3 REVIEWS
SERENA'S REVIEW
The Last Keeper’s Daughter is a strange book; I’m not sure myself if that’s a positive or a negative description! There’s a lot of potential and a lot of great characters and new creatures, something that makes the story truly fascinating but somehow, it’s lacking. I hate saying that; I know how Rebecca Trogner, the author, will have slaved over this story, but I felt like a big piece of the puzzle is missing.
I’d give a brief synopsis of what happens here, but it’s all a bit convoluted and even after finishing the book, I’m still not entirely sure of everything. The writing is pretty powerful, enough to keep you hooked and while this is a supernatural story, it’s just a bit much. There are so many things going on that it’s a little hard to focus and in the end, I just felt a bit lost.
I really enjoyed the premise; but the characterization of the main characters was a bit of a let down. Krieger and Lily are the main characters and while we learn a lot about them, it isn’t enough. I didn’t feel as though I really knew them. Lily could be quite irritating and even though her life is up in the air, the way she treated Krieger was just annoying. I was waiting for something to occur between Lily and Krieger; but this book contains no real sexual content (there are some small, inoffensive scenes) and I missed that, I think. Especially between the central pair.
When the story ended, it came as a shock. It’s 300 pages or so and a lot happens, but somehow, it’s not condensed enough. It’s a busy story and that isn’t necessarily a bad thing; but too much is happening without clarification. At the end, mostly everything had been tied up, but I was still waiting for more answers. I’m guessing that there’s another book and I think I’d read it just for further clarification of what was going on; why Lily had visions?; the outcome of her relationship with Krieger; where Lucien fit in; what Nina had to do with the story…
I understand the premise of wanting to hook a reader so they’ll read the next novel, but there are a lot of questions in dire need of answering.
So, what do I rate this story? I like Rebecca Trogner’s writing style. I like her imagination and the plot is fantastic, in the sense that it’s out-of-this-world. I would have preferred for less to be happening though, for me to understand what was going on. The characters were good, not great. Something was missing; a loose end that just kept everything from being tightly woven. Some disturbing things occurred between Lily’s parents – mega disturbing! You’ll see what I mean, when you read it.
This book is classed as Romance/Mystery with the predominant theme of Fantasy. The romance elements are there, but not enough to consider it a romance. Mystery and fantasy; sure, there’s so much stuff happening that I’m dazed! But, that being said, I continued to read it and not just because I had to review it.
WALKI'S REVIEW
Walter Ayres, the last keeper of his line, entrusts his daughter Lily to Krieger Barnes, the Vampire King he has worked for his entire life, before flying to London. Detective Hunter is called to a crime scene where he contemplates the dismembered remains of Walter and another keeper, before being hired by the Elder and discovering there is more to meet the eyes in the world: Vampires, Werewolves, Ancients, Revenants, and more Others. There is also the apparently fragile Lily Ayres. But what is Lily exactly?
This novel has distant echoes of Elizabeth Kostova's 'The Historian', but Rebecca Trogner's vampires need not kidnap historians as they willingly enter a secret society to protect the vampires and others' world. Characters are well-defined and intriguing, with each a specific role to fulfil. While we try to understand who would want all the keepers dead, we never forget about the fragile Lily, fed with Krieger's blood and growing day by day stronger.
The Last Keeper's Daughter' is the compelling first volume in a series. I suspect Lily is the key to the entire series, as, while we discover her hidden past and the reasons for her otherworldly qualities, there is still much more mystery to solve around her. Rebecca Trogner leaves us with a light cliffhanger full of promises.
JENNY'S REVIEW
This book isn't a typical vampire book like the ones I normally read. It's quite complicated and there are a lot of different characters which made it a bit confusing for me sometimes. Because it wasn't just about vampires, but also about werewolves, Others and even fallen angels. When you're reading this book you really need to focus otherwise you won't be able to keep up, which isn't a bad thing. I mean, don't we all love to immerse ourselves in the world we're reading about and forget everything around us?
Lily is a normal human being, although maybe not that normal, because she almost never speaks. At least not in the beginning of the book. Lily's father Walter is the Vampire King Krieger's keeper. But it isn't until Walter gets murdered, that Lily finds out what Krieger actually is. When Krieger gets to know Lily, he feels a deep connection to her, and even though Lily feels it too, she doesn't act on it. Krieger saved Lily's life and because of that, they are now bonded, which means Lily can't trust her own feelings anymore. Does she really like Krieger or is he making her feel that?
Although I can understand that Lily is confused about her feelings for Krieger, it was also frustrating that she kept changing her mind about him. I'm a sucker for a good love story, but this was a different story than what I expected. Which can be refreshing of course, when done right. It's just that, for me, too much was left unresolved between Krieger and Lily. The ending of this book obviously makes it clear that there will be a sequel, but I wasn't aware of this at first. I prefer to know beforehand if the book is a stand alone or part of a series so I can prepare myself for a cliffhanger.
Nevertheless, The Last Keeper's Daughter is a very good book. The main focus of the book is on finding out who killed Walter. Throughout the book I had no idea whatsoever who could have done it. My compliments to Trogner for that, because she keeps you hooked and makes you want to keep reading to find out if they will resolve the mystery. And even after your questions are answered, you still want more. The ending makes sure of that. I can't wait to read the second book, obviously, so I can get more information about what will happen between Krieger and Lily.