Ok mostly giving this three stars for the missing cat storyline, anyone who has ever had a pet disappear, the not knowing is by far the worst.
Secondary storyline, we finally learn how Miss Spindler aka Old Hawk Eyes sees everything and I have to say, without spoiling the "surprise" for anyone...it sucked..made no sense and actually betrayed the Amish and sorry but you have to read it to find out what I mean..not at all like Beverly Lewis, I'm going to chop it up to her being tired of writing for this series maybe, she only did 3 series that were 10 books long, the rest go for like 5 or 6 maximum, so she was still learning her limits when she wrote this.