Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read.

Start by marking “The Cunning Woman's Cup” as Want to Read:

Other editions

Enlarge cover

Rate this book

Clear rating

1 of 5 stars 2 of 5 stars 3 of 5 stars 4 of 5 stars 5 of 5 stars

Open Preview

The Cunning Woman's Cup

Sue Hewitt

4.48 · Rating details · 60 ratings · 16 reviews

When Alice McCleish's gardener Brian unearths an object of great archaeological significance deep under the compost heap it is not only Alice and her burgeoning friendship with Margaret Allerton, retired Professor of Anthropology, that are affected: the family, friends and neighbours of Alice, who people the narrative, are also touched by subsequent events. Alice and Marga ...more

Get A Copy

Or buy for $4.00

Paperback, 480 pages

Published March 7th 2014 by Createspace Independent Publishing Platform

More Details... Edit Details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Reader Q&A

To ask other readers questions about The Cunning Woman's Cup, please sign up.

Be the first to ask a question about The Cunning Woman's Cup

Lists with This Book

This book is not yet featured on Listopia. Add this book to your favorite list »

Community Reviews

Showing 1-30

Average rating 4.48 ·

Rating details

· 60 ratings · 16 reviews

More filters

Sort order

Start your review of The Cunning Woman's Cup

Sep 02, 2015 Cathy Ryan rated it it was amazing

Shelves: contemporary-fiction

The book opens with a haunting flashback to a period in pre Romanic Britain where we meet Mordwand of the Brigantes (the cunning woman), who survived being aborted and was raised by a wolfhound. After the hound died Mordwand became ‘the eyes and ears’ of the healer who aborted her, and learned what she could from the old woman until old age took her as well, and Mordwand found herself alone once more. Short, intriguing and sometimes distressing passages from her life begin each chapter and I lov The book opens with a haunting flashback to a period in pre Romanic Britain where we meet Mordwand of the Brigantes (the cunning woman), who survived being aborted and was raised by a wolfhound. After the hound died Mordwand became ‘the eyes and ears’ of the healer who aborted her, and learned what she could from the old woman until old age took her as well, and Mordwand found herself alone once more. Short, intriguing and sometimes distressing passages from her life begin each chapter and I love how these chart the significance of certain items, as well as the history of the stones.

Alice McCleish’s cottage stands by the stone circle near the village of Duddo in Northumberland, where she’s lived alone but for her dog, Nipper, since her husband, Callum, passed on. While out with Nipper one day Alice meets retired Professor Margaret Allerton, who is on a walking holiday. The two ladies form an instant bond, even though to all outward appearances they have little in common and lead completely different lives. Nevertheless their meeting is the start of a lasting and close friendship, which is demonstrated in part by the exchange of lovely letters between the two of them.

Alice is a mainstay in the close community of Duddo, and has lived in her cottage for more than forty years, she and Callum having bought it from Callum’s boss, farmer Wyllie Turnbull. Wyllie and his wife, Violet, are both suffering in their different ways from the pain and sorrow of a past tragedy.

The mystical standing stone circle is a catalyst in the story, events and tragedies over the years playing out from echoes of the distant past. The arrival of Avian Taylor, a psychic and healer who can sometimes hear those echoes, helps where she can and in doing so raises questions of long-held beliefs in some of the residents of Duddo. At the same time Avian opens up new avenues of acceptance. An ancient artifact (the cup of the title) is unearthed by Alice’s gardener, Brian, and brings more characters into play in the form of an archaeological dig. There are several connecting storylines, which could have been overwhelming, but each is built expertly into the narrative creating a multi layered and exceptionally skilful debut novel which flows smoothly and fluently

Sue Hewitt also very cleverly weaves issues into the story which relate to the present day. Most notably with Alice’s son, Michael and his wife, Penny, revealing how people can be drawn into living to work, rather than the reverse, without realising the rewards are sometimes empty and meaningless, the old values, community and neighbours who care, not as outdated as they might once have seemed. The nature and persona of the characters is explored and developed through easy, believable dialogue and their reactions to the world around them. Struggles with grief, loss and the differing systems of belief, all round out and individualise each person. The setting is fabulous and described so vividly. The cover, which I absolutely love, evokes the atmosphere of the book. I’m fascinated by stone circles and have seen a few but not the Duddo stones, so perhaps a trip to Northumberland is in my future. ...more

flag 4 likes · Like · see review

Jun 01, 2015 E.L. Lindley rated it it was amazing

The Cunning Woman’s Cup is such a rich and layered read, I hardly know where to start. In any other hands, the complex structure and stories within stories might have lacked cohesion but Sue Hewitt asserts herself from the onset as a writer who is in complete control of her craft. I was in her thrall from the very first page.

The story, on the surface, is a simple one – the tale of two elderly women, Alice and Margaret, who meet by chance and forge an enduring friendship. The story ripples out f The Cunning Woman’s Cup is such a rich and layered read, I hardly know where to start. In any other hands, the complex structure and stories within stories might have lacked cohesion but Sue Hewitt asserts herself from the onset as a writer who is in complete control of her craft. I was in her thrall from the very first page.

The story, on the surface, is a simple one – the tale of two elderly women, Alice and Margaret, who meet by chance and forge an enduring friendship. The story ripples out from the two women, however, and incorporates other stories of people whose lives interconnect with theirs. The story is set mainly in the village of Duddo in Northumberland, where a stone circle overlooks the village, lending a mysterious and spiritual atmosphere. The ‘cup’ of the title is unearthed which leads to the past impinging on the present and setting in motion dramatic changes.

Alice and Margaret are polar opposites. Alice has been widowed after a long and happy marriage and has spent her life caring for others. She is a traditional woman and fears ideas that challenge her Christian way of life. Margaret, by contrast, is an independent, spiky retired professor, who never married, choosing instead to travel extensively. One of the most enjoyable and life affirming aspects of the novel is the fact that Alice is in her late 60s and Margaret in her 80s but they still live full and exciting lives. There is not even a whiff of a stereotypical elderly person in this book, Hewitt’s senior citizens are all full of passion and zest for life.

The novel concerns itself with both spiritual and everyday issues. Alice’s traditional views are shaken by the arrival in the village of Avian, a psychic healer. Many people in Duddo, including Alice’s late husband hold pagan beliefs, celebrating the land and nature as represented by the stone circle. I found Hewitt’s exploration of grief and the afterlife to be particularly poignant.

At the same time, Hewitt highlights many modern dilemmas, not least the way in which elderly people can often be ignored and lonely. She also depicts the differences between rural and city life and how seeming success can bring hollow rewards as people try to buy happiness. We also see how young people can become lost without guidance and purpose. Hewitt touches on several very relevant social issues in a way that is both realistic and moving.

The structure of the novel is very interesting and clearly demonstrates Hewitt’s skill as a writer. Each chapter begins with a first person account from Mordwand, an ancient Celt who is the ‘Cunning Woman’ of the title. She survives being aborted and abandoned before being taken in by the old medicine woman who performed the abortion. Ironically, she then takes over from the woman as an abortionist and healer. Mordwand’s angry spirit lives on amongst the stones with terrible consequences for one family in particular. After the short account from Mordwand, Hewitt switches to 3rd person narrative, which allows her to develop all of the characters in her novel equally. In addition to this, some of the story is also told via letters sent between Alice and Margaret.

I loved this novel and found myself totally immersed in the life of Duddo, so much so I felt almost bereft when I finished it. It is a warm, deceptively cosy read which snakes its way into the reader’s heart, raising some provocative philosophical questions.

...more

flag 3 likes · Like · see review

Jan 15, 2015 Ken rated it it was amazing

Shelves: e-books

4.5 stars

I’m not part of the target demographic for this book, due to my Y chromosome, but I enjoyed it immensely. Hewitt does a great job detailing the setting—the small, rural town of Duddo near the Scottish border in Northumberland. You can feel the chill of a foggy morning in your bones and the mud squelching under your boots after a long rain. The bonds of friendship between two women, as well as the site of their chance meeting, near an ancient stone circle, form the primary threads for th ...more

flag 3 likes · Like · see review

Mar 28, 2017 Jill's Book Cafe rated it it was amazing

Shelves: authors-personal-reviews, fiction

4.5 stars

I seem to be increasingly drawn lately to books with older characters and this book was no exception, however dealing as it does with families, friendships and relationships it also has a much wider appeal than it might initially appear.

The main character is Alice, and the book traces the development of her friendship with Margaret, her fraught relationship with her daughter in law, her evolving relationship with her grandchildren and her involvement with her neighbour Violet and garde 4.5 stars

I seem to be increasingly drawn lately to books with older characters and this book was no exception, however dealing as it does with families, friendships and relationships it also has a much wider appeal than it might initially appear.

The main character is Alice, and the book traces the development of her friendship with Margaret, her fraught relationship with her daughter in law, her evolving relationship with her grandchildren and her involvement with her neighbour Violet and gardener Brian. Not forgetting Nipper the terrier, who is as much a character as any of his human companions.

Life for widowed Alice starts to change after her chance meeting with Margaret as she discovers a new friend and more importantly a confidant, something she lost with the death of her husband Callum. It also seems to spark a renewed interest in her surroundings and leads her to take on a gardener to oversee her garden, something that had been largely Callum's domain. This not only introduces Brian and his family to the story but more importantly leads to the discovery of the 'Cunning Woman's Cup'. A discovery that will impact on all their lives in ways they could never have imagined.

Intertwined with this story is the story of the eponymous Cunning Woman who was actually called Mordwand and member of the Brigantes. These were a Celtic tribe in pre-Roman Britain who settled in an area largely covering Northern England, but especially Northumberland, Durham and Yorkshire. A 'Cunning Woman' was a practitioner of folk medicine, a healer and wise woman. As her story unfolds it becomes more pertinent to the present day story as it not only explains where the cup came from, but also provides a link from the past to the present. It serves to highlight that the powers of healing and 'seeing' are not just restricted to the past.

Initially I will admit I found the Mortwand element an intrusion that took away from the contemporary story, however as its relevance became more apparent and her story also took on a different mood, it became far more compelling. However, as the two strands are clearly defined it is possible to choose to omit this element, though I'd recommend you stick with it.

I loved this story, it was very much character driven and given the wide cast of characters it was also very well-balanced and exceedingly well done. We get to see the problems faced by Alice's family and how they resolve them. We discover the tragedy that has afflicted her neighbour Violet and we learn a lot about Margaret and her life. Everyone that is introduced plays a part and we are not left with without answers or resolutions. It is a story of everyday folk, going about their normal lives and coping the best they can. As well as being very character driven, the setting was also very much a living part of the story. The village with its church, its customs, the way of life, the scenery, the people and the everyday activities of farming and baking made it feel very much a real, warm and supportive community to be a part of.

What I really enjoyed about this book is the way in introduced and dealt both universal and contemporary topics in a quiet understated way, which possibly had more of an impact precisely because of that. It introduced the age-old themes of belief and spirituality and made you think about the nature of religion and how we 'fit' with our surroundings. It introduced the very modern 'God' of materialism and how we lose sight of what really matters in the pursuit of the temporal. It looks at grief and death and how we cope with loss. There was a strong natural spiritual element running throughout the book which also had a hint of the magical. I'll be honest and say this would not normally appeal to me, but the context and background made it less paranormal and more mystical and acceptable. There was a sense that we've lost the ability to understand and appreciate the old folk customs and belief systems strongly allied to the natural world in the face of both organised religion and a modern and scientific approach to life. It certainly made me think.

While the above makes this book sound very deep, it is in fact written in a very warm and almost chatty way. The characters that inhabit the pages are very realistic and by turns funny, sad, annoying and very normal. It is testament to the author's skill that she has written on the face of a gentle yet contemporary novel that manages to encompass so many themes and emotive issues without being preachy or evangelical. It's only when you sit back and think about the story that you start to think about its themes.

This is a heartwarming story, that stays with you after you've finished reading and I have deliberately left out much of the plotline so you can discover all the characters and their stories for yourself. I can only recommend that you join Alice, her family and friends for a spellbinding read. ...more

flag 2 likes · Like · see review

Sep 25, 2018 Michael Tweed rated it it was amazing

A gem of a book. Loved it.

flag 2 likes · Like · see review

Jul 31, 2014 Iona Carroll rated it it was amazing

If any reader has visited the ancient standing stones of Duddo in Northumberland, they will quickly identify with this interesting debut novel by Sue Hewitt. There is a believable mix of characters, an unfolding mystery and local rural interest. All these elements provide intrigue from the first page. Sue Hewitt’s clever approach to her novel preludes each chapter with excellent descriptive prose reaching back in time to the stones –
I was Mordwand of the Brigantes. Called Dead and cast out when If any reader has visited the ancient standing stones of Duddo in Northumberland, they will quickly identify with this interesting debut novel by Sue Hewitt. There is a believable mix of characters, an unfolding mystery and local rural interest. All these elements provide intrigue from the first page. Sue Hewitt’s clever approach to her novel preludes each chapter with excellent descriptive prose reaching back in time to the stones –
I was Mordwand of the Brigantes. Called Dead and cast out when I was alive. People feared me. It was late in the pregnancy of the woman who bore me – too late, the old woman said. The old woman took payment, laid her down, placed the heavy flat stone on her rounded belly, added more weight – it is but one of the ways. She died, but I survived – small, bloody, blue and broken. The old woman cringed back when I drew breath and I cried into the cold air. She left me, she said, to die. But I would not.
The pace then alters as the story begins. Alice McCleish, a widow living near the stones meets and becomes friends with Margaret Allerton, a retired Professor of Archaeology from Durham. Thereafter, discoveries are uncovered from ancient times when Brian, Alice’s gardener uncovers a cup in the compost heap. This proves to be of great archaeological significance. Throughout the novel the voice from a long time ago hints that there is much to learn about the material and the spiritual world. A delightful mix of the mundane make for identifiable reading – the agricultural year, the seasons, love of nature, gardening, baking and preserving, local place names. The characters are contemporary and brought to life by believable and seemingly effortless dialogue.
All the while the spirit world runs like a golden thread throughout the story. The arrival of the mystic Avian Taylor, with her powers of healing and her knowledge of herbs and potions, offers a release from the problems that beset the characters. Sue Hewitt uses Avian to question traditional held Christian beliefs and contemplate the unseen world that the stones inhabit.
The author is clearly biased in favour of the rural life and Alice’s son and daughter-in-law, modern city dwellers who are caught up in the London rat race, are contrasted with the more preferable country existence. The tension throughout builds as secrets, both ancient and modern are linked and finally revealed.
I enjoyed this unusual novel and it proved to me, once again, that modern fiction doesn’t have to have dysfunctional angst-ridden heroes and unlikely plots to make a good story. Sometimes the ordinary can become an extraordinarily good read and if this is combined with descriptive and well written prose, the results speak for themselves. There is something reassuring in being able to identify with everyman and woman.
I look forward to reading a sequel – what else can be uncovered hidden deep in the compost heap?

...more

flag 2 likes · Like · see review

Jun 17, 2015 Rosie Amber rated it it was amazing

The Cunning Woman's Cup is a contemporary piece of fiction woven around ancient standing stones and family dramas. It is set in Duddo, Northumberland near the Scottish border.

There is an ancient stone circle at Duddo made of 5 megaliths. We are introduced to Mordwand of the Brigantes a healing woman burned at the stake. Her story threads throughout the book in a series of small flashbacks.

Alice McCleish lives with Nipper, her dog, close to the standing stones. The small community is close and su The Cunning Woman's Cup is a contemporary piece of fiction woven around ancient standing stones and family dramas. It is set in Duddo, Northumberland near the Scottish border.

There is an ancient stone circle at Duddo made of 5 megaliths. We are introduced to Mordwand of the Brigantes a healing woman burned at the stake. Her story threads throughout the book in a series of small flashbacks.

Alice McCleish lives with Nipper, her dog, close to the standing stones. The small community is close and supportive of each other and Alice is one of the backbones of village life. She meets Margaret Allerton whilst out walking and they begin a friendship which will give them both a new lease of life.

I loved the way the author built this story introducing new layers and new characters once I'd got a good picture and feel for the place. Alice employs Brian Rigden to help restore her garden to the splendour it once was when her husband Callum was alive. Callum was a man at one with the land and the spirits which watched over them, while Alice was a true believer in God and his church. They agreed to disagree on spiritual matters.

It's Brian who discovers an ancient cup whilst digging in the garden and the rare find warrants a full archaeological dig. The cup's discovery starts off a whole series of changing events, Violet Turnbull has not left the house for nearly 30 years. An Agrophobic until she talks to Maisie one of the young students from the dig. With help from Maisie's Aunt, Violet takes her own destiny onto her hands.

There's so much more I'd love to tell you about the book, but I'd give too much away. I thought it was an inspiring read, I was off baking my own bread and yearning to make some lemon curd, but more importantly I was researching more about Duddo stones and I'd never thought much about the new business which takes over Henge Farm, but now I'm mulling it over as a sensible option to our human needs.

This book left me with questions, got me thinking, sent shivers down my spine, had me laughing and crying and although I knew it must end, I really didn't want it to, I'd found a new friend, now I'm just off for a spiritual walk to the stones and then I'll settle down for coffee cake and tea with Alice and Nipper. ...more

flag 2 likes · Like · see review

Aug 10, 2016 Whispering Stories rated it really liked it

Alice McCleish has lived in the Northumberland countryside all of her live. She lives in Duddo, a small remote village with her house overlooking an ancient stone circle. Now alone, after the death of her beloved husband Callum, Alice only has her dog Nipper, the Border Terrier, for company.

It is whilst out walking Nipper that Alice crosses paths with retired professor Margaret Allerton. Margaret is trying to locate the nearest village for a cup of tea, but with the nearest place being miles awa Alice McCleish has lived in the Northumberland countryside all of her live. She lives in Duddo, a small remote village with her house overlooking an ancient stone circle. Now alone, after the death of her beloved husband Callum, Alice only has her dog Nipper, the Border Terrier, for company.

It is whilst out walking Nipper that Alice crosses paths with retired professor Margaret Allerton. Margaret is trying to locate the nearest village for a cup of tea, but with the nearest place being miles away, Alice offers Margaret a cup of tea at her house. The two women end up becoming firm friends after their chance meeting.

Alice’s gardener, Brian, comes across and ancient cup, whilst digging in her garden. The cup turns out to be very old and very valuable. The discovery leads to a full archaeological dig of the site.

What is unearthed causes the lives of the villagers to change, and for Alice and Margaret to question their beliefs.

The Cunning Woman’s cup, is quite an unusual book. It ties in ancient pre-roman times via flashbacks, with modern day events. It’s during these flashbacks that we find out about ‘Mordwand of the Brigantes’, who was burned at the stake, for she was deemed to be a witch. Her story interweaves with the modern day main plot.

I found it lovely to be able to research about Duddo and the standing stones, as both really do exist. The stones are dated to be from the bronze age. There used to be seven of them, but two were taken many, many years ago.

This isn’t an action, thriller, suspense-filled book. This is a wonderful heart-felt story about the lives of the villagers, especially Alice and Margaret. There are a lot of characters, all of whom are lovely and welcoming, and will go out of their way to help one another. There were no good-guy/bad-guy moments, it is just a contemporary read.

The one thing the book will do though is hold you in the village, have you experiencing the smells, sounds, scenery and beautiful food.

A sweet, yet powerful book that will really hit you, and have you wishing that the story never ends.

Reviewed by Stacey at www.whisperingstories.com ...more

flag 2 likes · Like · see review

Dec 13, 2015 Babus Ahmed rated it really liked it

This contemporary fiction delves into history to tell us about an ancient cunning woman and her plight at the times of the Romans. Her story is progressed at the start of each chapter telling us about Alice and her family. Alice has lived in rural Northumberland all her life and the object linking the past and present in this novel is a cup that is unearthed in her garden by her gardener, Brian. The countryside plays a prominent and positive role throughout this mystery and family drama.

I found ...more

flag 2 likes · Like · see review

Mar 26, 2019 Tara rated it really liked it

This was such a touching story. I loved the perspective of all the older women and how they interact. I did think it would have more about the ancient cunning woman than it did. It was only one small paragraph at the beginning of each chapter. I also don't like that very British habit of pairing everyone off at the end of a book. The other very British habit of not being able to recall anything pre Romans..... But other than those two minor flaws that no one else but myself would even care about ...more

flag 1 like · Like · see review

Dec 09, 2017 Gretchen rated it it was amazing

Really enjoyed this book which I swapped at a hostel in Ecuador. Rich relationships develop. Great setting in Scotland around ancient stones. Would read anything this author wrote though it’s not my typical genre.

flag 1 like · Like · see review

Sep 15, 2018 Clemency rated it it was amazing

Amazon tells me that I downloaded this Kindle Unlimited book on the 7th March this year. I started reading the book on the 1st September. This happens frequently!

For whatever reason, I left it half a year before I read this book. Of course, most people wouldn't remember the blurb so I had no idea what the book was about and I fumbled my way through the early pages, wondering what the plot was. If I had remembered the blurb, I would have known where the story was leading.

But the blurb wouldn't re ...more

flag 1 like · Like · see review

Aug 09, 2015 Elizabeth Lloyd rated it it was amazing

In The Cunning Woman's Cup, echoes from long ago reverberate in the lives of a small community in Northumberland. The tragic life of Mordwand of the Brigantes is briefly told in episodes at the beginning of each chapter. Events from her life impinge into the modern day lives of the other characters in the narrative and help to clarify the spiritual dimension which they experience.

Alice McCleish is a widow, sharing her cottage with her dog Nipper near to the farm of Wyllie and Violet Turnbull, wh In The Cunning Woman's Cup, echoes from long ago reverberate in the lives of a small community in Northumberland. The tragic life of Mordwand of the Brigantes is briefly told in episodes at the beginning of each chapter. Events from her life impinge into the modern day lives of the other characters in the narrative and help to clarify the spiritual dimension which they experience.

Alice McCleish is a widow, sharing her cottage with her dog Nipper near to the farm of Wyllie and Violet Turnbull, who sadly lost their sons many years before. Alice's perspective on life is expanded when she makes friends with Margaret Allerton, a professor of anthropology, who is walking in the area. In turn, through meeting Alice, Margaret discovers an empathy for others which she was unaware of in the past.

As the story evolves we meet Alice's son, Michael, a successful but dissatisfied accountant and his irritating wife Penny. We encounter their clever daughter Marsha and practical son Dexter and soon the whole family make life-changing decisions.

All these events are triggered by a discovery in Alice's garden which brings a group of archaeologists to the area, challenging Alice and others in the village to reappraise their beliefs. A new character, Avian Tyler, comes into their lives. She is attuned to the undercurrents engendered from the stone circle which dominates the skyline on Wyllie’s farm and she senses the pain and suffering hidden in the people she meets.

The dominantly female cast of characters in the novel undergo changes in their attitudes and lifestyle. For most, this is life-enhancing but there is also suffering. This book shows the love of a family and fellowship of friendship in a mystical setting but it also expresses the trials of modern life and the need for adaptation to the rhythms of our environment.

I found myself reading the book slowly so as to get to know the characters properly. With this knowledge the storyline is very rewarding even though Mordwand’s tale is distressing and I wasn’t able to fathom Avian properly. It makes a refreshing read in our hectic modern world.
...more

flag 1 like · Like · see review

Apr 21, 2015 Rhoda D'Ettore rated it liked it

Rhoda D'Ettore Reviews: I was given this book in exchange for a fair and honest review

This is an interesting tale of a valuable discovery in a woman's garden, the interactions of neighbors, and a tale of the past that eventually becomes woven into the present.

The characters are fleshed out well, with lines such as "Hand me my teeth". In one scene, a strange woman walks by a rural area and the characters ponder if she's a salesperson or a Jehovah's Witness. Some of the dialogue in this scene made ...more

flag 1 like · Like · see review

Jun 10, 2015 Matthew Harffy rated it it was amazing

I bought 'The Cunning Woman's Cup' some time ago when I realised it was set on the border of Scotland, in the tiny village of Duddo in Northumberland. The standing stones on the cover are ancient and are mentioned briefly in my own writing about the area, and I used to live near there too, so I was intrigued by the setting.

At first I thought the novel would be historical fiction about a cunning woman (or witch) from long ago, and there are elements of this in the book. But the main story is set ...more

flag 2 likes · Like · see review

May 20, 2015 Joyce Barrass rated it it was amazing · review of another edition

Shelves: contemporary-fiction

Wonderfully written, tenderly observed. Absolutely loved this story from the first page to the last! Every character is deftly and subtly drawn and the descriptions of the stunning Northumbrian landscape, flora, wildlife, history and atmosphere haunt the imagination. Liminal spaces and "thin places" are brought to life with an exquisitely sensitive touch. Equally engaging is the author's ear for the mundane comical cut and thrust of everyday dialogue: "please stop fussing and pass me my teeth,’ ...more

flag 1 like · Like · see review