What do you think?
Rate this book
291 pages, Paperback
First published July 12, 2016
Actual rating: 3.7 stars
“What about Alice? Did she have a happy ending?”
That's what you'll have to find out after reading this book. But let's think for a moment what are happy endings for the books like this one?“The world gobbles us and chews us and swallows us,” Hatcher said, in that uncanny way he had of reading her thoughts. “I think happy endings must be accidents.”
“But we hope for them all the same,” Alice said. She looked sadly at the remains of those hopeful faces. Above all, we hope not to die in terror.
Yes, this book still has this gripping feeling of desperation and lost hope about it, and happy endings are something distant and out of a fairytale. By the way, one of the things I liked about this book is how Alice during her journey remembered fairytales her governess told her. And these tales urge your belief in the absence of happy endings to bloom more and more.
She remembered a story one of her governesses told her, about a little girl who went into a house that wasn’t hers. She sat in three chairs and tasted three bowls of porridge and rolled in three beds. And for being too curious (and, Alice thought, very rude) the little girl was eaten up by the bears who lived there.
In our world this fairytale would've been a nice story about a little girl who was greeted by three nice bears into their house and who lent her one of their beds to rest a night.
But in spite of this story been gloom, the mood of the dark fantasy that was constantly present in the previous book, did not stay in this one. We don't have as many scary moments as we had before, and Alice's adventures are simply adventures, not something nightmarish. And, alas, this is the main flaw of this story; I found myself more than once bored by Alice and her getting from point A to point B without anything extraordinary happening on her way. Yes, there were curious moments, but that's it: they were just curious and nothing more.
This book is mostly centered on Alice after the circumstances parted her and Hatcher. She has to find her way to the person she cares about, and on her way she'll conquer some goblins and giants and such. I also appreciated the unexpected twists about some of the characters from the previous book and, of course, the author made some curious tricks on a well-known history of Red Queen and her sister White Queen.
The main topic of this book is love. I've noticed some people were not happy about it, saying that this book was centered of Alice's and Hatcher's romance. But Alice was on her own for the most of the book, and, well, you can't have romance with yourself (unless you are a princess from Madly). So to speak, this book is centered on the topic of love in a wider sense: love for siblings, your friends, lovers and such. Romantic love was also the topic, and frankly, I always liked Alice and Hatcher together as they make a rather strange couple, and their love in its madness has some charm. But it was not the center of the story.No man in the New City could love her as Hatcher did—of that Alice was certain. It was deep and all-consuming but somehow never suffocating. It was unselfish. It did not ask for anything and yet he made no secret of his need. There was no one in the world like Hatcher, and if she hadn’t been mad, there would be no Hatcher for her.
A bear that would turn into a prince, she thought, and then smiled sadly to herself. Her prince was not a bear, but a madman. Alice had learned that you could not choose whom to love. If royalty appeared out of nowhere and offered her a future, she would have to turn away from it, because Alice could never love any other but the one with grey eyes and bloodstained hands.
And, of course, this book is about finding your own true self. Who Alice is and what she must become in order to slay her demons and become a full-powered magician?She didn’t have to be Cheshire’s ideal of a Magician or Hatcher’s ideal of a lover or her parents’ ideal of a daughter. She could be Alice.
One more thing I adore about this duology is that the villains are never as scary as they seem at first. Every time Alice's destination lead her to creatures of terror and legend who terrified people and bathed in human blood. But up front they were not as scary as it seemed, and often more pathetic than terrifying. The thing is, our greatest fears when we face them, are nothing but illusions, smoke and mirrors>.
All in all, it was a decent continuation of a wonderful book, but nevertheless it lacked in tension and atmosphere. Also, there's an issue with potential sequels, though the story ended logically and without cliffhangers, the author still left some threads that could be used for more stories if needed. I just hope if that ever happens, it'll be as engaging as its predecessors.
"The world gobbles us and chews us and swallows us," Hatcher said, in that uncanny way he had of reading her thoughts. "I think happy endings must be accidents."
"But we hope for them all the same," Alice said. She looked sadly at the remains of those hopeful faces. Above all, we hope not to die in terror.
"What about Alice? Did she have a happy ending?"
"This is rather like a game of chess, isn't it? A White Queen and a Black King and all the little pieces--me and Hatcher and the children from the village--moving in between, trying not to get swiped."
“The world gobbles us and chews us and swallows us,” Hatcher said, in that uncanny way he had of reading her thoughts. “I think happy endings must be accidents.”
“But we hope for them all the same,” Alice said. She looked sadly at the remains of those hopeful faces. Above all, we hope not to die in terror.”
After defeating the Jabberwocky, the only thing Alice wants is to go home. But there is no home for her and she promised Hatcher to go find his daughter.
So they go on another journey. A journey that has a wicked Queen who steals children and a town of Ghosts and Monsters.
In the end, Alice will have to find out who the real monsters are and what made them monsters to begin with.