Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read.
Start by marking “Carnegie's Maid” as Want to Read:
Carnegie's Maid
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating
Open Preview

Carnegie's Maid

3.94  ·  Rating details ·  47,911 ratings  ·  4,297 reviews

From the author of The Other Einstein, the mesmerizing tale of what kind of woman could have inspired an American dynasty.

Clara Kelley is not who they think she is. She's not the experienced Irish maid who was hired to work in one of Pittsburgh's grandest households. She's a poor farmer's daughter with nowhere to go and nothing in her pockets. But the other woman with the

Kindle Edition, 342 pages
Published January 16th 2018 by Sourcebooks Landmark
More Details... Edit Details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Reader Q&A

To ask other readers questions about Carnegie's Maid, please sign up.
Popular Answered Questions
Belleofbooks Absolutely none. In fact, the book portrays the proprietary rules of the day quite convincingly in my opinion. I think it would make an excellent book…moreAbsolutely none. In fact, the book portrays the proprietary rules of the day quite convincingly in my opinion. I think it would make an excellent book club choice. (less)
This answer contains spoilers… (view spoiler)

Community Reviews

Showing 1-30
Average rating 3.94  · 
Rating details
 ·  47,911 ratings  ·  4,297 reviews

More filters
Sort order
Start your review of Carnegie's Maid
May 16, 2017 rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
4 out of 5 stars to Carnegie's Maid, a historical fiction novel set to be published in January 2018 by Marie Benedict.

Why This Book
I saw this show up on NetGalley and wanted to read something about the Carnegie family. I've been on a hunt to read/learn more about all the "tycoons" of America, curious about all the connections between them. I enjoy both fiction and non-fiction, so I requested this one and was approved. I picked it up last month because of a trip to the Vanderbilt Est
Dec 11, 2017 rated it liked it  ·  review of another edition
Shelves: netgalley
This book starts with an unbelievable premise, on which the whole plot hangs. Clara Kelly assumes the identity of a dead girl with the same name who happened to be traveling on the same boat to America. It gives you a good taste of the trials of the Irish immigrant and is a reminder how American prejudice used to be directly squarely at the Irish Catholics.

The book reminds me in some ways of Jane Eyre and other books from the period that looked to have love bridge the social gap between rich an
Jul 02, 2021 rated it it was amazing  ·  review of another edition
Recommends it for: Fans of historical fiction
Why am I following author Marie Benedict? Because even though I've only read 3 of at least 6 well-researched books that she has written (and the others are on my WTR list), I've learned something new each time!

From protagonist, Clara Kelley (fictitious lady's maid), I learned:
1. how and why lone female Irish immigrants left destitute Ireland in search of a better life for themselves and/or their families; and,
2. what the expectations were of a lady's maid in the late 1800s (reminded me of "Downt
Jennifer ~ TarHeelReader
4 Steelers’ Stars to Carnegie’s Maid ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️

The Author’s Note at the beginning by Marie Benedict set the stage. In a letter, supposedly steel-hearted Andrew Carnegie professed that he would do more for the immigrants and working class in America. After that time, he founded his famous library, which later led to him being a full-fledged philanthropist. Why was he inspired to change his ways? Marie Benedict has some ideas based on her own family’s experience.

The writing was smooth, and the
Jul 18, 2017 rated it liked it
If ever there was a market for this book, it would be me - a born and raised Pittsburgher who has read nonfiction works about Carnegie's life, is a massive historical fiction fan, has visited the former house museum of his arch enemy, Henry Clay Frick, (twice) because I am so fascinated with the era...I even got married at Carnegie museum. So a fictional account of a love story involving Andrew Carnegie? Sign.me.up.


I can't be sure if it's this bias that left me disappointed with this b
Always Pouting
Aug 20, 2019 rated it really liked it
Just found out the author also wrote The Other Einstein and I have to say i enjoyed this one much more. The book follows Clara Kelly as she becomes a lady maid to Andrew Carnegie's mother and eventually develops a relationship with Andrew. I really liked Clara and was really rooting for her through out. I actually kind of wish the book had been longer and we had spent more time building up to the end. I don't know if it was that the end just felt kind of abrupt. The book does follow Clara as she ...more
Susan - on semi hiatus
Ladies Choice.

Clara has just emigrated to the United States at the request of her poor Irish family who barely scraped her boat fare together. She and many others were crowded into the windowless bottom of the ship and her story as a resourceful survivor had me hoping for her success.

By using her wits, she finagles a position as a Lady’s Maid instead of the scullery kitchen job she was designated for. As she learns her new role, she takes an interest in the business dealings of the master of the
Elizabeth of Silver's Reviews

Clara Kelley needed to help her family financially since their 20-acre farm in Ireland was slowly being sold to pay their bills.

The best place her father thought she could be of help was in America. Since she was educated and not really suited to be a farmer's wife, off to America she went in search of work, but she was not sure why it was to be in servitude.

Clara made it across the ocean and into the household of the Carnegie family in Pittsburgh. She became the lady's maid for Mrs. Carnegie.

Suzanne Leopold (Suzy Approved Book Reviews)
Clara Kelley leaves for America seeking employment to help her family in Ireland. She hopes that she will earn enough to keep her family from losing their farm. Her journey by ship was tough and many fell ill and died on the voyage. When she arrives at the dock she hears her name being called by a gentleman seeking a different Clara Kelley. Deciding to take a risk, she follows him to Pittsburgh to take a job as a lady’s maid.

Clara finds herself working in the home of the Carnegie family. She has
Jul 09, 2018 rated it liked it  ·  review of another edition
Shelves: library-borrowed
All I knew about Andrew Carnegie was that he had a hall named after him. This novel does intrigue me to know more about him. I was very lukewarm over the whole stretch of a dalliance with a maid. Having read The Other Einstein I do like that Marie Benedict enjoys bringing strong minded women to the forefront of her novels. I certainly enjoyed Clara Kelley's determination to support her family in Ireland and in the USA. It was a good fast read, but because it slowed down in the middle I am givin ...more
Sep 28, 2021 rated it it was amazing  ·  review of another edition
My second Benedict novel, and it didn’t disappoint!

The Carnegie’s Maid tells the story of Clara Kelly, an Irish farmer’s daughter who immigrates to Pittsburgh to help support her family. Clara arrives by boat and learns that another girl by the same name has died on the passage. After a moral deliberation, Clara decides to take her position as a Lady’s Maid for Mrs. Carnegie. She succeeds in hiding her true background.

Clara is introduced to Andrew Carnegie, who was a Scottish immigrant that be
Magdalena aka A Bookaholic Swede
I was thrilled when I got the chance to read this book long before it was released. I mean as I write this review is it more than half a year left before the book is released. But, I just had to read it!

So, by the two stars rating have you probably figured that I did not truly love this book. Now, before I start to explain what worked and what did not work for me will I just tell you that I'm sure many will love this book. It's not badly written or anything. It's just that I'm pretty picky when
Marialyce (absltmom, yaya)
Andrew Carnegie, originally an Scottish immigrant grew to be the most powerful and richest man in America. He was assuredly a self made man, one who grew to control the steel industry in America and later became a philanthropist and is given credit for the concept of a free library where all could educate themselves through the reading of books. Having little formal education, he grew up in a family where education through books was valued. Andrew carried this throughout his life and believed th ...more
Karren  Sandercock
During the Irish potato famine, Clara Kelley immigrates to America, she's hoping to find her distant cousin Patrick and a job. Her family is struggling, she's the obvious one to emigrate to America being the smartest in her family and they desperately need her to send money home. Clara endures the long voyage to America on the Envoy, in steerage and it's a nightmare.

When she arrives, she is mistaken for another woman, they have the exact same name but they come from very different social backgro
With this book, I have now read all of the books written by Marie Benedict. I have enjoyed each one. I have been impressed with her skills as an historical novelist. Many years ago, I took a summer course at the University of California on how to do research, both on site and off, for writing historical fiction. The course was taught by Irving and Jean Stone. I was amazed at the amount of work and detailed investigation that goes into writing historical fiction. In those days Irving Stone was th ...more
Katie B
3.5 stars

I don't normally read much historical fiction that takes place prior to the 1900s but I knew a little bit about Andrew Carnegie from watching history programs with my husband, so I thought I'd give this one a chance. I wouldn't say this is a must-read but I found it to be charming in its own little unique way.

I think it's important to note the author chose to base this novel on why Andrew Carnegie ended up donating so much of his fortune. This historical fiction novel is comprised much
capture stories
Mar 15, 2022 rated it really liked it
Marie Benedict provided a delightful and credible scenario beautifully written and engaging. There are a surprisingly small amount of main characters that are well cast. There’s also a beautiful, forbidden love story in between the master and maid, which makes the story exciting and sad at the same time. Clara, the main character, is a good person, became interested in the affairs of Carnegie and listened attentively to his ideas and opinions. The thrill of the story lies with Clara might have h ...more
May 14, 2020 rated it really liked it
Shelves: u-l
Clara Kelley arrives in America to have a better life and to help her family back in Ireland financially. When she arrives at the dock she hears her name being called. Who could this be? She is not expecting anyone to meet her. The man calling her name is very well dressed and distinguished He couldn’t be anyone for her. She decides to go along with this and tells him she is Clara Kelley. Obviously she is the wrong Clara Kelley. She secures a job as a ladies maid for the Carnegie family. Clara h ...more
Jan 27, 2019 rated it it was ok  ·  review of another edition
A bit of mistaken identity, a bit of deception, and a newly arrived Irish immigrant is placed as lady’s maid to Mrs. Carnegie. Without any training or experience in wealthy homes, she immediately intuits all the knowledge she needs to win over the difficult Mrs. Carnegie and win the heart of Andrew Carnegie. Not only does she instantly master the expectations and needed skills of a lady’s maid, but she also solves business problems and recommends new business ventures for Andrew. I realize that ...more
Aug 11, 2017 rated it it was amazing  ·  review of another edition
Wow... This was a great read for me. :))) I really want to talk about this book's ending and if I talk about it I would give spoilers so I won't say anything about that. :)) I would recommend to everyone who likes historical fiction. And this book was the first book that goes on my favorites list that published this year or will be published. Don't miss it. It isn't published yet but will be published on 01 Jan 2018.

The story happens in the 1860s (fixed :). This story begins with giving us the l
Andrew Carnegie came from humble beginnings in Scotland, and in America, he became an iron magnate and the richest man in the world. He used his wealth to improve society, creating free libraries. He sparked philanthropy with pouring money into education and scientific research.

Nevertheless, some accused him of being ruthless. And that’s what this story explores, his character.

Clara Kelley (fictional character) is a very moral, likeable and interesting character. She comes from humble beginning
Linda Hart
Feb 26, 2019 rated it it was amazing  ·  review of another edition
This well-done historical fiction is the story of the early years of Andrew Carnegie's life, the building of his empire, and an interesting glimpse into the glaring inequities of life between the lives wealthy and the poverty stricken during the gilded age. The story is told from the perspective of his mother's fictitious lady's maid. By the time Carnegie was 35 he had decided to give away all of his money and one of his most enduring gifts to the U.S. was the building and furnishing of over 2,5 ...more
Sep 08, 2021 rated it it was amazing  ·  review of another edition
I must admit that I was late to the party in reading Carnegie’s Maid but as the saying goes…better late than never. Hats off to Marie Benedict for penning this extraordinary historical fiction novel with such strong, vulnerable and complex characters. This was the second book by Marie Benedict that I have had the pleasure of reading. In Carnegie’s Maid, Marie Benedict was able to weave the fictional account of Clara Kelly’s life as lady’s maid to Andrew Carnegie’s mother with the true aspects of ...more
Jan 28, 2018 rated it really liked it
Wonderful storyline ! !

Thanks to Netgalley and respective publishers for providing copy for me.

Comprehensive, exceptionally written book.
I've not read any good Historical fiction after prolong time period.

A novel, merely described about life of Immigrants especially about leading characters and how they flew with their masters.
I like whole description of each and every character as well as flow of story.
So many wishes for the Author.
May 06, 2022 rated it liked it  ·  review of another edition
Carnegie’s Maid - Marie Benedict is about the Carnegie family primarily the eldest son as he builds public libraries. He supposedly takes many of his ideas from Irish born lady maid of his mother, Clara Kelly. The story was interesting and kept me interested. Historical romances or romances in general are not my interest. It will certainly be more enticing to those who do enjoy. As always Marie Benedict’s book is very well researched and stayed with the times. I love learning about history throu ...more
2.5 stars

Hailing from Pittsburgh's East End, I was eager to read this book — overeager, after having loved the author's previous historical novel, The Other Einstein.

The central theme is the same (the man's legacy is due to the woman), but the basis of the plot differs: the other stems from debate; this one is invented.

I would not have minded, if it were realistic, but it isn't. At the 78% mark, I was done suspending disbelief.

It took me several sittings just to get that far. After a strong star
Stephanie Anze
Clara Kelley was onboard a ship from Ireland to America. As many families in Ireland, Clara's family was struggling to support themselves so Clara was chosen to travel and work overseas. Upon arrival, Clara hears her name being called at the port. Realizing that this other miss Clara Kelley died onboard, she takes a chance and takes her place. Clara is told that she is to be a lady's maid, a position that she has no prior knowledge of. She winds up in the household of Andrew Carnegie, being the ...more
Apr 05, 2018 rated it liked it  ·  review of another edition
3-1/2 Stars

Will the real Clara Kelly please stand up?

I’m finding that I am enjoying historical fiction more and more as of late. I am always curious as to which aspects of the book are true. Which is funny because I was never interested in history during school!

Carnegie’s Maid is a fictional love story that was fun to read. I never knew much about Andrew Carnegie before reading this but after reading it I looked up a few things and he had an interesting life.

I recommend this when you are in th
Deanne Patterson
Having been born in Pittsburgh, PA I am very familiar with the name Andrew Carnegie. I was pleased as punch to be approved for this book. Very fascinating story of a young girl, one of the many Irish immigrants coming to America to find work after the potato famine. Having a very common name of Clara Kelly she poses as the Clara Kelly who dies on the ship on her way to America. That Clara Kelly was on her way to a well paying position as a ladies maid for Mrs. Carnegie, Andrew Carnegie's mother. ...more
Karen R
Nov 14, 2017 rated it really liked it
Clara Kelley, a recent immigrant and newly hired ladies’ maid in the Carnegie household captures Andrew Carnegie’s heart and captured mine almost immediately with her ingenuity and reinvention. The two of them together? Magic and fireworks.

Clara is a wonderful character - smart and industrious. She and Andrew first meet in the family library and based on their love of books, a mutual respect and admiration grows. According to the author, historians had theorized that a personal relationship may
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 next »
topics  posts  views  last activity   
Play Book Tag: Carnegie's Maid by Marie Benedict - 3.5 stars 7 12 May 30, 2022 01:05AM  
Mary Lib Saleh Eu...: Historical Fiction July 1 5 Jul 25, 2020 01:31AM  
YCLD Book Club: Questions From the Reading Guide 3 22 May 27, 2020 10:15PM  
Play Book Tag: Carnegie's Maid-3 stars 3 19 Aug 20, 2019 05:02PM  
Play Book Tag: Carnegie's Maid – Marie Benedict - 4 stars 3 18 Jul 18, 2019 06:59PM  
Play Book Tag: Carnegie's Maid / Marie Benedict - 3*** 1 14 Feb 04, 2019 12:47AM  

Readers also enjoyed

  • The Singing Trees
  • Sold on a Monday
  • The Last Rose of Shanghai
  • Write My Name Across the Sky
  • The Orphan Collector
  • The Keeper of Happy Endings
  • The Second Mrs. Astor
  • Finger Prints
  • The Second Life of Mirielle West
  • These Tangled Vines
  • The Storyteller of Casablanca
  • The Lobotomist's Wife
  • The Passing Storm
  • Chasing Fireflies
  • The Last Green Valley
  • West with Giraffes
  • The Magnificent Lives of Marjorie Post
  • Family Money
See similar books…
See top shelves…
Marie Benedict is a lawyer with more than ten years' experience as a commercial litigator at two of the country's premier law firms. While practicing as a NYC lawyer, Marie dreamed of a fantastical job unearthing the hidden historical stories of women -- and finally found it when she tried her hand at writing. She embarked on a new, thematically connected series of historical fiction excavating th ...more

Related Articles

If you’ve ever been on a serious historical fiction kick, then you already know how rewarding it can be. When it's done properly, historical...
64 likes · 9 comments
“As Mrs. Barrett Browning says, ‘The world of books is still the world.” 3 likes
“I have searched for you for well over a year. I have hired detectives and bounty hunters and I have employed my own security men as well. They have looked in Pittsburgh, Philadelphia, New York, Boston and pretty much everywhere in between. Even the staunchest of private detectives found not a trace of you after you left the bank in Pittsburgh. It was as if you never existed. But you did exist, Clara. You stamped your mark upon me, and I will stamp your mark upon the world to prove your existence and remind myself to stay your course. As you would have desired, any fortune I amass will be dedicated for the betterment of mankind, particularly the education and improvement of the poorer and immigrant classes by the establishment of free libraries.” 3 likes
More quotes…