Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read.
Start by marking “Roommates (Puck Buddies, #2)” as Want to Read:
Roommates (Puck Buddies, #2)
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating
Open Preview


(Puck Buddies #2)

3.78  ·  Rating details ·  7,176 ratings  ·  480 reviews
Life is full of expectations.
For Brady Coldwell it’s always been about the game.
Hockey is and always will be, his life.
His family sacrificed everything to get him here and he won’t let them down.
He knows what’s expected of him.
Natalie Banks is no different.
She too knows what it means to have everyone sacrifice for you.
She knows about the debt that’s left owing in the end a
Kindle Edition
Published October 25th 2015
More Details... Edit Details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.
This book is not yet featured on Listopia. Add this book to your favorite list »

Community Reviews

Showing 1-30
Average rating 3.78  · 
Rating details
 ·  7,176 ratings  ·  480 reviews

More filters
Sort order
Start your review of Roommates (Puck Buddies, #2)
Nov 27, 2015 rated it did not like it
Reader Enjoyment Warning: male MC has explicit sex scenes with other women after he meets female MC and even after he develops feelings for her.

Why in the ever-loving hell of all hells do authors do this f'd up shit to readers?!? Why? Just why?


The book starts out with good girl Nat being a sheltered only child wanting to spread her wings in a new "adult" apartment, only to find out her sneaky friend lied to her about the gender of her new roommate. Nat is cute, funny, innocent, and swe
3.5 Stars

Roommates is the lighthearted story of two unlikely people finding a way to live together and not only make it work, but thrive because of it.

Nat's the girl who's spent her life doing exactly what she should. Right schools, right boyfriend, rich and famous on a Kardashian level best friend. Brody, or "BJ" (yes, that nickname is meant to conjure dirty things) has spent his life working towards his one and only goal, the NHL. He doesn't do relationships and his famous sex move is the "Cli
Liv ☾

☾I am such a sucker for a good friends/roommates/lovers story. So naturally I was super excited to read this once I found the book. Brady and Natalie's story was very typical, that's not a bad thing but I think it was missing something to make the book stand out.

☾I really enjoyed going through Natalie's journey with her. Especially because I can relate with the parents aspect of her story. When she moves to New York and moves in with Brady, I felt like a proud mom. I'm not a mom, so...
Melissa (Ever So Mela)
I finally finished!!!

Look....just no. No on all accounts.
The fact that I am seriously struggling to remember their freaking names seconds after finishing is not a glowing recommendation. I just had to look that crap up.
So, No.

No to Brady and his sleazy way of life.

No to Natalie and her wholesome self.

No to Sami, the over the top rich friend who I'm tired of hearing is RICH! We got it the first 100 times!

No to Matt, the other rich best friend no one gives a crap about.

No to the ex boyfriend and
DNF - I am not telling you not to read it. This is just my opinion.

This did not work for me and I loved the premise. The hero thinks he is moving in with a guy named, Nate, and the heroine thinks she is moving in with a girl named, BJ. However, Nate is actually a girl and BJ is actually a professional hockey player named, Brady.

Dual POVs. The writing just did not work for me. I can't put my finger on it. I am not sure if it was because there was a frequent switch in POVs or something else.

By t
Cute room mates romance, nicely paced with a good build up and some feels at the beginning. For me it tapered off a bit and didn't quite deliver on its early promise or it would've been a more satisfying read. I was expecting a build up to something but it kind of began to peter out at about 60% and limped to the finish.

I also struggled with some of the dialogue, confusing who was saying what. I'm not sure whether it was the formatting style, the writing or just me, but I had to stop and re-rea
Nov 12, 2015 rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
3.75 Stars
It's been a few days since I finished this book, and have since read 3.5 other books, and it still on my mind. For me, that is the equivalent of a glowing review. This wasn't the deepest of topics nor did I learn something insightful, but it was great entertainment, and that for the most part is why I read. well done Tara Brown!!
Michelle [Helen Geek]
Nov 03, 2015 rated it liked it  ·  review of another edition
Recommends it for: Anyone loving a sports themed romance.


The hockey theme snagged me. I really liked most of it. The whole Clinton thing was just gross and overdone. I'll read others by this author. 3 stars.
May 13, 2016 rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
Natalie thinks that she is finally getting out of her parents house and getting set up with a perfect roommate by her best friend. Supposedly a female roommate named BJ. She is completely surprise to find out BJ is in fact a male named Brady, a hockey player. Brady is equally surprised thinking he was getting a male roommate named Nate.

This was a good book, cute story line/concept. It had a lot of funny parts - the funniest being their nicknames for each other, BJ and Nate Dog. Also Nat kicking
Nov 08, 2015 rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
So I clearly have a weak point for hockey players.. but turns out I also seem to like room mate novels... well at least when they this well written, funny and super cute.
I kept giggling while reading this. YEP, you read right. GIGGLING! I know, right. Good thing it's Sunday and I wasn't reading in public. My whole badass rep would be ruined for good.
This was the perfect cute & fluffy. The right amount of sizzling, smut and gooey- left me warm and fuzzy.
The only thing that went on my nerves- the
Oct 29, 2015 rated it liked it  ·  review of another edition
Way too much of a man-slut. I can deal if it was before the characters meet, even deal with it being mentioned that he is still doing things. But for the love of God, please authors, don't describe sexual encounters that don't involve the main characters. Oh, and this guy was off the slut meter even for romance-book man-whores. ...more
★ Belle The Bibliophile ★
A very unputdownable read with a well-written relationship build up, really cute as hell couple and LOL moments. Need I say more?
Jan 25, 2016 rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
Fluff alert! I love a good fluffy new adult read. That is exactly what this book is. There isn’t a ton of conflict, or outside forces into play here. Just a lot of angst and sexual tension, wrapped up into one of my favorite tropes. Unsuspecting roommates!

This book follows our two protagonists as they navigate their new living situation. After being “set-up” by both of their best friends, to be roommates. They decide to make the best of a bad situation and become friends. Natalie is sheltered, a
Donna ~ The Romance Cover
3.5 stars!! This was a cute feel good read, not a lot of angst, a tad predictable but an easy page turner that just left you smiling from ear to ear. Brady was a promising Hockey player and Natalie was finally getting out from under her parents wings and breaking out into the work force on her own away from home. Friends had set up their accommodation for them and with Brady's nickname being BJ and a slight slip of some conniving fingers Nat became Nate and these roommates thought they were shar ...more
♥ Sarah
Feb 02, 2016 rated it did not like it  ·  review of another edition
Shelves: fiction
I wanted to like this. I really did. But, NO. I'm surprised I even finished this book.

"BJ" is a dickwad and Natalie is a TSTL pushover who takes what she can get from a dude who sleeps with other hockey groupies who throw themselves at him. He just takes them where he can get 'em - even with old, married women, even AFTER he meets and starts having feelings for the MC. Gross. And there are EXPLICIT, detailed, long-ass scenes re: his sexual encounters.... more detailed scenes with him and the ot
Nov 01, 2015 rated it liked it  ·  review of another edition
It was a good enough read. I was entertained.
There were so many things off about this book. It wasn't bad, really, but it definitely wasn't good.

1. SO. MUCH. SLUT-SHAMING. All of the girls who like sex in this book are sluts and whores. To be fair, Brady is called a slut too, but why can't everyone just like sex? Why do they have to be sluts?

2. Transphobia and homophobia. This was perplexing to me, because there's a point in the book where the characters are discussing whether someone is gay and one of the minor characters says "not to br
I have to start this review by saying Brady is a pig. I loathe books where the H has explicit relations with other women in the book. Brady did. I hate players. Brady was. I hate books where the H thinks sex thoughts about other women. Brady did. Having said this, I really liked this book.

Brady and Nat met by chance, well if you consider chance your 2 best friends secretly putting you together. Nat is coming off of a bad relationship, so she has major trust issues. Brady is Mr. Hockey. All wome
This was not what I expected, but so much better! I loved it! Yes, Brady was a manwhore and a dawg, but he was so loveable and when he realized he had feelings for Natalie, he immediately stopped whoring it up. He was a one woman man and I loved it. I also loved that once they were together, there was some drama, but not any break up drama where they had to find their way back to each other. It was awesome. Lots of LOL moments too. I really hope the author has books planned for Sami and some of ...more
Oct 26, 2015 rated it did not like it  ·  review of another edition
To be honest, this was very VERY nearly a DNF, although I’m not sure if skim reading really counts as ‘read’.

Also, the constant references to Brady's 'signature move' were a right turn-off.

"I like to call it the Clinton."

Michelle Monroe
Oct 27, 2015 rated it it was amazing  ·  review of another edition
**To top off the perfect body great hair thing, his face is like a Michelangelo. He’s a god.
Yup, he’s too hot to be a roommate.

That's exactly what Natalie thought when she seen that her roommate wasn't some butch girl who played Hockey, but a superstar hockey player that was hot as h*ll. It made her uncomfortable, she hasn't had that much experience with guys, only having had the one serious boyfriend, and being in her 20s and just now being away from home.

Brady thought he was rooming with a co
Madeline Maureen
Nov 05, 2015 rated it did not like it  ·  review of another edition
Recommends it for: no one
Not my cuppa. Just nope. If I never hear/read "Clintoned" again it would be too soon. It's not funny or endearing it's middle school locker room humor that falls flat and makes me want to gag. This is supposedly supposed to be a romance, but it's just kind of a gross telling of how a dirty manwhore finds his "bland toast". Little romance, with very little sexy if any in my opinion. Could have done without most of Brady's stories of past and present conquest. I need a brain scrub and a bath.
I ke
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it, click here.
Dec 04, 2015 rated it it was amazing  ·  review of another edition
Sweet and Super Funny!

This book was funny and sweet, and had the perfect ending. Spoiler alert!!! I kept waiting for the formulaic break up at around 70% (when everything seems to be going well, and a stupid misunderstanding breaks them up only to have them get back together at 99%). But it never happened! It was a refreshing, sweet, really funny read and I HIGHLY recommend this book!
Julia Kai
Oct 27, 2015 rated it it was amazing
Loved it ! First time when I read a book by this author and i like it. Now i want Sami and Matt story
Nov 01, 2015 rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
Cute story of a manwhole changing his ways. of course throw hockey in, I'm there ...more
3 1/2 stars

So, I will be 100% truthful. I almost dnf'd this right out of the gate. I absolutely despise detailed sex scenes with other women even if the main characters aren't together yet. You can "tell" me it happened but don't give me the details. I don't want or need them. Everyone got the fact that Brady was a man-whore, we did not need the level of description that was provided. I literally cringed through those scenes. Ugh! Yes, there were more than one.

That aside, I really enjoyed the re
Nov 11, 2015 rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
Shelves: sports, swoon, lol
Nat and Brady start living together due a "misunderstanding" caused her best friend and her best friend's boyfriend. They totally tried set them up. It worked. And it was great.

My first impression of Brady wasn't very good. I mean, I knew he was a manwhore, but I wasn't expeting read a scene where he is about to have sex with an almost married woman and say something like: "oh, you have someone, it's cool, let's do it anyway, I won't tell". I was like: wtf 0.o

Nat was a little freaked out about
Jackie (No Bent Spines)
Sorry. Can't do this. Sexism and stupidity annoy me. So many cringes in so little time. Let's talk about gender roles, shall we?

DNF @ 19%

Reason Number One: Gender Role Serotypes. *gags* Oh this book was stuffed with them. Super manly-he man with cave man qualities and must (excuse the medical terminology) copulate with anything that breathes. Usually this wouldn’t bother me so much. But it went hand in hand with the female gender role: super flimsy main girl
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 next »
topics  posts  views  last activity   
Run from Reality ...: This topic has been closed to new comments. April Group Read: Roommates by Erin Leigh 9 5 Apr 11, 2016 09:47AM  

Readers also enjoyed

  • Delivery Girl (Minnesota Ice #1)
  • The Romantic Pact (Kings of Football, #2)
  • Getting Lucky Number Seven (Taking Shots, #1)
  • The Bookworm's Guide to Faking It (The Bookworm's Guide, #2)
  • Pucks & Penalties: Pucked Series Deleted Scenes and Outtakes Version 2.0 (Pucked, #6.5)
  • Anatomy of a Player (Taking Shots, #2)
  • #Delete
  • Hard Love (Trophy Boyfriends, #3)
  • The Revenge Pact (Kings of Football, #1)
  • Destiny on Ice (Boys of Winter, #1)
  • Not My Match (The Game Changers, #2)
  • Crazy Pucking Love (Taking Shots, #3)
  • Slapshot (Moo U #2)
  • One Night with the Rebel (Looking to Score, #0.5)
  • Just a Taste
  • Yanked (Frenched, #1.5)
  • Player
  • The Bookworm's Guide to Dating (The Bookworm's Guide, #1)
See similar books…

Other books in the series

Puck Buddies (5 books)
  • Puck Buddies (Puck Buddies, #1)
  • Bed Buddies (Puck Buddies, #3)
  • Girl Next Door (Puck Buddies #4)
  • Baby Daddies (Puck Buddies #5)

News & Interviews

  If you listen to NPR regularly, you’ve likely heard the voice of Shankar Vedantam, the longtime science correspondent and host of the radio...
10 likes · 2 comments
“over me. And his brother offers me his hand. “The girl who tamed the beast. It’s nice to finally meet.” Andy laughs. I can tell by the sparkle in his eyes he knows exactly what his brother is like. “Come on, let's sit and get ready.” Their mom sits and drags me with her. “How did BJ seem today? He gets tense sometimes when it’s game day. Was he tense?” She’s tense but I get it. This is a lifetime of work coming to a head. The culmination of a family full of dreams all coming true in one moment. Sami sits next to me, doing her indifferent face. It’s weird being with them and being with my family. The life was the same and then completely opposite. His parents wanted what was best for him, same as mine, and they had a dream for him, same as mine, but they let him choose the dream, in the end. My dad did that for me, but my mom didn't. I wish she could see and feel what this moment is like. I wish I” 1 likes
“If only we were smart enough to follow our hearts the first time we walk away from something.” 1 likes
More quotes…