Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read.
Start by marking “A Forbidden Rumspringa (Gay Amish Romance #1)” as Want to Read:
A Forbidden Rumspringa (Gay Amish Romance #1)
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating
Open Preview

A Forbidden Rumspringa

(Gay Amish Romance #1)

4.17  ·  Rating details ·  3,715 ratings  ·  717 reviews
alternate cover edition of ISBN 9780993859823

When two young Amish men find love, will they risk losing everything?

In a world where every detail of life—down to the width of a hat brim—is dictated by God and the all-powerful rules of the community, two men dare to imagine a different way. At 18, Isaac Byler knows little outside the strict Amish settlement of Zebulon, Minnes
ebook, 231 pages
Published September 3rd 2014 by KA Books (first published August 31st 2014)
More Details... Edit Details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Community Reviews

Showing 1-30
Average rating 4.17  · 
Rating details
 ·  3,715 ratings  ·  717 reviews

More filters
Sort order
Start your review of A Forbidden Rumspringa (Gay Amish Romance #1)
Heidi Cullinan
Sep 05, 2014 rated it it was amazing
Scroll through my Twitter feed Friday evening from about 5 until 9 on September 5, and you will see me freaking the fuck out over a book. This is the book.

I've been seeing this book around, and I gotta tell you, I was saying no. Because I could think of eight million ways this setup could go horribly, terribly wrong. Having grown up in a family full of pastors and living near two different Amish communities in my life, one the Amish/Mennonite megahub that is Kalona, Iowa, I know Amish, well, and
~✡~Dαni(ela) ♥ ♂♂ love & semi-colons~✡~
Heart-rending, poignant, and unbearably moving, A Forbidden Rumspringa is without a doubt one of the best books of the year.

Raw, real, intense, this is a story of a forbidden affair, a Rumspringa of the heart, a sexual awakening of the deepest kind.
As he collapsed with David on top of him, still buried in him, pressing little kisses to his neck and murmuring tender words of praise and love, Isaac didn't care.

Let it be like this.

Religion oppresses, but growing up “plain,” conservati
Sep 05, 2014 rated it liked it
Shelves: m-m
3.5 stars. Review completed September 15, 2014

 photo oie_o8LKrKgVRRdt_zps002889a9.gif

 photo oie_tllHJWiaFjwe_zps734bb76b.png

First things first. I’ll admit I had my little epiphany after the 15 % mark. Rumspringa sounds similar to our Swiss German umeschpringä and after Googling a bit I know it is also spelled rumschpringe. Now that does sound like Swiss German too because Switzerland knows plenty of different dialects. (view spoiler)
Shile (Hazard's Version) Maroon on semi-hiatus
Audiobook - 4 stars

Story 3.5 stars

Not what I expected and ended up enjoying it more.

My take is this is what happens when two boys discover what their hands and dicks can do, orgasms, ass, lips, prostate etc. Isaac and David did use what God gave them for betterment of their sex lives.


Yapp, they fucked like bunnies.


I liked that the religion stuff was not extreme. I ended up enjoying it.
☆ Todd
Jun 16, 2021 marked it as freebie

Now *FREE* on Amazon, 2021-06-16:


Heather K (dentist in my spare time)
**Kindle Freebie 9/17/20!**

I swear, one day I WILL read this book.

Keira Andrews
FREE five days only until 07/17/22. You can Whispersync the audio narrated by the wonderful John Solo!

Amazon US: https://amzn.to/3yz3orO
Amazon Universal: https://readerlinks.com/l/2408143

P.S. I know some folks hesitate to read Isaac and David’s story because of the role religion plays, and I completely understand that. I’m not religious at all, and while I respect others’ beliefs, there’s no religious messaging directed toward readers in this series. It’s also very steamy with on-page sex--I don
Sep 11, 2014 rated it it was amazing

4.5 stars

Well shit. This book was like looking in a mirror.

...except of course I'm a single, heterosexual, Asian woman living the life of awholelottasin...and Isaac & David are...not.

Other than that...

Ok, so you don't really need to know my whole life's history. But in a nutshell, I grew up in a REALLY crazy Christian background (two words: "Jesus Camp") and how I ended up being where I am today is a long, sordid tale. Let's just say that I related almost uncomfortably with the struggles of
Eli Easton
Sep 05, 2014 rated it it was amazing
Every once in a while, a writer reads a book and thinks "Damn it! I wish I'd written that." In case it's not clear, that's a high compliment. :-) This is one of those books.

I live in Lancaster County, PA, (Amish country) and this past spring wrote a murder mystery/romance set among the Amish that's currently making the publisher rounds. So I was anxious to read this book.

In a word: it's very well done! I love that both of the MCs are Amish and the setting and their personalities felt very real t
OK, I have given this review some thought and this is how I've decided to handle it:

I am a great fan of Keira Andrews and I thought she did a fantastic job with this book, like she does with all her books. If I had known the true content of the book before reading it, I would NOT have read it, because I found the subject matter so off-putting. Therefore, I will not be rating this one.

I cannot adequately express just how much I absolutely loathe anything to do with organized religion. I mean
5 Heartbreaking Eechel stars

Heading into this story, I didn't really know what I was in for. And I'm so very glad I've read it.

A forbidden romance... *sigh*

For me this story was believable, heartbreakingly raw, honest and filled with love. David and Isaac are two characters who will stay with me... *sigh*

David and Issac were so beautiful and intense together

“I’ve dreamed about this. Having you here. Properly, I mean.” He pressed a kiss to Isaac’s throat, then unhooked his shirt, punctua
Written September 28, 2014

4 1/2 Stars - Wonderfully touching and beautifully tender. A love-story in my taste.

This Amish M/M topic felt irresistible interesting. I saw an update about this new book a couple of weeks ago and couldn't resist the temptation. I did as I usually do, I clicked and downloaded.
Photobucket Pictures, Images and Photos

A Forbidden Rumspringa cracked. Memorable good!
I kind of fell head over heels for this amazing story from the first page. A partially very quiet and low-key novel with all emotions tr
Dec 02, 2014 rated it it was amazing

BR with friends on 8 december!

What a fantastic book!

A Forbidden Rumspringa is real, intense, this is a story of a forbidden affair, a “Rumspringa” of the heart, a sexual awakening so moving, so heart-rending both the writing and storytelling were fantastic!

Keira Andrews brings us into the heart of the Amish, a super conservative religious sector within the Amish community that rigid by the bishop lifestyle where everyone is under constant surveillance and believes in zero contact with the “eng
Lisa Henry
Sep 03, 2014 rated it really liked it
For some reason I thought I wouldn't like this book.

For some reason I bought it anyway.

This book gave me real human feelz. I'll try not to hold that against it.

It is, ultimately, a sweet story about two young men who fall in love, with the added complication that they live in a very strict Amish community. I loved the attention to detail here, BTW. I don't know much about the Amish, and I feel like I actually learned something from this.

As much as I wanted these guys to get their HEA... a pa
Nick Pageant
Sep 05, 2014 rated it it was amazing
Shelves: m-m
You can read a wonderful review here. ...more

BR, June 25th with Paul, Nathan and Julie (re-re-read for Julie, Nathan and myself)

BR, January 31st with Marco, Momo, Marte and Julie... (re-read for Julie and Myself)

Sequel, February 3rd

Again... 5 utterly deserved stars!!!!


Maybe I'll add in my review tomo. I don't have words now. I'm sobbing again!!! So beautiful....


BR, Friday September 19th with Susan, Penumbra, Kaylor and Julie

This is a difficult rev
Aug 30, 2016 rated it it was amazing
Finally another book I can put in this year's top ten list of favorite reads.

'A Forbidden Rumspringa' surprised me with bone breaking realism, a young and strong character who questions his world and a love interest who is so determined to do the right thing and stand by his family that he almost loses himself.

Isaac is an 18-year-old Amish boy who doesn't really get the attraction behind courting girls and driving them home after a Sunday singing. In his Amish community, young men end their scho
The Bursting Bookshelf of a Wallflower
Story: ⭐⭐⭐⭐
MCs: ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Cover: ⭐⭐⭐

With Keira Andrews being the author of one of my all-time favorite M/M romance books (Semper Fi), I decided to give A Forbidden Rumspringa a try despite the fact that is focusing on organized religion - a topic that I am not usually going for.

---The Blurb---
Growing up in the strictly religious community of Swartzentruber Amish in Zebulon in which things such as mirrors, in-house bathrooms, zippers, computers and feelings such as pride and homosexual love are f
* A Reader Obsessed *
4.5 Stars

This is what I would have wanted to know before going into this series.

1. Is this really religious?
The Amish community depicted here is extremely strict in all that they do. There are rules upon rules upon rules, governing pretty much every aspect of their lives. As one would guess, this religion looks at the modern world with disdain and at homosexuality as a grave and serious sin.

2. How angsty is this story?
Pretty darn angsty.
I would say my anxiety levels were moderate and they
Simply wonderful.

I was so worried this would be overly angsty for no other reason than it would be easy to do so.

But, no.

No, this was about Issac's journey to finding his own happiness. Taking his own rumspringa, regardless of the strict rules that govern his life.

When Issac is first assigned to be an apprentice for David he knew it was a bad idea. He knew being around David would worsen his already sinful thoughts about the other boy. As they continued to work together, Issac realized that his
4.5 stars 💫

When I read the first chapter, I wasn't sure I would continue this book. I started it a bit slow. My finger twitched to DNF it. I felt bored and I was distracted in many ways. 😴😴 But I thought this was one of Keira Andrews’s books, and if I didn't give it a try, I would regret it. 😶 So I read it, and it was a pleasant surprise. I liked this book so much. 🥺

The two boys, Isaac and David who fell in love with each other are bounded by rules. They are Amish, and it is an abomination to
Jul 24, 2021 rated it liked it  ·  review of another edition
Shelves: adult, mm, contemporary
3.5 Stars

I'd been waffling on whether to write a review for this and I realised so few people will see this anyway it won't make a difference.

I've been a fan of Andrews' since I read Semper Fi years ago and discovered the wonderful world of mm. It was liberating and exhilarating to finally read stories featuring mlm protagonists that get happy endings and could be as explicit as their mf counterparts.

I, however, was not keen on this one because of the Amish connection. I tend to avoid stories
A Forbidden Rumspringa is a beautiful story of love, family and faith. It was not preachy, it did not paint the Amish in a bad light and it pulled me right into the strict, insular community where David and Isaac live.

I loved the portrayal of both men, old enough to remember what it was like in their former community, which was slightly less restrictive about dealing with the English (non-Amish) and allowed the young a rumspringa to explore life outside the community before they decided to join
Dec 01, 2014 rated it it was amazing
Well, this book is absolutely fantastic!How Isaac and David develop their forbidden relationship is magical. The awareness of feelings that shouldn't exist in their world, the discovery of what sex should meant to them, and how hot that sex could be, brought those two young Amish boys to together! And they surely fit well!!!

This was my first Amish book, and though I had an idea of how reclusive this community is, I never imagined how much. In our age, it's really difficult to see a world where p
Sep 11, 2014 rated it it was amazing
This was so beautiful!
Absolutely perfect.

I read about Gay-love in the Amish community before, but this book was better, in the way that it really let you into the heart of the religion, the believes, the day-to-day life, the way they look/dress, and why...
It was truly a learning experience, and I was amazed to see how VERY similar the Amish are to the extreme religious Jews (after googling a bit, I even learned that they share the same genetic illnesses due to the same way of living. Amazing!)

3,5 stars rounded to 3

I see everybody loved this book and I can totally understand why. Unfortunately it didn't really work for me. I enjoyed parts of it and it kept me entertained, BUT I was just too busy being heartbroken for Isaac and David... Well maybe Gay Amish Romance isn't for me. Not sure I'll continue this series. Maybe after a while.

There are some great reviews here and I don't want to spoil it for others. If this kind of stories work for you, then you should give it a try. The writi
I have no words for how much I loved this book. I don't think I can adequately describe my reading experience or how these characters touched my heart. I think you just need to read it and discover it for yourself. ...more
Ariana  (mostly offline)
Dec 17, 2016 rated it it was amazing
Shelves: lgbtq
*4,5 stars*

This was sitting on my tbr shelf for quite while, because I wasn't sure about its theme and whether I would like it. I really take my hat off to Keira Andrews. I got sucked into David and Isaac's story on page one and spit out at the end, rushing to get book 2. What an amazing book!

To be frank, the severe and strict rules of Zebulon did shock me, and from my very 'English' POV there were a lot of things extremely hard to understand. How can it be wrong to hug a child? How can it be wr
Oct 12, 2014 rated it really liked it
Whoaaa. Hold up!
Please deposit all presumptions here and personal baggage goes over here and….
Wouldn't it be nice to ‘turn yourself off’ sometimes? No matter how open-minded you might be, you inevitably bring things along with you. You can’t help but carry a load of opinions, experiences and emotions wherever you go.
It makes you ‘who’ you are.
Well, for me, I have Amish neighbors and friends and they are vastly different than the Amish community portrayed here.
I know this dampened my enjoymen
Kaje Harper
Aug 18, 2014 rated it really liked it
Shelves: favorites, m-m
This books is infused with the details of life in a very restrictive Amish community, one which has drawn back from the modern world to the point where the young people are given no permissive Rumspringa. In this group, adolescence does not include any chance to sample the allure of the "English" world of luxuries and technology and decadence and risk, before committing to home and church. A tragedy back home was the trigger for these folk to draw away from their more permissive origins into a r ...more
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 next »
topics  posts  views  last activity   
Buddy Read with Trish starting 11th January, 2015 24 11 Jan 12, 2015 11:56AM  
BR with friends from Monday 8 December 2014 24 27 Dec 12, 2014 12:58PM  

Readers also enjoyed

  • A Second Harvest (Men of Lancaster County, #1)
  • Tender Mercies (Men of Lancaster County, #2)
  • Gravity
  • Pieces of Us (Missing Pieces, #3)
  • Tic-Tac-Mistletoe (Hartbridge Christmas, #1)
  • Angels in the City
  • Better Than People (Garnet Run, #1)
  • Winter Waites (Aster Valley #0.5)
  • Right as Raine (Aster Valley #1)
  • Pieces of You (Missing Pieces, #1)
  • Two Tribes
  • Painted Lace
  • Pieces of Me (Missing Pieces, #2)
  • Play Dirty (Wages of Sin, #2)
  • Galaxies and Oceans
  • Imago (Imago, #1)
See similar books…
LGBT > Gay
See top shelves…
Keira aims for the perfect mix of character, plot, and heat in her M/M romances. She writes everything from swashbuckling pirates to heartwarming holiday escapism. Her fave tropes are enemies to lovers, age gaps, forced proximity, and passionate virgins. Although she loves delicious angst along the way, Keira guarantees happy endings!

Other books in the series

Gay Amish Romance (3 books)
  • A Clean Break (Gay Amish Romance #2)
  • A Way Home (Gay Amish Romance #3)

News & Interviews

Here at Goodreads World Headquarters, we're always on alert for any shifts in readerly attention that we can spot. Recently we've noticed a...
72 likes · 6 comments
“I think about what it would be like to live with you instead of a wife. To share a bed every night, and work side by side each day. I know its a terrible sin, but the thought of it makes my heart so glad." He sucked in a breath, trying in vain to stop tears from forming. "I want to be with you forever.” 3 likes
“But the Bible says it's wrong." The nail dug into Isaac's palm as he squeezed it. David sighed. "I know. When I try to make sense of things, I always end up there. But isn't the Bible only more words?" "Holy words, though!" Isaac sputtered. "We know everything in the Bible is true." "Do we? It was written by men, wasn't it? If it's all true, then why don't men sell their daughters into slavery anymore? It's in the Bible. So is being able to buy slaves as long as they're foreigners.” 2 likes
More quotes…