‘Soon, we will have the serious immigration law I promised during my campaign.’
Michael DiGrasso, the newly elected California governor, pursues the passage of an immigration law aimed at preventing ‘illegals’ from entering the state, finding those already in California and returning them to their countries of origin. The law is passed, and is declared unconstitutional by the Supreme Court, but Governor DiGrasso refuses to accept the ruling.
‘I will not obey the Supreme Court ruling regarding this state’s immigration law, because it has no right to adjudicate on legislative matters.’
There is a strong possibility that the resultant clash between federal, state and judicial powers will impact on the country’s justice and political systems. Just what is the proper role of the federal courts? And how will President Martin Ballard, a long-time friend of Michael DiGrasso, respond?
Elizabeth Stern, one of the opposition members, proposes a new immigration law that will pass judicial review. She wants Governor DiGrasso to obey the Supreme Court’s decision, and isn’t above a little blackmail to achieve her objective.
‘Defying a Supreme Court decision reflects badly on our entire legislature, our entire state.’
As the politics plays out, there are others in the community – including two Mexican families - directly affected by the changes proposed. There is also a group of radical political activists keen to undermine Governor DiGrasso and comfortable using violence to do so. Where, and how, will it end?
‘Sometimes you can’t compromise, sir.’
While on one level, the novel is about abstract concepts and impersonal collective decisions, it’s the impact of those concepts and decisions on individuals and families that brings the novel to life. For those people, it is probably irrelevant whether the relevant law is federal or state. Mostly I enjoyed this novel for its depiction of quite complex and seemingly intractable issues. At times I felt that a slower development of some of the various storylines would have better served the story, and that sometimes character development was sacrificed to action.
Globally, immigration (whether legal or not) is a particularly topical issue at present. Balancing the needs of people and meeting the requirements of the rule of law is challenging, and can be heartbreaking.
Note: I was offered and accepted a copy of this novel for review purposes.
Jennifer Cameron-Smith