by Amanda Siegrist is a sweet Christmas romance story that will warm your heart. This is my first book by this author and I can't wait to see what else she will have for us. This story will take you on a roller coaster ride of various emotions from laughter to maybe a few tears. It also has some twists and turns that you won't see coming. This story will show you that opposites can be attracted to each other and prove the old saying correct. This ...more
Dec 15, 2017 rated it really liked it
4 Stars

Mistletoe Magic is the second book in A Holiday Romance Series by Amanda Siegrist. This is a contemporary holiday romance that incorporates a small-town romance, a police romance and has a bit of a friends to lover’s aspect to the story. It is a standalone, and is a quick read.
Theresa is the waitress in the local diner and has a reputation for making the worst coffee ever. But this doesn’t stop people from buying it, as they often make bets on just how bad it will be, or whether it could
Kayla Morrell
Dec 02, 2017 rated it it was amazing
Mistletoe Magic by Amanda Siegrist is book two in A Holiday Romance Novel series. This light hearted romance novel was simply addicting, I read it in once sitting. The two main characters, Theresa and Officer Aiden Crowl have quite an interesting relationship. Theresa is a waitress in the local diner and has the hardest time making a good pot of coffee. Regardless of how bad Theresa’s coffee is, Aiden visits before every shift just to get some. Unfortunately, Aiden is not the most sociable perso ...more
Dec 06, 2017 rated it it was amazing
Mistletoe Magic by Amanda Siegrist is the second book in her Holiday Romance series. It was a very appropriate book to read while the holiday season is coming around and you feel there is something special in the air! You can easily read it as a standalone like I did, I guess it would have been great to have read the first book first as that would have set the scene and we’d know more about the other people that we came across in the story but I did at no point feel that I was missing something ...more
Dec 08, 2017 rated it it was amazing
Mistletoe Magic (A Holiday Romance Novel Book 2) by Amanda Siegrist

5 Stars

Awwww this was such a great read, quick, smooth, and fun! The words flowed perfectly, the storyline was great and if I wasn't already filled with Christmas spirit, this would have done it. This is my first book by this author and won't be my last, I can't wait to read Merry Me, the first in this series with The Chief and Lynn because I fell in love with them in this book. Also hoping the next might be about Bentley and Dap
Dec 02, 2017 rated it really liked it
Shelves: 2017
Mistletoe Magic by Amanda Siegrist is the second book in her Holiday Romance series, and it was a great holiday read that really kept me wanting to know more from the beginning to the end. This book focuses on Theresa and Aiden who both live in a very small town where any business is everyone’s business, so having any sort of private life just doesn’t happen without allot of planning. Theresa has a bit of a problem, no only can she not make a cup of coffee to save her life, she has had the bigge ...more
Dawn Daughenbaugh
Dec 13, 2017 rated it it was amazing
5 Star

Mistletoe Magic  (A Holiday Romance Novel Book 2 ) By Amanda Siegrist


Mistletoe Magic  ( A Holiday Romance Novel Book 2 By Amanda Siegrist Is a very heart warming Christmas romance story.I loved this story, I couldn't put it down once I started reading. This is my first book by this author but it definitely won't be my last.This story warmed my heart but also pulled at my strings as well.These characters will take you on a journey,about letting go and moving on. There are a few twists and
Jenni Bishop
Dec 12, 2017 rated it really liked it
Mistletoe Magic is book two in the A Holiday Romance Novel series by Amanda Siegrist. It is a contemporary Christmas romance story, that is told in the dual perspective of our main characters, which I love. I have not read the first book but it didn’t make much difference as I read this book.

Theresa works at the local diner and is happy with her life except for the one thing she craves, the one she has always been on the outside looking in. She has always had dreams but would those dreams ever
Katie Kearney
Dec 13, 2017 rated it it was amazing
Mistletoe Magic by Amanda Siegrist is a wonderfully written book about letting guilt go and living life to the fullest. This is book two in her Holiday Romance series but can be read as a standalone without hindering the story, I read this one first but will definitely be going back for book one! This story is about Aiden & Theresa. Aiden's letting the past rule his present and future and Theresa is waiting and hoping one day he'll wake up from his fog. These two have a connection that comes ali ...more
Dec 14, 2017 rated it it was amazing
Book Review: Mistletoe Magic
Author: Amanda Siegrist
A very sweet and suspenseful book. This book has its twists and turns and will keep you rivited to your seat. Turning page by page quickly as you scour the pages and read the delicious words. You will feel sorry for Theresa but you will quickly find you shouldn't. She definately has a hold of life by the horns and she will bounce back from anything.
Officer Crowl on the other hand is a Scrooge. His frosty demeanor and attitude is someth
Dec 17, 2017 rated it it was amazing
Mistletoe Magic is book 2 in A Holiday Romance by Amanda Siegrist. I did not know when I read it, that it was in a series. The book can be read as a standalone, but now I want to go read book 1. I really enjoyed this book The main characters were mostly likeable, Aiden annoyed me at time though, because he is kind of a jerk. His so back and forth and was really harsh and cold to Theresa, and sends mixed signals left and right. Even though he is rude, and confusing, she still is drawn to him. It ...more
Dec 08, 2017 rated it really liked it
a brilliant read about trying to move on. Officer Aiden Crawl is struggling with events after the loss of his fiancée. whilst doing so, he regularly visits Theresa's coffee shop diner for some coffee. As he becomes a regular customer, Theresa starts being friendly with him. Will Aiden move on to a new relationship or stick to the past?
A brilliant read. well developed plot. well developed characters, especially in the case of Aiden with his vulnerabilities and strengths to make him a more rounded
Kaitlynn Taylor
Dec 10, 2017 rated it really liked it
Mistletoe Magic- Amanda Siegrist

4 star review

Mistletoe Magic by Amanda Siegrist is a fun read filled with so much Christmas Cheer! It made for the perfect read for this time of year! It’s full of all things Christmas: baking, décor, Christmas trees, family, friends and of course Love!

Theresa and Aiden are two very different characters who manage to fit so well together. Their interactions were often awkward and silly yet I couldn’t help but love them together. I adored Theresa, she was so posit
Dec 15, 2017 rated it it was amazing
Mistletoe Magic (Holiday Romance Novel Book 2)
By Amanda Siegrist

Theresa works in a diner and possibly makes the worst coffee ever and, yet the customers keep coming back for more. Aiden is the hot policeman in town, and works a lot of hours which gives him absolutely no social life. Aiden and Theresa couldn’t be more different character wise, and yet they seem to fit together perfectly. Aiden has somewhat of an arrogant or unapproachable appeal to him but honestly this man is carrying so much g
Dec 16, 2017 rated it it was amazing
I loved Mistletoe Magic by Amanda Siegrist. This book is a Christmas romance. It takes a look at a small town waitress named Theresa and the local police officer Aiden.
Theresa works in the local cafe as a waitress she is not the best coffee maker but she is happy she has always felt that she has been on the outside looking in. Theresa loves what she does, she has had a major crush on Aiden since high school and she looks forward to him coming in every day for his coffee even if she is the worst
Krystal gaston
Dec 16, 2017 rated it really liked it
A Holiday Romance Novel Book 2: Mistletoe Magic written by Amanda Siegrist. This is a nice, slow romantic, difficult, love story. Nothing with love is ever easy though is it. The story starts off kind of slow, Mistletoe Magic is the type of book you savor and enjoy over a day or two. Not the type you splurge and speed read to get to the end as fast as you can. The story’s point of view alternates between Officer Aiden Crowl and Theresa’s point of view as they are the two main characters. Their r ...more
Dori cousley
Dec 01, 2017 rated it it was amazing
Mistletoe Magic is the second book in the Holiday Romance Novel Series by Amanda Siegrist, it is a sweet romance about second chances, love and forgiveness. Everybody in town knows how horrible Theresa’s coffee is, but always go back for more. Theresa has not had the easiest of lives, and does not help her brother James is an alcoholic with a violent temper. Then you have Officer Aiden Crowl, who has been miserable for the past year. This was due to the death of his fiance. Theresa has always ha ...more
Jean Martin
Dec 01, 2017 rated it it was amazing
Mistletoe Magic is a really great, sweet, wonderful christmas read. It is relatively short, I got through it in a night and, I wanted more. I really love Amanda Siegrist’s writing. She puts together a wonderful story full of very real people.
Ms. Siegrist has absolutely captured the spirit of Christmas. This story is full of forgiveness, redemption and love. It reiterates how important forgiveness is and how difficult it is to accomplish. Especially when the one you need to forgive is yourself.
Krystal Gregory
Dec 10, 2017 rated it liked it
Mistletoe Magic, is book 2 in the Holiday Romance Novels, by Amanda Siegrist. This book is full of cheer, love, and mistletoe mischief. I adore Ms. Siegrist’s build of characters in both Theresa and Aiden. Aiden is reeling from the loss of his fiance, but things are not what they seem. Theresa takes every day one day at a time. She adores Christmas, He is withdrawn and barley smiles, She needs his help one evening, he needs her help to rebuild what he believes is lost. This book had be laughing, ...more
Dec 11, 2017 rated it it was amazing
Mistletoe Magic is a beautiful holiday romance. Theresa is not a perfect woman. She has her flaws and a fairly hard life. She lives in a small town where everyone knows everything about everybody. She’s a waitress at the local diner and does what she can to get by. She also struggles with making a good cup of coffee.

Officer Aiden Crowl hasn’t been the same since tragedy occurred a year earlier. He can’t even bring himself to smile to make others happy. The reputation of the waitress who makes r
Lucy Berson
Dec 13, 2017 rated it it was amazing
A 5 star read for Mistletoe Magic, A Holiday Romance Novel by Amanda Siegrist. This is a new author to me. Getting into the holiday spirit and once I saw this, I knew I had to read it! I am so glad I found it.
Theresa has always had a secret crush on Officer Crowl. He comes in the diner where she works everyday for a cup of her coffee. Even tho the entire town knows that she makes the worst coffee. One day Theresa gets the shock of her life when Officer Crowl kisses her uber the mistletoe at the
Claire Griffiths
Dec 14, 2017 rated it it was amazing
I give 5 stars to Mistletoe Magic (A Holiday Romance Novel Book 2) written by Amanda Siegrist.

This is a first read for me from this author and I was not disappointed a great feel good Christmas read. Will be recommending to friends for a Christmas day read.

My favorite kind of read is dual POV which this book has.

This is a great Christmas story of a struggle to let go of the past, or to keep living in it.

Aiden Crawl is a officer of the law, and has being struggling with the death of his fianc
« previous 1 3 next »
There are no discussion topics on this book yet. Be the first to start one »

Readers also enjoyed

  • Wanted by the Marshal (Angel Point, #2)
  • Dark Path (Bodhi King #1)
  • Sensible Shoes: A Story about the Spiritual Journey (Sensible Shoes #1)
  • Breaking Defenses (BSU Football, #1)
  • Just Roommates (Blue Beech, #5)
  • When He's Dirty (Walker Security: Adrian’s Trilogy, #1)
  • Must Love Forever (425 Madison Novel, #11)
  • Fight From The Heart (Heart Collection, #4)
  • Merry & Bright
  • Hott and Handled
  • Wyoming True (Wyoming Men, #10)
  • Filthy Rich Revenge (Filthy Rich Billionaires, #1)
  • This Is Forever (This is, #4)
  • Swept Away: Love Trap (Stone Creek Book 1)
  • Her Butterfingers (Kappa Sweets Series #5)
  • Reclaim
  • Mr. Heartbreaker (Black Mountain Academy)
  • The Drowned Woman (Jericho and Wright, #2)
See similar books…
I’m a USA Today Bestselling Author that loves to write sweet contemporary romance and romantic suspense novels, although I am partial to romantic suspense. Honestly, I love anything that has to do with romance. As long as there's a happy ending, I'm a happy camper. And insta-love…yes, please! I love baseball (Go Twins!) and creating awesome crafts. I graduated with a Bachelor's Degree in Criminal ...more

Other books in the series

A Holiday Romance Novel (5 books)
  • Merry Me (Holiday Romance Novel, #1)
  • Christmas Wish (Holiday Romance Novel, #3)
  • Snowed in Love (Holiday Romance Novel, #4)
  • Snowflakes and Shots (Holiday Romance Novel, #5)

Related Articles

As an administrator in Student Affairs at Iowa State University, Denise Williams’ life on campus has not only distracted her from the "abnormal...
4 likes · 1 comments