What do you think?
Rate this book


250 pages, Paperback
First published January 1, 2013
Lawrence S. Wittner shows well enough how the complicity of universities with their corporate funders—leading to campuses such as at UAardvark with its "Petroleum Quad, Insurance Quad, Chevron Hall, and Koch Industries Hall" (chp 2, p.9)—makes a shambles of the wonted independence of the Fourth Estate. Universities are supposed to be a check on power, historically, no? Similar to the Fifth Estate, or the independent press.
The main problems appear to be threefold (inferring from the story here, strictly relevant to the American university context): how the academic faculty are relegated to the status of minions; how the business model has imposed an unaccountable and unqualified CEO over the whole, creating "executive tyranny" (chp.39, p.217); and that the faculty union is ineffective—when such a union exists at all on campus. The story told here—fictional as it may be—would appear to apply to both publicly- or privately-funded institutions, whether colleges or universities (the author works at a state university, according to the liner note). One suspects that the details in the novel are based on reality, but there are no references to actual news sources that may have inspired the story-line. (Perhaps a critical edition can provide some facts, barring the libel problem, if any should arise.) Even as fiction, the criticisms may hit too close to home for some readers, or as Wittner puts it: "Many recognized similarities between the corporatization of UAardvark and developments on their own campuses." (chp.34, p.187) Some readers may well recognize that their local college or university is as complicit with the military-industrial-complex (MIC) as is UAardvark, albeit in ways different than those depicted here. As to limitations of the novel, the horizon is purely American; there is no attempt at a cross-cultural perspective. But across the pond, in the U.K., where the Fourth Estate is arguably in a better position, the University Senate is the governing body, and only tenured academics have a vote in the direction that their educational institution is taking, while any administrator is relegated to carrying out the policy agreed upon by the whole—pretty much the exact opposite of the situation in most American universities. Not to say there haven't been some effective attempts at lampooning the British university, notably, Porterhouse Blue by Tom Sharpe (originally published 1974, and later made into a TV mini-series, Porterhouse Blue for Channel 4 in the UK). If it's more of the campus novel that you're looking for, there is one title that must be mentioned: the not-so-funny novel set in South Africa, Disgrace, by J. M. Coetzee (published in 1999, and adapted into a film in 2008).