After loving the anime I immediately wanted to jump into the novels. This first one does a great job of introducing the characters and main theme of the series, although it doesn't have as punchy an overarching mystery and climax as Hyouka (Kotenbu)'s first volume did. However, it makes up for that by having some really mechanically fun short mysteries. The stand-out one is definitely the uber-small scale impossible crime story "How To Make Delicious Hot Cocoa", though the final deduction of the novel also showed some impressive chains of reasoning which would make Ellery Queen nod in appreciation (and which I could never write, because my brain just doesn't work that way). However, I am definitely looking forward to the second installment, since that was my favorite arc in the anime, and might even give Hyouka a run for its money, so I can't wait to read it in novel form.
Cozy mystery book. Main characters are Japanese high schoolers. I got tired so quickly of the way these kids talk. Hot cocoa drink mystery made me angry. Is this a joke? I can only blame myself because I cannot resist dessert mysteries. The cover was so cute. There are other books in this series. Their cover was even cuter with such interesting title of the books! No thanks.
Another book by Yonezawa sensei and I really enjoyed reading it! Shoushimin might has similar plotline with Hyouka, but I found this series darker than the infamous one. Shoushimin had its mysterious vibe in it and I couldn't help but feeling eager to finish this novel sooner. At first, I was so curious of the relationship between our two leads and how it formed, and then I dove into the daily misteries which developed to the climax of the story, and I liked how this first novel ended. Still, I still had the thirst to know the detail story of the incident that happened to Kobato and Osanai in their middle school year which made them striving to become petite bourgeoisie now in high school. Hopefully, I could get a glimpse of it in the next novel. Hahaha..
Yonezawa is definitely a one of a kind voice in the mystery genre and this is no exception. The small scale mysteries are all done so well (I especially like “for your eyes only” and the last one) but the best part is the overarching development of the characters backsliding into their old habits (which as a reader is not necessarily a bad thing). I think the idea of striving to be a “小市民” (understood by the MCs to be living a basic/unassuming life) is both unique and interesting, and while it is very frustrating for the reader I actually think that’s the point. Some of the stories have such unsatisfying conclusions that leave the reader feeling frustrated, but I think this is for sure one of Yonezawa’s biggest strengths and it works really well in this novel as well.
I decided to try the light novel, after being obsessed with the anime's first season. I get some viewers when they said it's boring HAHA. The book though is focused on the mystery (ofc). Since I started with the anime, the book gave me more details in terms of the 'evidence' and how Kobato-kun processes information. The story in the anime further added a slice-of-life feel with portrayals of highschool life of our MCs. i love it There must have been 1 or 2 chapters that were not in the anime. I've also enjoyed the 2nd season, so I'll be reading the following volumes too