I received a free review copy of this audio book, at my request, and am voluntarily leaving this unbiased review.
This book goes back to the tone of books 1 and 2, and leaves the dark tone of book 3 behind.
The stakes of this plot remains high, and the personal safety of our favorite characters remains in question. However, the book remains light and snarky through out. I found this to be a great relief. I understand why book 3 needed to be more serious, but I'm glad this book was able to be closer to the first.
That's not to say this book is as light as the first 2 books. Books 1 and 2 introduced the plot, settings and characters. Book 3 had them get into the worst possible situation they could and book 4 is the resolution. So while not the dark tone of book 3, this book still has a lot of heavy lifting to do, plot wise. But it is approached mostly from the Pan's POV, with all the implications that brings.
Most of our friends are back, for this one. Big Merv, Lucy, the parrot, Trev, etc. New characters are introduced or expanded on, like Pub Quiz Allen (sorry if it's spelt wrong, audiobook) , and the resistance members. This is where the heart of the story lies. The author crafts characters that it is easy to form a bond with. Characters like Allen were just background before this book and within a chapter or two of him being a secondary character in this book, I felt like I knew him and cared for him.
There's little new in the setting, it all takes place in K'bath. Familiar places and situations. To be expected in a book of this type. So much has been explored in other entries in the series that building on that seems more natural than inventing new places to go.
The plot is fairly straightforward and satisfying. There are, however, a few places where I would have liked to see something more complex introduced. The Pan can be frustratingly simple at times, though. For the most part this felt fine and I wouldn't want him to be more in the know, but sometimes he felt unnaturally slow witted. This had the consequence of slowing the plot, occasionally, and dragging things out that should have been delt with and left behind.
The voice narration, by Gareth Davies, is amazing, again. His voices are great. Timing is perfect. He does an excellent job, as I have come to expect.
All in all, this was a great book and a wonderful conclusion of the story. The tone was much lighter than the last book and this made for a much more enjoyable read. Our favorite characters are back, new ones are added or expanded on. The plot progresses naturally for the most part and only has a few wrinkles. The voice narration was first rate, as it has been for the entire series.
This was an amazing series, and I whole heartily recommend.
*** Spoilers***
There were 2 aspects of the plot I was disappointed with. Well, 2 aside from how dense the Pan was at times.
Firstly, in the first book Sir Robin showed the Pan how he could use a thimble to reach through and remove objects. In the demo, it was a bottle of alcohol from the bar. This skill is never used again. I don't know if Lord Vernon knew about this skill, but I was hoping he would use it to kill the Supreme Leader. Reach through with a dagger and kill him from another room. In any case, I don't like when a cool idea I'd floated once, and never brought up again.
Second, the General. We had POV's from Lucy and Ruth, The Pan, the Resistance members, Lord Vernon, etc. But in the while series the General never had the story told from his POV, or at least not that I can remember. As he was a double (triple?) agent, I suspected it was done deliberately to keep his loyalties secret. However, as the story progressed and it became less likely that he was actually loyal to Lord Vernon, I was hoping for a shake up. Either his POV, or that he would turn out to be trying to kill LORD Vernon to take his place, etc. Something to justify keeping his motivations secret. This doesn't negatively affect the story, it would have just spiced things up a bit.
Still, though, minor things overall. I really did enjoy this series.