When I originally heard about this one, I was so excited, because...what a fantastic idea. What a rich world to mine for additional stories. King had only pulled on a few threads...what other fascinating lives and stories could we look into? Now, I've only read one book by Christopher Golden, and it didn't do much for me, and I'm not a fan of Keene (you could say, I'm not keen of Keene) nor is he of me. Back when I was on social media, he saw fit to take offense to me calling him out on some of his more odious behaviour, and blocked me. Oh well. No great loss.
So, much as it pained me to put money in Keene's pocket, the idea of this collection was too compelling.
Flash forward to a few days ago, and I found out. Well, here we go.
PART ONE: DOWN WITH THE SICKNESS
Fully half of the stories in the book are in part one, and cover the coming of Captain Tripps and the world falling apart.
Room 24 - Caroline Kepnes - So, this book should come out of the gate with an absolute banger. 34 stories to choose from, there's a guaranteed banger here, right? Well, sorry, this ain't it. This anthology starts with a whimper. The story is barely connected to THE STAND, and the main character feels like Kepnes just created Joe Goldberg's brother for this story. Only okay. 2.5 stars
The Tripps - Wrath James White - Nice, solid connection with THE STAND, and a simple, yet effective story. 3.5 stars
Bright Light City - Meg Gardiner - Not bad characters, and set in Vegas, but pre-Flagg. 3 stars
Every Dog Has Its Day - Bryan Smith - Okay story, nothing special, but not horrible. 3.5 stars
Lockdown - Bev Vincent - This one surprised me, as Vincent has never impressed me much as a writer, but this story, so far, is the best of the bunch. 4 stars
In a Pig's Eye - Joe R. Lansdale - Oh thank god. Finally an author who never disappoints. Similar story to all the others (Captain Tripps comes, most die, only the really good and the really bad are left, and they have to square off), but this one has that unbeatable, totally readable Lansdale style. 5 full stars
Lenora - Jonathan Janz - And we're still stuck on the variations on the theme mentioned above, and not only is it becoming more and more disappointing with each story that treads the same ground, but also (with the exception of Lansdale) more frustrating as most just can't break out and make it something special. This is a solid average. 2.5 stars
The Hope Boat - Gambino Iglesias - And another variation on the theme, but at least we're getting a bit more variety here. Not earthshaking, but not horrible. Most of these survivors trying to make it feel like variations on King's own "Night Surf" story. 3 stars
Wrong Fucking Place, Wrong Fucking Time - C. Robert Cargill - Okay, but it felt almost more like an essay on what horror is about at times, rather than a story. 3 stars
Prey Instinct - Hailey Piper - This one didn't do a damn thing for me. Hard no. 1 star
Grace - Tim Lebbon - YAY! Fantastic concept! YAY! Someone trying something different! But...boo. The story was more annoying than anything. 2.5 stars
Moving Day - Richard Chizmar - Ugh. This guy. He just can't stop himself from killing the story by tossing a gigantic, unimportant info dump right at the beginning. And then, pretty much nothing happens. 1 star
La Mala Hora - Alex Segura - Overall, while this one was one of the better ones, the connection to THE STAND was tenuous, and the ending was disappointing. 3.5 stars
The African Painted Dog - Catriona Ward - Okay, on this one, I'll say the story is well written, but I hated it because I just don't like stories narrated by animals. Prejudice is mine, so I'll be nice and give it a 2.5 stars
Till Human Voices Wakesm and We Drown - Poppy Z. Brite - YES! FINALLY, an author willing to take a chance, go out on limb, and make the world their own, while still staying within the bounds. Fifteen stories in, and this is the first one that actually impressed me. 5 BIG stars
Kovach's Last Case - Michael Koryta - And right after that, a second one that actually takes some chances and goes in a different direction. Reasonably predictable, but at least it's not the same old same old. 4 stars
Make Your Own Way - Alma Katsu - Well written, that doesn't surprise me with Katsu, but back to the same old formula. 3.5 stars
PART TWO: THE LONG WALK
I Love The Dead - Josh Malerman - A story about the world's biggest Deadhead. Annoying. 2 stars
Milagros - Cynthia Pelayo - I'm liking the different cultures we're getting to see, and now that we're getting away from the Tripps, it's all about getting away. Well written, but just an okay story. 3 stars
The Legion of Swine - S.A. Cosby - Like Lansdale, Cosby can do no wrong. This is once again, more of the same (there's a whole lotta that in this book), but in the hands of an incredibly skilled author—and Cosby is one of those, no question—new life is breathed into it. This one was a pleasure to read. 5 stars
Keep The Devil Down - Rio Youers - Now, this one? THIS was an injection of adrenaline, and it was sorely needed. FINALLY, while this is still a good against bad, Team Nebraska against Team Vegas story, this one's got some balls. I should have been able to guess that Cosby and Youers would be two of the authors who would bring the heat. 5 stars
Across The Pond - V. Castro - And then we're back down again. Sigh. All the trademarks are here. Sex? Of course. The wrong kind? Yes, that too. But, did the story make sense? No, not so much. 1 star
The Boat Man - Tananarive Due and Steven Barnes - One of the better ones, with a fun little question at the heart of the story. 4 stars
The Story I Tell Is the Story of Some of Us - Paul Tremblay - Sigh. Okay, so, it's Tremblay, so it's well written, and there's a vague mystery at the heart of the story, but it never coalesces, and never really goes anywhere which, unfortunately, is kind of what Tremblay does, and why I can't read him anymore. 1.5 stars
The Mosque of the End of the World - Usman T. Malik - Again, totally different culture, wildly different point of view, that I enjoyed a lot, and a great twist. 4 stars
Abagail's Gethsemane - Wayne Brady and Maurice Broaddus - Okay! Another risk taking story, and one that digs into Mother Abagail...before she was Mother Abagail. I truly enjoyed this one. 4 stars
PART THREE: LIFE WAS SUCH A WHEEL
He's a Righteous Man - Ronald Malfi - Once again, an interesting take on THE STAND, way out from left field that I truly did not expect to enjoy, yet really did. And all this from an author I'm not that crazy about. 4 stars
Awaiting Orders in Flaggston - Somer Canon - Good story of the insanity of some leaders and the extreme lengths they will go to to retain their leadership. 3.5 stars
Grand Junction - Chuck Wendig - Well look at that! Another much better than expected story! And this one in the decades after the events of THE STAND. 5 stars
Hunted to Extinction - Premee Mohamed - Oh Canada! YAY! But, dammit, only an okay story. 2.5 stars
Come The Last Night of Sadness - Catherynne M. Valente - An interesting twist on Asimov's Mule from his original FOUNDATION trilogy, but written in a somewhat schizophrenic way that I found hard to enjoy. It could have been one of the better ones. 2.5 stars
The Devil's Children - Sarah Langan - This was just a meh for me. 1.5 stars
PART FOUR: OTHER WORLDS THAN THESE
The Unfortunate Convalescence of the SuperLawyer - Nat Cassidy - So, unlike the Tremblay story above, this one? This is confusion done right. Enjoyed this one. 4 stars
Walk on Gilded Splinters - David J. Schow - And here we are at the end with a story that was just about as dull as the opener way back at the beginning. 2 stars
So, that's it. Take all those individual scores and you get a firm 3 star, middle of the road collection, which is sad. I keep seeing readers saying things like, "look at that line up of authors!" (yeah, I was one of them), but now I'm just saddened at the lack of imagination. And the fact that half the damn book was about good people losing everyone around them, then having to fight against the bad guys, then (often) striking out to go...somewhere.
It's like they all drank the same Kool-Aid.
So, I was very excited for this, and hey, I did get some great stories out of it, but overall, this was a truly disappointing collection. Let's hope they don't strip mine any other King books this way.