Yes, it did in fact take me over 6 years to finish this anthology, and not for lack of picking it up, which I probably did at least once in every one of those years. The vast majority of these were just... a slog. Uninspired, or off-putting, or actively gross (and not in a fun horror kind of way.)
Three standouts are the only reason I'm not giving it one star.
- I liked "Memorabilia" but that's mostly all I have to say about it. Some kind of 3.5 runner up.
- I thought "'Til Death" by Barbara Hambly was the best horror of the collection, and caught a glimpse of another review about it I thought missed the point. It's not that hell is an airport with your wife, it's a "hell is me (and I can't other-people my way out of that)" take I found really refreshing after the ad nauseam takes on "hell is other people." It made me upset, I was not having a good time: That's good horror. 4.5 stars.
- I actually read "If I Could See Lazarus Rising" by Kathleen O'Mally last, which I'm glad about, because it made my cry, and it was the best all around story of the book. Absolutely beautiful. 5 stars.