Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read.
Start by marking “Drei Kameraden” as Want to Read:
Drei Kameraden
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating
Open Preview

Drei Kameraden

4.48  ·  Rating details ·  20,602 ratings  ·  547 reviews
THREE COMRADES

The year is 1928. On the outskirts of a large German city, three young men are earning a thin and precarious living. Fully armed young storm troopers swagger in the streets. Restlessness, poverty, and violence are everywhere. For these three, friendship is the only refuge from the chaos around them. Then the youngest of them falls in love, and brings into the
...more
Paperback, 590 pages
Published March 8th 2014 by Kiepenheuer & Witsch (first published 1936)
More Details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.
This book is not yet featured on Listopia. Add this book to your favorite list »

Community Reviews

Showing 1-30
4.48  · 
Rating details
 ·  20,602 ratings  ·  547 reviews


Filter
 | 
Sort order
Adolgushin
Jul 05, 2012 rated it it was amazing  ·  review of another edition
Краткое содержание любой книги Ремарка (и похоже Хэмингуэя тоже):

Я проснулся и выпил немного рому. Рана жутко болела, поэтому я выписался из больницы и погулял по городу. Денег не было, поэтому я купил пальто и пошел в кафе "Интернациональ". Там я поел и выпил рому. Погода в горах была паршивая, так что я выпил рому и вспомнил как на войне снаряд убил Петруцци и Лебовского. "Чёртова война!" -- подумал я и сел на поезд, прихватив в дорогу бутылочку рому. Приехав, я снял комнату в отеле. "Чёрт, з
...more
Vit Babenco
Jan 12, 2018 rated it it was amazing  ·  review of another edition
Youth is an age of magic: you’re full of pep, zest, enthusiasm, hopes, friendship… love.
She began to speak, but soon I no longer heard what she was saying. I heard only her voice, and as I sat there on the table in the dark hall, between the boar's head and the kitchen with the haricot beans, a door seemed to open and a wave of warmth and light came in, soothing and bright, full of dreams and desire and youth. I propped my feet against the table, I rested my head in my hand, I looked at the boar
...more
Luís C.
What a beautiful love story! Described in the inter-war with, in the background, crisis and rising unemployment. Nazism announced back cover watermark appears only towards the end of the book.
It is well written, it's fun and it holds up the whole time, and that's saying something since the three friends, comrades, are crazy about cars and keep a garage.
A great discovery.
রিফাত সানজিদা
পরথম বিশবযুদধের তিন পোড়খাওয়া সৈনিকের গলপ থরি কমরেডস। রবারট, গোটফরীড আর ওটো। ওদের সঙগী হিসেবে আছে আরো একজন-- কারল, দয রোড সপুক। আপাতঃ লককড়ঝককর চেহারার তাগড়াই এক রেসিংকার। কারলকে নিয়ে রাসতায় রেস দিতে গিয়েই ওদের সঙগে পরিচয় হয় পযাটরিসিয়া হফমযানের।
তারপর?
কখন, কীসের টানে মানুষ পায় যে বেঁচে থাকার মানে; ঝাপসা চোখে দেখা এইসব, সেইসব শহরে..

পযাটের মধযেই রবারট খুঁজে পেয়েছিল সেই বেঁচে থাকার মানে। সবপন দেখেছিলো এক আকাশের নিচে বাকি জীবনটা একসঙগে কাটানোর।
কিনতু এক উনমতত বিধাতার তৈরি এক ধূসর- অনতবিহীন আকাশ, মানুষ
...more
Omiana
Очень яркий и проникновенный роман о любви. Действие разворачивается в Германии 30-х гг., со всеми ее "прелестями" в виде тяжелого экономического кризиса и всеобщего упадка настроений, дикой инфляции, растущей безработицы и общего ощущения какой-то безнадежности, когда будущее кажется абсолютно беспросветным. Хотя даже и в такой обстановке есть место для любви, но для любви соответствующей обстоятельствам – надрывной, искренней, отчаянной, находящейся на грани жизни и смерти.
Читала книгу не отры
...more
Jonfaith
With blinded eyes I stared at the sky, this grey, endless sky of a crazy god, who made life and death for his amusement.

I think my grandmother would've liked Three Comrades. She may have read it. She passed in 2003 and I often miss her. The ranks of my rogues gallery of family contained only one reader and Stella Short was that and certainly something else. I'd like to think she died with a book in her lap.

Three Comrades is a melodrama about survivors of the Great War discovering the extent of
...more
Ilona
Jan 18, 2013 rated it it was amazing  ·  review of another edition
Shelves: favorites

"Es ist besser, zu sterben, wenn man noch leben möchte, als zu sterben und man möchte auch sterben." (it's better to die while you still want to live, than to die and want to die)

The novel is called Three Comrades but there were actually 4 of them - Robert Lohkamp, Otto Köster, Gottfried Lenz and Patrice Hollmann whom they meet in the very beginning of the novel and who became an essential part of it. And there were also other people who weren't formally "comrades" but they could be called so

...more
SAHAR
May 19, 2017 rated it it was amazing  ·  review of another edition
وبكل بساطة انتهت !

ثلاثة رفاق والرابعة انا هكذا كانت الرواية !
إن لم تكن احد الرفاق اثناء قراءتها فأنت لم تقرأها

كارل كوستر لينس روبي وبات

في الصفحة الاخيره تمنيت لو ان يدي تمسك بمئة صفحة اخرى لم اقرأها واصل اليها.


الرواية تتحدث عن ثلاثة رفاق في احداث مابعد الحرب العالمية في المانيا ومعاناة الشباب في البطالة ومحاول كسب المال بشتى الطرق

رواية عن الحب والصداقة والكفاح لكن بدون الم بنظرات ايجابية وضحكات ورومنسية كـ رومنسية لينس فيها.

Deanna L
Apr 30, 2012 rated it it was amazing  ·  review of another edition
Shelves: favorites
Read this book twice and would read it over and over again. Definitely a staple in my library. I have the Russian edition, I am not sure how the english one reads but it is an absolutely amazing read that touches on so many topics so many of us can relate to.. the lost generation, the destruction brought about by the war and the dispersed populace living or scrambling to make a living in many countries. that shamed german diaspora that's not really german in a sense that they did not support nas ...more
Maria
Oct 10, 2011 rated it liked it  ·  review of another edition
Shelves: german
Хорошая книга. Я с ней опоздала. Точно знаю в какой именно временной отрезок эта книга, если бы я ее прочитала именно тогда, стала бы любимой на долгие годы. Точно знаю на каких страницах я бы плакала. Знаю, кто стал бы любимым героем. Сейчас я читала ее, как патологоанатом делает вскрытие, бесстрастно препарируя- вот грустный момент, вот смешная шутка.
Очень жаль, книга действительно хороша, а Ремарк отличный писатель. А я по видимому, плохой читатель :)
Rizwan
This novel is the 2nd Greatest book I've read, 2nd only to another Remarque classic, All Quiet On the Western Front. I like to think of myself as the full-blooded manliest man there is (its true), but I don't feel even an ounce of shame to admit that this is the very first time I cried while reading a book, and every time i re-read it (I almost memorized the whole novel after reading countless times), it never fails to bring a drop of tear on my eye. This is the BEST DAMN Romantic Story/Friend-c ...more
Aila Sako
Nov 06, 2018 rated it it was amazing  ·  review of another edition
Magjik!!! Nen optiken time Remarku e ka shpalosur gjithmone talentin e tij ne pershkrimin e raporteve njerezore. Ne kete liber do gjeni nje romance jo si gjithe te tjerat, ndjenja te jashtezakonshme, miqesi te verteta, mbijetese... Nje liber magjik dhe me shume ndjenja. Dashuroj cdo faqe te tij. Keshtu do ta dashuroni dhe ju 😉 Jua rekomandoj me patjeter ☺ ...more
Dan
Feb 21, 2019 rated it it was amazing  ·  review of another edition
The music enchanted the air. It was like the south wind, like a warm night, like swelling sails beneath the stars, completely and utterly unreal... It made everything spacious and colourful, the dark stream of life seemed pulsing in it; there were no burdens any more, no limits; there existed only glory and melody and love, so that one simply could not realize that, at the same time as this music was, outside there ruled poverty and torment and despair.

Three Comrades by Erich Marie Remarque the
...more
Gulbanu Bibicheva
Книга неймовірно близька і зрозуміла. Вона про радість відчувати кожен день життя. Без далеких планиів на майбутнє, бо воно може ніколи й не відбутись.
Радостина Даскалова
Ще започна с малко предистория.
Преди почти 2г. една скъпа приятелка ми прати файл, беше книга на Хемингуей и ми написа следното:
- Прочети я.
- Какво е това?
- "Безкраен празник" на Хемингуей. След като я прочетеш, ще ти се прииска да се омъжиш.
- Да, бе. За тоя ли? Дет се женил четер' пъти, пропил се и се самоубил.
- Като видиш какво пише, ще ти се прииска да си седемнайстата.
- Идиотка.
След близо седмица започна да ми досажда: "Прочете ли я?", "Прочете ли я?" Все отговарях с кратичкото "не". Накрая
...more
Nevena
Oct 28, 2017 rated it it was amazing  ·  review of another edition
Когато бях тийнейджърка, това беше един от моите три любими романа, заедно с "Цитаделата" на Кронин и "Вино от глухарчета". Интересно ми беше сега, след толкова години, как ще го възприема. Усещането ми беше като завръщане вкъщи. Да, страничният наблюдател вероятно би забелязал малко повече патетика в определени моменти, но аз не съм такъв. И друго ми дойде наум, като откритие: едва ли има друг писател, който толкова много да ми е повлиял. А последно го бях чела преди няколко десетилетия.
Christina Stoyanova
Ако можех, бих дала и 10. Истинска, тежка, разтърсваща. История за хора, които се опитват да намерят любовта и доброто в един грозен, брутален свят, който не прощава. Рядко книга ме запленява така от самото и начало. Книга за това да черпиш сила и вдъхновение от приятелството и любовта, за това как човешките емоции могат да ни отведат извън всякакви граници, които можем да си представим. От другата страна на фронта хората са точно като нас - борейки се до последен дъх да запазят честта и хуманно ...more
Dawn Breeze
رحلة طويلة طويلة جدًا مع روبي وكوستر ولينس وبات

الرواية تصف الأوضاع الاجتماعية والاقتصادية في ألمانيا زمنَ ما بعد الحرب العالمية.

أسلوب الكاتب فيها ممتع وفيه الكثير من الفلسفة، لكنها مليئة بالتفاصيل الدقيقة جدًا، وعدد الشخصيات فيها مرعب!

طريقة الكاتب في السرد مختلفة جدًا عن طريقته في ليلة لشبونة، حيث فيها الكثير من السخرية والنكات التي تجري على ألسنة الشخصيات خصوصًا لينس.

النهاية كانت مزعجة جدًا، لم أتخيل أن يموت كل من لينس وبات
وماذا حل بألفونس وكوستر؟ فقد انقطعت قصتهما
التفاصيل والتشعبات كثيرة ولا ت
...more
Sara Ali Owaisheer
Apr 11, 2015 rated it it was amazing  ·  review of another edition
Shelves: 2015
ثلاثة رفاق

من روائع الروايات المترجمة التي قرأتها ..
عندما يكون غموض الكاتب دافعا لنا لإكمال القراءة واكتشاف الأبطال وكأننا نغوص في تفاصيلهم ..

تعايشت مع الأبطال مواجع الموت و الفراق المؤلمة ..

تلك المواقف التي نرقبها على أمل العودة ..
والتضحيات من أجل الاحبة ..
Nouf Baw
Apr 28, 2018 rated it it was amazing  ·  review of another edition
تبًا لك يا ريمارك

ما عساي أقول؟ أكره مراجعات الكتب كرهًا شديدًا
تتحدث الرواية عن وضع ألمانيا بعد الحرب العالمية الأولى بعد خسارتها، الأوضاع الإقتصادية المتردية بالذات
أبطالنا هم 4 رفاق، وأنا الرفيقة الخامسة

كانت وتيرتي مع هذه الرواية غريبة، أحببتها في البداية، كرهت منتصفها، لم أستطِع كبح دموعي عند الفصول الأخيرة
ما أزعجني حقا هو حجم الواقعية، كل المأساة كانت اعتيادية، اعتادوها.
غضبت عندما أقدمت إحدى الشخصيات على الإنتحار ثم ذهبوا لتناول العشاء بعدها، هكذا بكل بساطة!
كرهت عبثيتها ولكن مقتي هذا عائد
...more
Prerazmišljavanje
Nov 14, 2018 rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
Shelves: 2017, po-preporuci
Bojim se da mi postaje predvidiv, iako je uvek lepo topiti njegove rečenice na jeziku.
classic reverie
A wonderful finish to Erich Maria Remarque's trilogy of "All Quiet on the Western Front". All three books deal with a different group of soldiers but the mention of some names present in the other books but not related to this story. The first two books are more closely dealing with the war and aftermath but "There Comrades" has a storyline less war related but more in line of the poverty all around Germany and these men making due. I had seen the 1938 movie years ago but not until I started to ...more
🐶 Con Bé Ki 🐶
Cuốn này đẹp và buồn. Có những chi tiết khiến mình lặng người đi, như khi Koster chạy như bay trên chiếc xe Karl trong đêm tối chỉ để mang cho bằng được ông bác sĩ đến khám cho... vợ của bạn; hay như khi anh quyết định trả thù cho cái chết vô tình của bạn mình - cái con người lãng mạn cuối cùng ấy; và cả việc bán đi chiếc xe yêu dấu... Cuốn sách tràn đầy tình yêu thương, tình đồng đội, tình yêu dấu... ấy đã khiến mình đọc miệt mài, đọc say sưa mà không muốn dừng lại.
Daniel Villines
Great books of great length always seem to fulfill their destiny at the end. There is a journey to be had and a certain number of pages is required to complete the adventure. Sometimes that number is small and sometimes that number seems to be insurmountable, but at the end, if the book is great, that number seems perfect.

Thee Comrades simply attempts to be too many things. It attempts to define a type of friendship that is forged out of horrific experiences, it attempts to describe the struggle
...more
Stella
Nov 18, 2008 rated it it was amazing  ·  review of another edition
This book was recommended to me by one of my best guy friends, as his favourite book. It was my first novel from remarque, but since I have read amny, and this still remains my favourite. I don't understand why Arch of Triumph is the more praised or famous, when Three Comrades is so pure, maybe that isn't the word, the truths and facts of life he tells us about are gripping in his simple presentation.

I love war novels, and this one is one of the best ones I have read, what I particularly love ab
...more
الخنساء
انتهيت منها قبل فترة، وكل ما قررت الكتابة عنها أحتار ولا أجد شيئا لأكتبه، مراجعات الروايات صعبة وعسيرة
الرواية تتحدث عن فترة مابعد الحرب العالمية الأولى، ألمانيا حينها مهزومة وتعاني من مشاكل عدة، والرواية تقدم جوانب إجتماعية وتغطية لأوضاع قطاع معين من الشعب الألماني خلال تلك الفترة
في الرواية شيء مختلف، يصعب التعبير عنه أو وصفه وتحديده، لكن بقرائتها يتضح ذلك
أعجبني الكثير فيها: تأملات البطل، حواراته الداخلية، حديثه المتكرر عن الجبهة والقتال، الحب، المرض، الفقر، الجوع، السياسة الخ، شخصيات الأبطال عم
...more
Md. Faysal Alam Riyad
Jan 18, 2017 rated it it was amazing  ·  review of another edition
Shelves: favorites
ইহা একটি পরেমের উপনযাস।
ইহা একটি দারশনিক উপনযাস।
ইহা কয়েকজন বনধুর বনধুতবের গলপ।
ইহা একটি জীবন বাসতবতার গলপ।
ইহা পরথম বিশবযুদধের তিন সাহসী যুদধার গলপ।

সব কিছুকে হাতের নাগালের একটু বাইরে রাখা ভাল। কেননা নাগালের মধযে রাখলে ছুঁতে পারবে, আর ছুঁতে পারলেই সেটা নিজের করে নিতে চাইবে।

আসলে পৃথিবীতে কোন কিছুই সমপূরণ নিজের করে পাওয়া যায় না............
...more
Anna
Mar 18, 2012 rated it it was amazing  ·  review of another edition
Shelves: german
"Нежность, в которой растворялось желание"


Эта книга ознаменовала мое знакомство с творчеством Ремарка. И скажу просто, до этого момента я действительно и не подозревала, что обычная книга может настолько тронуть, настолько зацепить и настолько вывернуть душу своим повествованием.

Для меня "Три товарища" - это символ. Чистой любви и крепкой дружбы. Символ жизни.
শালেকুল পলাশ
রবারট, গোটফরীড, ওটো। থরী কমরেডস। ১ম বিশব যুদধের সারভাইভার সৈনিক তারা। যুদধকে খুব কাছে থেকে দেখেছে। যুদধ পরবরতী নড়বড়ে অরথনীতির জারমানীতে গযারেজের বযবসা খুলে বসেছে তারা। কোন মতে চলে যাচছিল তাদের।

হঠাত করেই একদিন ভাগযকরমে দেখা হয়ে যায় তাদের সাথে পযাটরিসিযার। অনিনদয সুনদর বলতে যা বোঝায় তাইই সে। রবারট, যার ধারাবরননায় লিখা বইটি, পরথম দেখায় ভাল লেগে যায় তাকে। আসতে আসতে ঘনিষঠ হতে থাকে সে পযাটের। টানা টানির সংসার তাদের দুইজনের বাট ভালই চলছিল সব কিছু। এর মাঝে দেখা দেয় পযাটের অসুখ।

বইটা যাসট এক কথায় মাসটার
...more
Ada Tabaku
May 05, 2018 rated it it was amazing  ·  review of another edition
I mrekullueshem
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 next »
topics  posts  views  last activity   
Goodreads Librari...: This topic has been closed to new comments. Add description and other data 7 23 Aug 26, 2018 11:19AM  
"Three comrades" or "Arch of Triumph" 8 76 Jun 17, 2014 03:04PM  
  • Epifānijas
  • Theatre
  • The Little Lady of the Big House
  • Dvēseļu putenis
  • Aija
  • Agrā rūsa
  • Dzeja
  • The Stoic (Trilogy of desire, #3)
  • Всадник без головы
  • Pasakas par ziediem
  • Kaķīša dzirnavas
  • Goya
  • Bille
  • Dievų miškas
  • The Cage
  • კაცი, რომელსაც ლიტერატურა ძლიერ უყვარდა
  • Silva Rerum
  • Jelgava 94
3,258 followers
Erich Maria Remarque (pen name of Erich Paul Remark) is one of the best known and most widely read authors of German literature in the twentieth century.

Remarque's biography is essentially marked and his writing fundamentally influenced by German history of the twentieth century: Childhood and youth in imperial Osnabrück, World War I, the Weimar Republic, and most of all his exile in Switzerland
...more
“It's only terrible to have nothing to wait for.” 698 likes
“I did not want to think so much about her. I wanted to take her as an unexpected, delightful gift, that had come and would go again — nothing more. I meant not to give room to the thought that it could ever be more. I knew too well that all love has the desire for eternity and that therein lies its eternal torment. Nothing lasts. Nothing.” 276 likes
More quotes…