What do you think?
Rate this book
242 pages, Kindle Edition
First published May 3, 2016
What I liked: First, Minimalism is a needed force to push against the excess in our modern society. Our houses are (on average) *1000* square feet larger than in 1970 (2700 vs. 1700). This is despite the fact that our families are smaller. We have come to expect walk in closets in the master bedroom, and some houses even offer "his" and "hers" separate walk in closets!! We like to buy things, and companies have capitalized on this by promoting gift giving at virtually every holiday. Gone are the years when Easter baskets had a bunny and some candy. Now they have Iphone accessories, gift cards, clothes, etc. Do we really need all this? Is it actually making us happy? Becker asks us to examine these questions.
Second, Becker reminds us multiple times that relationships are what are important, and that relationships (more than possessions) give us love, security, a sense of belonging, and a purpose in life. When we work overtime to make mortgage payments on a ginormous house or a luxury car we are not only adding stress to our lives, we also have less time to spend with our family and friends. He brings this concept up again in the last chapter when he talks about donating time and/or money to charity. He mentions the positive benefits to communities from strong networks of active volunteers. Again, relationships build security. In this case, it builds a strong, resilient community.
Finally, Becker touts buying quality over quantity. For those of us who are interested in minimalism for environmental reasons, this is an important point. We have become a "throw away" society in a sense. 100 years ago people took care of their possessions, and fixed them whenever possible. Now seamstresses and shoe cobblers are a dying breed b/c most people would rather buy new shoes instead of fixing the sole on their current pair. When we study reviews, do our research, and then pick products based on their durability/quality we put less trash in the landfill, and probably save money in the long run too!
What I didn't like: Fair warning, Becker is a minister, and his beliefs come through loud and clear in the book. If you don't mind that, or share his beliefs, then no problem. But many people will have a hard time relating to the religious references.
Second, Just as people can focus too much on possessions, its possible to focus to much on a *lack* of possessions. He advocates the "29" rule. Basically put stuff in boxes, and if you don't use it within 29 days, then it is safe to throw/give it away. For clothing and kitchen items this is probably a decent rule of thumb (although don't put your winter boots in a box in June!), but for the garage and many other items this rule breaks down. We go camping 1-2 times a year and it is a great source of enjoyment for our family. I'm not going to throw away our assorted (organized) gear b/c we don't use it monthly. Same goes for beach towels, our canoe, and our holiday decorations. Also, I have a well stocked first aid kit (I'm a nurse after all!). I *HOPE* I don't have to use it every 29 days, and I'm certainly not going to throw it away if I don't. I understand that his point was to use this method for items when you are unsure of their value, but I would argue that seldom used things are not worthless. And I certainly don't need to purge my home of many of them.