This book was weird. It falls into the strange trend of works (circa 2000s) that exist as solely an homage to popular anime instead of being good on its own merits. (I'm not bashing Amerimanga here btw, there are some manga that are excellent by Western authors, but they actually try to create a fully fleshed out story of their own. This one doesn't.)
They also went wayyyy too broad with the homage as it was not only an homage to just shonen in general but the whole world hopping plot device is just a thin excuse for the authors to just write a bunch of loosely connected stories from different genres. Dystopian? Check. Mecha? Check. And vol 3 is going to be about Frankenstein. yayy.
It's kind of like they took only the few elements that didn't work for me in Spirit Circle and used generic characters you would find in an Isekai series.
I was on board with this series for the first third of the book. The pacing was good. The characters seemed to have potential. But the moment when Alvin explained his backstory with heavy and unnatural exposition I knew we were in for trouble. And when the action happened, everything was rushed and NOTHING was explained.
One thing I did like about the series was the art style. It was crisp, kind of generic anime style, but it really worked. The artist was fantastic in drawing lineart and crisp body shots- nothing looked wobbly or rushed, everything looked extremely professional, better than some real shonen I've read. I also think that the character designs for Colleen and Hiro were well thought out. Especially Colleen, they really hit a jackpot with her character design imo.
I was also impressed with some of the bolder decisions the books chose. I was NOT expecting there to be any death so I was shocked. It was a great decision as it took the tone away (for a second at least) from being super generic. However, THE boldest, most daring decision was later retconned, which really irritated me. If you're going to go for it, go for it. Don't tease your readers. If we've accepted that something happened, don't take it away.
Overall score:
+1 star for great art, great character design for some characters (not Alvin tho), great paneling
+1 star for showcasing different personalities in the characters and having consistency, dialogue that was just okay but didn't suck at least, a great first third of the book, occasional bold plot decisions
0 stars for literally a billion cliches, having backstories for Hiro and Alvin that were so generic they made me roll my eyes, Tom and Drake were very one-dimensional and it seemed unnecessary to have the two of them
0 stars for generic series setup, no explanation for technology, setup, or some events, and the plot was just an excuse for the writers to write what whatever they wanted to
0 stars for pretending like the characters have deep bonds even though they met THE DAY OF the action, tacked-on crushes or thin romance, and fast pacing with no breaks for character exploration
= 2/5 stars