551 books
—
1,986 voters
Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read.
Start by marking “Re: Colonised Planet 5, Shikasta” as Want to Read:
Re: Colonised Planet 5, Shikasta
(Canopus in Argos #1)
by
This is the first volume in the series of novels Doris Lessing calls collectively Canopus in Argos: Archives. Presented as a compilation of documents, reports, letters, speeches and journal entries, this purports to be a general study of the planet Shikasta, clearly the planet Earth, to be used by history students of the higher planet Canopus and to be stored in the Canopi
...more
Hardcover, 365 pages
Published
1979
by Jonathan Cape
Friend Reviews
To see what your friends thought of this book,
please sign up.
Reader Q&A
To ask other readers questions about
Re,
please sign up.
Be the first to ask a question about Re
Community Reviews
Showing 1-30
Start your review of Re: Colonised Planet 5, Shikasta
THIS IS THE WAY THE WORLD ENDS -
NOT WITH A BANG, BUT WITH A WHIMPER.
The Hollow Men
Eliot’s is indeed such an apt envoi for the Shikastan world, if you know the plot of this novel...
Doris Lessing seems to have been BORN to write sci-fi - though most of her critics were relatively aghast at such presumptuous temerity on her part, back in the 1970’s.
And whenever I consider the brilliance of this marvellous Nobel laureate - in the panoptic Vision of her superb novels like this one - it almost seems a ...more
NOT WITH A BANG, BUT WITH A WHIMPER.
The Hollow Men
Eliot’s is indeed such an apt envoi for the Shikastan world, if you know the plot of this novel...
Doris Lessing seems to have been BORN to write sci-fi - though most of her critics were relatively aghast at such presumptuous temerity on her part, back in the 1970’s.
And whenever I consider the brilliance of this marvellous Nobel laureate - in the panoptic Vision of her superb novels like this one - it almost seems a ...more
This book is so terrible that I added a new shelf: "refused-to-finish". It has managed to supplant Red Mars by Kim Stanley Robinson as the worst book I've had the misfortune to encounter (and this includes Breaking Dawn!).
The main problem with this book is that the writing is bad. Doris Lessing won the Nobel Prize in literature for this series, so I had high hopes that at a minimum the prose would be good. It's not. Not even a little bit. There have been precisely two moments in the 156 pages I ...more
The main problem with this book is that the writing is bad. Doris Lessing won the Nobel Prize in literature for this series, so I had high hopes that at a minimum the prose would be good. It's not. Not even a little bit. There have been precisely two moments in the 156 pages I ...more
My favorite quotes from this book both come from the introduction:
"Shikasta has as its starting point, like many others of the genre, the Old Testament. It is our habit to dismiss the Old Testament altogether because Jehovah, or Jahve, does not think or behave like a social worker."And, indeed, the overall effect is rather as though Olaf Stapledo ...more
"I do think that there is something very wrong with an attitude that puts a 'serious' novel on one shelf and, let's say, First and Last Men on another."
The full title is Canopus in Argos: Archives Re: Colonized Planet 5: Shikasta: Personal, Psychological, Historical Documents Relating to Visit by JOHOR (George Sherban): Emissary Grade 9: 87th of the Period of the Last Days.
To begin, we receive a Preface from the Nobel-winning author. It contains a brief defense of S-F as a literary form. Lessing’s contribution to S-F is rarely, if ever, mentioned. Totaling over 1100 pages, her 5 novel series constitutes an exhaustive study of a fictionalized ga ...more
To begin, we receive a Preface from the Nobel-winning author. It contains a brief defense of S-F as a literary form. Lessing’s contribution to S-F is rarely, if ever, mentioned. Totaling over 1100 pages, her 5 novel series constitutes an exhaustive study of a fictionalized ga ...more
Aug 05, 2013
Zanna
rated it
it was amazing
Recommends it for:
anarcho-feminist sci-fi lovers
Shelves:
environment,
philosophy
First read January 2005
This book does three ambitious things.
1. It takes the Old Testament of the Bible as inspiration for its mythical geo-historical content, but instead of an angry bearded guy in charge, it has a super-advanced utopian-collectivist space-travelling civilization colonising Earth and then struggling to maintain a shadow of hope and stability through thousands of literally star-crossed years when the unfortunate planet is fed on and influenced by another, evil space-travelling c ...more
This book does three ambitious things.
1. It takes the Old Testament of the Bible as inspiration for its mythical geo-historical content, but instead of an angry bearded guy in charge, it has a super-advanced utopian-collectivist space-travelling civilization colonising Earth and then struggling to maintain a shadow of hope and stability through thousands of literally star-crossed years when the unfortunate planet is fed on and influenced by another, evil space-travelling c ...more
May 31, 2008
Kersplebedeb
rated it
liked it
Recommends it for:
people with a tolerance for preachiness and slow plots.
Shelves:
science-fiction
i first read Shikasta fifteen years ago, and found it fantastic but very difficult. Rereading it now i felt differently, it was both a lot easier but also a lot less impressive.
A white woman who grew up in Zimbabwe back when it was Rhodesia become a nobel laureate in literature last year. Amongst her reactions were something like "what took you so long" and "my science fiction was my most important work."
Shikasta is the first book in Lessing's science fiction series, and it is very much a long, ...more
A white woman who grew up in Zimbabwe back when it was Rhodesia become a nobel laureate in literature last year. Amongst her reactions were something like "what took you so long" and "my science fiction was my most important work."
Shikasta is the first book in Lessing's science fiction series, and it is very much a long, ...more
They say North America is full of troubles but I said I didn’t want to listen any longer.I have always admired Doris Lessing’s vision as a novelist and a humanist; The Golden Notebook was (as was The Diaries of Jane Somers, about which I wrote at length, and very personally, here) such an important book to me, and continues to be to this day, and I think its focus on our deep psychological and interpersonal rifts is still highly visionary, ominously prescient.
With that said, and perhaps beca ...more
This is absolutely the most janky book I have ever read.
from the 1st Dictionary of Nate:
janky--JANE-key (adjective); 1: thrown together at random; patchwork. 2: containing multiple elements, many of which contradict each other, and some that are mutually exclusive 3:top-heavy; lurching randomly in every direction at once 4:aspirations beyond achievement, and/or aspirations that are impossible to achieve 5:distinctive in being completely psychotic 6:something designed over the course of eons by a ...more
from the 1st Dictionary of Nate:
janky--JANE-key (adjective); 1: thrown together at random; patchwork. 2: containing multiple elements, many of which contradict each other, and some that are mutually exclusive 3:top-heavy; lurching randomly in every direction at once 4:aspirations beyond achievement, and/or aspirations that are impossible to achieve 5:distinctive in being completely psychotic 6:something designed over the course of eons by a ...more
I read this book shortly after it was first published. I've since finished re-reading it in its eBook form.
It was hard. But then, Lessing's "Briefing for a Descent into Hell" was hard, and worth the trouble.
Shikasta was then, and remains, a book of huge scope. It runs across all of human history, adding in pre-history and moving forward beyond today and into the future.
As I read it I fancied I discovered echoes of "The Four-Gated City", the final book in Lessing's Children of Violence series. I ...more
It was hard. But then, Lessing's "Briefing for a Descent into Hell" was hard, and worth the trouble.
Shikasta was then, and remains, a book of huge scope. It runs across all of human history, adding in pre-history and moving forward beyond today and into the future.
As I read it I fancied I discovered echoes of "The Four-Gated City", the final book in Lessing's Children of Violence series. I ...more
I read this edition in 1979. Bought the hardcover, even! Went on to buy the rest in hardcover, and devour them, enjoying the bravura performances that they were...but they're not good SF. The genre's conventions are simply disregarded, if (and this is by no means certain) Lessing was even aware of them.
My rating is for my memory of the melancholic mournful musicality of the prose. I'm not going to claim that, forty years on, I retain a grasp the subtleties of the story told, and I don't have the ...more
My rating is for my memory of the melancholic mournful musicality of the prose. I'm not going to claim that, forty years on, I retain a grasp the subtleties of the story told, and I don't have the ...more
Nov 26, 2008
Joe
rated it
it was amazing
Recommends it for:
mystics, conspiracy types, grouches
Recommended to Joe by:
Nilary B
This is a very depressing book, an alternate take on human history, but I like being miserable so I dug it. It is very well-written and I don't feel it is slow-moving at all. Ms. Lessing does a great job of making such a ( seemingly ) far-fetched story believable.
One thing--Am I the only person who noticed the similarity to "Beelzebub's Tales to His Grandson" by G.I. Gurdjieff? The plot and even some of the writing style are so much alike. Since Ms. Lessing was a student of Sufism and Idries Sha ...more
One thing--Am I the only person who noticed the similarity to "Beelzebub's Tales to His Grandson" by G.I. Gurdjieff? The plot and even some of the writing style are so much alike. Since Ms. Lessing was a student of Sufism and Idries Sha ...more
I enjoy Doris Lessing and I enjoy speculative fiction. Somehow though, the combination had a tragic outcome. An attempt to be clever that fails in an impenetrable epistolary mess. If you want great epistolary spec-fic, try The Prestige by Christopher Priest instead. If you want great Lessing, read anything by her that's realist. Ignore this novel. Erase it - if you can - from you memory because Lessing was actually a super talented writer.
...more
I have fond memories of reading Doris Lessing's space opera series ”Canopus In Argos” but do not remember that much of the actual content in those books beyond the broad strokes: The series' basic concept of rivalling extraterrestrial empires influencing human history behind the scenes; most of the viewpoint characters being aliens in human disguise; as well as Lessing predicting a near future where the People's Republic of China becomes the Earth's dominant superpower. As a result I decided to
...more
Feb 14, 2014
Simon
rated it
did not like it
·
review of another edition
Shelves:
sf-mistressworks,
sf
I really wanted to like this but it was just too dull. I really wanted to finish this but life is too short. I got nearly two hundred pages in and just found myself dreading reading time because I knew I would have to pick this up.
There's no plot for the reader to follow. There are no characters for the reader to engage with. There is no point to this narrative other than to show how stupid and corrupt humanity is. Yeah, well, I already know that and this is not what I call entertainment.
This is ...more
There's no plot for the reader to follow. There are no characters for the reader to engage with. There is no point to this narrative other than to show how stupid and corrupt humanity is. Yeah, well, I already know that and this is not what I call entertainment.
This is ...more
This work is kin to Oryx and Crake, and to a lesser extent Babel-17: conservative where it needs to be progressive, progressive where it needs to be informed, and all in all amounting to little more than a done to death rehashing of various mainstream assumptions sprinkled with a few intriguing hints at veritable open fields. The insensate jabbering on and on about the evils of history with nary a holistic breakdown into tiers of intra community issues and intersectional community action outside
...more
Oct 14, 2014
Jörg
rated it
really liked it
·
review of another edition
Shelves:
english-lit,
science-fiction
Shikasta is the first of five volumes in Lessing's Canopus in Argos cycle. Lessing herself calls these books space fiction and explains that this genre (i.e. a type of science fiction) in her eyes is unjustifiably maligned and provides the opportunity to think beyond boundaries.
Essentially, the five books together represent nothing less than a holistic view of Earth and mankind. The planet Shikasta is clearly recognizable as Earth. Canopus is the home planet of a superior, almost transcendental ...more
Essentially, the five books together represent nothing less than a holistic view of Earth and mankind. The planet Shikasta is clearly recognizable as Earth. Canopus is the home planet of a superior, almost transcendental ...more
I first read this book over 20 years ago. I reread it a couple of times in the following 10 years. I am not a person who rereads books; especially not novels. My reading comprehension is and always has been extremely high. So I generally get it when I first read it. The fact that I read this book multiple times is an indication of the importance that this work holds in the constellations of some people’s universes.
I made the mistake of reading some of the negative reviews. I am astonished at th ...more
I made the mistake of reading some of the negative reviews. I am astonished at th ...more
A book like Shikasta is hard to describe and difficult to reflect upon. It's full of ideas. Perhaps so many ideas that it is too big and too full to truly coalesce into itself and become that perfect creation that every book has the potential to be. But that's not unfamiliar territory for Lessing, an author who often got away from herself when she was writing but also, often, and maybe even always, wrote something that really mattered when she did. I finished reading Shikasta convinced that it i
...more
I don’t recommend this book. Actually I don’t think it should have ever seen print. Don’t get me wrong, I like slow, deep books with profound spiritual and political messages, especially if their science fiction. I don’t recommend this book for one reason: it is inexcusable boring. Let me explain. I liked the three page introduction, where Lessing makes some important comments about science fiction. The first half of the novel, a retelling of the Old Testament with SF elements, is kind of intere
...more
I am including this book in my "favorites" because of the unusual impact it had on me for about 25 years. I have the 1981 paperback image that's shown. I read most of the book sometime soon after that. It's a rather old book, but, still, I'll use the spoiler alert since what I'm going to say reveals something not that far from the end.
(view spoiler) ...more
(view spoiler) ...more
This novel is the first of Lessing's classic "Canopus in Argos: Archives" series. It differs from much modern science fiction in that is defies classification. In part science fiction, in part psychological-religious exploration, in part modern doomsday tale, in part pseudo-historical documentation, the story follows the earthly life of Geoge Sherban, human incarnation of the Canopan being Johor. George/ Johor visits a near future Earth where human society is on the brink of total breakdown. Joh
...more
Rating 1¾ of 5 stars.
I had to abandon this book!
I read about half of it and skimmed the other half, reading some pages here and there. It just didn't work for me. I was bored almost all of the time. The writing style is way too wordy to me, the sentences too long where they don't necessarily have to be.
I neither found a coherent story, nor any characters to care for, and parts of it is too much of a lecture to me. This, combined with the biblical/mystical/esoteric undertones was enough to finall ...more
I had to abandon this book!
I read about half of it and skimmed the other half, reading some pages here and there. It just didn't work for me. I was bored almost all of the time. The writing style is way too wordy to me, the sentences too long where they don't necessarily have to be.
I neither found a coherent story, nor any characters to care for, and parts of it is too much of a lecture to me. This, combined with the biblical/mystical/esoteric undertones was enough to finall ...more
I think I'm just reading the wrong Doris because I know people love her but this was the boringest thing ever. Just a dull froth of myth + sci fi. IT'S EARTH THE PLANET IS EARTH OMG. Hated it. Forget why I started it. Not finishing it.
...more
Jul 26, 2008
Stephanie "Jedigal"
rated it
really liked it
·
review of another edition
Shelves:
1001-books
Wow. I am happily surprised how much I liked this book. My 1st try at D. Lessing was THE GOLDEN NOTEBOOK, and I could not get myself into it, gave it up pretty quickly. When I was researching her work, I was curious to hear she had written a series of sci fi titles.
The "sci" in this sci fi is on the light side. As is the case in much of the finest science fiction, distancing us from the known world can help an author frame a story the better to make points about that same world. The basic point ...more
The "sci" in this sci fi is on the light side. As is the case in much of the finest science fiction, distancing us from the known world can help an author frame a story the better to make points about that same world. The basic point ...more
May 13, 2009
Erik Graff
rated it
did not like it
·
review of another edition
Recommends it for:
no one
Recommended to Erik by:
no one
Shelves:
sf
Doris Lessing was first recommended to me by Karen Spilke, my next-door neighbor in the senior year at Union Theological Seminary, who read part of her Golden Notebook aloud while I was driving her car up to visit her parent's summer house near Leeds, New York. I had certainly heard of Lessing before and this reading put it back in my head to get down to reading her fiction.
Then, Shikasta came out, a science fiction novel by the intended. Great! I bought it in hardcover and two of the subsequent ...more
Then, Shikasta came out, a science fiction novel by the intended. Great! I bought it in hardcover and two of the subsequent ...more
This was the latest in my Nobel Laureate readings, and I started this one I think back in May. It took me this long to finish it, and if it weren't for the fact that it was part of my challenge this year... I may not have forced myself through it.
I chose this because I thought it was interesting that a Nobel Laureate had written a sci-fi novel, but I've been really careful to NOT read reviews before I read one of these books, since I'm trying to stay open minded. But... I really wish I had chos ...more
I chose this because I thought it was interesting that a Nobel Laureate had written a sci-fi novel, but I've been really careful to NOT read reviews before I read one of these books, since I'm trying to stay open minded. But... I really wish I had chos ...more
This is not an easy book to review. I'm not even sure of my own opinion. If I rate the book highly, it's not for the usual reasons one might cite - that it was a particularly emotional read, or one that I found tremendously gripping or thrilling (a "page-turner"). Quite the opposite. The book, both while you're reading it and in retrospect, comes across as rather deliberately dispassionate - the intellectual calisthenics of a highly political literary mind finally let free to experiment with a n
...more
What if all of human history and pre-history was a carefully monitored experiment by civilizations that dwelt on nearby stars. An experiment which wasn't always controllable and was affected and impaired by the movements of heavenly bodies as well as forces of chaos. What if such forces nurtured various species (some gigantic, other less so - with interesting variants emerging with passage of time), cross-bred them, steered them through evolution but also at times saw them dwindle, degrade and p
...more
I know that a book is exceptional if I’ve read it more than once. More than twice, and it has to be extraordinary. Doris Lessing’s Re: Colonised Planet 5, Shikasta (the first in a series known as Canopus in Argos) is one of those. Known for her extensive corpus of mainstream, left-leaning fiction, Shikasta represents her first foray into science fiction., and into mysticism. Her die-hard fans hated her new direction and hoped it wouldn’t last. She’d already tried their patience with Briefing for
...more
The first volume in Doris Lessing’s praised sci-fi quintet is a truly curious piece of literature. I almost hesitate to call “Shikasta” a novel, due to its erratic structure. Lessing’s style here brings to mind Virginia Woolf, early Jack Vance and most of all William S. Burroughs. It’s much like “The Naked Lunch,” even though its sci-fi setting creates a bit more congruence between the individual stories, manifesto’s, apologies and philosophical as well as mythological deconstructions the whole
...more
| topics | posts | views | last activity | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| /r/Fantasy Discus...: * July 2021: Re: Colonised Planet 5, Shikasta | 1 | 18 | Jul 03, 2021 10:36AM | |
| Canopus Shammat and Anarchy | 1 | 3 | Aug 21, 2019 11:58PM |
221 users
101 users
29 users
19 users
14 users
14 users
13 users
12 users
10 users
9 users
Both of her parents were British: her father, who had been crippled in World War I, was a clerk in the Imperial Bank of Persia; her mother had been a nurse. In 1925, lured by the promise of getting rich through maize farming, the family moved to the British colony in Southern Rhodesia (now Zimbabwe). Like other women writers from southern African who did not graduate from high school (such as Oliv
...more
Other books in the series
Canopus in Argos
(5 books)
Related Articles
Thirty-four years after the publication of her dystopian classic, The Handmaid's Tale, Atwood returns to continue the story of Offred. We talked...
370 likes · 58 comments
“We are all creatures of the stars.”
—
62 likes
“Standardisation of intellectual and emotional patterns had become extreme. A main mechanism for achieving this was a device that supplied identical indoctrinational material simultaneously into every living or working unit, whether that of a single person, a family, or an institution, through a whole country. These programmes were standardised, particularly for children. At best they reinforced a low level of ethic—kindness to animals, for instance—but the worst was inherent in the sheer fact of the infinite repetition.”
—
5 likes
More quotes…
















