What do you think?
Rate this book
The Five Gold Bands
Libro usado en buenas condiciones, por su antiguedad podria contener señales normales de uso
144 pages, Paperback
First published January 1, 1950
6 people are currently reading
164 people want to read
About the author
Jack Vance
777 books1,591 followersAka John Holbrook Vance, Peter Held, John Holbrook, Ellery Queen, John van See, Alan Wade.
The author was born in 1916 and educated at the University of California, first as a mining engineer, then majoring in physics and finally in journalism. During the 1940s and 1950s, he contributed widely to science fiction and fantasy magazines. His first novel, The Dying Earth , was published in 1950 to great acclaim. He won both of science fiction's most coveted trophies, the Hugo and Nebula awards. He also won an Edgar Award for his mystery novel The Man in the Cage . He lived in Oakland, California in a house he designed.
The author was born in 1916 and educated at the University of California, first as a mining engineer, then majoring in physics and finally in journalism. During the 1940s and 1950s, he contributed widely to science fiction and fantasy magazines. His first novel, The Dying Earth , was published in 1950 to great acclaim. He won both of science fiction's most coveted trophies, the Hugo and Nebula awards. He also won an Edgar Award for his mystery novel The Man in the Cage . He lived in Oakland, California in a house he designed.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 46 reviews
July 25, 2021
Vance's first novel, TFGB was first serialized in the 40s and published as a book in 1950. Pretty typical pulp space opera, meaning Vance employed the going tropes of the day. While it has an interesting premise, the two lead characters (and their cheesy romance) really drag the story down. Further, although there are some tantalizing hints of what would make Vance so excellent, such as his innovative world building and socioeconomic analyses, these serve primarily as window dressing here.
Paddy Blackthorn, our main protagonist, is stereotypically Irish, complete with accent and all (never mind that the time frame is several centuries from now). Humans have settled the universe to a degree, thanks to finally finding a FTL drive. The inventor the drive gave each of his five sons pieces of the engineering aspects of the drive and they still have monopoly control over space drives. Whether it is due to genetic tinkering, or human adaptability, the human race has radically diverged from the native stock. Each of the five sons settled a different planet and as a result, they can scarcely be called human anymore (although they still can breed with other 'races').
Paddy, charged with death for a crime in the opening pages (trying to steal a space drive) gets 'employed' to be a translator for the annual meeting of the decedents of the five sons due to his linguistic skills (and that they have to kill the translator after the even to keep meeting's secrets). Miraculously, Paddy survives the meeting and kills all five decedents and takes their 'gold bands' (hence the title) and escapes. Within the bands Paddy hopes to find the secrets of the FTL drive, but what he finds instead are a series of clues that hopefully lead to the actual secrets. Paddy teams up with Fay, an Earth secret agent, on an outlaw world and the quest begins...
So, on the one hand, TFGB is 'classic' quest novel set in space featuring a slick con-man and a top spy from Earth, intending to find the secrets of the drive and give them to Earth (now largely a backwater). On the other hand, this is a cheesy romance novel between Paddy and Fay. Lots of stereotypes involved to be sure and the sensibilities of the 40s make them selves felt to a crushing degree.
I might recommend this to die-hard Vance fans and those who want to complete his opus, but definitely not a good place to start on Vance. It is pretty amazing to read this after other excellent stories Vance told in his later career-- he sure came a long way! 2 meh stars.
Paddy Blackthorn, our main protagonist, is stereotypically Irish, complete with accent and all (never mind that the time frame is several centuries from now). Humans have settled the universe to a degree, thanks to finally finding a FTL drive. The inventor the drive gave each of his five sons pieces of the engineering aspects of the drive and they still have monopoly control over space drives. Whether it is due to genetic tinkering, or human adaptability, the human race has radically diverged from the native stock. Each of the five sons settled a different planet and as a result, they can scarcely be called human anymore (although they still can breed with other 'races').
Paddy, charged with death for a crime in the opening pages (trying to steal a space drive) gets 'employed' to be a translator for the annual meeting of the decedents of the five sons due to his linguistic skills (and that they have to kill the translator after the even to keep meeting's secrets). Miraculously, Paddy survives the meeting and kills all five decedents and takes their 'gold bands' (hence the title) and escapes. Within the bands Paddy hopes to find the secrets of the FTL drive, but what he finds instead are a series of clues that hopefully lead to the actual secrets. Paddy teams up with Fay, an Earth secret agent, on an outlaw world and the quest begins...
So, on the one hand, TFGB is 'classic' quest novel set in space featuring a slick con-man and a top spy from Earth, intending to find the secrets of the drive and give them to Earth (now largely a backwater). On the other hand, this is a cheesy romance novel between Paddy and Fay. Lots of stereotypes involved to be sure and the sensibilities of the 40s make them selves felt to a crushing degree.
I might recommend this to die-hard Vance fans and those who want to complete his opus, but definitely not a good place to start on Vance. It is pretty amazing to read this after other excellent stories Vance told in his later career-- he sure came a long way! 2 meh stars.
May 28, 2024
This 138 page novel was written in 1949 and first published under the title "The Five Gold Bands" in 1950 in Startling Stories magazine. In 1953 it was reissued with the title "The Space Pirates" and in 2002 it was published under the title "Rapparee." Vance himself preferred the Rapparee title. A rapparee was an Irish gorilla fighter from the 1690s, and our main character once refers to himself as being one.
For the most recent review and other Vance reviews please see:
https://vancealotjackvanceinreview.bl...
Our main character is the Earther, Paddy Blackthorn, who has gone to the planet Akhabats where valuable space-drives are assembled. Paddy is apprehended by Kudthu guards while he is trying to steal some of the rare and costly space-drives. The penalty for this is mandatory death. But when the "Koton Councillor" learns that Paddy is a master of numerous languages, he decides to delay the execution and use Paddy as a translator at an upcoming annual council meeting of the Five Sons of Langtry.
As the novel progresses we learn the interesting background story. Many years ago a man named Samuel Langtry from Earth invented the "space-drive" that allows ships to travel at great speeds through space. Instead of turning the secret plans for creating space-drives over to the government or others on Earth, he distributed the information among his five sons. These sons left Earth and settled on five different planets. The descendent heirs of the original Five Sons of Langtry, now twenty generations later, continue to be the only ones who can produce space-drives. Each of the descendent heirs rules his own planet and has part of the instructions for building this drive. Together they have a monopoly on manufacturing space-drives which are essential to trade and commerce. These drives are strictly rationed to Earth inhabitants who do not know how to build them. People from Earth are also considered inferior by the residents of the five planets and are not even allowed to use the same hotels when visiting.
The gravity, atmosphere, food and other factors on each planet have lead to adaptations so that the humans on each of the five planets act, think and look dissimilar to Earthers and each other, often strikingly so even though they all are still human and could even interbreed. Some planetary inhabitants are short, squat and very muscular from the greater gravity on their planet. On another planet the humans look like 8 foot tall eagles. These physical and mental changes appear to have happened over twenty generations since our main character meets with the Koton twentieth Son of Langtry.
Each of the descendent Five Sons of Langtry wears a gold band with information or clues enclosed in a compartment in the band regarding where each of them has hidden their partial instructions on how to build a space-drive. One of the bands also has a key in it. After Paddy is able to take possession of all five of the gold bands, he tries to decipher the information or riddles included in each band. To locate the actual space-drive plans he will have to visit each of the five planets on a treasure hunt like expedition. Once he has all five sets of space-drive instructions, he hopes to be able to sell them for a vast sum of money to the highest bidder.
Paddy initially flees to the planet Spade-Ace in the Thieves Cluster where he has major surgery to alter his face, voice and fingerprints. While there he joins up with a woman, Fay Bursill, who is an Earth Agent with her own space ship who has been trying to locate Paddy so she could eventually bring the space-drive instructions back to Earth. The two of them then undertake adventures to visit each of the five planets to decipher the instructions, find the hidden space-drive plans and eventually return them to Earth. Although Paddy makes disparaging remarks about Fay's body, appearance and personality, a romance gradually develops between them. In the meantime an intensive and massive hunt is undertaken by others from the five planets and elsewhere to find Paddy and Fay, with immense rewards offered to the person who captures them alive. In the face of such intensive search efforts, Paddy and Fay will have to find a way to slip into each planet without being discovered and arrested.
Vance fans will notice some of his signature marks in this novel. There is some world building, for example, although it is rather simple compared to what Vance would do in other novels. We see some of Vance's ideas of how living on different planets changes the inhabitants. When migrants from Earth settle on different planets the gravity, atmosphere, foods and other conditions on the planets modify the physiques, thoughts, behaviors, skills and limitations of the settlers. Then we have a Vancian type main character who is not an idealistic or romanticized hero. Paddy here is more of a lecherous, insulting, self serving, brash, ruffian and thief. There is also a typical Vancean quest or adventure, this time almost resembling a treasure hunt.
This is the third time I've read this novel, and I've read everything by Vance that was ever published. To me this very early writing is simply not one of Vance's better novels. The dialog is merely routine, even sparse or choppy at times. The narration sometimes seems patchy and disjointed. Compared to other works by Vance, the writing here is rather flat and grey scale, sometimes more like a draft than a final product. So, although the plot is somewhat interesting with an intriguing background story, and we do see Vancian touches in the work, I wouldn't recommend this novel to most readers unless they are Jack Vance enthusiasts. I liked it somewhat and rate it a Goodreads 3 or "liked it."
P.S. In addition to "rapparee," a word I had to look up was "propinquinty." Reading Vane can expand one's vocabulary.
For the most recent review and other Vance reviews please see:
https://vancealotjackvanceinreview.bl...
Our main character is the Earther, Paddy Blackthorn, who has gone to the planet Akhabats where valuable space-drives are assembled. Paddy is apprehended by Kudthu guards while he is trying to steal some of the rare and costly space-drives. The penalty for this is mandatory death. But when the "Koton Councillor" learns that Paddy is a master of numerous languages, he decides to delay the execution and use Paddy as a translator at an upcoming annual council meeting of the Five Sons of Langtry.
As the novel progresses we learn the interesting background story. Many years ago a man named Samuel Langtry from Earth invented the "space-drive" that allows ships to travel at great speeds through space. Instead of turning the secret plans for creating space-drives over to the government or others on Earth, he distributed the information among his five sons. These sons left Earth and settled on five different planets. The descendent heirs of the original Five Sons of Langtry, now twenty generations later, continue to be the only ones who can produce space-drives. Each of the descendent heirs rules his own planet and has part of the instructions for building this drive. Together they have a monopoly on manufacturing space-drives which are essential to trade and commerce. These drives are strictly rationed to Earth inhabitants who do not know how to build them. People from Earth are also considered inferior by the residents of the five planets and are not even allowed to use the same hotels when visiting.
The gravity, atmosphere, food and other factors on each planet have lead to adaptations so that the humans on each of the five planets act, think and look dissimilar to Earthers and each other, often strikingly so even though they all are still human and could even interbreed. Some planetary inhabitants are short, squat and very muscular from the greater gravity on their planet. On another planet the humans look like 8 foot tall eagles. These physical and mental changes appear to have happened over twenty generations since our main character meets with the Koton twentieth Son of Langtry.
Each of the descendent Five Sons of Langtry wears a gold band with information or clues enclosed in a compartment in the band regarding where each of them has hidden their partial instructions on how to build a space-drive. One of the bands also has a key in it. After Paddy is able to take possession of all five of the gold bands, he tries to decipher the information or riddles included in each band. To locate the actual space-drive plans he will have to visit each of the five planets on a treasure hunt like expedition. Once he has all five sets of space-drive instructions, he hopes to be able to sell them for a vast sum of money to the highest bidder.
Paddy initially flees to the planet Spade-Ace in the Thieves Cluster where he has major surgery to alter his face, voice and fingerprints. While there he joins up with a woman, Fay Bursill, who is an Earth Agent with her own space ship who has been trying to locate Paddy so she could eventually bring the space-drive instructions back to Earth. The two of them then undertake adventures to visit each of the five planets to decipher the instructions, find the hidden space-drive plans and eventually return them to Earth. Although Paddy makes disparaging remarks about Fay's body, appearance and personality, a romance gradually develops between them. In the meantime an intensive and massive hunt is undertaken by others from the five planets and elsewhere to find Paddy and Fay, with immense rewards offered to the person who captures them alive. In the face of such intensive search efforts, Paddy and Fay will have to find a way to slip into each planet without being discovered and arrested.
Vance fans will notice some of his signature marks in this novel. There is some world building, for example, although it is rather simple compared to what Vance would do in other novels. We see some of Vance's ideas of how living on different planets changes the inhabitants. When migrants from Earth settle on different planets the gravity, atmosphere, foods and other conditions on the planets modify the physiques, thoughts, behaviors, skills and limitations of the settlers. Then we have a Vancian type main character who is not an idealistic or romanticized hero. Paddy here is more of a lecherous, insulting, self serving, brash, ruffian and thief. There is also a typical Vancean quest or adventure, this time almost resembling a treasure hunt.
This is the third time I've read this novel, and I've read everything by Vance that was ever published. To me this very early writing is simply not one of Vance's better novels. The dialog is merely routine, even sparse or choppy at times. The narration sometimes seems patchy and disjointed. Compared to other works by Vance, the writing here is rather flat and grey scale, sometimes more like a draft than a final product. So, although the plot is somewhat interesting with an intriguing background story, and we do see Vancian touches in the work, I wouldn't recommend this novel to most readers unless they are Jack Vance enthusiasts. I liked it somewhat and rate it a Goodreads 3 or "liked it."
P.S. In addition to "rapparee," a word I had to look up was "propinquinty." Reading Vane can expand one's vocabulary.
August 17, 2020
This is one of the weakest Vance stories I've read, which might be due to it being one of his relatively early published novels. Wikipedia lists it as being published in 1953, and my copy lists a 1950 copyright. The characters are weak, showing only glimmers of the odd but compelling style he developed later in his career. The plot is a fairly straight-forward quest, with a moderately dissatisfying ending, and the sexism is a bit heavy. Also there's some very weird references to Christianity that feel completely out of place, but may have been pandering to the mores of the time. The book was still enjoyable, as light space faring fantasy, but didn't have much meat to it.
July 6, 2011
It's an early work and it shows.
The components are all there, of course: a dashing, slightly self-delusional rogue of a hero; a picaresque treasure hunt quest; a series of weird societies and human variants that have evolved away from core humanity.
But in this case the result lacks the usual polish and flair. The language is relatively flat and there's little reveling in the oddness of the planets visited.
The components are all there, of course: a dashing, slightly self-delusional rogue of a hero; a picaresque treasure hunt quest; a series of weird societies and human variants that have evolved away from core humanity.
But in this case the result lacks the usual polish and flair. The language is relatively flat and there's little reveling in the oddness of the planets visited.
January 15, 2016
sometimes even Vance had to pay the bills.
September 23, 2015
It was OK, but definitely not worth a re-read.
April 28, 2024
This 138 page novel was written in 1949 and first published under the title "The Five Gold Bands" in 1950 in Startling Stories magazine. In 1953 it was reissued with the title "The Space Pirates" and in 2002 it was published under the title "Rapparee." Vance himself preferred the Rapparee title. A rapparee was an Irish gorilla fighter from the 1690s, and our main character once refers to himself as being one.
https://vancealotjackvanceinreview.bl...
Our main character is the Earther, Paddy Blackthorn, who has gone to the planet Akhabats where valuable space-drives are assembled. Paddy is apprehended by Kudthu guards while he is trying to steal some of the rare and costly space-drives. The penalty for this is mandatory death. But when the "Koton Councillor" learns that Paddy is a master of numerous languages, he decides to delay the execution and use Paddy as a translator at an upcoming annual council meeting of the Five Sons of Langtry.
As the novel progresses we learn the interesting background story. Many years ago a man named Samuel Langtry from Earth invented the "space-drive" that allows ships to travel at great speeds through space. Instead of turning the secret plans for creating space-drives over to the government or others on Earth, he distributed the information among his five sons. These sons left Earth and settled on five different planets. The descendent heirs of the original Five Sons of Langtry, now twenty generations later, continue to be the only ones who can produce space-drives. Each of the descendent heirs rules his own planet and has part of the instructions for building this drive. Together they have a monopoly on manufacturing space-drives which are essential to trade and commerce. These drives are strictly rationed to Earth inhabitants who do not know how to build them. People from Earth are also considered inferior by the residents of the five planets and are not even allowed to use the same hotels when visiting.
The gravity, atmosphere, food and other factors on each planet have lead to adaptations so that the humans on each of the five planets act, think and look dissimilar to Earthers and each other, often strikingly so even though they all are still human and could even interbreed. Some planetary inhabitants are short, squat and very muscular from the greater gravity on their planet. On another planet the humans look like 8 foot tall eagles. These physical and mental changes appear to have happened over twenty generations since our main character meets with the Koton twentieth Son of Langtry.
Each of the descendent Five Sons of Langtry wears a gold band with information or clues enclosed in a compartment in the band regarding where each of them has hidden their partial instructions on how to build a space-drive. One of the bands also has a key in it. After Paddy is able to take possession of all five of the gold bands, he tries to decipher the information or riddles included in each band. To locate the actual space-drive plans he will have to visit each of the five planets on a treasure hunt like expedition. Once he has all five sets of space-drive instructions, he hopes to be able to sell them for a vast sum of money to the highest bidder.
Paddy initially flees to the planet Spade-Ace in the Thieves Cluster where he has major surgery to alter his face, voice and fingerprints. While there he joins up with a woman, Fay Bursill, who is an Earth Agent with her own space ship who has been trying to locate Paddy so she could eventually bring the space-drive instructions back to Earth. The two of them then undertake adventures to visit each of the five planets to decipher the instructions, find the hidden space-drive plans and eventually return them to Earth. Although Paddy makes disparaging remarks about Fay's body, appearance and personality, a romance gradually develops between them. In the meantime an intensive and massive hunt is undertaken by others from the five planets and elsewhere to find Paddy and Fay, with immense rewards offered to the person who captures them alive. In the face of such intensive search efforts, Paddy and Fay will have to find a way to slip into each planet without being discovered and arrested.
Vance fans will notice some of his signature marks in this novel. There is some world building, for example, although it is rather simple compared to what Vance would do in other novels. We see some of Vance's ideas of how living on different planets changes the inhabitants. When migrants from Earth settle on different planets the gravity, atmosphere, foods and other conditions on the planets modify the physiques, thoughts, behaviors, skills and limitations of the settlers. Then we have a Vancian type main character who is not an idealistic or romanticized hero. Paddy here is more of a lecherous, insulting, self serving, brash, ruffian and thief. There is also a typical Vancean quest or adventure, this time almost resembling a treasure hunt.
This is the third time I've read this novel, and I've read everything by Vance that was ever published. To me this very early writing is simply not one of Vance's better novels. The dialog is merely routine, even sparse or choppy at times. The narration sometimes seems patchy and disjointed. Compared to other works by Vance, the writing here is rather flat and grey scale, sometimes more like a draft than a final product. So, although the plot is somewhat interesting with an intriguing background story, and we do see Vancian touches in the work, I wouldn't recommend this novel to most readers unless they are Jack Vance enthusiasts. I liked it somewhat and rate it a Goodreads 3 or "liked it."
P.S. In addition to "rapparee," a word I had to look up was "propinquinty." Reading Vane can expand one's vocabulary.
https://vancealotjackvanceinreview.bl...
Our main character is the Earther, Paddy Blackthorn, who has gone to the planet Akhabats where valuable space-drives are assembled. Paddy is apprehended by Kudthu guards while he is trying to steal some of the rare and costly space-drives. The penalty for this is mandatory death. But when the "Koton Councillor" learns that Paddy is a master of numerous languages, he decides to delay the execution and use Paddy as a translator at an upcoming annual council meeting of the Five Sons of Langtry.
As the novel progresses we learn the interesting background story. Many years ago a man named Samuel Langtry from Earth invented the "space-drive" that allows ships to travel at great speeds through space. Instead of turning the secret plans for creating space-drives over to the government or others on Earth, he distributed the information among his five sons. These sons left Earth and settled on five different planets. The descendent heirs of the original Five Sons of Langtry, now twenty generations later, continue to be the only ones who can produce space-drives. Each of the descendent heirs rules his own planet and has part of the instructions for building this drive. Together they have a monopoly on manufacturing space-drives which are essential to trade and commerce. These drives are strictly rationed to Earth inhabitants who do not know how to build them. People from Earth are also considered inferior by the residents of the five planets and are not even allowed to use the same hotels when visiting.
The gravity, atmosphere, food and other factors on each planet have lead to adaptations so that the humans on each of the five planets act, think and look dissimilar to Earthers and each other, often strikingly so even though they all are still human and could even interbreed. Some planetary inhabitants are short, squat and very muscular from the greater gravity on their planet. On another planet the humans look like 8 foot tall eagles. These physical and mental changes appear to have happened over twenty generations since our main character meets with the Koton twentieth Son of Langtry.
Each of the descendent Five Sons of Langtry wears a gold band with information or clues enclosed in a compartment in the band regarding where each of them has hidden their partial instructions on how to build a space-drive. One of the bands also has a key in it. After Paddy is able to take possession of all five of the gold bands, he tries to decipher the information or riddles included in each band. To locate the actual space-drive plans he will have to visit each of the five planets on a treasure hunt like expedition. Once he has all five sets of space-drive instructions, he hopes to be able to sell them for a vast sum of money to the highest bidder.
Paddy initially flees to the planet Spade-Ace in the Thieves Cluster where he has major surgery to alter his face, voice and fingerprints. While there he joins up with a woman, Fay Bursill, who is an Earth Agent with her own space ship who has been trying to locate Paddy so she could eventually bring the space-drive instructions back to Earth. The two of them then undertake adventures to visit each of the five planets to decipher the instructions, find the hidden space-drive plans and eventually return them to Earth. Although Paddy makes disparaging remarks about Fay's body, appearance and personality, a romance gradually develops between them. In the meantime an intensive and massive hunt is undertaken by others from the five planets and elsewhere to find Paddy and Fay, with immense rewards offered to the person who captures them alive. In the face of such intensive search efforts, Paddy and Fay will have to find a way to slip into each planet without being discovered and arrested.
Vance fans will notice some of his signature marks in this novel. There is some world building, for example, although it is rather simple compared to what Vance would do in other novels. We see some of Vance's ideas of how living on different planets changes the inhabitants. When migrants from Earth settle on different planets the gravity, atmosphere, foods and other conditions on the planets modify the physiques, thoughts, behaviors, skills and limitations of the settlers. Then we have a Vancian type main character who is not an idealistic or romanticized hero. Paddy here is more of a lecherous, insulting, self serving, brash, ruffian and thief. There is also a typical Vancean quest or adventure, this time almost resembling a treasure hunt.
This is the third time I've read this novel, and I've read everything by Vance that was ever published. To me this very early writing is simply not one of Vance's better novels. The dialog is merely routine, even sparse or choppy at times. The narration sometimes seems patchy and disjointed. Compared to other works by Vance, the writing here is rather flat and grey scale, sometimes more like a draft than a final product. So, although the plot is somewhat interesting with an intriguing background story, and we do see Vancian touches in the work, I wouldn't recommend this novel to most readers unless they are Jack Vance enthusiasts. I liked it somewhat and rate it a Goodreads 3 or "liked it."
P.S. In addition to "rapparee," a word I had to look up was "propinquinty." Reading Vane can expand one's vocabulary.
June 29, 2021
The Rapparee by Jack Vance
aka The Five Gold Bands, The Space Pirate
The Rapparee is an early, stand alone SF novel by Jack Vance about an Irishman called Paddy Blackthorn who, upon obtaining the five gold bands which hold the secrets to space travelling technology, sets upon a quest to restore Earth's position amongst rival species in the galaxy.
The plot, although simple is quite an enjoyable one, and is backed up well by an interesting back story. A scientist from Earth called Langtry invented the “space drive” which enabled man to colonise the galaxy. His five sons, known as the Sons of Langtry, each colonised a different planet where they became the evolutionary starting point of five new mutant human races.
These five new races have now become dominant over Earth, and they control space drive technology, thus monopolising trade and progress throughout the galaxy. People from Earth are derogatorily known as “Earthers” and have became a second-class species, effectively an evolutionary dead-end, who are no longer privy to the secrets of space drive technology and have no say in how the technology is shared amongst the races and planets.
After outwitting the five Sons of Langtry and capturing their gold bands, Paddy Blackthorn goes on a quest to collect the five pieces of information that collectively reveal the secret of space drive technology to restore Earth's position in the galaxy.
The two main characters in The Rapparee are Paddy and Fay. Paddy Blackthorn, an Irishman, is a typical Vance character, brash and confidant. Whereas Fay Bursill provides the romantic hook to the story, an Earther agent who is determined to help Paddy for the good of her home planet.
The prose throughout The Rapparee is, by Vance's high standards, quite plain and ordinary for the most part. Similarly, the dialogue between characters, barring a few exceptions, is not quite playful or delightfully obscene like his other works. This is strange considering that this story was first published in the same year as The Dying Earth. The following quote is one of these exceptions, and has Vance describing Paddy's affections towards Fay in only the way he can:
One of Jack Vance's finest skills is his ability to paint exotic worlds and alien cultures and, unlike other aspects of his writing in The Rapparee, this is something that it very much present in full force here. A personal favourite was the idea of the Thieves Cluster, an area of space where authorities are too scared to venture, an area which is the only safe haven in the galaxy for criminals. Besides this, each of the Langtry planets was interesting and varied enough to hold the readers attention but perhaps lacked the depth of background information that we are spoilt with in The Demon Princes books.
Overall, The Rapparee is a short and enjoyable story which on one hand showed glimpses of Jack Vance's unique style that he was to go on and develop, whilst at the same time also struggled to break away and find its own voice from other 1950's SF literature of the time. This is not a book for readers new to Jack Vance, but it is certainly an enjoyable read to those already well acquainted with his works.
aka The Five Gold Bands, The Space Pirate
The Rapparee is an early, stand alone SF novel by Jack Vance about an Irishman called Paddy Blackthorn who, upon obtaining the five gold bands which hold the secrets to space travelling technology, sets upon a quest to restore Earth's position amongst rival species in the galaxy.
The plot, although simple is quite an enjoyable one, and is backed up well by an interesting back story. A scientist from Earth called Langtry invented the “space drive” which enabled man to colonise the galaxy. His five sons, known as the Sons of Langtry, each colonised a different planet where they became the evolutionary starting point of five new mutant human races.
These five new races have now become dominant over Earth, and they control space drive technology, thus monopolising trade and progress throughout the galaxy. People from Earth are derogatorily known as “Earthers” and have became a second-class species, effectively an evolutionary dead-end, who are no longer privy to the secrets of space drive technology and have no say in how the technology is shared amongst the races and planets.
After outwitting the five Sons of Langtry and capturing their gold bands, Paddy Blackthorn goes on a quest to collect the five pieces of information that collectively reveal the secret of space drive technology to restore Earth's position in the galaxy.
The two main characters in The Rapparee are Paddy and Fay. Paddy Blackthorn, an Irishman, is a typical Vance character, brash and confidant. Whereas Fay Bursill provides the romantic hook to the story, an Earther agent who is determined to help Paddy for the good of her home planet.
The prose throughout The Rapparee is, by Vance's high standards, quite plain and ordinary for the most part. Similarly, the dialogue between characters, barring a few exceptions, is not quite playful or delightfully obscene like his other works. This is strange considering that this story was first published in the same year as The Dying Earth. The following quote is one of these exceptions, and has Vance describing Paddy's affections towards Fay in only the way he can:
Paddy waited like a spent swimmer. Zhri Khainga watched him carefully for a moment, then said, "You have a projective identification with this woman?"
Paddy blinked. "Eh, now? What are you saying?"
"You 'love' this woman?"
One of Jack Vance's finest skills is his ability to paint exotic worlds and alien cultures and, unlike other aspects of his writing in The Rapparee, this is something that it very much present in full force here. A personal favourite was the idea of the Thieves Cluster, an area of space where authorities are too scared to venture, an area which is the only safe haven in the galaxy for criminals. Besides this, each of the Langtry planets was interesting and varied enough to hold the readers attention but perhaps lacked the depth of background information that we are spoilt with in The Demon Princes books.
Overall, The Rapparee is a short and enjoyable story which on one hand showed glimpses of Jack Vance's unique style that he was to go on and develop, whilst at the same time also struggled to break away and find its own voice from other 1950's SF literature of the time. This is not a book for readers new to Jack Vance, but it is certainly an enjoyable read to those already well acquainted with his works.
October 28, 2016
The book was a little sexist (which reflected the 1950 publication date) but it was also entertaining and funny. I think it had enough action and scenery to make it a more enjoyable movie than a book.
August 11, 2016
Irascible rogue Paddy Blackthorn, Irish Earther, has the misfortune of being caught when he breaks into an alien facility to steal valuable space-drives. See, the powerful races of the universe have banded together in an act of self-interest, and limit the distribution of space-drives (e.g., FTL spaceship engines)… preventing small, worthless planets such as Earth from gaining access to too many space-drives. For his attempted theft, Paddy is sentenced to death but, at the last minute, is discovered to be multi-lingual. Instead of immediate execution, he’s shipped off to translate for the Five Sons of Langtry, leaders of the alien nations and descendants of the space-drive’s creator.
Paddy manages to get out of this predicament from dumb luck and quick thinking, and makes off with the golden circlets the Five Sons wear around their arms—each one with a clue, a puzzle hinting at the blueprints to construct space-drives. And with that secret worth potential billions to the Earth Government, Paddy realizes what he’s going to do next. As he evades the authorities, and teams up with an attractive woman secret agent working on behalf of Earth, Paddy criss-crosses the galaxy to track down the formula of the space-drives.
All told, a rather unexceptional read… very early in Vance's career, it's got the right elements, but misuses them in its haste. I did like reading a work from Vance’s early years, and I don’t have anything to complain about other than its shallowness and brevity. It’s not without merit, but it’s also without greatness — and lacked that distinctive spark that characterizes Jack Vance's best novels. Five Gold Bands is a short and entertaining book, but falls into mindless action novel territory, and nothing new or exciting happens within it. Recommended for Vance fans and completists only, because there are dozens of better Vance novels out there for the fair-weather reader to seek out.
Full review found here.
Paddy manages to get out of this predicament from dumb luck and quick thinking, and makes off with the golden circlets the Five Sons wear around their arms—each one with a clue, a puzzle hinting at the blueprints to construct space-drives. And with that secret worth potential billions to the Earth Government, Paddy realizes what he’s going to do next. As he evades the authorities, and teams up with an attractive woman secret agent working on behalf of Earth, Paddy criss-crosses the galaxy to track down the formula of the space-drives.
All told, a rather unexceptional read… very early in Vance's career, it's got the right elements, but misuses them in its haste. I did like reading a work from Vance’s early years, and I don’t have anything to complain about other than its shallowness and brevity. It’s not without merit, but it’s also without greatness — and lacked that distinctive spark that characterizes Jack Vance's best novels. Five Gold Bands is a short and entertaining book, but falls into mindless action novel territory, and nothing new or exciting happens within it. Recommended for Vance fans and completists only, because there are dozens of better Vance novels out there for the fair-weather reader to seek out.
Full review found here.
June 5, 2013
The Irish adventurer or robber depending on your moral viewpoint, Paddy Blackthorn, is caught as he attempts to steal an interstellar space drive and is sentenced to death by the ruling council of mutant humans. These mutants, five species, are all descended from the sons of the original adventurer who accidentally discovered the space drive. Their descendants mutated under the influence of their new planetary conditions and after a bit came to despise earth men.
The five councilors each have a ring; effectively separate clues to the drive to preserve its secret from everyone else. The rings are hidden in five secret locations. Paddy, with the help of the beautiful but scrawny human secret agent, Fay Bursill, attempts to find them.
Published in the fifties, it's brilliantly written for the time. Paddy seems a bit over American Irish but beyond that its a great read - a bit like a Harry Harrison's Stainless Steel rat for grown ups.
The five councilors each have a ring; effectively separate clues to the drive to preserve its secret from everyone else. The rings are hidden in five secret locations. Paddy, with the help of the beautiful but scrawny human secret agent, Fay Bursill, attempts to find them.
Published in the fifties, it's brilliantly written for the time. Paddy seems a bit over American Irish but beyond that its a great read - a bit like a Harry Harrison's Stainless Steel rat for grown ups.
August 28, 2023
Der Abenteurer Paddy will einen Rauschiffantrieb klauen, wird aber erwischt. Das bedeutet die Todesstrafe.
Wie man liest, war das Vances erster Roman. Das Liebesgeplänkel zwischen dem Abenteurer Paddy und der Agentin Fay fand ich amüsant, andere Leser fanden es sexistisch. Ansonsten ist es bei weitem nicht sein stärkstes Werk. Es hat arge Glaubwürdigkeitsprobleme
Wie man liest, war das Vances erster Roman. Das Liebesgeplänkel zwischen dem Abenteurer Paddy und der Agentin Fay fand ich amüsant, andere Leser fanden es sexistisch. Ansonsten ist es bei weitem nicht sein stärkstes Werk. Es hat arge Glaubwürdigkeitsprobleme
February 3, 2019
Maybe not the best of Vance. I read it as a kid and have kept a foundness for this book. There is a sense of freedom in it, of exploration of many worlds.
There can be a lot of critics of the structure and the book itself and many in this site are true. But, it remains a cool fun read.
There can be a lot of critics of the structure and the book itself and many in this site are true. But, it remains a cool fun read.
February 22, 2017
Un bon Jack Vance, qui s'approche beaucoup du cycle de Tschaï.
July 4, 2019
A mid-century space opera, in which protagonist Paddy Blackthorn finds himself in possession of the titular quintet, the five bracelets which offer clues to the whereabouts of the greatest secret of Paddy’s age, faster-than-light space travel. In order to gain this knowledge for the human race, Paddy will need the help of Earth Agency’s young agent, Fay Bursill. The book is fast-paced, complete with the captures of the heroes, daring escapes, and ironic reversals of fortune that were de rigueur for the pulp era. The Five Gold Bands is a rollicking adventure, even if it only occasionally rises above cliché.
The book is from the early phase of Jack Vance’s career, and it shows. The hero and heroine are two-dimensional enough that they might as well be named “Wily Irish Rogue” and “Secret Agent Chick.” And there are elements of the book that have not aged well, e.g., I’m not sure that there’s that much “faith and begorra”-type talk in Ireland now, and there will probably be even less of it in the 27th century (or whenever this yarn is supposed to be taking place.) Even Vance’s extensive vocabulary is barely in evidence, although I will admit that I had to look up the word “rapparee.”
I found the Five Gold Bands to be a breezy, fun read, with a few cool settings (e.g., the Thieves’ Cluster, an eight-star system with 100k satellites, where the laws of sentient beings do not reach.) Nevertheless, the book never achieves the level of surprise or inventiveness found in Vance’s later work. I doubt that anyone besides a hard-core Vance fan is going to want to read this book more than once.
The book is from the early phase of Jack Vance’s career, and it shows. The hero and heroine are two-dimensional enough that they might as well be named “Wily Irish Rogue” and “Secret Agent Chick.” And there are elements of the book that have not aged well, e.g., I’m not sure that there’s that much “faith and begorra”-type talk in Ireland now, and there will probably be even less of it in the 27th century (or whenever this yarn is supposed to be taking place.) Even Vance’s extensive vocabulary is barely in evidence, although I will admit that I had to look up the word “rapparee.”
I found the Five Gold Bands to be a breezy, fun read, with a few cool settings (e.g., the Thieves’ Cluster, an eight-star system with 100k satellites, where the laws of sentient beings do not reach.) Nevertheless, the book never achieves the level of surprise or inventiveness found in Vance’s later work. I doubt that anyone besides a hard-core Vance fan is going to want to read this book more than once.
December 12, 2022
Mostly interesting as a period piece. Vance almost always writes interesting characters with dubious or at least unconventional ethics, and has a gift for weird variant human cultures. In this early work, the roguish Irish protagonist .
July 5, 2020
The Five Gold Bands, AKA The Space Pirate is Jack Vance's first novel and it shows much of his promise as a future Grand Master of science fiction.
This is a simple adventure story, the secrets of the space drive were stolen generations ago and kept by five families, each with a home on five separate planets in the known universe. Along comes Paddy Blackthorn as he tries to steal some of the information. A miscalculation and he is captured and taken to a secret meeting of the five families. There he manages to escape and incidentally kills all the patriarchs of the five, from whom he acquires five wrist bands of gold each of which holds a clue the where the secrets are kept on each of the five planets. From there the novel takes us on a trip around the galaxy as Paddy seeks to stay one step ahead of the galaxy wide search for him. He meets and forms an alliance with an Earth Agent, Fay Bursill and they go about attempting to recover the secrets.
This novel shows Jack Vance's humor and skill with description, for which he is justly famous for. Early Vance is still better than many other writers in their prime. A good rollicking read, enjoy it, I did.
This is a simple adventure story, the secrets of the space drive were stolen generations ago and kept by five families, each with a home on five separate planets in the known universe. Along comes Paddy Blackthorn as he tries to steal some of the information. A miscalculation and he is captured and taken to a secret meeting of the five families. There he manages to escape and incidentally kills all the patriarchs of the five, from whom he acquires five wrist bands of gold each of which holds a clue the where the secrets are kept on each of the five planets. From there the novel takes us on a trip around the galaxy as Paddy seeks to stay one step ahead of the galaxy wide search for him. He meets and forms an alliance with an Earth Agent, Fay Bursill and they go about attempting to recover the secrets.
This novel shows Jack Vance's humor and skill with description, for which he is justly famous for. Early Vance is still better than many other writers in their prime. A good rollicking read, enjoy it, I did.
May 31, 2024
This 138 page novel was written in 1949 and first published under the title "The Five Gold Bands" in November, 1950 in Startling Stories magazine. In 1953 it was reissued with the title "The Space Pirates" and in 2002 it was published under the title "The Rapparee." Vance himself preferred “The Rapparee” title. A rapparee was an Irish gorilla fighter from the 1690s, and our main character once refers to himself as being one.
For the most recent review and other Vance reviews please see:
https://vancealotjackvanceinreview.bl...
Our main character is the Earther, Paddy Blackthorn, who has gone to the planet Akhabats where valuable space-drives are assembled. Paddy is apprehended by Kudthu guards while he is trying to steal some of the rare and costly space-drives. The penalty for this is mandatory death. But when the "Koton Councillor" learns that Paddy is a master of numerous languages, he decides to delay the execution and use Paddy as a translator at an upcoming annual council meeting of the Five Sons of Langtry.
As the novel progresses we learn the interesting background story. Many years ago a man named Samuel Langtry from Earth invented the "space-drive" that allows ships to travel at great speeds through space. Instead of turning the secret plans for creating space-drives over to the government or others on Earth, he distributed the information among his five sons. These sons left Earth and settled on five different planets. The descendent heirs of the original Five Sons of Langtry, now twenty generations later, continue to be the only ones who can produce space-drives. Each of the descendent heirs rules his own planet and has part of the instructions for building this drive. Together they have a monopoly on manufacturing space-drives which are essential to trade and commerce. These drives are strictly rationed to Earth inhabitants who do not know how to build them. People from Earth are also considered inferior by the residents of the five planets and are not even allowed to use the same hotels when visiting.
The gravity, atmosphere, food and other factors on each planet have lead to adaptations so that the humans on each of the five planets act, think and look dissimilar to Earthers and each other, often strikingly so even though they all are still human and could even interbreed. Some planetary inhabitants are short, squat and very muscular from the greater gravity on their planet. On another planet the humans look like 8 foot tall eagles. These physical and mental changes appear to have happened over twenty generations since our main character meets with the Koton twentieth Son of Langtry.
Each of the descendent Five Sons of Langtry wears a gold band with information or clues enclosed in a compartment in the band regarding where each of them has hidden their partial instructions on how to build a space-drive. One of the bands also has a key in it. After Paddy is able to take possession of all five of the gold bands, he tries to decipher the information or riddles included in each band. To locate the actual space-drive plans he will have to visit each of the five planets on a treasure hunt like expedition. Once he has all five sets of space-drive instructions, he hopes to be able to sell them for a vast sum of money to the highest bidder.
Paddy initially flees to the planet Spade-Ace in the Thieves Cluster where he has major surgery to alter his face, voice and fingerprints. While there he joins up with a woman, Fay Bursill, who is an Earth Agent with her own space ship who has been trying to locate Paddy so she could eventually bring the space-drive instructions back to Earth. The two of them then undertake adventures to visit each of the five planets to decipher the instructions, find the hidden space-drive plans and eventually return them to Earth. Although Paddy makes disparaging remarks about Fay's body, appearance and personality, a romance gradually develops between them. In the meantime an intensive and massive hunt is undertaken by others from the five planets and elsewhere to find Paddy and Fay, with immense rewards offered to the person who captures them alive. In the face of such intensive search efforts, Paddy and Fay will have to find a way to slip into each planet without being discovered and arrested.
Vance fans will notice some of his signature marks in this novel. There is some world building, for example, although it is rather simple compared to what Vance would do in other novels. We see some of Vance's ideas of how living on different planets changes the inhabitants. When migrants from Earth settle on different planets the gravity, atmosphere, foods and other conditions on the planets modify the physiques, thoughts, behaviors, skills and limitations of the settlers. Then we have a Vancian type main character who is not an idealistic or romanticized hero. Paddy here is more of a lecherous, insulting, self-serving, brash, ruffian and thief. There is also a typical Vancean quest or adventure, this time almost resembling a treasure hunt.
This very early writing is simply not one of Vance's better novels. The dialog is merely routine, even sparse or choppy at times. The narration sometimes seems patchy and disjointed. Compared to other works by Vance, the writing here seems rather flat and grey scale, sometimes more like a draft than a final product. So, although the plot is somewhat interesting with an intriguing background story, and we do see Vancian touches in the work, I wouldn't recommend this novel to most readers unless they are Jack Vance enthusiasts. This is the third time I've read this novel and I rated it a 3 or "liked it" each time.
For the most recent review and other Vance reviews please see:
https://vancealotjackvanceinreview.bl...
Our main character is the Earther, Paddy Blackthorn, who has gone to the planet Akhabats where valuable space-drives are assembled. Paddy is apprehended by Kudthu guards while he is trying to steal some of the rare and costly space-drives. The penalty for this is mandatory death. But when the "Koton Councillor" learns that Paddy is a master of numerous languages, he decides to delay the execution and use Paddy as a translator at an upcoming annual council meeting of the Five Sons of Langtry.
As the novel progresses we learn the interesting background story. Many years ago a man named Samuel Langtry from Earth invented the "space-drive" that allows ships to travel at great speeds through space. Instead of turning the secret plans for creating space-drives over to the government or others on Earth, he distributed the information among his five sons. These sons left Earth and settled on five different planets. The descendent heirs of the original Five Sons of Langtry, now twenty generations later, continue to be the only ones who can produce space-drives. Each of the descendent heirs rules his own planet and has part of the instructions for building this drive. Together they have a monopoly on manufacturing space-drives which are essential to trade and commerce. These drives are strictly rationed to Earth inhabitants who do not know how to build them. People from Earth are also considered inferior by the residents of the five planets and are not even allowed to use the same hotels when visiting.
The gravity, atmosphere, food and other factors on each planet have lead to adaptations so that the humans on each of the five planets act, think and look dissimilar to Earthers and each other, often strikingly so even though they all are still human and could even interbreed. Some planetary inhabitants are short, squat and very muscular from the greater gravity on their planet. On another planet the humans look like 8 foot tall eagles. These physical and mental changes appear to have happened over twenty generations since our main character meets with the Koton twentieth Son of Langtry.
Each of the descendent Five Sons of Langtry wears a gold band with information or clues enclosed in a compartment in the band regarding where each of them has hidden their partial instructions on how to build a space-drive. One of the bands also has a key in it. After Paddy is able to take possession of all five of the gold bands, he tries to decipher the information or riddles included in each band. To locate the actual space-drive plans he will have to visit each of the five planets on a treasure hunt like expedition. Once he has all five sets of space-drive instructions, he hopes to be able to sell them for a vast sum of money to the highest bidder.
Paddy initially flees to the planet Spade-Ace in the Thieves Cluster where he has major surgery to alter his face, voice and fingerprints. While there he joins up with a woman, Fay Bursill, who is an Earth Agent with her own space ship who has been trying to locate Paddy so she could eventually bring the space-drive instructions back to Earth. The two of them then undertake adventures to visit each of the five planets to decipher the instructions, find the hidden space-drive plans and eventually return them to Earth. Although Paddy makes disparaging remarks about Fay's body, appearance and personality, a romance gradually develops between them. In the meantime an intensive and massive hunt is undertaken by others from the five planets and elsewhere to find Paddy and Fay, with immense rewards offered to the person who captures them alive. In the face of such intensive search efforts, Paddy and Fay will have to find a way to slip into each planet without being discovered and arrested.
Vance fans will notice some of his signature marks in this novel. There is some world building, for example, although it is rather simple compared to what Vance would do in other novels. We see some of Vance's ideas of how living on different planets changes the inhabitants. When migrants from Earth settle on different planets the gravity, atmosphere, foods and other conditions on the planets modify the physiques, thoughts, behaviors, skills and limitations of the settlers. Then we have a Vancian type main character who is not an idealistic or romanticized hero. Paddy here is more of a lecherous, insulting, self-serving, brash, ruffian and thief. There is also a typical Vancean quest or adventure, this time almost resembling a treasure hunt.
This very early writing is simply not one of Vance's better novels. The dialog is merely routine, even sparse or choppy at times. The narration sometimes seems patchy and disjointed. Compared to other works by Vance, the writing here seems rather flat and grey scale, sometimes more like a draft than a final product. So, although the plot is somewhat interesting with an intriguing background story, and we do see Vancian touches in the work, I wouldn't recommend this novel to most readers unless they are Jack Vance enthusiasts. This is the third time I've read this novel and I rated it a 3 or "liked it" each time.
October 9, 2021
I disagree with most of the reviews posted about this book, mostly because it's unfairly compared to later Vance's masterpieces.
Yes, The Five Gold Bands is full of stereotypes, yes there is a cheesy romance included, but the pace is fast and fun, and the action is worth anything from a Mission Impossible movie. It's short enough to be read in one sitting and is far better than wasting time watching a bad SF movie such as Hollywood is usually plagued with (with some exceptions of course).
So, sit down, take a deep breath, and dive into The Five Gold Bands. A seriously underrated little gem.
Yes, The Five Gold Bands is full of stereotypes, yes there is a cheesy romance included, but the pace is fast and fun, and the action is worth anything from a Mission Impossible movie. It's short enough to be read in one sitting and is far better than wasting time watching a bad SF movie such as Hollywood is usually plagued with (with some exceptions of course).
So, sit down, take a deep breath, and dive into The Five Gold Bands. A seriously underrated little gem.
July 2, 2025
Libro minore di Jack Vance che però contiene tutte le sue tematiche: avventura; esplorazione di altri mondi; thriller; prosa scanzonata.
In sintesi. Nel lontano futuro in cui i terrestri si sono diffusi nella galassia un ladro cerca di recuperare i segreti dei moderni voli spaziali diventati tecnologia monopolista di 5 ex colonie. Sulla falsariga di una caccia al tesoro il nostro eroe dovrà intrufolarsi come un turista qualsiasi in questi mondi (ciascuno con usi e costumi particolari e aspetto fisico mutato, adatto all'ambiente, degli ex coloni).
Pura fantascienza classica priva di alcuna velleità hard-science (come in Star Wars per capirci)
In sintesi. Nel lontano futuro in cui i terrestri si sono diffusi nella galassia un ladro cerca di recuperare i segreti dei moderni voli spaziali diventati tecnologia monopolista di 5 ex colonie. Sulla falsariga di una caccia al tesoro il nostro eroe dovrà intrufolarsi come un turista qualsiasi in questi mondi (ciascuno con usi e costumi particolari e aspetto fisico mutato, adatto all'ambiente, degli ex coloni).
Pura fantascienza classica priva di alcuna velleità hard-science (come in Star Wars per capirci)
July 3, 2019
I simply love JackVance, he has to be one of my favourite writers. If you are into Sci-Fi i wholeheartedly recommend any book of his. This book was funny and interesting to read, but frankly, the ending was a bit dissatisfying. After reading about all of the adventures Paddy and Fey went on, I expected them to do something with it, but yeah, they didn't. But all of the adventures in the mean time were cool and i like paddy blackthorn's character, that slut, with his women of Meave with their legs and behinds
February 4, 2023
This is one of Vance's earliest and quaintest works. Whilst it is cast in the shape of many of his best, the wit, playfulness and inventiveness he is known for is at best unrefined. I'd recommend this only to Vance completionists.
May 12, 2017
Rýchlovka. Neurazí ale ani neohúri.
January 12, 2018
It's one of those classic Jack Vance novels that I like to read. Not one of the most memorable though.
May 22, 2018
A weak example of Vance’s early work, only if interest to devoted fans or people exploring his full catalogue. The writing is significantly poorer then his later works.
March 16, 2021
Turns out i had read this one under a different name "The five gold bands"
June 5, 2023
Decent 50’s SF adventure that’s fast paced and short. The plot is typical pulp action of its time and has some fun elements. Overall it’s just bland. 2.5 stars.
December 30, 2025
Tough to follow, lots of tropes, outdated relationship dynamics, the protagonist always finds an easy way around ever single issue
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
March 28, 2025
Love ya Jack but this ain't it!
May 31, 2021
As someone else here said, even Jack Vance had to pay the bills. This story is nothing special. However, it's a testament to Vance as an author that he can make a banal story pretty readable and achieve a decent level of world building in such a short book. The cluster of Outlaw planets was interesting and I'd have liked to have seen them expanded on. Humanity diverging into various different sub species based on their planets environment is pretty cool, but I found it a little unbelievable to have such radical changes in biology with a couple of generations (it's implied all are natural evolution without any genetic engineering). A quick easy read to while away a few hours. Can easily be read within a day or plane journey.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 46 reviews