Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

The Broken Girls

Rate this book
A breakout suspense novel from the award-winning author of The Haunting of Maddy Clare.

Vermont, 1950. There's a place for the girls whom no one wants--the troublemakers, the illegitimate, the too smart for their own good. It's called Idlewild Hall. And in the small town where it's located, there are rumors that the boarding school is haunted. Four roommates bond over their whispered fears, their budding friendship blossoming--until one of them mysteriously disappears. . . .

Vermont, 2014. As much as she's tried, journalist Fiona Sheridan cannot stop revisiting the events surrounding her older sister's death. Twenty years ago, her body was found lying in the overgrown fields near the ruins of Idlewild Hall. And though her sister's boyfriend was tried and convicted of murder, Fiona can't shake the suspicion that something was never right about the case.

When Fiona discovers that Idlewild Hall is being restored by an anonymous benefactor, she decides to write a story about it. But a shocking discovery during the renovations will link the loss of her sister to secrets that were meant to stay hidden in the past--and a voice that won't be silenced. . . .

326 pages, Hardcover

First published March 20, 2018

Loading interface...
Loading interface...

About the author

Simone St. James

12 books12.2k followers
Simone St. James is the New York Times and USA Today bestselling author of The Book of Cold Cases, The Sun Down Motel, The Broken Girls and The Haunting of Maddy Clare, which won two RITA awards from Romance Writers of America and an Arthur Ellis Award from Crime Writers of Canada. She wrote her first ghost story, about a haunted library, when she was in high school, and spent twenty years behind the scenes in the television business before leaving to write full-time. She lives outside Toronto, Canada with her husband and a spoiled cat.

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
29,556 (32%)
4 stars
42,609 (46%)
3 stars
16,686 (18%)
2 stars
2,400 (2%)
1 star
608 (<1%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 10,843 reviews
Profile Image for megs_bookrack.
1,537 reviews9,791 followers
May 9, 2023
The Broken Girls was an absolute delight, exceeding all of my expectations. This story will definitely stick with me!

I went into this with very little knowledge of the plot. The only information I had was that it was a Mystery set at an all-girls Prep School in Vermont.

While I intensely love this set-up, upon reading, I pleasantly discovered there is a lot more to this story than that brief description lets on.

This novel is replete with an absorbing gothic atmosphere that transports you in time and place.

It is the perfect amount of suspense, with extra special paranormal goodness sprinkled on top!

The main portion of the story alternates back and forth between 1950 and 2014. The narrative follows different women in and around Barrens, Vermont, and more importantly Idlewilde Hall.

I certainly wish I hadn't put off reading this for months after getting it.

I can't explain it. It just kept getting shuffled down the ole' TBR list.

Now, I can say, I am physically distraught at not having picked this up as soon as I received it.

Admittedly, that may be taking it a little far, I am nothing if not dramatic, but I do wish I would have picked it up immediately.

Honestly, I do not have even one constructive criticism for this story.

This book is incredible. This book wants you to read it. This book will keep you up nights. READ IT!

Thank you so much to the publisher, Berkley Publishing Group, for providing me with a copy to read and review.

I apologize to you ((and myself)) that I didn't get to it until now!
Profile Image for Mary Beth .
381 reviews1,651 followers
October 25, 2019
5 SHINY STARS, I would give a lot more if I Could.

Mary Hand Mary Hand, Dead and buried underland. She'll say she wants to be your friend. Do not let her in again.

The setting is in Vermont. There are rumors that the boarding school Idlewild Hall is haunted. This is a place where girls go who are troublemakers, illegitimate and too smart for their own good. Their parents rarely visit them. Four roommates are friends and they bond very well until one of them disappears.

Fiona Sheridan is a journalist. Twenty years ago her sister's body was found lying in the overgrown fields, near the ruins of Idlewood. Her sister's boyfriend was tried and convicted of murder. She keeps revisiting the events surrounding her sister's death. Fiona has a strong suspicion that the case isn't what it was made out to be. Fiona then finds out that Idlewild Hall is being restored and decides to write a story about it.
Shockingly she discovers that the renovations link to secrets that were meant to stay hidden in the past.

This is an awesome spooky ghost story plus a great mystery. It is so much more than your average ghost story. If you usually don't like ghost stories, I still think you would like this one. It is a Gothic suspense novel and I could just feel the Gothic atmosphere brewing. It is more of a mystery than horror. It didn't really scare me but the secrets were frightening but more suspenseful. It was also very chilling.
It hooked me in straight from the beginning and didn't let go until the very end. The suspense kept me turning the pages and kept me reading into the earl hours of the morning. The story goes back and forth from the past to the present. From 1950 to 2014, two stories merge into one. There are several twist and turns that gave me surprises that I didn't see coming with a great murder plot.

The book is very well written and is a character driven novel. I just loved some of the characters. I recommend this to those who like a Gothic suspense novel.

I got this arc on Edelweiss.
Profile Image for Deanna .
664 reviews12.4k followers
July 4, 2018
My reviews can also be seen at: https://deesradreadsandreviews.wordpr...

4.5 Stars!!

“Mary Hand, Mary Hand, dead and buried under land…
Faster, faster. Don’t let her catch you.
She’ll say she wants to be your friend…
Do not let her in again!”

I’m not usually one for paranormal/ghost stories, but when I read the description for “The Broken Girls” I was really intrigued. I’m thrilled to say that this was even better than I expected.

Barrons, Vermont - November 1950.

A young girl has just gotten off a bus. She has two choices. She can take the normal route or she can cut through the woods to get there faster. But cutting through the woods means leaving the safety of the main road. Suddenly she turns and sees a figure coming towards her. But how is this possible?

She was the only one who got off the bus….

Katie, Ce-Ce, Roberta and Sonia are roommates at Ildewild Hall, a boarding school for “troubled” girls. Over time they have become close friends. They bond over their painful life stories. They trust and depend on each other.

We are given insight into why each “broken” girl is at Idlewild though chapters from their perspective. We learn about their lives and what they’ve been through and about the mystery surrounding them all.


Fiona was seventeen at the time of her sister’s murder. Twenty years later, unanswered questions continue to plague her. Although a man was convicted for her murder and is serving his sentence in a maximum-security prison, he has always maintained his innocence.

And now Idlewild Hall is being restored. Why would someone bother re-building a place like Idlewild? Fiona decides to write about the restoration for the local paper. She has strange feelings whenever she is near the property and the old school. Is it possible that the rumors about Idlewild being haunted are true?

Then a shocking discover changes everything. Could there be a link between what happened all those years ago and Fiona's sister’s murder?

There are so many secrets surrounding Idlewild and Fiona is determined to find out what those secrets are. But could all of her investigating end up putting her in danger?

The story alternates between 1950 and 2014. The chapters in 2014 are told from Fiona’s point of view. The chapters in 1950 are from the point of view of the four roommates. Though it alternates and there are quite a few different perspectives, I thought it flowed easily back and forth between past and present.

“The Broken Girls” was a unique and impressive novel. While I did find the beginning of the novel a bit slow, it wasn’t long before I was completely caught up in the story. It was an engrossing read that really struck a chord with me. I ended up reading more than half of the book in just a few hours.

You can tell that the author has done her research; she brings everything together in an excellent way. Though some parts are dark and disturbing, I feel the author handled these difficult subjects with respect and sensitivity.

“The Broken Girls” was a captivating read that I really enjoyed. I’m looking forward to reading more from Simone St. James.

Thank you, Berkley Books for providing an advanced readers copy of this book for me to read in exchange for my honest review.

Profile Image for Julie .
4,027 reviews58.9k followers
March 19, 2018
The Broken Girls by Simone St. James is a 2018 Berkley publication.

Now THIS is my kind of book!!

Set in Vermont, alternating between 1950 and 2014, this well rounded thriller, centers around a girl’s only school named Idlewood Hall. During the fifties, this school was where troubled girls were sent, and where a group of girls forge an unlikely and formidable friendship which would cause a rippling effect for decades to come.

Over the years, the abandoned school was nothing more than an eyesore, protecting its memories and ghosts from the outside world, its most recent claim to fame being the general location of where Fiona Sheridan’s sister was found dead over twenty years ago.

Now, in present day, 2014, someone has taken an interest in Idlewood, determined to restore the old boarding house, which only intensifies Fiona’s obsession over her sister’s death. She convinces her boss to allow her to do a story about the school's restoration for the magazine she works for. While she barely manages to conceal her ulterior motives, the restoration efforts inadvertently led to a shocking discovery, and sends her down a rabbit hole, as she searches, not only for peace of mind concerning her sister’s death, but for the answers to a decades old mystery.

This gloomy, atmospheric thriller enveloped me in its Gothic fog, keeping me utterly riveted and on the edge of my seat from the beginning to end.

The creepy aura surrounding Fiona’s investigation into her sister’s death is nail biting suspense at its finest. This is a crime drama, thriller, and chiller all rolled into one. While the haunting of Idlewood adds a deliciously spooky element to the story, what is truly haunting is the heavy toll that losing a daughter and sister had on Fiona and her family, as well as the ever present feeling of impending doom.

But, the mystery of the disappearance of one of Idlewood’s boarders during the fifties was a story that goes beyond the ghostly rumors. It is poignantly sad and infuriating tale, that slowly morphs into an inspirational and touching story of friendship and long overdue closure.

I have always been a sucker for a good ghost story, mainly because contrary to the creepy, spooky, chilling aspects of hauntings, more often than not, ghosts are quite often helpful, or asking for help from the living, to give them long sought after peace, which is a not at all frightening when you look at it from that angle. This story is no exception, but I have to tell you, this ghost story packs a powerful punch and is incredibly edgy!!

But, mostly, this story is about solving all the mysteries surrounding two very different types of crimes, with two entirely separate circumstances. The author manages to connect the past to the present fluidly, despite the stark differences in themes and urgency. While the location and Idlewood provide a physical link, it is really the power of familial love and the enduring bonds of friendship, with a little help from beyond, that brings everyone and everything together in the end.

This story is evenly paced, giving the well timed twists a great deal of power. It is very well written, and embodies everything I love about a good thriller. Overall, this was an immensely satisfying read.

Pulling out all the stars for this one! 5 stars!!
Profile Image for Meredith (Slowly Catching Up).
793 reviews12.4k followers
January 28, 2018

Hauntingly suspenseful read about a former boarding school for “troubled girls.”

There’s something sinister at work in Barrons, Vermont at the abandoned Idlewild Hall. Ghosts have been seen, bodies have been found, and secrets have been long buried. When a journalist begins digging into the dark, dismal history of Idlewild, she exposes a web of corruption and hidden crimes.

In the 1950’s four girls were roommates and the best of friends at Idlewild Hall, a boarding school for “troubled” girls. The girls are the closest of friends and rely on each other to survive living in the repressive, gloomy, world of Idlewild. When of them goes mysteriously missing, the school believes she has run away, but the friends believe that she was murdered.

Switch to 2014: When journalist Fiona Sheridan learns that Idlewild, which had been shut down and abandoned, is going to be restored she is determined to find out more, as Fiona has an inherent interest in Idlewild as it is the spot which her murdered sister’s body was found 20 years ago. The more and more Fiona digs up about Idlewild, the more she puts herself in danger.

The Broken Girls is an intelligent, well-written creepy, atmospheric read that I could not put down! There’s something about Simone St. James’ writing style that sucked me in--I honestly had to force myself to put this book down. The characters voices are compelling, and their stories equally interesting. I loved the eerie, gothic like atmosphere, and of course Mary Hand’s presence kept me on edge. There are some paranormal elements, which I normally would have rolled my eyes at, but they serve a purpose and really work in this book.

I cannot say enough good things about The Broken Girls! I might just have to go reread and experience it all over again!
Profile Image for Kaceey.
1,067 reviews3,613 followers
March 18, 2018
A dark, haunting novel that includes a whopper of a ghost story. When I first sought out this book I had no idea the plotline involved a supernatural element. Had I known, I probably would have just passed on it. And boy, what a shame that would’ve been. In fact, the supernatural slant ended up being my favorite part of the book!
So even if ghosts tend to scare, (like they do for me👻) don’t run! It blends perfectly into the story.

The book is split into two timelines. Past and present. Interestingly, I was completely captivated by the past timeline and left wanting more. Versus the present storyline, that I found more difficult to stay connected to and felt it just didn’t mesh with the feel of the rest of the book.

Overall I found it to an enjoyable read and would recommend!

This was a very large and engaging Traveling Sister read!

Thank you to Edelweiss for an ARC to review.

For this review and our full Traveling Sister review please visit Brenda and Norma's fabulous blog:
Profile Image for BernLuvsBooks .
773 reviews4,642 followers
September 20, 2019
4 Haunting Stars for The Broken Girls

The Broken Girls is part paranormal story, part mystery and I enjoyed how Simone St. James blended the two together. I was actually surprised by how much I enjoyed the ghost aspect of the story.

The story unfolds via two separate storylines, set decades apart. At the center of each storyline stands Idlewild, a home for troubled girls. In 1950, a girl gets off a bus and goes missing. The only people who are convinced something is wrong are her roommates. Fellow troubled girls, Katie, CeCe and Roberta, know Sonia didn't just run away but no one cares enough to really investigate.

Years later in 2014, Idlewild is set to be reopened. Journalist, Fiona Sheridan is drawn to the land as it is where her older sister was found murdered 20 years before. She decides to write about the restoration for a local paper and uncovers so much more than she bargained for.

I was engrossed by the storyline and all its secrets. The mysteries of the deaths of these two girls with the added layer of a ghost haunting Idlewild kept me turning the pages. I really enjoyed the 1950's storyline and found each of the girls' backstory interesting. Their bond was touching and I appreciated their friendship in light of all the hardship they suffered.

There were several plot twists here and some I definitely didn't see coming! The Broken Girls was a suspenseful and haunting read that I thoroughly enjoyed.
Profile Image for Dorie  - Cats&Books :).
991 reviews2,766 followers
April 1, 2022
Wow, this book blew me away! It had everything I love in a book, amazing believable characters, smooth flowing prose, mystery within mystery within mystery. The past and present narrative style works wonderfully in this book and I was equally interested in both parts of the book.

In Barrons, Vermont there was a private school called Idlewild Hall for “troubled” girls. This could range from those who had suffered mental and emotional trauma, girls that just didn’t fit the right mold, girls fathered by someone who wanted to hide these “other” offsprings to just girls who didn’t behave in the way their parents wanted.

In the 1950’s there were four very special girls who, living as roommates, struck up a friendship as a way to survive this horrible school and the constant repressive and stagnant nature of teaching. The girls, Cece, Katie, Sonia and Roberta have at one time or another spotted the rumored ghost of Idlewild hall, a mysterious lady veiled, and in black dress. They also hear her say things to them which is personal to each of them. When one of them goes missing, the others try to solve the mystery.

Flash to 20 years later and the long vacant school and property have been purchased and is rumored to be planned to reopen as a school once again. A young journalist, Fiona Sheridan, is grief stricken at the this thought. Her older sister had been found strangled in the field by the school, her boyfriend being found guilty of the crime and currently in jail.

Some things just aren’t adding up for Fiona and with the help of her policeman/boyfriend and fellow journalist she starts to dig and dig for more information about her sister’s death and also the person who has purchased the land and why.

There was never a dull moment in this book, I really didn’t want to stop reading. The characters were all beautifully well developed and I cared about all of them. I highly recommend this book to anyone who enjoys a wonderful, brilliantly written book that will keep you guessing until the satisfying end.

I received an ARC of this novel from the publisher through Edelweiss, thank you.
Profile Image for Felice Laverne.
Author 1 book3,204 followers
February 12, 2020
Idlewild was the boarding school of last resort, where parents stashed their embarrassments, their failures, and their recalcitrant girls. Hidden in the backwoods of Vermont, it had only 120 students: illegitimate daughters, first wives’ daughters, servants’ daughters, immigrant girls, girls who misbehaved…

The Broken Girls proved to be a breezy and exciting read in all of the best ways. The hooks were there, pulling me further and further into the story until I became one with it. Until the hours and pages flew by alike and I realized I’d finished it all in one sitting. Who isn’t intrigued by the thought of “throw away” girls from a time long ago? Simone St. James makes her own literary footsteps in shoes she fills well, for The Broken Girls is most definitely Ruth Ware meets Fiona Barton with an American Northeast twist.

If that line wasn’t enough to tell you exactly what to expect here, I’ll elaborate. This novel reminded me of an equal cross between and The Widow and The Lying Game from the very start. The writing style is very similar—fluid and paced so that the read flies by breezily, tinged with intrigue. Even the theme of camaraderie among boarding school girls—their mischief, their backstories, their own haunting pasts—investigated in present-day scenes by a character who also has skin in the game, is the same. Here, you can even cozy up to the same scenery: wide open fields ringed with thickets of trees and old dirt gravel roads of the past. These novels were all cut from the same cloth, though they all told their stories in a way of their own.

While so many thrillers suffer from too many ideas in the plot, The Broken Girls weaves together a handful of story lines with just the right recipe. A chase here, a haunt there—a thrilling journey to the end—all brought to a boil and served up heartily leaving me full and satisfied in the end. None of the story lines felt overpowering or underdeveloped; they all fit together hand in hand, seamlessly drawing me back and forth between two periods of time over sixty years apart. Because of this skillful flow, St. James’ Girls read at a quick pace, allowing me to immerse myself in the story without interruption. That’s half the battle with a thriller, right? I was most impressed with the handling of the ghost story here in this novel. It was brilliantly done, haunting me as it haunted those four girls—never overdone or melodramatic, relying on parlor tricks like flashing lights and other theatrics; this ghost was a leading lady all her own and deserving of the space she occupied with those pages.

As is sometimes a danger with thrillers, I will say that there were a few areas that were obviously formulaic, plucked straight out of the “thriller-with-a-villain” motif and those couple of sections in the novel made me cringe enough to warrant shaving off a star. BUT, the rest of St. James’ The Broken Girls was deftly handled and intricately woven in a way that made me want to come back for more. I highly recommend this novel for anyone in need of a cozy thriller and for absolutely anyone who has read and loved Ruth Ware or Fiona Barton, because these Broken Girls served up more twists than I’d expected and more intrigue than so many novels of the same genre, scoring an easy and strong 4 stars. ****

**Thanks to the publicity department at Berkley / Penguin Random House for reaching out to me to review this book!**


Goodreads | Twitter | Instagram | Get a Copy of My Book | Book Editing, Author Coaching, Submit Your Book to Me
Profile Image for Jennifer ~ TarHeelReader.
2,124 reviews30.2k followers
December 26, 2018
4 eerie, ghostly stars to The Broken Girls! 🌟 🌟 🌟 🌟

The Broken Girls started off with a bang and with a dynamically engaging prologue! Was there a ghost right from the start?

If you think you do not enjoy ghost stories, I have to say, this one is executed well. Spooky is done with a light hand, not overdone, even feasible if that’s possible for a ghost story?! The atmosphere is perfectly staged with an old school building featuring “tooth-shaped windows.”

In Vermont in the 1950s, there’s a home for wayward “throw-away” girls at Idlewild Hall. The local town has rumors that Idlewild is haunted. Four girls are sharing a room, and they forge a deep bond that continues to grow until one friend disappears.

Also in Vermont, but in 2014, Fiona Sheridan is a journalist obsessed with events around her sister’s mysterious death. Twenty years prior, she is fond in the fields of Idlewild Hall.

It turns out that Idlewild is being restored by someone who does not want to be named, and Fiona decides to write a story about it. Fiona discovers something that links her sisters death to other secrets...and something you’d never expect.

Told in dual story lines, past and present, that later converge, I found the past timeline slightly more interesting, which featured a boarding school in Vermont for “wayward” girls in the 1950s. I enjoyed the present storyline with Fiona, too, but the former held me captive. The girls in the school were each so interesting and likable.

Overall, this was a well-written, atmospheric, spooky ghost story, and one I enjoyed immensely. It’s the perfect read for this time of year, to cozy up with a blanket and fall into a story.

Thanks to Berkley for the complimentary ARC. All opinions are my own.

My reviews can also be found on my blog: www.jennifertarheelreader.com
March 19, 2018
4.5 stars! I loved the gothic and mysterious feel of this gripping novel!

From page one, I was drawn into this fascinating story surrounding Idlewild Hall, an old crumbling abandoned girls boarding school. In the 1950’s, an Idlewild Hall student disappeared, leaving for a weekend family visit, never to return. Almost fifty years later, a local girl is left dead in the open field surrounding the abandoned property of Idlewild Hall, the school having closed down decades prior. Add into the story the numerous sightings of Mary Hand, a ghost known to haunt the property.

The novel is presented in dual timelines which flowed perfectly. We meet four roommates living in Idlewild Hall in the 1950’s. I loved each and every one of them! In 2014, we follow freelance journalist Fiona Sheridan on a trail to uncover long buried secrets hidden at Idlewild Hall which has now been purchased and is in the midst of being renovated.

I found this novel to be extremely well-written, addictively suspenseful and chillingly atmospheric! This was a Traveling Sister Read and we all enjoyed it. To find this review along with the other Traveling Sister Read reviews, please visit Norma and Brenda’s fabulous blog at:


A big thank you to Edelweiss, Berkley and Simone St. James for providing an ARC in exchange for an honest review!

Expected Date of Publication: March 20, 2018
Profile Image for Melisa.
324 reviews515 followers
February 22, 2018
A seriously atmospheric, creepy, spooky, eerie (seriously, think of a synonym for any of those words and it will fit the bill) tale that will haunt you day and night.

I am not one for supernatural books, but this one was SO well done, it had me believing in ghosts by the time I was finished. So well done, in fact, that I went and bought this author’s entire back catalogue of titles. Mary Hand is a fascinating character and her powers are definitely unique. I loved her storyline, and would have enjoyed learning more about her history.

I thoroughly enjoyed this dual timeline story, I think this structure worked really well for this book. I was totally invested in these characters and couldn’t wait to find out what happened to them.

On a side note, I was in the car while waiting to pick up my kiddos from school, and a dear friend banged on my window to scare me, and I just happened to be reading this book. Let’s just say I screamed like crazy!😆

This was a Traveling Sisters read and I thoroughly enjoyed the thoughts brought to the table by my friends. A very enjoyable experience!

Advance copy provided by Edelweiss - thank you.
Profile Image for Diane S ☔.
4,735 reviews14.1k followers
February 23, 2018
3.5 A storyline fifty years apart. A deserted school for girls, a school that in the fifties, housed girls that had problems. Four become fast friends, and then one goes missing never forgotten, but never seen again. A murder in more current times, body found on school grounds and a sister who wants answers. Now a wealthy woman is undertaking a renovation of the school, opening and exposing old secrets. Oh yes, and we must forget the ghost!!

The atmosphere, spooky, gothic, tense, the definite star of this novel. Fast paced, quite a page turner, constant revelations. Did like the past story more than the present one, which is often the case with these dual storylines. the atmosphere though kept me immersed, and in fact found this entertaining, until the last quarter where it just became too muddled. Too much happening, too many coincidences thrown in the mix, and then the writing faltered. Hence, my rating which for most of the book would have been higher just for the enjoyment factor.

This was a sisters read, one which we all enjoyed in varying levels. Quite a good discussion ensued.

ARC from Netgalley.
Profile Image for jessica.
2,534 reviews32.5k followers
September 4, 2021
picked this up because it popped up on a dark academia list and i couldnt resist. however, even though a large portion of the story involves a boarding school, i wouldnt consider this DA. its definitely more of a gothic ghost story (with a little bit of WWII historical fiction thrown in).

and because of that, it took me some time to warm up to and get invested in school girl chapters set in 1950 because it wasnt quite the DA story i was expecting. i was much more interested in fionas present day POV, her investigation of the murders, and the unearthing of past secrets.

this a very atmospheric and haunting story, a prefect halloween kind of read, packed full of mystery and murder.

3.5 stars
Profile Image for Danielle.
806 reviews400 followers
February 9, 2021
2018 F.A.B. Bookclub pick # I.❤️. F.A.B.

This was full of mystery. A great read for this time of year. Pretty spooky, ghostly story with lots of things to dig up to find out ‘who done it?’.
Profile Image for Kendall.
638 reviews640 followers
October 31, 2017
"Mary Hand, Mary Hand, dead and buried under land.... Faster, faster. Don't let her catch you. She'll say she wants to be your friend...."

What a bloody brilliant story! The Broken Girls by Simone St. James is a creepy, chilling, and BOLD ghost story. Oh my gosh... I absolutely loved how Simone created a mystery within a paranormal/ghost story. I have read previous novels where authors have tried to create a paranormal feel to the mystery/thriller and it failed miserably but wow... I am utterly impressed with Simone's talent.

What can I say about this novel? Plain and simple... READ it!

Idlewild Hall is a boarding school for girls that are troublemakers or as you can say the "leftovers". Idlewild is located in Vermont and is rumored to be haunted by a woman in a black veiled dress.
Katie, Sonia, Cece, and Roberta are roommates at Idlewild Hall who bond over this mysterious lady in black and the strange things that start happening at Idlewild until Sonia mysteriously vanishes without a trace in 1950.

20 years later journalist Fiona Sheridan can't stop thinking about her older sister's death. Twenty years ago, Fiona's sister's body was found lying in the field of Idlewild Hall. Her sister's boyfriend has been found guilty and is serving time in prison. But, Fiona can't let her sister's case go and something isn't adding up.

Is the death of her sister somehow linked to the missing girl Sonia in 1950? What secrets are being hidden about Idlewild Hall? Is Vermont hiding something more sinister about these mysterious girls that keep going missing?

Simone does an amazing job with characterization and depth of illustration in this novel. I could not get enough of the beautiful writing and details in this creepy and chilling ghost story. I highly recommend this novel!

Overall, 4.5 stars for this addicting read. Thank you to Netgalley and Berkley for an advanced arc in exchange for an honest review.

Expected publication date: 3/20/18.
Profile Image for Jennifer Masterson.
200 reviews1,128 followers
April 12, 2018
I hate to give it the “meh” but that’s how this book was for me. The audio is very good though. Most people enjoyed this book way more than I did so don’t take my word for it.

Profile Image for Kim ~ It’s All About the Thrill.
539 reviews619 followers
May 26, 2020

3.5 stars
You say this is a book about a super creepy all girls boarding school? You say there are ghosts? You say that the vibe is super goth? I say yessss please! Hand it over, give it to me now. Okay this book has to have been the most recommended book to me ever since I have been on Goodreads. Probably because The Sun Down Motel is one of my favorite thrillers ever. Yep it is on my little Goodreads shelf of all time favorites. Yet...this one didn't do it for me like Sun Down did.

You have a deserted boarding school with a crazy history. Nobody wants to touch this property with a ten foot pole. It sits there locked up behind the iron gates. With a history of ghosts, deaths and girls that are "broken." Yet along comes an investor and wants to reopen this creepy place. Who on earth would send their daughter there? That is a question Fiona wants answered. She can't move on from the wicked history. Especially since her own sister was found murdered on the grounds many years ago.

This book has some stellar reviews and it is very popular! This may just be a "it is a me thing." Why, I am not sure but it just didn't grab me like her other book did. When I read Sun Down I felt I was there at the motel, that place was creepy! I felt every fiber of that story. This one I just didn't connect with any of the characters, I didn't find it all that creepy. The back story of Mary Hand just felt a little hard to believe. It just wasn't a page turner for me and I found my mind wandering. Again, probably a me thing...we can't love them all.
Profile Image for Norma.
551 reviews12.2k followers
April 16, 2018
3.5 stars!

The Broken Girls was a quick, entertaining, fast-paced and atmospheric gothic mystery novel that was an enjoyable and satisfying read. I did enjoy the dual storylines, but I thought that the past timeline was a little more interesting than the present one though.

I do love a good ghost story and the supernatural and I definitely thought the author delivered a spooky read here, but for some reason when I was reading this novel, I wasn't overly impressed with the author's prose though so that really affected my total enjoyment for this novel. I was the only one from the Traveling Sisters that was reading this that had a problem with that though so I still absolutely recommend this novel!

Update: Thank you so much to NetGalley, Berkley Publishing Group, and Simone St. James for also providing me with a copy of this book to read and review.

Thank you so much to Edelweiss for the advanced copy of this book!

Review written and posted on our themed book blog:
Two Sisters Lost In A Coulee Reading

Coulee: a term applied rather loosely to different landforms, all of which refer to a kind of valley.
Where I live I am surrounded by Coulees!
Profile Image for MarilynW.
1,110 reviews2,797 followers
April 1, 2022
The Broken Girls by Simone St. James, Rebecca Lowman (Narrator)

There are a lot of moving parts and timelines in The Broken Girls but they worked for me. Throughout all the timelines there is a sense of danger, someone watching, and dread. In 1950 we follow four fifteen year old girls living at the boarding school, Idlewild Hall. Girls sent to Idlewild Hall are usually being punished or hidden away, troublemakers, from the "wrong side of the sheets", embarrassments to their families. Life doesn't get better at Idlewild Hall and all the girls can't wait to get away.

In 2014, Fiona Sheridan, hates the decrepit, decaying Idlewild Hall and it's grounds for a different reason. Twenty years earlier her sister's body was found on the property, she'd been murdered, and even though her killer is in prison, Fiona is still not sure justice can ever be achieved. She is obsessed with her sister's death and is appalled that someone is planning to restore Idlewild Hall to its former inglorious state.

One other timeline is a rumor. Long ago someone may have died here, maybe a baby is buried in the garden, maybe a girl or woman haunts the place wearing funeral attire. From the beginning of Idlewild Hall's existence, there have been verbal and written stories of a haunting, things seen, sounds heard, words said, that terrified the residents of the hall. It doesn't help that one of the school's residents disappeared from the school and was never heard from again.

The atmosphere is dense and foreboding and as journalist Fiona digs deeper into Idlewild Hall's past and into her sister's murder, she is stirring up resentment and receiving threats. But she can't let this go, can't let her sister's murder be forgotten, and she may be stirring up ghosts with her persistence to bring attention to the past. There is a lot to take in and keep track of in this story and I especially enjoyed the 1950 timeline of young girls just trying to hold their own when both adults and teenagers seem to be against them.
Profile Image for Theresa Alan.
Author 10 books1,017 followers
December 28, 2017
I don't believe in ghosts in real life, but I absolutely believed in the ghost of Mary Hand haunting a girls' boarding school, even after it was shut down in 1979. The writing of Broken Girls is wonderful and unique.

The story is told during two diferent periods in history. In 2014, journalist Fiona Sheridan, daughter of a famous journalist, is still looking for more solid information on the murder of her sister twenty years earlier, even though Deb's boyfriend was convicted and has been imprisoned since her body was found in a field at Idlewood Hall in a remote part of Vermont.

In 1950, we get to meet four roommates, girls abanoned because they were born outside of marriage or they're orphans or their parents just didn't know how to deal with the challenges of raising a spirited daughter, especially at a time when we don't have the knowledge about mental health that we do now (and therefore it was shameful to not be sunny and agreeable at all times if you were female). I loved these four fifteen-year-old girls. When one of them goes missing, neither the police nor the teachers do much to investigate. She's a throwaway girl. Her friends, however, know that she was murdered because she'd never run away.

Fiona's search for the truth makes for an intriguing and enjoyable mystery. I really liked this book, which RELEASES MARCH 20, 2018.

Thanks to NetGalley and Berkley Publishing for the opportunity to review this book.

For more of my reviews, please visit: http://www.theresaalan.net/blog
Profile Image for Holly  B (Short break!).
812 reviews1,866 followers
April 6, 2018
An eerie ghost story set in Vermont. Two timelines (1950 and 2014) merge to unfold a haunting tale with plenty of spine tingling revelations.

A boarding school for troubled girls in 1950, conceals secrets that are begging to be told. The foreboding rhyme of Mary Hand is whispered through the walls. One of the four bonded roommates disappears and the others are left afraid and worried for their friend.

It’s 2014 and Fiona has questions about her sisters murder, although it has been twenty years. Her body was found nearby the school and she has some of her own suspicions.

What is the story behind Idlewild Hall, Mary Hand, and Fiona’s sister? Is it too late for the truth to be revealed?

I enjoyed this spooky, atmospheric read and the images of Idlewild Hall that the author’s descriptions conjured up. I wanted to know more about Mary Hand and I was expecting the end to be a bit more electrifying, but still one you won’t want to miss! Enjoy!
Profile Image for LIsa Noell "Rocking the Chutzpah!.
579 reviews156 followers
May 1, 2023
I seldom do book reviews on a book that I've purchased. Mostly because I'm a wee bit tired of it all.
In this case, I will make an exception.
As usual, this is not a review. It's mostly about how this story affected me.
This damn book hurt my heart. I loved the ghost 👻 story, but the real murders in the book? Crikey. At times it felt like a huge weight on my chest. I'd fall asleep reading this, and then dream about it. Awful. I'm a lucid dreamer, but these were dreams that I had no control over.
I can't imagine being sent away by my parents for being "unruly." That right there just breaks my heart.
Finding out who died, and why...
Honestly? That was rough.
But, those so called "Broken Girls?" Wowsers!
I loved everything about this story! I've seen a few negative reviews, and I would encourage everyone to ignore them. Find this book on sale or at your library. It's so worth the read.
Profile Image for Jasmine from How Useful It Is.
1,294 reviews343 followers
January 27, 2020
This book is a fantastic and thrilling read right from the first page! I literally bite my teeth and take shallow breaths as I devour the pages in this story. I couldn’t put down every time I pick up this book and I’m angry that this month I couldn’t read in peace because there is always something that needed my attention. I like finding out the secrets of each characters. I like the mystery and suspense. The bit of ghost story really got my heart racing. I like the two timelines. I love the friendships. I like how radio was the thing to be cherished of the past.

This book is set in Barrons, Vermont, told in the third person point of view following Katie, Roberta, Cece, and Sonia in 1950 and Fiona in 2014. The four girls are all 15 years old and they are roommates at Idlewild Hall, a last resort boarding school for girls. One thing that keep them up at night is the ghost story about Mary Hand and their friendship. There is a rumor that the school is haunted by Mary Hand and past students jot down their own experiences with her in school textbooks for future students. Each of the four girls has their own dark secrets that placed them at the school. In the present day, Fiona, a journalist is writing a story about Idlewild Hall because Margaret Eden wanted to restore the abandoned school. Fiona’s grief over the murder of her sister Deb from 20 years ago is always alive because her body was found on the sports field of the school. Even though Deb’s boyfriend is charged for her murder, Fiona just couldn’t figure out how he could’ve done it. She too had heard of the school being haunted but never believed it. As the construction begins to restore the school, Fiona scored an interview with the owner’s son Anthony, to tour the school for her news article. As they were touring the school grounds, another body was discovered. Soon, a whole web of secrets are to be unraveled.

This book is very well written. I like the history and the background of each character. I feel for each character and they all are unique. I resemble Cece because big fat tears fall down my cheeks as I read Sonia’s background. I like Fiona and how she doesn’t give up despite people around her seems to do so. I like her chase to find the answer and her commitment to learn the truth. I feel tense and thrill reading this book. Every chapter kept me hooked and it was hard for me to put it down. I love the ending. I love the prologue and epilogue. I love the big reveal. This book is an excellent thriller and I highly recommend everyone to read it!

Pro: fast paced, page turner, thrilling, boarding school, ghost story, suspense, chilling, mystery, secrets, friendship

Con: none

I rate it 5 stars!

***Disclaimer: Many thanks to Berkley Publishing Group for the opportunity to read and review. Please be assured that my opinions are honest.

Jasmine at www.howusefulitis.wordpress.com for more details
April 5, 2021
This was one of our largest Traveling Sisters group reads that we have done and it was such a great, fun read. I really enjoyed discussing everyone’s thoughts on this one. Interesting with such a large group we ended up in the same coulee but were split into different sides of the coulee.

The Broken Girls is a creepy gothic, suspenseful, supernatural thriller that pulled us deep into the weedy brushes along with this interesting and entertaining story. We all settled in under the sun and soon things started to get a little dark.

Simone St. James does a good job creating an interesting atmospheric setting here with the vivid descriptions of Idlewild Hall a creepy, eerie abandoned boarding school that was like a character itself. We all enjoyed exploring the ruins along with Fiona and the eerie feeling it left us. We loved being taken into the past when the school was open to troubled girls and we meet four interesting damaged girls all with their own conflict. We learn their dark and tragic backstories and this became the favorite of the two timelines for us.

Simone St. James does a good job balancing a mystery with the supernatural that surprised some of us with how much we enjoyed the ghost story to this one. Things got really quiet amongst us as we learned of the ghost that haunts the school and at times all that could be heard was the faint sound of “I will survive” playing from the coulee.

Towards the end is where we started to split into different sides with how we felt about this one. For some of the TS, there was just too much going on in this story for them and they felt it didn’t pull together well enough to leave them completely satisfied. For me and the rest of the TS we thought everything tied together well and we were completely satisfied in the end. We highly recommend!

Publishing Date: March 20, 2018

Thank you so much to NetGalley, Berkley Publishing Group and Simone St. James for a copy to read and review.

Profile Image for Jayme.
1,140 reviews1,880 followers
October 20, 2021
1950: Idlewild Hall, is still open, despite the rumors that it is haunted, by a girl called Mary Hand.

“Don’t let her in!”

Girls with nowhere else to go attend the school, passing down the story of Mary Hand to the next class, by writing about their sightings in the margins, of the textbook, “Latin Grammar for Girls”, which is used every semester...

“Mary Hand wears a black dress and veil. She laughed like my dead little brother. Madeleine Grazer, February 2, 1935”:

The latest roommates and friends using the textbooks are Katie, Roberta, CeCe and Sonia, till one of them disappears....

Vermont 2014: Idlewild Hall sits in disrepair, having been closed for years. It’s garden is where Mary Hand is still spotted on occasion. It’s crumbling school the one a student disappeared from in 1950, and its grounds were the final resting place for a murdered girl’s body twenty years ago..

The body found was that of journalist Fiona Sheridan’s older sister.

So when Fiona learns that an anonymous donor wants to reopen the school, Fiona decides to do a story about it. But as she is touring the grounds during the initial renovations, a discovery is made, which will change the focus of the article.

A discovery that will tie the past and present together in ways you cannot imagine.

The narratives alternate between the past and present but are easy to follow.

When I first began reading this, I was thinking that I enjoyed the way the author was able to create a mood, and set the scene, but would this book really be any different from the many, many books out there, with a “student narrative” (usually boring to me) where you learn about the students’ secrets...and an “adult” narrative, where the secrets get exposed??

Well, let me assure you...the “students” narrative definitely took a turn I could’ve never predicted and it was not only surprising but also enlightening.

Be sure to read the epilogue"......the fact that some of what you’ll read about actually occurred is “haunting” in itself...
Profile Image for Dem.
1,186 reviews1,097 followers
April 30, 2018
I wish it didn't have to end................This is my guilty pleasure style novel. I loved the gothic, mystery feel to this book and my only regret on this one is that I don't actually own a hard copy for my real life book shelf.
Broken Girls is a chilling murder / suspense story set in Idlewild Hall, an old abandoned boarding school in rural Vermont. I am a sucker for gothic or modern gothic style stories and throw in an old abandoned Manor or Boarding school with a mysterious past and a haunting tale and you got me from page one.
I enjoyed the suspense with this one and couldn't wait to pick it up each evening and loved how the story is told in two time frames ( 1950s & 2014) which works perfectly for this story.

Great characters that well interesting and likable and a couple of them I am having a hard time parting company with now that the book is over.

I think readers who enjoy novel's like the The Thirteenth Tale by Diane Setterfield or kate Morton's The House at Riverton The House at Riverton by Kate Morton may well enjoy The Broken Girls.

A solid 4 Stars from me on this one and look forward to other books by this author.
Profile Image for Chelsea (chelseadolling reads).
1,478 reviews19.3k followers
October 17, 2018
I enjoyed this SO MUCH MORE than I expected to. Wow. What a surprisingly spooky read. Definitely going to add a million Simone St. James books to my tbr now bc I think I’m obsessed?
August 4, 2018
4.5 couldn't stop reading stars rounded up

This was a story of tragedy, of death, of girls seeking love and finding it with one another in a boarding school in Vermont. It was a story with Gothic overtones that kept this reader totally engaged from the very first page unto its satisfying conclusion.

What better way to get rid of a daughter, a young girl, or a family problem, than to shut her away in a boarding school far from others and seldom visit or even care about her? The girls we meet are just such girls, not wanted by their families, considered problems, destined to be hidden among the somewhat ruins of a dilapidated school that has a history of a young woman's ghost haunting its environs. These four young girls carry secrets, things done to them that they had no control over and when one of them goes missing, their lives are irreparably changed.

This book follows two time spans, one fifty years ago where we meet four of the girls at Idlewild Hall and one in the present. We met Fiona Sheridan whose sister was murdered and left on the grounds of the now abandoned Idlewild School grounds in 1994. Unable to ever forget what happened to her sister, Fiona, becomes involved once again when a mysterious benefactor decides to rebuild the school. Fiona, a small town reporter, decides to write a story about the school and events take a macabre and sinister turn as Fiona and her boyfriend, a local policeman, become involved in the stoy of the girls from fifty years ago. What happened at Idlewild Hall and who was this Mary Hand who seems to haunt the grounds, the buildings and the lives of those who traverse the environs of this school both now and in the past? What happened to her sister and is the man who is in prison for her murder the real killer?

This was a wonderful thriller that possessed all the elements to make it so. Ms St. James has created a book that combines the ideas of murder, eerie surroundings, and a ghost to make a truly mysterious and scary novel. I recommend it most highly to those who want to read such a well constructed story that will have you turning pages into the dead of the night.

Thank you to the author, the publisher, and Edelweiss for providing this reader with an ARC of a most thrilling read.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 10,843 reviews

Can't find what you're looking for?

Get help and learn more about the design.