Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read.
Start by marking “The Vital Question: Energy, Evolution, and the Origins of Complex Life” as Want to Read:
The Vital Question: Energy, Evolution, and the Origins of Complex Life
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating
Open Preview

The Vital Question: Energy, Evolution, and the Origins of Complex Life

4.17  ·  Rating details ·  3,152 ratings  ·  426 reviews
The Earth teems with life: in its oceans, forests, skies and cities. Yet there’s a black hole at the heart of biology. We do not know why complex life is the way it is, or, for that matter, how life first began. In The Vital Question, award-winning author and biochemist Nick Lane radically reframes evolutionary history, putting forward a solution to conundrums that have pu ...more
Paperback, 368 pages
Published June 21st 2016 by W. W. Norton Company (first published April 23rd 2015)
More Details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Reader Q&A

To ask other readers questions about The Vital Question, please sign up.
Popular Answered Questions
Inna Some ideas and concepts as well as the general fascination with the mitochondria will sound familiar to a reader of "Power, Sex, Suicide", but this is…moreSome ideas and concepts as well as the general fascination with the mitochondria will sound familiar to a reader of "Power, Sex, Suicide", but this is a whole new book with new insights and ideas and little direct overlap of content with PSS. Totally worth the read.(less)

Community Reviews

Showing 1-30
4.17  · 
Rating details
 ·  3,152 ratings  ·  426 reviews


Filter
 | 
Sort order
Brian Clegg
Apr 15, 2015 rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
This is a bravura, hit-you-between-the-eyes popular science book which, were it not for a couple of failings, would not only be five star, but quite possibly the best popular science book of the year so far.

Nick Lane succeeds on two levels. One is opening the eyes of a relatively ignorant reader on the subject of biology like me to the sheer, magnificent complexity of biological mechanisms. I was aware, for instance, of mitochondria as the power sources of eukaryotic cells, but hadn't a clue jus
...more
Socraticgadfly
Oct 11, 2015 rated it it was amazing  ·  review of another edition
Shelves: science
I learned a lot from this book, and unlearned some old things about biology and biochemistry. Here's some notes I took about the book, to save on my computer:

0s Nick Lane: The Vital Question


1. Endosymbiosis was a one-off between an archaeon body and a bacterium that became mitochondrium. Golgi bodies may or may not have invaded later; other “subbodies” were likely produced by internal action, tho Lane doesn’t specify.
2. Archaea and bacteria didn’t diversify at black smoker vents on seafloor ridg
...more
Charlene
Until now, Nick Lane has been my favorite author. Increasingly, or at least in my estimation, he is joining the ranks of the old science guard who work hard to a) politicize science and b) make important science inaccessible to the non-scientific, but intelligent and curious, reader. If his discussion of Margulis had been half as balanced as the male scientists he discussed, who also got a few things right and a few thing very wrong, chapter one would have been tolerable. Francis Crick believed ...more
Science (Fiction) Comedy Horror and Fantasy Geek/Nerd
How have physics and biochemistry been so perfectly matched in such tiny organisms?

Please note that I have put the original German text to the end of this review. Just if you might be interested.

Billions of years nothing. Then long stagnation. And then an evolutionary and complexity explosion that can only be explained with a variety of vague hypotheses. Something has enabled higher life, has given primitive life forms the impossible-seeming ability to evolve further.

The biochemist's point of vi
...more
Carlos
Apr 01, 2016 rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
Shelves: non-fiction-btr
Wow this book was so interesting, it's main goal is to put forward the theory that the ability to harness energy by single cell organisms was the leap that was necessary for said organism to evolve into more complex organisms and therefore us, it explains the processes by which this could be possible attained 4 billion years ago, it argues that achieving this feat was nothing short of a miracle that it's very likely to not happen again. It also predicts that life in other planets would be simila ...more
Pooja Babu
Dec 18, 2015 rated it it was amazing  ·  review of another edition
Shelves: science
Have you ever wondered what "life" is? Not in the philosophical complexity of how hard it is to lead one, but what actually defines life in a scientific sense. Ever tried to comprehend the complexity of living, wondered on what makes "life", what concept or part it is that makes you say an organism is alive or dead? In the general sense, if you stop breathing, you are considered dead. Okay, you breathe, you walk, you talk. But what is it that makes you breathe autonomously in the first place? If ...more
Vicky Chijwani
Dec 08, 2015 rated it it was amazing  ·  review of another edition
Shelves: science, favorites
A compelling theory of the origin of life and its progression to complexity, built from first principles and intimately linked with energy.

I found a glowing mention of this book at the end of Bill Gates' Best Books of 2015 blogpost and immediately bought it after reading the intriguing premise. If you liked The Selfish Gene and are ready for a more challenging book, I highly recommend this one.

Prerequisites: basic understanding of cell biology and a bit of chemistry. Some familiarity with the co
...more
Emma Sea
A gorgeous book, so clear and well-written. Worth reading for the description of the ATP synthase alone: I wish science writing this good had been around when I was at high school.

If you're considering reading it, basically it's about the importance of mitochondria. Lane's ideas got super fascinating in chapter 9, and if you don't currently have time to read all 305 pages of Lane's book, and you know a little about cell biology already, I rec picking up the book just to read this chapter alone.
...more
Ross Blocher
Aug 03, 2017 rated it it was amazing
This is the book I've been waiting for... So many discussions theological and biological jump immediately to the conundrum of abiogenesis. It's a particularly difficult problem, with the origins of life shrouded in the ancient past, and a good deal of complexity to be conjured from natural processes alone. Enter Nick Lane, a biochemist in the Department of Genetics, Evolution and Environment at University College London, leader of their Origins of Life Program. Lane tackles numerous features of ...more
Deogratias Rweyemamu
Best argument for evolution thus far

Reading this book made me feel like am back in my high school biology class. The subject matter is much more complicated but extremely meaningful in pondering the great questions of origin of complex life.

Nick Lane has managed to construct a brilliant argument that us laymen could follow and reason out. His central ideas around endosymbiosis, ATP synthesis, Redox Reactions, Chemiosmotic Hypothesis, Apoptosis and free radical leak - provide clear cut evolutiona
...more
Arafat Rahman
Oct 13, 2016 rated it it was amazing
এ বইটার উললেখ পাই বিল গেটসের 5 Books to Read This Summer পোসটটিতে। বিল গেটস পাঁড় পাঠক। শুধু পড়েনই না, নিয়মিত পড়া বইগুলো নিয়ে gatesnotes.com সাইটটিতে লেখেনও। এ পাঁচটি বইয়ের মধযে Sapiens: A Brief History of Humankind-ও রয়েছে।
বইটার তিন লাইনের সারাংশ: আমরা পরাণকে ডিএনএ-তথয রেসিপি হিসেবে দেখতে অভযসথ। তবে বুড়ো হওয়া, কোষীয় আতমহতযা থেকে শুরু করে যৌনতা ইতযাদি অনেক রহসযের গোঁড়া হচছে এর শকতি উৎপাদন পরকরিয়ায়। এ বইটিতে সামপরতিককালে জীববিজঞান গবেষণায় এই তথযকেনদরীক বনাম শকতিকেনদরীক 'পযারাডাইম শিফট' বা সামগরিক
...more
Rossdavidh
Feb 20, 2016 rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
Shelves: black
You remember that teacher you had, in junior high or high school, who was so enthusiastic about his or her topic that you found yourself enjoying the class? Even if it was in a field you had not liked up until then, the right person can have a level of excitement with a subject that is contagious. Nothing is more boring than someone who is bored, and very little is as exciting as someone who is excited about what they're trying to teach. Reading Nick Lane's book is a little like having a teacher ...more
Tony
Nov 03, 2015 rated it liked it  ·  review of another edition
Shelves: science
THE VITAL QUESTION: Energy, Evolution, and the Origins of Complex Life. (2015). Nick Lane. ***.
The field of molecular biology evolved in the late 1960s. By that time, I had graduated from college with a MS in Chemistry, and was working in the field of colloid and surface chemistry. I had no formal training in any of the science being developed related to cell chemistry. I was also trying to catch up with what had been happening in my field of specialization. When I encountered this book – and ot
...more
Nikki
Jun 29, 2017 rated it really liked it
If you have a solid grounding in science already, particularly biology, this is probably going to be accessible for you — but if not, you might struggle a little. It starts off alright, but it gets quite dense in places, and if you’re not super-interested, you’ll probably get bogged down. That said, to me it was fascinating, and generated testable hypotheses about how early life could have functioned.

I still disagree with Nick Lane on some points, like the dismissiveness with which he treats “ju
...more
Radiantflux
Jul 04, 2017 rated it really liked it
Shelves: ebook, biology
41st book for 2017.

This is definitely one of the most interesting science books I have read. Nick Lane (who comes across as a kind of genius) puts forward his ideas about how the archaea and bacteria originated and are related, how complexity started in eukaryotes, why bacteria/archaea never became complex, how the sex and death originated, and to finish throws in some speculations about where and how life will evolve in the universe.

Atila Iamarino
Mar 28, 2016 rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
Gostei bastante, uma discussão bem atual é bem completa sobre o que leva à formação de células complexas. Mas tendo lido há pouco tempo o Sex, Power, Suicide, do mesmo autor, boa parte do livro fica redundante. Recomendo esse direto e desisti de ler o Oxygen dele, já que é o mais antigo e tb um tanto redundante.
Peter Mcloughlin
Covers the story of life from origins up to multicellular creatures with a focus on biochemistry and cell biology. Not bad. Lots of questions to be answered in this field but we are learning new things all the time.
Thomas Ray
Nick Lane, The Vital Question: Energy, Evolution, and the Origins of Complex Life, 2015, 360pp. ISBN 9780393088816

Bleeding-edge science for the general reader. Lane has plausible, partly detailed explanations for how life may have arisen from natural geochemical processes—and how complex life may have arisen from bacteria and archaea.

He has new ideas—including testable hypotheses, and is testing some of them.

The atmosphere 4.4–4 billion years ago was mainly carbon dioxide, water vapor, nitrogen
...more
Sreejith Pp
Feb 13, 2019 rated it it was amazing
It took almost 2 billion years for a wet planet teeming with single-celled life to develop the first multi-celled life form. Why? This is the question that this wonderful book aims to answer and in doing so, it links thermodynamics and life, taking you to the great past to the possible origins of the very first life form. We follow its journey and see how, almost 2 billion years later, the first eukaryote was born. Then, by analyzing this ancient being we try to derive its properties (probable h ...more
Erik Möller
Mar 16, 2016 rated it it was amazing  ·  review of another edition
Can a book be both dry and riveting? Yes, it can. Although Nick Lane does not always succeed in his ambition to do better than textbook style writing, this challenging and exhausting book rewards the reader with an up-to-date understanding of the evolved nanotechnology we call "life".

This isn't a book about cool animals, or about evolution as a whole. Lane focuses very much on life at the very small scale, such as the inner workings of mitochondria, the power houses of the cell. It's an underst
...more
Philipp
Aug 27, 2015 rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
Shelves: biology, non-fiction
Extremely interesting, and challenging read. Can you look at evolution not through the lens of (population) genetics but through the lens of biochemistry, specifically, energy. Lane starts at the "beginning" - how come the last common eukaryotic ancestor already possessed so many complicated traits? He goes to introduce an origin of life that depends on energy in the form of protein gradients, and argues that life depending on protein gradients can only evolve under very constrained circumstance ...more
Steven
May 22, 2015 rated it it was amazing  ·  review of another edition
Shelves: own
An impressive book. Nick Lane has taken years of highly original research and deduction on the origins and evolution of life on Earth, the product of which is distilled into this relatively concise book. The result is challenging but enlightening.

Although admirably written for a general audience, Lane's ideas are dumbed down as little as necessary and I must admit (as someone with very little formal education in Biology or Chemistry) that I did end up feeling quite lost at times amongst the tech
...more
Bharath
This book details important concepts around cell evolution addressing the most important question of all - how did complex life evolve? There are detailed discussions around why it is difficult, how it could have happened, what constraints had to be overcome and will life fare similarly in the rest of the universe. These are important questions and make for fascinating reading.

The material is obviously top-notch and also authoritative, and while it aims to be a book which everyone can read - it
...more
Dan Graser
Jun 19, 2016 rated it it was amazing  ·  review of another edition
This is hugely rewarding reading and a remarkable thesis for the origin of LUCA - Last Universal Common Ancestor of all cells on Earth. His assertion that alkali vents on the sea-floor, miles from the smoker thermal vents, as the likely candidate for the first prokaryotic endosymbiosis event is a bold claim and an endlessly fascinating story, highly recommended! Lane gives a staggering amount of detail as well as an interesting narrative that incorporates the processing of energy in early lifefo ...more
Lada
Mar 19, 2018 rated it it was amazing
If you've ever wondered: Why are we here? Why are there so few aliens visiting? Why do some birds have ridiculously brightly colored feathers? Why do we age? etc. etc. This books explains why and why it can't be any other way; because we're all pumping protons and the eucaryote thing happened only once (successfully) in all the billions of years and these things have dictated sex and everything else ever since.
Mick Kelly
May 14, 2015 rated it it was amazing  ·  review of another edition
What an exciting, fascinating and absorbing book this is. At last we have a coherent account of how life could evolve and make the difficult move into multi-organ cells and multi-cellular creatures. At last we have a coherent description of what life actually is. Bravo Nick! Best science book I've read this year - make that 'last 5 years'.
Thom
Nov 28, 2018 rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
Shelves: non-fiction
This is a dense book that took me most of November to read. That said, it's quite interesting, delving deeply into biology back to the most likely origins of complex life on this planet.

Each cell in your body contains two distinct sets of DNA - one belongs to the mitochondria. This book examines both sets, how that came to be, what they are used for, and how the cell works at a fundamental level. The author also investigates defect handling, cell death, and gender development in humans and other
...more
Gy
Jan 01, 2016 rated it it was amazing  ·  review of another edition
If comes to life the thinker can't avoid Schrödinger's..not his cat,but his book:What is life?By him life is the only that can defy II Law! Forty years ago,at the dawn of molecular biology, French Monod wrote his famous book "Chance and Necessity", which argues that the origin of life on earth was a freak accident.Life,as Hungarian biochemist Albert Szent-Györgyi observed,is nothing but an electron looking for a place to rest!

It was a fascinating sensation to delve into the cell biology again, a
...more
Sookie
Mar 26, 2017 rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
Shelves: non-fiction
Nick Lane goes on an exploratory adventure to understand the life - biologically, that is, as it has come to be. There are many familiar conjecture he arrives at that sounds plausible with the information that is available today. He makes no great leaps in theories that borderlines on miraculous thus keeping the conversation very well within the boundaries of science. Lane's hypothesis are derived out of years of observations, cross-discipline research and fundamentals of biology. It is humbling ...more
Hasanul Banna Siam
May 14, 2017 rated it it was amazing
This is a book with groundbreaking ideas and hypotheses directed forward with a view to solving some of the key questions of Biology. You will get answers to some cool questions like: Why do Eukaryotes have a nucleus but not prokaryotes? Why do Bacteria always remain bacteria? Who was LUCA? How did Life emerge on earth? How reliable is the phylogenetic tree? etc. If you are a student of Biological Science, this book is a must read for you.

This is a pure science book that heavily deals with Evolu
...more
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 next »
topics  posts  views  last activity   
18 Chakras of Energy 1 1 Apr 03, 2019 06:00AM  
What do you do when you don’t understand ? 1 5 Aug 23, 2018 11:57PM  
  • Life's Ratchet: How Molecular Machines Extract Order from Chaos
  • Life's Engines: How Microbes made the Earth Habitable
  • Sustainable Materials - With Both Eyes Open
  • The Power to Compete: An Economist and an Entrepreneur on Revitalizing Japan in the Global Economy
  • Arrival of the Fittest: Solving Evolution's Greatest Puzzle
  • Weird Life: The Search for Life That Is Very, Very Different from Our Own
  • Life Unfolding: How the Human Body Creates Itself
  • Improbable Destinies: Fate, Chance, and the Future of Evolution
  • Genesis: The Scientific Quest for Life's Origin
  • The Machinery of Life
  • Eradication: Ridding the World of Diseases Forever?
  • House on Fire: The Fight to Eradicate Smallpox
  • What Is Life?: How Chemistry Becomes Biology
  • Life's Greatest Secret: The Race to Crack the Genetic Code
  • The Epigenetics Revolution
  • Endless Forms Most Beautiful: The New Science of Evo Devo and the Making of the Animal Kingdom
  • The Grid: Electrical Infrastructure for a New Era
  • Sustainable Energy - Without the Hot Air
357 followers
Dr Nick Lane is a British biochemist and writer. He was awarded the first Provost's Venture Research Prize in the Department of Genetics, Evolution and Environment at University College London, where he is now a Reader in Evolutionary Biochemistry. Dr Lane’s research deals with evolutionary biochemistry and bioenergetics, focusing on the origin of life and the evolution of complex cells. Dr Lane w ...more
“One begins to wonder if all the most interesting problems in physics are now in biology.” 8 likes
“I shall argue that the distinction between a ‘living planet’ – one that is geologically active – and a living cell is only a matter of definition. There is no hard and fast dividing line. Geochemistry gives rise seamlessly to biochemistry. From this point of view, the fact that we can’t distinguish between geology and biology in these old rocks is fitting. Here is a living planet giving rise to life, and the two can’t be separated without splitting a continuum. Move” 3 likes
More quotes…