Viaggio avventuroso tra gli indiani
Riusciranno a fermare la mandria di enormi bisonti impazziti?
-There are plenty of indigenous people writing about their own cultures and histories so tbh I don't see the point of anyone else writing "educational stories" like this and profiting off of them unless there's significant collaboration involved. Not to mention a lot of this is inaccurate and/or offensive, sooo.
-This is about two white kids (Jack and Annie) who travel back in time to visit a Lakota encampment. As if Lakota people ...more
Osborne has largely steered clear of the history of the Americas in her series, and with good reason: the legacy of colonialism is an enormously difficult subject to approach for any age group. In the latest story arc of the series, which includes books 17-20, Osborne has finally ventured into the relatively recent American past and the results -- at least here -- are mixed.
While she describes the mass slaughter of the bison unambiguously, even making the point that it was a military maneuver de...more
Lots of good information in this one. Jack and Annie go back in time and spend a day with some Lakota indians. Jack's trusty research book had some great facts to share about the Indians, but they also spent some time with an Indian "grandmother" who taught them some fascinating things about their beliefs and way of life.
The adventure with the buffalo was improbable and somewhat worrisome. I grew up not far from Yellowstone National Park, and we'd visit at least once a year. So perhaps ...more
Jake and Annie go on an adventure back in time to the Great Plains and learn how the Indians obtained their resource and their belief in the Great Spirit. Jack and Annie learned quite a bit from the Indians. It was a simpler time that should've never been disturbed. In my opinion, Indians had it right, and the white man ruined it.
The main characters in “Magic Tree House #18: Buffalo Before Breakfast” are Jack, Annie, Black Hawk,and Grandma. Jack and Annie are two kids f ...more
Jack and Annie have to tread carefully when making contact with the Lakota villagers. The rely on Morgan's book for how to introduce themselves and how act respectfully and bravely. They meet a boy of similar age who lives with his grandmother.
Together Jack, Annie and the Lakota boy go hunting for bison. The learn an important lesson about the difference betwee ...more
Sam (8): 4.5 stars. I liked it because it gave some more information about buffalo and the, uh, Mary, what were they called? The people? Dad, you better not be writing that. The Lakota? Yes. Okay, what about them? I liked it when Jack saved them. ...more
Author: Mary Pope Osborne
Illustrator: Sal Murdocca
Genre: Transitional Chapter Book
Theme(s): Lakota Indians, tree houses, magic, North American Natives.
One summer day in Frog Creek, Pennsylvania, a mysterious tree house appeared in the woods.
Brief Book Summary:
In this series, siblings Jack and Annie travel through time to complete missions given to them from a magical librarian. In their magic tree house the duo point to a ...more
This story is about an adventure that Jack and Annie took to the Great Plains. When they arrive, they are greeted with a Lakota Indian boy, Black Hawk. They are on a mission to find another gift in order to save Teddy, the dog, from his curse. After telling Black Hawk that they come in peace, he allows them to come with him back to his village and there they meet Grandmother. Grandmother allows Black Hawk to show Jack and Annie w ...more
Estoy de acuerdo con otros lectores que lo que sucedió a los lakotas no es bastante verdadero. De hecho a los mataron y las tierras robaron los pobladores blancos. Y no hace falta que perpetúa el mito que las gentes indígenas se quedan tradicionales y luditas. La atrocidad del gobierno de los estados unidos es diluida y ¿por qué? Los niños deben aprenderla y comprenderla.
This was educational with a great plot. This would be awesome for kids who want to know a little more about the Native American way of life without having to read a textbook for it.