Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Ice Lords #2

Bend the Pucking Rules

Rate this book
Bend The Pucking Rules is the second book in the sexy and suspenseful Ice Lords Series. An Enemies to Lovers, Why-Choose, Dark College Hockey Romance.

I know too much and now, I’m paying the price.

One secret shattered my world.
Three boys wrecked my life.
And one of them just might own my heart—if only he could remember.

As Callan fights to piece together the memories we shared and the time we lost, I’m caught in the crossfire of rival teams, bitter betrayals, and players who would love nothing more than to watch me fall.

Someone is out there.
Whispering. Watching. Waiting.
And if I want to survive, I’ll have to trust the very people who broke me.

Aidric. Sebastian.
Maybe even Callan

Sebastian says he hates me.
But hate doesn’t burn this hot.
I see it in his eyes. I feel it every time he looks at me.
I’m just not sure if his fire is meant to save me, or burn me.

When Callan finally remembers, will it be enough to put us back together?
Or will the bond I’m building with his best friend tear us all apart?

They say you can’t have the best of both worlds.
But I’m beginning to realize, the three of us were never meant to live by the rules.

309 pages, Kindle Edition

Published July 18, 2025

153 people are currently reading
778 people want to read

About the author

Rachel Leigh

40 books4,563 followers
Rachel Leigh is a USA Today and international bestselling author of new adult, dark romances. She’s drawn to writing flawed, irresistible heroes and strong, resilient heroines. Her stories blend dark elements, a touch of suspense, and plenty of steam—perfect for readers who crave passion with an edge.
Her goal is to sweep readers away on an unforgettable adventure while reminding them that even in the darkest moments, love conquers all.

Rachel resides in Michigan with her husband, three kids, and a couple of spoiled fur babies. When she isn’t lost in a book, you’ll find her in cozy leggings with a coffee in hand, binge-watching her favorite reality TV shows.


Rachel Leigh is represented by Beck Literary: Josi@beckliterary.com


Join Rachel's Readers Group: http://bit.ly/rl_ramblers
Facebook: rachelleighauthor
Instagram: rachelleighauthor
www.rachelleighauthor.com

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
458 (54%)
4 stars
273 (32%)
3 stars
91 (10%)
2 stars
10 (1%)
1 star
3 (<1%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 401 reviews
Profile Image for Kursed Reads.
808 reviews9,420 followers
July 21, 2025
BYPH left us on that cliffy and Bend the Pucking Rules picks up right where it left off. As Callan recovers in the hospital, Sebastian begins burrowing himself under Avery’s skin despite their previously volatile relationship. That’s not to say that Sebastian becomes a cinnamon roll – far from it. Yet while Sebastian thaws toward - and falls for - Avery, Aidric is decidedly more dickish. Jealous much?

Moreover, evidence piles up indicating that the personal responsible for the threats against the society is one of their own. No one can be trusted. Nothing is as it seems. And tensions rise throughout this installment as the Lords and their lady navigate secrets, lies, and ever-increasing danger.

Book two leaves us with more questions than answers as the body count climbs and the betrayal becomes more brazen. I’m looking forward to Aidric’s POV and hoping we get to see him grovel a bit.

Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️1/2
Burn: 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
Darkness: 🖤
Heat: 🌶️🌶️
Range of Emotions: 😳☺️🫠🥵🤯
Ending: 🧗🏻‍♀️ {Cliffy}
POV: 👫🏻 {Multiple}

🗄️ Genre: Contemporary Romance
🗂️ Subgenre(s): Dark(ish), Psychological Thriller, Sports, Suspense, Young Adult

✨ Tropes: Amnesia, Blackmail, Enemies-to-Lovers, Forbidden, Forced Proximity, Found Family, Heroine in Danger, Second Chance, Secret Society, Why Choose
 
💫 Microtropes: Alphahole, College, Jealous/Possessive, Pet Name, Sassy FMC

💋 Kinks: n/a

⚠️ Warning: This steamy read will leave your panties damp and your cheeks flushed.

🚩 Safety Squad: Cheating (Not Really/Within Harem), Unalìvíng, Violence, and other potentially triggering elements. If you have any hesitation, check the warnings before diving in. Otherwise, blind is best!!

📣 Type: Bend the Pucking Rules is part of the Ice Lords series and ends on a cliffhanger. This series must be read in order.

🛑 Be Advised: My Goodreads shelves are … explicit in both senses. As such, they could be considered spoiler-y.
Profile Image for Koisty.
455 reviews1,134 followers
July 28, 2025
4 Numbered Rock Stars ⭐️
Spicy Rating: 🌶️🌶️.5/5
If my little lamb wants to run into fire, you best believe her wolf is going to be at her back, hunting her the entire time.
I am still absolutely feral over this series. Rachel Leigh has me in a chokehold, and this sequel just cemented my obsession. It picks up with emotional intensity right where Break Your Pucking Heart left off, and holy hell… I was on edge the entire time.

Note: This is book 2 in the Ice Lord's Series and NOT a standalone. If you care about spoilers, I strongly suggest you stop here, go binge the first book, and THEN come back. Otherwise… CARRY ON!

𝙎𝙮𝙣𝙤𝙥𝙨𝙞𝙨:
Callan has just been in a horrific car accident, and after everything he and Avery went through to finally connect, he wakes up with zero memory of her! HE STILL BELIEVES HE HATES HERwhich absolutely shattered me. While he struggles with this, Avery finds herself choosing to stay in the hockey house, with threats from a stalker looming and leaving her terrifying messages. It's the safest place for her to be. Now, forced to stay close to Sebastian and Aidric for protection, that proximity causes a LOT of tension. AND THIS IS MARKETED as a Reverse Harem... so we know we are not going to get some love triangle drama... SO EXPECT THE TENSION TO EVOLVE INTO MORE... (This book focuses on the journey Avery takes with Sebastian)

𝙏𝙝𝙤𝙪𝙜𝙝𝙩𝙨 𝙖𝙣𝙙 𝙁𝙚𝙚𝙡𝙞𝙣𝙜𝙨:
Avery continues to be the chaotic, stupid badass I love. She’s feisty, mouthy, and refuses to let anyone control her... even when it puts her in reckless situations. She breaks into places she shouldn't be and snoops on things she shouldn't. She also continues to poke and provoke Aidric every chance she gets... AND I JUST LOVE HER PUSHING HIS BUTTONS.

The dynamic shift from Avery's outlook on the boys to this one was interesting. In the first book, she was fighting to avoid being part of their world. Now, she’s fighting when she’s excluded. She’s accepted that she’s in this life, she’s an accessory to the chaos, and she refuses to be left out. And when she is, her spitfire attitude comes out.

It broke me seeing her go through the setback with Callan while he dealt with his memory loss, staying in the background for him to recover at his own pace. She was there, quietly loving him, even when nobody else was in her corner. Her best friend pushed her away, and her family couldn't care about her... She is alone with noone except Sebastian.

And oh my god… Sebastian!

This man has officially taken over as my favourite of the boys. He’s level-headed and logical, but then also arrogant in the sexiest way, and wields his power like a king or right hand to the King. His obsession with Avery grows into something so much more than lust; it's this deep devotion to give her everything she needs. An obsession with having her as a possession.

It's also books like this that make me fall harder for Reverse Harem books because each boy gives her something the other can't. Callan is the boy she loved first. He is her emotional anchor and her sweetheart. Sebastian is her protector and the one who pushes her through fear into strength. And Aidric... I am dying to see what he’ll bring to the table.

𝙏𝙧𝙤𝙥𝙚𝙨:
▶ Hockey Bully Romance
▶ Enemies to Lovers
▶ Memory Loss
▶ Reverse Harem
▶ Secret Society
▶ Touch Her You Die
▶ Found Family
▶ Forbidden Romance
▶ Obsessive MMC's

and 𝙈𝙞𝙘𝙧𝙤 𝙏𝙧𝙤𝙥𝙚𝙨:
▷ "Don't Stop"
▷ "Tell me to stop"
▷ "You Taste Like"
▷ Hand Necklaces
▷ Chin Lift
▷ Share a Bath
▷ A Lot of Texting
▷ Hate Sex

Overall, this book ripped me apart in the best way. It’s dark, it’s toxic, it’s obsessive, and it’s everything I want. I am SALIVATING for the next book because I just know he’s going to wreck me.

Thank you to Valentine PR for the gifted copy! All thoughts and opinions are my own
Profile Image for Kendra Renae.
175 reviews42 followers
September 5, 2025
⭐️4.75 🌶️3.9

”When the lamb walks into the fire, it’s because its flames are safer than the wolf.

Avery and her diabolical men are back. We pick up right where we left off in book one with that crazy cliffhanger of Callan in his car accident. My poor Shayla struggles this whole book to find his way back to who he was.

On the other hand Sebastian and Avery become closer as we try to solve what at this point is a damn murder mystery that may go deeper than anyone thinks.

I love how each book follows the perspective of a different lord, while still focusing on how Avery takes in all these new developments. The twist and turns are at an all time high as we end on yet ANOTHER cliffhanger. 🫩 like girl I have more questions than answers solved. One thing I’m happy about is that it’s clear that Avery may have a big role in this, but it’s not aware to anyone yet. I just have a feeling that shit is about to get CRAZY. I have three guesses of who it is and I’m hoping one of them is right🤞🏾
Profile Image for Tiffani.
75 reviews40 followers
July 26, 2025
Book 1 left my heart in shambles, and I wasn’t sure how I was supposed to recover — but somehow Rachel Leigh made it hurt so good in book 2.

This one is even darker, steamier, and more unhinged in the best way. The tension? 🔥 The boys? Ruined me. The vibe? Delicious chaos.

If you love enemies-to-lovers, memory gaps, messy feelings, and the kind of hockey boys that make you question all your life choices… run, don’t walk.

The Ice Lords are not playing fair — and I’m obsessed.
Profile Image for M.
729 reviews316 followers
July 20, 2025
Book 2 picks up right where the first book left off. I couldn't get enough of this book. Avery and her guys were something else! I was falling out of hate with Sebastian all while his Little Lamb was starting to act out her feelings towards him.

This read was filled with mystery, twists and turns and spice. There's so much tension between everyone. The stakes are high and the secrets are still piling up. No one knows who's a friend or foe. Man, some pieces of the puzzle came to light and now there are even more hidden that need to be revealed.

Book one I loathed Seb. Now with the ending of this one, Aidric is on the top of my hate list. He shocked me with some of his comments about Avery. He best grovel if he wants to win her over!

Can't wait to see how RL concludes this series!!

Profile Image for Lindsay Jenkins.
388 reviews18 followers
July 31, 2025
I was able to snag the ARC for this one but didn’t realize it was not a standalone so I went back to read book 1 first and I was super happy to have this baby in hand and ready to go.

What to expect:
🤍Enemies to Lovers
🤍Why Choose
🤍Secret Society
🤍Hockey Romance
🤍Best Friend’s Brother
🤍Slow Burn

The slow is a little slow but very much worth it. Love the writing and character building.
Profile Image for Michellelovesreading.
1,503 reviews177 followers
July 18, 2025
This is the second book in the Ice Lords series and I loved it just as much as the first book. I 10/10 recommend if you like hockey and why choose romances.


Stars:⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️


Spice:🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️
Profile Image for Ashly.
446 reviews29 followers
July 18, 2025
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️/5
🌶️🌶️/5
📚 Book 2 in the "Ice Lords Trilogy" cannot be read as a standalone
🏒 Hockey Romance
🗣️ Multiple POV's
🖤 Why Choose MFM
⼚ Cliffhanger

Book 2 picks up where book 1 leaves off, and we finally get to remove ourselves from the cliffhanger. Its not a reprieve though, cause its a sucker punch to the heart to go through it with Avery and Callan. The only thing that makes it easier is we get to see Avery's relationship with Sebastian grow through this book. Sebastian was a hard core bully of Avery in book 1, so this "softer" side of him we get to see in book 2, is exactly what my heart needed.

There absolutely is still "bully" elements to this book, as Aidric’s still giving Avery the mostly cold shoulder with small glimpses into his softer side, and giving her shit for being with his two best friends...We know he's just jelly and cant wait to be included 😂

The suspense is suspencing!!! There are twists and turns as to be expected as the Ice Lords try to find out who is hunting them. They are used to being at the top of the food chain and this new player is at least 2-3 steps ahead of them at all times! Avery is also spiraling, which moves things with Sebastian forward, but does not bode well for her mental health. Can I also just say that Brogan is giving frenamie vibes for some reason...and I dont think its just her want to protect Callan.

I enjoyed this book more than the first, simply because of the "lessening" of the bully element. I loved both books, and I missed Callan in this one but Sebastian is 🔥

Tropes:
🏒 Who Choose
🖤 Enemies to Lovers
🏒 Secret Society
🖤 Dark Romance
🏒 College Hockey
🖤 Suspence/ Mystery
Profile Image for The_Book_Brat.
950 reviews165 followers
July 14, 2025
*Reverse Harem
*Contemporary
*Multi-1st-PoV
*College Setting
*Hockey Elements
*Secret Society
*Triggers - Dubcon
*Blackmail
*Mid Burn
*Established Harem (3)
*Book 2 / 3
Better book for me 😄
This book, for me, was better than the first 😄 it is milder in terms of the bullying/harsh treatment between the men and Avery which I found more palatable 🙈 the dark elements are absolutely still there in terms of the 💀, the stalker, and the blackmail - things certainly seem to be getting a lot worse for them on this second book 😣 poor Avery is spiralling with everything that’s being thrown at her, yet she consistently picks herself back up and gives her all in facing the next issue and handing their ‘hinds back to the guys when needed…especially Adiric 😡 there are some heart wrenching moments in this - particularly the aftermath of Callan’s and trying to piece their life back together, and her moms issues 😫 the biggest win for me in this book was seeing the character development in Sebastian and their revolving relationship, you see a side to him that truly cares - although he doesn’t give him his controlling side 😅 the back and forth between them is 🔥🔥 looking forward to seeing how the drama around the Lords and who is really out to get them is wrapped up especially with the red herrings being thrown around in this one 😳
Profile Image for Meredith Richardson.
267 reviews44 followers
July 19, 2025
This book is the second installment in the Lords series and I strongly recommend reading that before diving into this book. It takes place immediately after the first which left us in a cliffhanger.

I’m officially in my bad boy era! I don’t know who I like more… Callan, Sebastian, or Aidric. Why choose one when you can have all three?!?

The stakes continue to rise as they learn someone knows about their secret society and is not only threatening them but is willing to kill to get what they want. I spent the whole book trying to figure out their stalker and I still have no idea 🤷🏻‍♀️.

I can’t wait to read book 3 and get all the answers. I’m also hoping with the final installment we’ll get more of a backstory on some of our characters. We got a glimpse into Sebastian’s childhood in the prologue but then it’s never touched on again. I’m also really excited to learn more about Aidric and his relationship with his father.
Profile Image for Samantha Wood.
415 reviews5 followers
July 14, 2025
I wish I would have discovered Rachel’s books sooner but I am sooo glad that I found this series.

So we knew from the beginning that this was going to end up with more than one MMC love interest in a why choose situation. However we really only got Callen and Avery’s point of view. Well that changed with this book and we primarily got Avery and Sebastian’s POV. Which if it continues this way, book 3 will give us Aidric’s POV.

This book picks up immediately following the cliffhanger for book 1 that was admittedly pretty gut wrenching. But answers, without more questions, what’s that!? We did get some answers (but not as many as you want) but definitely are left with more questions. We ended on another cliffy that, while not devastating, it definitely was not what I saw coming AT ALL. While I have theories, I fully expect not a single one to correct at this point.

The spice also kicked it up a notch. I am loving both Callen and Sebastian as they do different things to help our girl. Avery also just gets stronger with each book and as the story goes on. I can’t wait to see where she goes from here!
Profile Image for Brooke.
1,011 reviews54 followers
July 16, 2025
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐-> ♾️🌟
🌶️🌶️🌶

🖤 Enemies To Lovers
☠️ Secret Society
🖤 Best Friend's Brother & Friends
🏒 Found Family
🖤 College Hockey Romance 🏒
☠️ Slow Burn Tension
🏒 Why Choose

⚠️ Please Check Your Trigger/Content Warnings ⚠️

✨️ ARC 📖 REVIEW ✨️

Well this book took me out y'all. I can't stop thinking about it loooong after I have finished it. I felt like I was on an emotional roller-coaster even though I had no skin in this game. But that right there tells me that no matter what happens Rachel has a talent that I can't even begin to fathom.

My reading on my kindle has been paltry because I couldn't get into the book. This one though?? Not a CHANCE! I WAS IN IT TO WIN IT!

There have been many days that I cannot remember what time I ate breakfast 🍳, but this book 📚 right here wasn't anywhere close to that girl. I was able to explain in detail to my husband the whole book 📖. I need my emotional support water 🚰 bottle for the whole thing but who's counting that? If you are, then imma have to ask you to mind yo bidness.

Lemme just start the breakdown by saying this book 📖 is going to live rent free in my head until 📖 3️⃣ is on my kindle. This isn't up for debate. This is straight FACTS 💯. All 4 of our main characters have a CHOKEHOLD ☠️ on me. I am LIVING for each one of their stories!

Avery, our girl 💕 who is sooo strong. She doesn't even know how strong she is, until she does. She has been through so much, yet still stands on business on BOTH FEET planted firmly on the ground. She definitely had the crap stick end of things 😩 for a little bit in this one. Dealing with her mom's health issues along with her sperm donor. Yeah you read it right 😘. Sperm donor. He doesn't deserve the title dad, and probably never will 😁.

But that didn't stop our girl from fighting for what she wants, and continually fighting for her and hers. She went through the ringer in this book but not without an unfortunate reason. She was able to see where she stands with all 3 men 🖤. She was able to see her place amongst all the havoc being thrown her way.


Callan the first man to steal our girls heart has been THROUGH IT Y'ALL 😩. He was in the worst type of way through a good chunk of this book. But that didn't stop him from coming back with the fire in his eyes not just for Avery but for his brothers. He definitely had a hill to climb but he wasn't afraid to do it! He hit the hill with running force (okay not really running, bc he couldn't, but you get what I'm saying.) He made it well known that he wasn't going to sit back and watch it all happen without him.

Sebastian, my man Seb as I so lovingly call him 😍. He was the rockstar in this book! He took Avery under his wing when she needed it the most. Not the approach some would have taken but it worked. For both of them. He made sure that she wasn't left behind, without her they were all going to fall 😭. Right when he didn't think it could happen it did. In a BIG way! He saw Avery in a different light than the Little Devil she had shown them she could be if they messed with her. She because his Little Lamb 🐑. He folded her into his life and couldn't imagine it without her 🥰.

He definitely gave me all of the alpha male vibes I needed for this book! I couldn't have loved him more in this 😍. I am soo excited to see how their dynamic shifts in the next book!

Aidrick, my 🖤 dark horse 🐎 🖤. I love his nonchalance in this book about Avery. It gave him so much more depth throughout and especially towards the end. He is the leader of the Society ☠️, and he definitely refused to let anyone else get that spot. He wasn't going to let anyone continue to mess with what they had going. The epilogue SENT ME 😁.

I KNEW he was going to come around. He just had to see that there was room for everyone. Not just the few he approved of.

I absolutely CANNOT wait for the final book! We definitely had the chase in this one and I hope that we get somw more in the next one as well! I still have no clue who this is running around doing the ABSOLUTE MOST. But I am here for it. SAT and ready 😏.


🔥 Let's Talk About Sex Baby 🥵:
🌶️🌶️🌶 /5


Thank you so much to Rachel Leigh for the free ARC 📖 copy 🫶🏻. All opinions✨️ are my own, honest and voluntary✨️.
Profile Image for Eliza_lovesbooks.
297 reviews110 followers
July 18, 2025
Perfection.

Bend the Pucking Rules picks up right where we left off from Break Your Pucking Heart - and we start to have even MORE questions about what is happening!

BTPR was wild in the best possible way. This series is giving “I Know What You Did Last Summer” vibes with the best possible spice & tension. True enemies to lovers, hate to love going on - which I can see will amp up in book three, Aidric’s time to shine.

BTPR is focused heavily on Ashley & Sebastian’s relationship and the tangled web of secrets & lies that surrounds The Ice Lords. The chemistry between these two was fire 🔥 and while, I love Ashley & Callen - I REALLY loved her with Sebastian. Don’t worry, there was also some spicy tension with Aidric but his time to shine will be book three.

Who is stalking Ashley and taunting the Ice Lords? Even when we think we know, we don’t…

Profile Image for Pana.
351 reviews43 followers
July 21, 2025
5⭐️
Spice: 🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️

I really really really enjoyed this story. More than Break your Pucking heart. I’m a HUUUGGGEE sucker for the “I had no where else to go” or “I didn’t know who else to call” microtrope, gahhhh 🤤🤤🤤🤤

So many secrets, betrayal, and murder. And I’m so here for it. I just knew I would love Sebastian as much as I did in this book. I really love how much one person can change the perspective of the “villain” and make their hearts melt.

Callan is just as dreamy. And that SUPAA SPICY SCENE 🥵🫠🤤
Literally melting just thinking about it, it’s a super soaker if you know what I mean 😉

You must read Break your Pucking heart first before reading Bend the Pucking rules!

Tropes:
MFM
“I didn’t know who to call.”
Bully trope
Dark romance
College Hockey
Secret society
Profile Image for Anja.
360 reviews69 followers
July 15, 2025
I ate this book up in one sitting practically! I have been anxiously waiting to continue after that wild cliffhanger in book one. This was so good!

The suspense, growing relationships, more secrets being revealed….I loved it all! It was so good getting to be inside Sebastian’s head in this book. I honestly love him so much & I think he’s definitely becoming my favorite . My heart did hurt for Callum because he forgot so much after the accident but I loved seeing him regain his memories. This ending had my jaw on the floor AGAIN. I can’t believe I have to wait until this winter for the final book! I am dying for it😭

Thank you so much Rachel Leigh & VPR for this ARC🤍
Profile Image for Litbyzuls.
146 reviews31 followers
July 16, 2025
The cliff hanger in book one had me shook and running to read book two IMMEDIATELY. The plot thickens in book two as we are brought along the chase for who is threatening and stalking the Ice Lords.

We get some group action (wink) and more mystery -I need the next book tomorrow please LOL. I enjoyed reading this book so much! Thank you to Valentine PR for the eARC.
Profile Image for Tina Morgan.
1,131 reviews11 followers
November 19, 2025



Lord love a duck!!! I absolutely love Rachel’s writing!! She can pull you into a story within the first page and you’re hooked!! I mean you will not want to move until you have devoured every single word of that book. And thank goodness this one picks up right where book 1 left us hanging!! We also get to know Sebastion a lot better. And I fell so hard for him!! And then what Callam had to deal with!! And Avery has all the love triangle issues going on with Callam and Sebastion. And the mystery is still happening. Notes showing up, pictures getting sent by text, videos playing in front of people and bodies going missing and showing up dead!! And just when they think they have it figured out bammmm!!! Another shock blows up in their face!!! So we are left with the mystery still open. Who is doing this to the Ice Lords? We have to wait to book 3 to find out!! And I can’t wait!!! I can’t recommend this book enough and yes you need to read book 1!!! 5 stars isn’t enough for this series and I haven’t read the last book yet!!









Profile Image for Casey Smailles.
195 reviews13 followers
July 22, 2025
Bend The Pucking Rules by Rachel Leigh

Tropes:
🖤Touch her and die
🖤College hockey
🖤Enemies to lovers
🖤Best friends brother
🖤Budding why - choose
🖤Secret society
🖤Suspense
🖤Dark romance
🖤Forced proximity

Firstly i want to thank the wonderful Rachel for the opportunity to read her book Bend The Pucking Rules which is the second book in the Ice Lords series. This one I devoured in a day. And it has left me needing more....

Bend The Pucking Rules follows Avery, Callan and Sebastian. These three each share A wonderful connection. Although in the beginning it appears Avery and Callan are together. Nothing is official. Remember what they say love and hate being a fine line. Well when someone sabotages Callans car and he is badly injured. Sebastian takes it upon himself to watch over Avery. But what happens when you spend too much time with your enemy and you see another side of them...

Once Callan regains his memorys. Avery finds herself in a hard place. Who will she choose? Or is it possible for both.... Stay tuned.

This one had me on the edge of my seat with suspense. Growing relationships. Swoony moments. Great banter. Tension. Fabulous chemistry. The spice was 🥵🥵

While that ending left me with so many more questions. I loved seeing Aidicks epilogue. I can't wait for book 3.

Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Spice: 🌶️🌶️🌶️
Profile Image for Jayme Muraco.
99 reviews4 followers
July 15, 2025
This book had me so locked in and I completely devoured it. This is book 2 in the Ice Lords trilogy, each one ending with a cliffhanger. So I’m still hanging at the edge of my seat at the moment.

Bend the Pucking Rules has all of my favorite tropes wrapped into one amazing suspenseful story.

🏒 Enemies to Lovers
☠️ Why Choose
🏒 Dark hockey romance
☠️ Suspense
🏒 Secret Society

Avery, Callan, Sebastian, and Aidric are all in too deep with each other, all in different ways. The guys being a part of the Ice Lords have many dark secrets that turn into being a dangerous adventure for these four. Callan is a part of Avery’s past, but they despise each other at the moment. Their hate turns into lust and wanting, but then turns into something so much more. Danger collides with Callan at the end of book 1 and leaves us wondering who tried to hurt him. He wakes up in the beginning of book 2 forgetting everything from the last few months, especially things that started up with him and Avery. Sebastian then swoops in to pick up the broken pieces and learns to open up and love- something he never knew growing up. I thought I hated Sebastian, but boy did he change my mind in this book.

There’s someone out there though who is watching their every move and waiting for moments to strike when they least expect it. Who is playing this game and why?? Does everything completely fall apart when Callan wakes up? Can they all work together to figure out who’s hurting them? And does Avery have to choose between Callan and Sebastian….or can they all get along….together?

This book is so suspenseful, exciting, and spicyyyy. The tropes alone had me running to this, and now I need all the answers. I’m soooooo ready for book three!!!!
Profile Image for Amber Kirk.
511 reviews2 followers
November 17, 2025
“I came back for you little lamb”

“You touch yourself thinking about him. But it’s me you see.”

“You don’t owe me a perfect version of yourself, Avery.”

Why choose
Secret society
Enemies to lovers
Dark college Sports romance
Suspense
Memory Loss (specifically short-term memory loss for one main character)
Bully Romance
Found Family
Forbidden Romance
Obsessive Male Main Characters (MMCs)
"Touch Her You Die" / Protective MMCs
Dark Romance
Suspense/Mystery/Intrigue
The book also includes micro-tropes and elements such as:
"Don't Stop" / "Tell me to stop" scenarios
Hate sex
Masked men
A shared bath scene
Intense emotional depth and character

Please check the tw

This book burned so good! I ate it up and binged the series that’s available!

HİS FINGERS HOOK BENEATH MY CHIM.
TILTING MY FACE TOWARD HIM.
"EYES ON ME, " HE SAYS. I WANNA SEE YOUR FACE WHILE MY BEST FRIEND F**KS YOU."

“If my little lamb wants to run into fire, you best believe her wolf is going to be at her back, hunting her the entire time.”

I am still absolutely feral over this series. Rachel Leigh has me in a chokehold, and this sequel my new obsession. It picks up with emotional intensity right where Break Your Pucking Heart left off, and holy hell... I was on edge of my seat!

Avery is unpredictable, she is feisty, mouthy, a badass FMC, and reckless I absolutely loved her chaotic energy!
It was heart breaking to see Callan lose his memories and to think he still hates Avery after all they’ve been through together.
And Sebastian! I freakin love him! This man has officially taken over as one of my favourites of the boys. He's level-headed and logical, but then also arrogant. He’s sexy as heck and wields his power with control, like a ma in power!
His obsession with Avery grows its deep devotion to give her everything she needs. Wanting her as his to own. Their tension and chemistry and the lust was palpable!
Sebastian is her protector and the one who pushes her through fear into strength. And Aidric... I am dying to see what he'll bring to the table! I can’t wait for the next book!!


Profile Image for Sandy.
359 reviews3 followers
July 17, 2025
Omg yassss !!! This book picked right up where the 1st left off and the intense craziness was brought to an even bigger level !!

Callan & Sebastian are soo freakin hot in this book !!! Lord Jesus these Ice Lords bring the suspense the crazy the drama and the epicness !

I am dying for Aidric’s voice now… because he’s the most unhinged of them yet - with his own demons to boot..

Avery is the queen of Unhinged , and uncontrolled, but god does she love the crap out of her boys- with her whole heart…

I cnt wait to see if she’ll invite aidric to the fold .
Profile Image for Dani.
301 reviews13 followers
July 22, 2025
Bend the Pucking Rules picks up right where Break Your Pucking Heart left off and man, Rachel did not come to play with this one! I was pulled in from the start and needed answers. I love the mystery and suspense that is really packed into this book. Honestly, I was a little scared myself at parts just feeling like someone was watching them and going to pop out at any moment, I loved it.

While I do love Callan (because like how can you not), this book really was Sebastian's time to shine, and boy did he. I was living for every moment he had with Avery. So much tension, banter, the hate sex/lust was off the mf charts. I devoured it and was sitting there giggling or drooling (or both) because it was so delicious. There was the perfect balance of plot, spice and just overall intimate/sweet moments between these characters. I love how cutthroat the men are and so dang possessive of what is theirs *cough Avery cough*.

I absolutely love Avery and how strong, defiant and determined she is. This girl really takes no shit and isn't afraid of anyone. I love that she goes for what she wants and isn't going to let anyone scare her.

The why choose aspect of this series has been fleshed out so nicely and just feels right. I love how much time Rachel has taken to develop each relationship. I am so excited to see how Aidric is going to fit into the mix.

I don't want to say too much and spoil the story because you really just need to read it but if you love thriller, suspense, murder mystery, steamy hate sex and a badass FMC, you need to check out this series.

I cannot wait to get Aidric's POV next book. The breadcrumbs he was giving in this one had me shook in the best way. I think this might be my favorite series by Rachel so far and I have read several of her series.

Expect to be on the edge of your seat the entire book and questioning absolutely everything and everyone. No one and nothing are safe here. I am beyond pleased with how this book played out and can't wait to read the next and final installment in this series. I need answers!

Thank you so much Rachel for the ARC, it is such a joy to be on your team.
Profile Image for Sílvia [ silviasbooknook ].
48 reviews2 followers
July 28, 2025
I waited anxiously for this book, and it did not disappoint, in fact, it exceeded my expectations. 😍

It has everything I love in a dark romance: broken, twisted characters who love intensely, I’d even say obsessively, who need each other like we need oxygen to breathe.
They break each other only to rebuild themselves all over again. ❤️‍🩹

Adding to this dark and twisted mix, we have a secret society, macabre secrets, a thirst for power and control, and a killer on the loose that adds a dangerous tension to the story, keeping us on the edge and holding our breath. 🫠

I’m a fan of the “why-choose” trope and love that Rachel is slowly unfolding it for us. 🖤

We got to know Callan and his relationship with Avery better in the first book, and now it’s Sebastian’s turn to show us what’s hiding behind his relentless Ice Lord mask. He’s struggling with feelings he never knew he could have for someone he’s supposed to hate.

Just like Avery hates him. She finds herself in an emotional conflict, Callan’s absence, Sebastian’s approach, the killer, her mother... Everything is happening at once, throwing her into a panic spiral, and it’s the Ice Lords who will be there to catch her.

Rachel loves to leave us in agony, and we’ll have to wait for the third Lord, Aidric. 🫠
I confess he’s my favorite, so reserved and harboring so much hatred towards people, especially Avery, who came to shatter the peace between the three men and put their friendship at risk.

Just one sentence he said in this book to completely won me over. My heart tells me he’ll be the most sensitive and vulnerable of the them.
I get emotional just thinking about it.

I loved the book, and once again, Rachel’s writing was perfect. 😍
You just can’t stop reading, and if you do, you can’t think about anything else until you pick the book up again.
I want more! Please be kind to Aidric! 🥹🖤 Thank you so much, @rachelleighauthor, for this amazing book 🖤
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for Mysti.
1,316 reviews27 followers
July 26, 2025
This story is just getting deeper and deeper into the plot. So many twists and turns to make your head spin. This one is mostly told through Avery and Sebastian’s POVs with a couple from Callan and Aidric. In book one we focused mostly on Avery and Callan repairing what they broke in HS, and her meeting Seb and Aidric. After the event at the end of book 1 Callan spends most of the book in the hospital healing and rehab center. So we get so much more Sebastian and his and Avery’s relationship. From hating each other to attraction to something more growing. All of this in the midst of someone being after them. Secrets they thought were covered become public, their suspicions of who could be doing it are dashed. And we get one hell of a spicy sharing scene! I can’t wait to find out who is behind everything, though I have a couple of guesses. I also can’t wait to see how Aidric makes good on his promise. Exciting and seriously fun series so far!

Read: 📱EARC
MMC: Callan Cromwell, Aidric Church, Sebastian Banks
FMC: Avery Castle
Spice: 2🌶️
Tropes: RH/Why Choose, Hockey, Suspense, Secret Society, Enemies to Lovers, Forced Proximity
Profile Image for Sarina Vega.
234 reviews15 followers
July 21, 2025
“It’s like my heart split clean down the middle and each of them owns a piece.”

I NEED THE NEXT BOOK IN MY HANDS NOW!!

Bend The Pucking Rules picked right back up where Book 1 left off. We got a temporary reprieve from that cliffhanger, but it didn’t last long. When Callan and Avery thought they were in a good place, but an accident causes a divide. Avery is alone trying to figure out the pieces but ends up having her enemy Sebastian there to lean on. He turns into a support system, which brought them closer. I loved this side of Sebastian. As much as I love Callan I think Sebastian is going to be my favorite. Avery is spiraling mentally. Sebastian is holding her together in more ways than one.

The twist and turns this story has taken is driving me crazy. Every time you think you have the stalker figured out, it just leads to another dead end. The suspense is top tier. The Ice Lords are always in control and right now they have no clue what or who is coming at them. This person is a few steps ahead. Every. Single. Time. And of course Rachel couldn’t leave us with answers or a reprieve. That cliffhanger left my jaw dropped. I’m begging Rachel to hurry with the next book.

Tropes: why choose, bully, dark romance, secret society, hockey, college, blackmail, revenge, cliffhanger, stalker.

Thank to you so much Rachel for the ARC in exchange for my honest review.
Profile Image for Courtney.
1,992 reviews210 followers
July 18, 2025
Rachel, Rachel, Rachel - you are torturing us readers in the best possible way. LOL

Bend the Pucking Rules starts exactly where book 1 left off (gut wrenching cliffy) but we are thrown a loop with Callan. Aidric is his typical alpha-self and tries to remind everyone of their place, all the while making sure nothing happens to them.

This book focuses more on Avery and Sebastian as she leans on him more while Callan is healing. We see a different side to Sebastian but he's still who he is at his core and that's what makes him even more intriguing as the story moves along.

Rachel does a phenomenal job with the twists and turns and keep readers on their toes the entire time. Just when you think you know something, she proves us wrong and throws another puzzle piece into the air. And I love how the romance plays right into the suspense of everything, just giving the book a whole new level of intrigue.

A fantastic book two and after that epilogue - I am dying for book three!

Profile Image for Marisela M. Chavez.
1,405 reviews8 followers
July 20, 2025
Bend the Pucking Rules is the second installment of the Ice Lord series. And let me tell you it will keep you on the edge of your seat till the very end.

Avery is still the strong girl everyone knows. She won’t let anyone push her around. Now she has to pick up the pieces after Callan’s accident. He doesn’t remember what they were becoming only just the hate. And she will try everything for him to get his memory back.

Callan and Avery connections runs deeps. When she kisses him he start to slowly getting some of his memory back.

We learn more about a little more background of Sebastian and what he went through. When Avery world is falling apart he is there. You see a soft side in him. He comes to her rescue’s more than once and you can’t help but root for them. And work together to see who wants to destroy the Ice Lords. A traitor is amongst them and they must work together to figure out who the threat is. You’ll literally be on edge of your seat with all the twist and turns.

This story has it all, especially when Callan, Avery and Sebastian become more. This story has it all suspense, mystery, chemistry off the charts and so much more. I can’t wait to see how everything will unfold in the end.

Arc provided for honest review
Profile Image for Vanessa.
427 reviews32 followers
July 17, 2025
someone’s gotta study what rachel put in this book because it was ADDICTIVE.

i LOVE LOVE LOVEEEE sebastian so much 🥹 seeing their relationship dynamic grow throughout the book had me GASPING for air UGH I LOVE THEM UR HONOR 👩‍⚖️

avery remains the badass she is, and just watching her deal with everything life is throwing at her makes me feel for her but she always takes it in stride and comes back stronger.

this book took me for LOOPS, it definitely kept me on my toes wondering what was next and who was involved … i will say i truly was not expecting that ending.

i cannot wait to see how avery & aidric progress … truly like two flames together and i have my marshmallows ready to go 🔥

callan was and will always be my baby, i love him this book too 😭

im so ready for the last book (but also sad it’s ending because i love these characters so much) 😩 thank you rachel for the arc!! all thoughts and opinions are my own.

also shout out to rooftops and starry nights 🌌 🥹
Displaying 1 - 30 of 401 reviews

Can't find what you're looking for?

Get help and learn more about the design.