Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read.

Start by marking “Ariel's Song (In Bed with the Enemy, #1)” as Want to Read:

Other editions

Enlarge cover

Rate this book

Clear rating

1 of 5 stars 2 of 5 stars 3 of 5 stars 4 of 5 stars 5 of 5 stars

Open Preview

Ariel's Song

(In Bed with the Enemy #1)

Evie Knight

3.77 · Rating details · 43 ratings · 27 reviews

Colin Hoskins, famous classical violinist, is tainted by his past. Angry at life, unable to move beyond the betrayal of his dead fiancé, he’s sworn off performing or falling in love ever again. All Colin wants is to be left alone, except no one listens. Especially the pretty little assistant he can’t fire and his body burns to claim.

Stranded in a foreign country, bankrupte ...more

Get A Copy

ebook, 206 pages

Published November 2nd 2013 by Evernight Publishing (first published October 28th 2013)

More Details... Edit Details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Reader Q&A

To ask other readers questions about Ariel's Song, please sign up.

Be the first to ask a question about Ariel's Song

Lists with This Book

This book is not yet featured on Listopia. Add this book to your favorite list »

Community Reviews

Showing 1-30

Average rating 3.77 ·

Rating details

· 43 ratings · 27 reviews

More filters

Sort order

Start your review of Ariel's Song (In Bed with the Enemy, #1)

Feb 02, 2015 Tammy rated it it was amazing

A sexy, intense read that had me hooked. The characters are wonderful in this read. Colin is hurt and is striking out at other, Ariel is alone and desperate to find work. Logan, Colin’s friend brings the two of them together. Can Ariel break Collin free of the walls he has built around his heart? This is a short and sexy read that kept me entertained throughout and I am looking forward to reading more of this series.

flag 2 likes · Like · see review

Mar 10, 2014 Babel rated it really liked it

Shelves: challenge, versiónoriginal

In a nutshell: Ariel's Song is the very sexy tale of how a passionate romp can turn into a story of redemption and freedom. I loved the idea of a tortured virtuoso who finds his way to happiness through unexpected love. And I loved how a lovesick woman is the one who actually rescues the man of her dreams from his nightmare.

Best Feature: story and sexy encounters.

Worst feature: not too fond of the writing style and the heroine gives in too easily.

Es español: ¿Por qué la he leído? por dos motivos ...more

flag 1 like · Like · see review

Oct 31, 2013 Liz F rated it really liked it

Review and author interview posted on Kindles & Wine

One of the very best parts of reviewing books is getting a chance to try out new authors. When I read one that I feel stands out from rest, I try to tell friends about it. Well, friends, I’m happy to say that I recently read Ariel's Song, the debut novel by Evie Knight, and I thoroughly enjoyed it! Read on to check out my mini-review and a Q&A with Miss Evie, herself!

I was surprised at how much I liked Ariel. This isn’t the usual heroine that I Review and author interview posted on Kindles & Wine

One of the very best parts of reviewing books is getting a chance to try out new authors. When I read one that I feel stands out from rest, I try to tell friends about it. Well, friends, I’m happy to say that I recently read Ariel's Song, the debut novel by Evie Knight, and I thoroughly enjoyed it! Read on to check out my mini-review and a Q&A with Miss Evie, herself!

I was surprised at how much I liked Ariel. This isn’t the usual heroine that I find myself raving about. She makes some really bad decisions, but when she makes a mistake, she owns up to it and apologizes or goes about trying to fix it. Sure, she may not be a perfect, ideal heroine, but I think she’s a very realistic character whose heart and true character shows through in her honesty and in how she handles herself with other people.

Then there’s Colin. The way he treats Ariel at first made it really difficult for me to warm up to him. He was very curt with her and a little harsh! But the more I learned about Colin’s past, the more I understood and liked him. He hasn’t had an easy time the last few years, what with being associated with his fiancée’s murder. I was on the edge of my seat to find out if he had a hand in her death or not! Being a celebrity musician made things even worse for him. I normally don’t have a lot of sympathy for the rich and famous, but as I read more of his point of view, the more he seemed like he was a good person who was the victim of rumors and lies. Not only is Colin a supremely talented musician, he is also one sexy beast, so there were times when I was less concerned about Colin’s history and more concerned with what naughty thing he was going to do to Ariel next!

I found myself really sucked in to this book. I was worried about Ariel; I was worried about the truth of Colin’s involvement in the death of his fiancée; I was even suspecting some of Colin’s friends of having ulterior motives. I swear, I was seeing conspiracies around every corner! And this isn’t even a thriller or a suspense! It was definitely chock-full of Sexy Time, no doubt about it. Ariel's Song is a very, very hot book and I had a lot of fun reading it.

Bottom Line
I really liked Ariel's Song. I think this would be a good book for anyone who likes a high heat level in romance novels. It was fun to dislike the hero at first and then to warm up to him slowly, so I think that readers who like a complicated and twisty-turny path to romance will also enjoy this.

Rating: A-

Review copy courtesy of the author in exchange for an honest
review ...more

flag 1 like · Like · see review

Nov 11, 2013 Yazmin rated it really liked it

In Ariel’s Song by Evie Knight, Colin Hoskins is a famous classical violinist, who made the crossover to other musical genres. Unfortunately, since the murder of his fiancé and after being considered a prime suspect, Colin walked away from the stage and everyone in his life. He cannot move on from her betrayal and he does not want to perform on stage or fall in love ever again.

Ariel Parks needs a job ASAP. She went left home to try and find her brother, only he has disappeared and she needs mone In Ariel’s Song by Evie Knight, Colin Hoskins is a famous classical violinist, who made the crossover to other musical genres. Unfortunately, since the murder of his fiancé and after being considered a prime suspect, Colin walked away from the stage and everyone in his life. He cannot move on from her betrayal and he does not want to perform on stage or fall in love ever again.

Ariel Parks needs a job ASAP. She went left home to try and find her brother, only he has disappeared and she needs money to be able to fund her stay there and save enough money to return to New York. So when she finds out about a job as assistant to Colin Hoskins, she cannot help but go to an interview. She was a fan of his when he performed on stage and has always had a crush on him, working close to him would be like a dream.

But what she does not expect is the surly man that interviews her. Sparks fly as soon as they meet, but Colin doesn’t want an assistant and does not want to perform again, so he is rude and nasty towards her to send her away. He even implies that if she works for him he will kiss her and more with or without her permission. So Ariel leaves angry at him and his words.

Only Logan, Colin’s friend and manager will not let her get away that easily. She is the only one that responded to the job and it seemed like the only one that has been able to get a reaction out of Colin in a while. He needs her help to make sure that Colin will perform again, and tells her that she would be working for him, not Colin, and offers to pay her double the original offer. Something that Ariel can really make use of to return home and find her brother.

Ariel knows that Colin will not be happy about her accepting the job and being his assistant. But she what she does not expect is the attraction between them that no matter what will not be denied. Her body will do as he wants and he cannot keep his hands off her. But while things may seem great between them, when he has to practice with the other players, Penelope will start making trouble again and she will do whatever she can to get her hands on him this time.

I honestly could not put this book down until I finished it. Colin made me angry with his bursts of irrational jealousy and how he sometimes treated Ariel like she was at fault. But I loved that he knew that he made a mistake and he worked to get Ariel to forgive him. Ariel is sweet but not a doormat, and she made sure that Colin knew that whenever he treated her wrong.

Ariel’s Song by Evie Knight is a HOT and fast read that you will not want to miss. But make sure that you have a glass of cool water next to you, you may need it very often. ;) ...more

flag 1 like · Like · see review

Nov 09, 2013 Phuong rated it it was amazing

I was given an ARC of Ariel's Song written by Evie Knight for an honest review and I have to say I was pleasantly surprised how much I loved this story and couldn't stop reading it. You see, the hero is completely different than what I'm used to when reading my romance books that features a musician; I'm used to the typical sexy, alpha rockstar who drives the woman crazy with lust and not an angry, classical musician getting ready to perform at the Philharmonic. I'm thinking that the hero is goi ...more

flag 1 like · Like · see review

Nov 26, 2013 Leslie Ferdinand rated it really liked it

Shelves: rock-star-hero

Ariel’s Song by Evie Knight

Published: October 29, 2013, Evernight Publishing

Series: In Bed With the Enemy #1

Colin Hoskins is a famous violinist who plays everything from Mozart to Metallica. He’s brilliant and world-renowned until a tragedy forces him out of the spotlight. He wants to be left alone, vowing never to perform or fall in love again.

Ariel Parks needs a job, so she answers an ad to become Colin’s assistant. Stranded in Great Britain, she can’t find two farthings to rub together. ...more

flag 1 like · Like · see review

Oct 28, 2013 LJT rated it liked it

3.5 stars

I have read quite a few books over the past year about rockers, rock bands and their lifestyles. Ariel's Song by Evie Knight tweaks this genre a little bit with the tortured hero being a classical violinist who is able to rock with the best of them. Colin Hoskins is a master violinist and composer. He stopped performing and became a recluse when he was a suspect and blamed by the press for his fiance's death.

The heroine, Ariel Parks, is a bankrupt heiress. Her funds are frozen, her brot ...more

flag 1 like · Like · see review

Dec 28, 2013 Buffy Kennedy rated it it was ok

I have mixed feelings about this one. I like how it ended and that Ariel brought Colin out of his shell and all that, but the way it all went down and how it was written was off-putting. The way the two of them spoke to each other right from the start made it feel like I started part way through the book for starters.

Ariel and Colin each have a bit of depth as characters, but as a couple they fall kind of flat. There’s no substance or foundation to them other than mutual (though occasionally que ...more

flag 1 like · Like · see review

Aug 01, 2014 Victoria Rainey rated it really liked it

Shelves: romancing-the-book-reviews

Romancing The Book Review

Original Review Published here: http://romancing-the-book.com/2014/06...

Ariel’s Song is the first book In Bed with the Enemy series by Evie Knight. I chose this book because I have not read this author before and the story was different than I expected it to be based on the title.

Colin Hoskins is a rich and famous classical violinist. He battles his past and his angry with life. He is obsesses with how his fiancé died and wants to find out who killed her. Colin continual ...more

flag 1 like · Like · see review

Oct 31, 2013 Amy rated it really liked it

A little suspense, a lot smexy action!

ARIEL’S SONG by Evie Knight is a smexy, fast-paced romance that contains hints of domination and suspense, but revels in the world of music and romance. One moment, Colin is fiery, angry, annoying, and arrogant and the next he’s making magic with his violin and writing a song in Ariel’s honor. We experience Ariel’s strength in the face of constant adversity on the part of Colin not be willing to open himself up to anyone, especially Ariel and in turn, we de ...more

flag 1 like · Like · see review

Nov 15, 2014 Estella rated it really liked it

I was given this book for an honest review.
This book is about Colin Hoskins and Ariel Parks. Colin is a famous classical violinist who has let his past taint his life thoroughly. He is very angry at the hand that life has dealt him. His deceased fiance' betrayed him and he can't get past it. Do to the betrayal he has sworn off love and performing.

Ariel Parks is stranded in a foreign country. Ariel is a bankrupted heiress. Now she has to take a job in order to get back home. So she believes she h ...more

flag 1 like · Like · see review

Jan 30, 2015 Negar Arvanaghi rated it it was amazing

If she's broke, why would she go to England?

The story is a lot deeper than the usual talking-in-between-sex-scenes that seems to be prevalent in erotica.

Oh Colin, keeping news from someone never turns out good. Although, he does tell her before she can get mad about it.

He thinks everything can be solved with sex, doesn't he?

Ha, soap.

What's up with Julianne and Gerard?

Tanner, don't you know not to run from people trying to help you.

The proposal was beautiful. Who else had to stop and listen to "Y ...more

flag 1 like · Like · see review

Jan 29, 2015 Heather andrews rated it it was amazing

Colin is a man not to be reckoned with when that boy says jump who ask how high, "you're moving in tonight. This place isn't safe. Anybody can break in. Do you need help packing your bags?" He can be a jealous man when it comes to his Ariel, "what does Penelope have to do with us?" He took a step toward her. "When you go out with me, you're with me. You don't leave with another man. Understand?" He can be emotional which I loved most about him, "your place is with me," he said, kissing her nape. ...more

flag 1 like · Like · see review

Dec 06, 2013 Ava rated it really liked it

Shelves: fav-read-of-all-time, rom-psycho-thriller-susp-mystery

I really enjoyed this book. was it about a fantasy David Garett??
it was steamy, colin lust and lust and made decision based on his lust and love for her. hopefully she found and put a stop into that. a relationship couldn't solely based on make up amd decision that way.
So in the end, big turnaround! !!
somehow I couldn't understand the title. not ariel's song but about the "in bed with the ennemy". I still want to bear about jules and Gérard. ...more

flag 1 like · Like · see review

Nov 17, 2013 Karen rated it really liked it

A good, likable romance of an heiress who needs money, so she goes to work for surly musician Colin. He hasn't performed in public since the death of his wife a few years before under a dark cloud of suspicion. Colin is rich, talented, and arrogant. Sometimes you just want to shake him and tell him to wake up before he blows it. There are a lot of steamy love scenes too. I was pleasantly surprised at this story.

I received a copy of the arc for an honest review. ...more

flag 1 like · Like · see review

Jun 29, 2014 Kristyn Wilde rated it really liked it

Evie creates an erotic mix of sexual tension, friendship, jealousy and mystery. Being that I'm a music junkie myself, I thoroughly enjoyed this read. ...more

flag 1 like · Like · see review

Dec 30, 2013 Diana (Offbeat Vagabond) rated it really liked it

Shelves: arc, contemporary, erotic, romance

Original review here: http://offbeatvagabond.blogspot.com/2014/02/book-review-ariels-song-in-bed-with.html

Ariel's Song follows a woman named Ariel. She is a bit down on her luck. She is used to having a lot of money being an heiress and all. But she finds herself bankrupt since it seems her brother has cleaned them out. She desperately needs a job or she will be homeless is a country she doesn't know that well. She decides that she wants to be an assistant to one of her favorite musicians, Coli Original review here: http://offbeatvagabond.blogspot.com/2014/02/book-review-ariels-song-in-bed-with.html

Ariel's Song follows a woman named Ariel. She is a bit down on her luck. She is used to having a lot of money being an heiress and all. But she finds herself bankrupt since it seems her brother has cleaned them out. She desperately needs a job or she will be homeless is a country she doesn't know that well. She decides that she wants to be an assistant to one of her favorite musicians, Colin. It would be a dream job to work for her dream man. That dream is quickly crushed when Colin is not the man she thought he was. He is angry and wants nothing but to be left alone. He is reluctant about hiring an assistant, but he does because his friend knows he needs the motivation. They both start having feelings for each other that they don't know how to face.

Wow, now that was an intense read. I couldn't put this down for a second. I really liked Ariel. She used to be a very rich girl, but she finds out that her brother stole from her family. He is now missing and she is worried about him. She knows he is in trouble and she wants to understand why he did what he did to their family. Her finding an assisting job with her favorite musician is the greatest thing ever. Not only because she is a fan, but because this means she won't be homeless. But the musician Colin sure as hell won't make it easy. Colin starts off as a very bitter man. I didn't like him at first, but that quickly changes. He has been in the news and accused of killing the woman he loved a couple of years ago. He has lost the passion to create music and his friend and manager wants him to get him back on track. I did like that Colin and Ariel were very attracted to each other, but Colin needed to get past his demons first. I loved seeing his progression through the book and Ariel was a big part of that.

I loved Colin's friend and manager, Logan. He convinces Colin to hire Ariel and Logan also befriends Ariel. I loved how helpful he was for the both of them. I loved the chemistry between Ariel and Logan as well. Colin is starting to have feelings for her, but he is still quite bitter. His anger gets the best of him when it comes Logan and Ariel's friendship. His anger gets the best of him quite a bit in this book. But trust me, you will love him in this book.

Colin is apprehensive about Ariel working for him. He wants to be left alone and hates that she is around especially since he is starting to feel something for her. I loved seeing their relationship grow and how much he sees Ariel is helping him get back to the man he was. I couldn't put this book down. I loved every minute of it. I knew this would be focused on Colin and the death of his girlfriend. But I didn't expect so much mystery though. There is so much more going on behind Colin' back then he realizes. The villain was quite a surprise. I was strongly leaning on one person in particular, but it definitely switched on me. There is also the story of what is going on with Ariel's brother. I would have loved to have more on this in the book.

This is a fantastic read. I loved this book a lot. Not only are Colin and Ariel amazing, but there are side characters that are just as interesting one including Colin's sister, Julienne. I hope we get her story next. This book was short and super sexy. Knight really knows how to turn up the heat. The story was fun and engaging. The dialogue was great. I wish the book was longer so we could have gotten more. This is a great read that you will love. ...more

flag Like · see review

May 06, 2014 Adria's Musings rated it liked it

Shelves: read-and-reviewed

Originally posted on Adria's Romance Reviews
* I received a copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.

Author Evie Knight has managed to create a dark, sensual story among the world of classical music that brought to mind dramatic concerts, passionate nights and murder.

Classical violinist Colin Hoskins just wants to be left alone. After being the center of a criminal investigation, he’s retreated into a solitary life. Bitter and angry, he wants nothing to do with life and especially wants Originally posted on Adria's Romance Reviews
* I received a copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.

Author Evie Knight has managed to create a dark, sensual story among the world of classical music that brought to mind dramatic concerts, passionate nights and murder.

Classical violinist Colin Hoskins just wants to be left alone. After being the center of a criminal investigation, he’s retreated into a solitary life. Bitter and angry, he wants nothing to do with life and especially wants nothing to do with his new assistant.

Ariel Parks has no choice but to accept a job as Colin’s assistant. She has fantasized about this man for years but the reality of him is a harsh wake up call, one she’s not sure she wants to deal with. Unfortunately the attraction between the two of them is too powerful to ignore.

Ariel’s Song brought to mind images of Phantom of the Opera and Beauty and the Beast. It’s not a happy go lucky romance!

Colin is pretty damaged by his past and it has changed him into a rude, snarling, control freak. At first his personality left a lot to be desired. He’s such a cruel character at times, knowing when and how to verbally strike at a person to inflict the most damage. How this man still had loyal friends I didn’t know. Though since he’s also a musician, he can be forgiven for some of his moodiness. Colin grew on me after a few chapters and while I never fell head over heels in love with him like Ariel, I sympathized with him and came to understand how he could have become so bitter and mean so maybe that’s why his friends stuck around for him.

Ariel was the problem for me. I wanted to like her but I couldn’t get past tolerating her. Here she is, a penniless heiress, stranded far away from home who has to suddenly get a job for the first time in her pampered life. Fine, but she makes a reader believe that she can’t afford to lose the job she has as Colin’s assistant, yet she can’t be in the same room with him for one hour before she’s tossing her clothes off and letting him do whatever he wants to her. She’s desperately attracted to Colin, I get that, but is that more important than getting the money to go home and find out why she’s suddenly penniless? Ariel is weak when it comes to Colin’s sexual appeal, she’s ready to drop her clothes if he so much as smiles at her and he sometimes used that to manipulate her which I wasn’t too crazy about. Ariel should have been stronger than that.

Colin and Ariel seem to have a sex only relationship in the beginning, which is hot, I won’t deny that but I couldn’t see how a relationship was going to form between the two if all they did was argue and then have sex. It took awhile, but slowly those two began to actually communicate and learn more about each other than what they looked like naked. It was good to finally get to know more about them individually.

Another thing about Ariel’s Song that I enjoyed was how Colin’s “healing” didn’t happen overnight, nor did it seem to come easily to Ariel to “fix” him. It was a real rollercoaster ride, which is expected because we’re talking YEARS of Colin living the way he was. It would have been ridiculous for him to be miraculously cured just because Ariel appeared in his life or shared his bed a few times.

Final Verdict: After a few ups and downs, Ariel’s Song settled into a dark, hot ride that I enjoyed. I didn’t enjoy the heroine but the story was interesting, the sex scenes were hot and Colin’s best friend Logan is now on my radar. ...more

flag Like · see review

Oct 29, 2013 Lola rated it liked it

Shelves: books-that-i-own, e-books-on-kobo, got-a-copy-for-review-reviewed

I got a copy in exchange for an honest review

I read Ariel's Song in one day, it was a light read and I really enjoyed, but I also had some issues with it. Ariel's Song it a hot romance novel, there are quite some sex scenes and especially at first I felt the focus was a bit too much on lust instead of love, luckily that changed a bit as the story progressed. The beginning was a bit confusing for me as the book starts with a scene which I found difficult to make sense of because I didn't had any I got a copy in exchange for an honest review

I read Ariel's Song in one day, it was a light read and I really enjoyed, but I also had some issues with it. Ariel's Song it a hot romance novel, there are quite some sex scenes and especially at first I felt the focus was a bit too much on lust instead of love, luckily that changed a bit as the story progressed. The beginning was a bit confusing for me as the book starts with a scene which I found difficult to make sense of because I didn't had any background information yet. The story really focusses on the romance, there are some subplots as well, but they don't get as much attention as I would've liked.

Ariel's Song is an enjoyable book, but also quite predictable at times. there where some surprises, but not a lot. Overall it was still an enjoyable book, the pace was right and I breezed through it. I liked the romance between Ariel and Colin, while at first I thought their relationship started a bit too fast, I liked some of the things that happened later. They both make some mistakes too and there where times I wanted them to tell to just talk with each other, because they seemed to solve more problems with sex than words. And in some cases I think the words would work better.

While I liked the characters, I would've liked learning a bit more about them. As the focus is on the romance and their physical relationship I felt like I didn't really connect with the characters. Ariel had some issues and problems to deal with, but all her thoughts seem to be about Colin. The side characters where mostly to fill up the story, although there was hinted at some more story between Gérard and Jullianne and I am curious what was going on between them and if we might learn more about them in future books. Also there where some moments I really wanted to shake some sense in some characters. I really disliked Penelope, she was so annoying and too persistent in trying to win Collin over.

To conclude: I enjoyed Ariel's Song. It's a bit predictable and I wouldf've liked if there was a bit more focus on things beside the romance between Ariel and Colin. Also their relationship progresses a bit fast at first with more focus on lust than love, although that did change a bit later they still solved more problems with sex than words. Overall it was still an enjoyable read. ...more

flag Like · see review

Feb 24, 2015 Heidi rated it really liked it

I was gifted a copy of this book via netgalley in exchange for my honest thoughts and a review.

Evie Knight is a new author to me so i went in to this book with a clear and opened mind.

Colin Hoskins is a world famous classical violinist, but he is tainted by his past. Colin is very angry at life, And still unable to move beyond the betrayal he suffered from his dead fiancé, he is swearing off from ever performing or falling in love again. Know all he wants is to be left well alone, except no one ...more

flag Like · see review

Sep 01, 2015 Romancing the Book rated it really liked it

Shelves: contemporary, erotica, romantic-suspense

Reviewed by Victoria
Book provided by the publisher
Originally posted at Romancing the Book

Ariel’s Song is the first book In Bed with the Enemy series by Evie Knight. I chose this book because I have not read this author before and the story was different than I expected it to be based on the title.

Colin Hoskins is a rich and famous classical violinist. He battles his past and his angry with life. He is obsesses with how his fiancé died and wants to find out who killed her. Colin continually battl ...more

flag Like · see review

Apr 26, 2014 Alexa rated it really liked it

This is the debut novel by Evie Knight. The best thing about reviewing books is getting the chance to read books from new authors. And Evie Knight did not disappoint. There was a no nascence feel to the book. We learned about the characters as their relationship grew, which I liked. Within the very first chapter of the book the characters are meeting and the sparks are flying.

The story really sucks you in. You have so many things going on you can’t really decide where to put your brain. There is ...more

flag Like · see review

Mar 11, 2015 Mariel Hoss rated it it was ok

***ARC from NetGalley in Exchange for an honest review***

While the main characters were portrayed with that underlying complexity from a painful past/experiences, I didn't think it made them likable. The dialogue and physical interactions seemed very rough to me and gave me the uncomfortable feeling of looking at a very dysfunctional and borderline abusive relationship. Throw in a fatal attraction Glenn Close antagonist and it just kind of fell of the cliff for me and the HEA seemed contrived. S ...more

flag Like · see review

Feb 07, 2015 Ash P Reads rated it liked it

Recommended to Ash P by: NetGalley

I received a free copy in exchange for an honest review

A decent enough read, about overcoming heartbreaks and fears. The composition and organization of the timeline in the story though was a little jumpy and haphazard. I found myself going back to reread previous pages so I could catch up with what was happening.

flag Like · see review

Feb 10, 2015 Barone1997live.com rated it it was amazing

This was a roller coaster ride of sex, murder, and tragic background secrets between Colin and Ariel. Held my interest until the very end. I loved the glimpse into the future, and the happy ending.

flag Like · see review