Mildly douchey, but a fair introduction to the genre with a recommended listening list and a logic that is nice and really the best thing here. Walsh, writing in the mid-90s, comes across as one of those insufferable people who periodically interrupt what would otherwise be a nice intro to opera for the lay person with his pointless non-apologies for being white, writing about a mostly white-dominated genre, and delights in deriding those who think we should be nice to others on a culturally relativistic basis. Whatever. If he had just stuck to the opera and kept his numbing intolerances to himself, I would've enjoyed this a lot more. As it is, I stopped reading when he started making fun of people who think the thousands spent on opera might be better spent on the homeless and mocked the pretension of "feelings".
Anyway, there is a nice suggested listening list and some commentary on those which is nifty for someone who knows squat about opera, proof that when he de-douches, he can be of value in some small way.