Jump to ratings and reviews

In the Wake of Golgotha

There is no crime to fit this sentence; there is no sentence to fit this crime. Roman Prefect Pontius Pilate's words are echoed by the zealot Judas Iscariot only hours before history takes a bloody turn on a cross atop Golgotha on Calvary Hill. Two thousand years later, these words are found scrawled in blood in New York next to three crucified men hanging on a basement wall.

Judas, now Jude Issachar, an enigmatic social worker and part-time professor, and Pontius, now Peter Pheiffer, an unsettled defense attorney at a ravenous global law firm, have lived many lifetimes since their original encounter. However, Jude is aware of his past and is cursed by the fateful lure of the noose and the tree. Peter is damned by a recurring ignorance, a cruel cyclical awakening that creeps up on him as he is compelled to defend a sociopath who crucified three men.

Condemned for their role in humankind's darkest betrayal, they must reckon with their pasts-and their futures-after a fateful, bloody collision of violence and addiction two millennia after their sentence began brings these lost souls together once more.

356 pages, Hardcover

Published March 3, 2026

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Daniel Grace

1 book27 followers
DANIEL GRACE is a London born, California bred, former owner of an international advertising agency who produces critically acclaimed Tuscan wines at his family winery, Il Molino di Grace, in Panzano-in-Chianti, Italy. He is a storyteller by trade and a mythologist at heart. Daniel splits his time between San Francisco and Tuscany with his wife, three daughters and English Setter. In the Wake of Golgotha is his debut novel.

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
46 (56%)
4 stars
22 (27%)
3 stars
5 (6%)
2 stars
5 (6%)
1 star
3 (3%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 42 reviews
Profile Image for Lynxie.
754 reviews80 followers
Did Not Finish
March 22, 2026
DNF @9%

This book sounds way better than it reads. This might have been in part due to the galley copy I got being formatted appallingly. It had no cover image, random returns in the text that breaks the flow of the story and lots of unnecessary detail added for each new scene and character introduced.

I understand that this book has a theme of religion or religious history, but the opening scenes were so explicitly religious and preachy it immediately put me off the story. I pushed through to the modern day storyline but the themes of religion and faith was simply too strong for my tastes.

The writing is ornate at best, flowery and overwritten at worst. Some of the scenes are engaging but I found myself skimming a lot of the detail.

*Note: I was provided an electronic copy of this book from Netgalley*
5 reviews
April 1, 2026
I had hoped this book would be my next five-star read, but sadly, it was not. It turned out to be very different from what I expected. I understood going in that it was fiction and might include imagined details or inaccuracies related to the crucifixion and other events in the story. However, the strong profanity was simply too much for me. I cannot enjoy books that use the GD word and the F word so frequently as if they are everyday language. That made me far too uncomfortable, so I returned the book and requested a refund. Unfortunately, I cannot recommend it for that reason.
Profile Image for Megan.
8 reviews2 followers
September 9, 2026
In The Wake of Golgotha intrigued me at first because of its modern day fictional story about what happened to the men who had the greatest humanly contribution during Jesus Christ being crucified 2000+ years ago. The book started out as a slow read, was initially a little hard to follow and it took a lot of concentration to learn who the characters were now versus their original Biblical roles. To be honest, this book took a lot of dedication and time until the halfway point when everything started to make sense and the storyline picked up a bit. This is a very long read for a modern book. Once I reached the middle of the story it became one of those books I can’t put down as I found myself intent to want to know what would happen on the next pages as each character gained an understanding of who they were, what they’d done, who they’d truly crucified and what that meant for each character. The author did a great job of crafting relatable modern day characters that you’d see while out in any city and built their backstories well to allow an understanding about what brought them to their present circumstances. Scenes set around the courtroom and trial of “Balthazar” felt almost electric at times and some carried an eerie darkness. Each character was skillfully crafted by the author and some held stronger storylines, but all worked together to tell the full story. I’ve already recommended the book to a couple of friends and family members with the warning that while the book takes a significant time investment, but is one that leaves you wondering what really happened to the real life men who played such terrible roles in Christ’s crucifixion. The author absolutely created a one-of-a-kind read!!!
Profile Image for Romulo Perez-Segnini.
346 reviews12 followers
April 1, 2026
An intriguing jambalaya of words that goes back-and-forth from events that occurred 2,000 years ago to modern life in NYC even quoting lyrics of modern songs.

Jude Issachar, a social worker and professor at Calcutta Community College in NYC is the incarnation of Judas Iscariot, the world’s most renown villain as the betrayer of Jesus Christ. He has vivid recollections of his first life but none of the other ones. Peter Pheiffer, a Harvard educated defense lawyer, is the incarnation of Pontius Pilate but his recollection of those days are sporadic dreams. Balthazar Bedrossian, an MRI technician with no criminal record brutally kills three individuals and crucifies them in his basement. He apparently knows of Peter’s true identity & hires him to defend him.

The facts seem to line up with historical assumptions though not sure of the depiction narrated in the Prologue.

Well written though at times it wonders aimlessly but overall thought provoking. Interesting ending.
Profile Image for Literary Reviewer.
1,588 reviews132 followers
Review of advance copy received from Author
December 23, 2025
In the Wake of Golgotha braids the crucifixion story with a dark, present day New York crime narrative. Judas and Pilate walk the earth again as Jude Issachar, a social worker and literature instructor with a secret habit of controlled self-hanging, and Peter Pheiffer, a corporate lawyer drifting into a death penalty case that begins to wake an old guilt he cannot name. Around them moves Balthazar Bedrossian, an MRI tech who turns into a crucifixion-obsessed serial killer and leaves three men nailed to crosses in a Chinatown basement, with a bloody message that echoes words spoken on Calvary. The book moves between Golgotha, courtrooms, shelters, subways, and art museums. It treats time like a loop rather than a line. The result is a theological thriller about responsibility, addiction, justice, and the long reach of one moment on a hill.

The prose is lush and sensory, full of heat, dust, blood, and cramped city air, then suddenly snaps into something clipped and almost conversational. I liked that swing. It kept me slightly off balance, in a good way, and it fit a story where characters feel unmoored from their own lives. At times, the sentences pile up, and the metaphors jostle for space, and I caught myself rereading a passage not because I missed a plot point, but because the language had become thick and crowded. When the book slows down and lets a simple image stand alone, like the quiet of a homeless shelter after breakfast or the tap of a condemned man’s bare feet, it lands very hard.

The ideas in this novel gave me a lot to think about. The reincarnation of Judas, fully aware of his past betrayal, turns guilt into a chronic condition rather than a single act, and I felt the weight of that on Jude’s shoulders every time he touched his neck. Peter’s arc hit me in a different way. He walks around convinced he is an ordinary guy who chose corporate comfort, then finds himself face to face with a killer who recreates crucifixion while a hidden past claws its way into the light. That mix of legal procedure, spiritual dread, and moral confusion made the courtroom scenes genuinely tense for me, even before any supernatural hints came in. The book obsesses over punishment and mercy, over how a single choice repeats through history, and it keeps asking whether anyone can ever really start fresh. I finished sections feeling uneasy, but also weirdly moved, like I had been invited into a long argument between God, the devil, and everybody who ever stood between them.

In the Wake of Golgotha is not a casual beach read. It leans into graphic violence, addiction, death row procedure, and heavy spiritual questions, and it rarely lets the reader off the hook. I would recommend it to people who like literary crime fiction that has a strong theological spine, to readers who enjoy novels that play with myth and scripture, and to anyone willing to sit with messy questions about blame and forgiveness. If you are up for a dark, ambitious story that blends ancient sorrow with modern city grit, I think it is worth your time.
1,752 reviews32 followers
April 16, 2026
In the Wake of Golgotha by Daniel Grace is a dark, metaphysical literary thriller that fuses historical religious mythology with contemporary crime fiction to explore cycles of guilt, identity, and moral recursion across millennia.

The novel’s premise bridges ancient history and modern legal drama, reimagining Judas Iscariot and Pontius Pilate as modern figures bound to repeating patterns of violence, memory, and consequence. This dual timeline structure creates a persistent tension between fate and reinvention, suggesting that certain moral wounds persist regardless of time or social context.

Grace uses the crucifixion of three men in a modern New York setting as a catalyst for unraveling buried identities and long-dormant recognition. The investigation is less procedural than existential, focusing on how responsibility echoes across lives and how recognition of past actions can fracture present stability.

The character of Jude Issachar, aware of his historical identity, provides the story’s most compelling psychological anchor. His awareness of recurrence introduces themes of inevitability and burdened consciousness, while Peter Pheiffer’s cyclical ignorance creates a contrasting perspective on denial and moral awakening.

Stylistically, the novel blends legal thriller pacing with theological allegory, creating a narrative that is both structurally grounded and symbolically dense. The result is a story that prioritizes philosophical tension over conventional resolution, asking readers to sit with ambiguity rather than closure.

In the Wake of Golgotha stands as a provocative and ambitious work of speculative theological fiction, particularly suited for readers drawn to morally complex narratives that reinterpret historical and religious figures through a modern psychological lens.
Profile Image for Leanne.
1,703 reviews118 followers
November 8, 2025
Daniel Grace’s debut novel is a bold, mythic meditation on guilt, redemption, and the long shadow of betrayal. Echoing across two millennia, In the Wake of Golgotha entwines ancient history with modern horror, as three crucified bodies discovered in a New York basement summon the ghosts of Calvary Hill.

Jude Issachar and Peter Pheiffer—reincarnations of Judas Iscariot and Pontius Pilate—are cursed to relive the consequences of their fateful choices. Grace’s prose is rich and evocative, steeped in philosophical weight and psychological nuance. The narrative moves with a dreamlike intensity, where time folds and memory bleeds, and the past is never truly past.

This is not a conventional thriller—it’s a literary reckoning. A story of addiction, violence, and the aching desire for absolution. Grace writes with the precision of a mythologist and the heart of a poet, crafting a tale that is as unsettling as it is profound.

A daring, unforgettable debut that asks: what does it mean to be condemned—and can the condemned ever be redeemed?

With thanks to Daniel Grace, the publisher and Netgalley for the ARC.
816 reviews8 followers
June 9, 2026
In the Wake of Golgotha is a powerful and thought-provoking novel that masterfully blends religious history, psychological drama, and contemporary suspense. Daniel Grace presents an imaginative reexamination of Judas Iscariot and Pontius Pilate, transforming them into complex modern characters burdened by centuries of guilt, memory, and consequence.
The novel's central mystery is gripping, but its greatest strength lies in its exploration of redemption and accountability. As Jude Issachar and Peter Pheiffer confront both a brutal modern crime and the weight of their ancient pasts, the story raises profound questions about forgiveness, justice, and the possibility of spiritual renewal.
Dark, intelligent, and emotionally resonant, In the Wake of Golgotha will appeal to readers who enjoy literary fiction, religious themes, philosophical storytelling, and narratives that challenge them to reflect on the nature of sin, grace, and human redemption. It is a memorable and ambitious work that lingers long after the final page.
5 reviews1 follower
May 1, 2026
I'll bet you never thought you might root for Judas Iscariot. Grace's clever, unique book is part thriller, part historical fiction and a deep reflection on what it means to repent and forgive. Its ingenious premise - a modern day reincarnation and meeting of Judas and Pilate who each have been existing along us for millennia - along with his retelling of their origin stories - provides a spark that will ignite your imagination and make you question what you think you know about these two complicated characters. He dives deeply into their histories and their complicated psyches. Grounding these two mystical forces on the gritty streets of NYC is a smart twist that makes this tale seem entirely plausible. Read this book - you will be entertained and challenged to think anew on two figures whose stories might just not be what you've been told.
Profile Image for Cheyanne.
60 reviews
September 16, 2026
I recieved a free copy of this book. And let me say, WOW! I was completely unsure of where this book would lead me and you talk about a rabbit hole. Who would have ever thought you could take the story of Christ's crucifixion and turn it into modern day legal thriller?

The first chapter I was on the fence about this book but once I got to chapter two I was hooked! I loved how the author took the two main individuals who lead to Christ's crucifixion, Judas and Pontius Pilate, and wrote them into a lifetime of reincarnation. Leading them to spend every life under the weight of guilt for what they had done. This book will fascinate you, make you grimace, and even feel empathy. Don't let the title or the premise deter you. This isn't what I'd call a Christian book. And I am so glad to have read this!
Profile Image for Kuu.
759 reviews6 followers
April 21, 2026
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for this ARC.

Whyyyyyyy did this book feel endless. I literally started reading it in December and now it's almost MAY and I still wouldn't be done if this book didn't literally vanish from my device within 24 hours. The premise was cool, but it dragged on so endlessly that I really couldn't enjoy it because I just wanted to be done 😭 I have to admit I probably skimmed the second half or so, so not giving a rating, but this book does feel super sluggish especially at the beginning and if you are unlucky like me, you continue to feel like it just won't. fucking. move. even when the plot picks up. Because why did the first chapter feel like it took 10 hours.
2 reviews
September 20, 2026
In the Wake of Golgotha is a dark and thought-provoking novel that blends religious mythology, supernatural mystery, crime, and psychological drama. I liked the unusual connection between ancient events and modern-day New York. Jude was my favorite character because of the burden he carries and his struggle to understand guilt, punishment, and redemption. The story raises interesting questions about whether people can escape their past and whether true change is possible. Some parts felt slow and complex because of the philosophical discussions and detailed writing, but the atmosphere was intense and memorable. This book would appeal to readers who enjoy unusual literary thrillers with deep themes and morally complicated characters.
1 review
April 27, 2026
Definitivamente uno dei miglior libri tra migliaia che letto. Inaspettato collegamento tra il passato ed il presente.
È la lettura che tiene il lettore senza fiato con un forte desiderio di leggerlo tutto prima possibile. E di aspettare con ansia il secondo libro di questo brillante autore. Consiglio vivamente di leggerlo.

Definitely one of the best books of the thousands I've read. An unexpected connection between the past and the present.
It's a breath-taking read that leaves the reader wanting to read it all as soon as possible. And eagerly awaiting the second book by this brilliant author. I highly recommend it.
468 reviews
June 22, 2026
In the Wake of Golgotha is a modern day version of Judas Iscariot and Pontius Pilate. Judas is Jude, a social worker at a rehabilitation center and college teacher; whereas Pontius Pilate, is Peter, a young lawyer attempting to defend a man who crucified three different people.

The thrill Daniel Grace weaves in his tale is a believable, complete connection to these characters we know from the Bible. After multiple sentences, Grace’s exquisite writing left me speechless. I would simply sit in the thought and richness of his text.

Not only riveting, but also adeptly researched, In the Wake of Golgotha is one not to miss. It’s easily a thought provoking masterpiece.
Profile Image for KATIEY SWAIM.
99 reviews8 followers
August 27, 2026
The book, Wake of Golgotha is a brilliant and genre-bending debut that seamlessly fuses a gritty noir thriller with profound theological fantasy. By reincarnating Judas Iscariot and Pontius Pilate in modern-day Manhattan, Daniel Grace creates a gripping narrative that explores guilt, redemption, and eternal damnation. The alternating timelines between ancient Judea and a dark, modern legal battle are meticulously paced. Grace masterfully handles complex religious themes with maturity and crafts deep characters amidst an atmosphere that js thick with tension. It is a highly original and thought-provoking powerhouse for fans of dark and intellectual mysteries.
Profile Image for Amanda.
3 reviews
September 2, 2026
I was lucky to receive an advanced copy of this fantastic novel.

The characters are compelling and developed so beautifully. It has been a very long time since I've enjoyed reading a work of literary fiction. Grace undertook a monumental challenge by effectively integrating a significant amount of literature, history, and art into the story, and it all means something. Some writers attempt to include elements from other mediums, to showcase their talent or enhance their work, but in reality, it just appears pretentious. Grace's novel is different. I'm just completely enamored and haven't been this excited by an author's debut since Hawkins' Girl on the Train.
Profile Image for BusyMommiesBookClub .
129 reviews2 followers
September 19, 2026
This was such an intriguing storyline. I liked how time was cyclical and how the characters were stuck in a forever repeating pattern. I also liked how they kept finding one another across life times only repeat history.

There were times when the time lines blurred a little too much, more so in thoughts and emotions than actually actions, which made it hard to differentiate what applied to when but I also think that was part of the story.

Despite this having a religious base, the story is less about God and more about how we live with our actions and how we're shaped by things that happened in our past. It dares to ask the big questions.
1 review
March 6, 2026
I don’t read many books… but man, In the Wake of Golgotha by Daniel Grace was an absolutely fantastic read. From the first few pages I was completely hooked. The storytelling, the depth, the emotion — everything about it just pulls you in and keeps you turning the pages.

The way Grace writes is incredible. He brings the world and characters to life in a way that feels vivid and real, and you can tell an immense amount of thought and care went into every part of the book. It’s the kind of story that sticks with you even after you finish it.
Profile Image for Cyrus.
61 reviews4 followers
May 13, 2026
That was a wild, thought-provoking read. I wasn't sure about a reincarnation story involving Judas and Pilate, but the way it jumps from Golgotha to a modern basement with three crucified men in New York just grabbed me. Seeing Jude carry the weight of knowing his past while Peter keeps forgetting and repeating his mistakes felt painfully real. The courtroom drama with the sociopath client was tense, and the whole thing left me thinking about guilt and redemption for days. Not a light read, but a really unique one.
10 reviews1 follower
September 1, 2026
In the Wake of Golgotha by Daniel Grace is a beautiful literary fiction that captivates your attention on every page. The story started many years ago and the characters, Judas, now Jude Issachar, a social worker and part-time professor, and Pontius, Peter Pheiffer, a defense attorney, have gone through many lives before they meet each other in New York. Jude is aware of his past but Peter is not and this makes the encounter even more interesting. Great clarity and sophisticated style of writing that draws you in the world of fiction and imagination.
1 review
Review of advance copy received from Author
February 26, 2026
Riveting read! This is one of those books that you can’t wait to get back to at night. It’s cinematic in its storytelling; I felt like I was watching a dramatic action thriller with characters so resonant I found myself thinking about them even after I stepped away from the book. A standout first novel for this author. Can’t wait for the Netflix series, though it’ll be hard to compete w the book.
Profile Image for Meredith.
109 reviews4 followers
May 5, 2026
Intriguing Take On Infamous Key Characters

This was a very interesting take on the story of what happened to the villains in the story of Christ crucifixion. It follows Judas as he is eternally, tormented by the repeating of his own demise. Other mean figures from this are also included, but only Judas knows that it continuously is happening. this story was very intriguing kept my attention and was a very interesting take.
Profile Image for Dee.
20 reviews1 follower
September 2, 2026
In the Wake of Golgotha surprised me. I did not expect to be so engrossed in the story from the start. I thought it would be interesting, but I could not put it down! The biblical references aren’t too much for non-Christians. The plot is intense and at times insane. I found myself rooting for Judas, something I never thought would happen. I fully recommend this book to anyone, mostly adults, that enjoys historical/contemporary fiction.
Profile Image for Amanda.
26 reviews
July 10, 2026
I was blown away by the astonishingly amazing prose throughout this book, and the incredibly detailed and well-thought-out premise. It was a deep and (at times disturbing) read but well worth it. I appreciated the philosophical and theological themes that really made my brain think - and the theme of damnation and the pursuit of redemption put my thinking on it's head!
1 review
March 7, 2026
This book offers a compelling exploration of its central ideas, combining engaging storytelling with thoughtful insight. By the end, it leaves the reader with both a deeper understanding of the subject and lingering questions worth reflecting on.
1 review
May 3, 2026
A fascinating, fun, provocative read. The story is both a crime thriller and a philosophical musing on redemption, guilt and choice. The writing style calls to mind some of Stephen King coupled with Nikos Kazantzakis.
Profile Image for Jenny Leblanc.
14 reviews
July 24, 2026
Daniel Grace has an amazing way of story telling! The words inventive, fabulous and wonderful come to mind in this retelling of an ever going battle! Easy to read and catching this book is a must read for all!
6 reviews
September 19, 2026
This Book is a deeply moving, evocative novel that beautifully captures the raw weight of grief, faith, and personal redemption. Reading it feels like a quiet, emotional journey through hardship toward hope, leaving you reflection-heavy yet profoundly inspired by the strength of the human spirit.
1 review
March 3, 2026
Riveting read from beginning to end. Thoughtful and thought provoking. Definitely a fresh and unique take on an age old story. Really enjoyed it.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 42 reviews