Too much extraneous information bogs down a decent guide
I decided to pick up the Unofficial Guide based on being a big fan of the Touring Plans website, and while I did find a lot of useful information, the guide is just so bogged down by extraneous nonsense that finding those tidbits was more tedious than it really needed to be. As just one example, in a book that points continually to the (excellent) website, why is so much page space devoted to tea leaf reading about Disney’s future projects in the parks? Not only are these rumors covered better and more extensively on the plethora of fan sites, fora, and podcasts in the Disney fan community, the print medium makes them laughably inaccurate or outdated as soon as they hit the page. It’s wasted space.
Similarly, while I understand that many visitors to the World are also hitting other theme parks in the area, I don’t understand why so much page space in a Disney World guide book is devoted to Universal Studios. No disrespect to those who enjoy it, but when I’m planning a WDW vacation, staying on WDW property, with my whole week spent there, I expect a guide book for WDW to not have entire sections that don’t apply to WDW. My finger got numb swiping through all these pages. And I found it very irritating that the Hollywood Studios section literally told people to go to Uni instead. If I wanted to go there, I would. But I purchased a Disney guide book, for Disney info.
Too much space is similarly devoted to the musings of random readers. While some were amusing, there are numerous fan forums for this kind of thing—free, even. I bought a book for something different. If for some reason I needed it, I can get Karen Mom of 3’s views on Haunted Mansion scaring her little angels for free.
In the spirit of positivity though, I did find the transportation section with travel times listed for the different resorts very useful, and I also deeply appreciated the “not a touring plan” touring plans for people who aren’t A types checking attractions off a list.
So I recommend it with heavy caveats—if you can exercise your scroll button. But in this day and age, just go on the website. It’s superior by every conceivable metric, even with the subscription fee.