Discovering the Vedas: Origins, Mantras, Rituals, Insights
First half of the book is interesting and informative but the rest is somewhat difficult to comprehend for a common reader; too much of linguistics !!!
The first few chapters which covered the pre-history and composition of Vedas were pure joy for me. But my real issue is about how he handles the alternate viewpoints. For instance, Soma as Fly Agaric mushroom has the valid criticism that it's a depressant (unless in small doses), the author talks as if it was never a depressant.
For now, this book is on hold because it's pretty dense as it stands.
This is a great book (hence 4 stars!) though a very dry academic work of linguistics and logic in the historical and geographical context of writing of the Vedas. It is fantastic if you are a linguist or logician but for most of us who are interested in history, spirituality and comparative theology, there is very little here.
This Is A Remarkable Book. It Untangles The Many Complexities Of The Vedas And Combines Staal S Scholarly Respect For The Texts, With Explanations That Are Lucid And Occasionally Witty. His Insights Are Thoughtful And Perceptive. Romila Thapar In This Unprecedented Guide To The Vedas, Frits Staal, The Celebrated Author Of Agni: The Vedic Ritual Of The Fire Altar And Universals: Studies In Indian Logic And Linguistics Examines Almost Every Aspect Of These Ancient Sources Of Indic Civilisation. St...more