164 books
—
721 voters
Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read.
Start by marking “The Lie” as Want to Read:
The Lie
by
Cornwall, 1920, early spring.
A young man stands on a headland, looking out to sea. He is back from the war, homeless and without family.
Behind him lie the mud, barbed-wire entanglements and terror of the trenches. Behind him is also the most intense relationship of his life, forged in a crucible of shared suffering.
Daniel has survived, but the horror and passion of the pa ...more
A young man stands on a headland, looking out to sea. He is back from the war, homeless and without family.
Behind him lie the mud, barbed-wire entanglements and terror of the trenches. Behind him is also the most intense relationship of his life, forged in a crucible of shared suffering.
Daniel has survived, but the horror and passion of the pa ...more
Get A Copy
Friend Reviews
To see what your friends thought of this book,
please sign up.
Reader Q&A
To ask other readers questions about
The Lie,
please sign up.
Be the first to ask a question about The Lie
Community Reviews
Showing 1-30
Start your review of The Lie
DNF @ 23%
I'm just not feeling this one. The story seems pretty flat and although the topic of the devastating effects of the WW1 experience is described well, neither the story nor the characters or the storytelling is engaging me enough to want to spend more time with this book. ...more
I'm just not feeling this one. The story seems pretty flat and although the topic of the devastating effects of the WW1 experience is described well, neither the story nor the characters or the storytelling is engaging me enough to want to spend more time with this book. ...more
This is not the kind of books I usually read but god I’m so glad I read this one. Daniel’s journey through the WWI and post war is something I will never forget. You cannot read this book without feeling the horrors and atrocities of the war cut through your heart. It’s a simple story, nothing fancy; it’s just the reality that stabs you.
And coming to the writing, it’s so graceful, so peaceful and soothing, that relieves you making sure that the worst has past.
And lastly, this terrifying tale of ...more
And coming to the writing, it’s so graceful, so peaceful and soothing, that relieves you making sure that the worst has past.
And lastly, this terrifying tale of ...more
This was an idea spread too thin with not enough plot and or originality. The writing was certainly good, and where the passages handled strong emotion it was very affecting. But not enough seemed to be done with the idea.
There are two halves to the narrative: the passages set in the trenches and a later time when the character is trying to readjust to normal life, with little success. The wartime scenes are well realised, although a little meandering. But the sections back in this country are a ...more
There are two halves to the narrative: the passages set in the trenches and a later time when the character is trying to readjust to normal life, with little success. The wartime scenes are well realised, although a little meandering. But the sections back in this country are a ...more
This is a beautifully written tale about the sacrifices of the WW1 generation. It's been marketed by the line "Can love survive the war?" but this is no simple love story. It's far more complex and layered than that involving a triangle of people who all love each other in such different ways. And the love theme is but one strand and it mostly just simmers under the surface of the story and remains ambiguous to the very end.
The three main characters have known each other since childhood and hav ...more
The three main characters have known each other since childhood and hav ...more
Amazing. Helen Dunmore's writing is rich, powerful and compelling. She is the master of the crescendo ending, fantastic at pacing and overall just so outstanding.
...more
Helen Dunmore is on top form with her latest novel. It’s a beautifully written and accomplished novel set in Cornwall in 1920. Daniel Branwell arrives home from the trenches, physically unscathed but emotionally and psychologically damaged. His mother died while he was away and he finds refuge with old and solitary Mary Pascoe, who lets him build a shelter on her small-holding in exchange for some practical help. But although the war is over, he can find no real peace here, for he remains haunte
...more
I've read a lot of both fiction and non-fiction around the First World War as it loomed large in my family.
I'd not come across Helen Dunmore before, but her skill at vividly evoking the horror of the trenches and the tortured soul that is the tragic and shell-shocked survivor Daniel is remarkable.
Her prose is poetic and deserves lingering over, but I found myself unable to put it down as I raced towards the end of the book. I've visited some of those muddy fields only recently and her words cont ...more
I'd not come across Helen Dunmore before, but her skill at vividly evoking the horror of the trenches and the tortured soul that is the tragic and shell-shocked survivor Daniel is remarkable.
Her prose is poetic and deserves lingering over, but I found myself unable to put it down as I raced towards the end of the book. I've visited some of those muddy fields only recently and her words cont ...more
I have long been an admirer of Helen Dunmore and am pleased to say that I greatly enjoyed her latest work. Obviously it is the Centenary of the First World War and so there are bound to be many books about such a cataclysmic historical event which changed Europe, and the people involved, forever. This is a moving read, but events and memories are unravelled slowly – almost poetically – and it is not a book to rush, but to savour and think about.
Daniel Branwell returns to his home in Cornwall aft ...more
Daniel Branwell returns to his home in Cornwall aft ...more
"They say the war's over, but they're wrong. It went too deep for that"
Dunmore has become one of our great contemporary writers: this short, sharp story revisits WW1, both the trenches and the dreadful aftermath as Daniel Branwell tries to rebuild some kind of life for himself after the war.
This is a very literary novel which deliberately uses literature itself to frame both this text, and the story contained within it. From the opening scene the ghosts of Homeric warriors invade this book as D ...more
Dunmore has become one of our great contemporary writers: this short, sharp story revisits WW1, both the trenches and the dreadful aftermath as Daniel Branwell tries to rebuild some kind of life for himself after the war.
This is a very literary novel which deliberately uses literature itself to frame both this text, and the story contained within it. From the opening scene the ghosts of Homeric warriors invade this book as D ...more
This was pretty close to 5 stars for me, something I rarely award fiction. My first Helen Dunmore, but I already have another on my wish list. Beautifully written, told in the first person, it is a poignant and moving story which flows seamlessly between events during the Great War and the aftermath. Usually when a story flicks backwards and forwards in time, the changes are delineated by chapters or scene markers. In this story, because we hear it through the main protagonist's thoughts, the ch
...more
A brilliant book. It was a page-turner, but not in the typical sense. I found myself having to stop reading at times, in order to digest the mood and fully appreciate the prose. Helen Dunmore captures the post-WW1 trauma quite magnificently. The protagonist's experience of the war and his relationship with Frederick is delivered in droplets through memories and flashbacks.
It's 1920 now, but is the war really over? He still lives it every day; it's just a different kind of battle. He still sees, ...more
It's 1920 now, but is the war really over? He still lives it every day; it's just a different kind of battle. He still sees, ...more
So far there seems to only be one other review of this book, and to be honest the only point at which I can concur with the other reviewer is in the comparison with The Absolutist; the two books really are rather similar in tone. Apart from that point I disagree with every other aspect of my rival reviewer's opinion. This is a rather lovely, heartbreaking book, which focuses mainly on the aftermath of years spent in the trenches. Daniel has returned 'home' to the far west of Cornwall, and has fo
...more
I heard The author speak at a literary lunch otherwise I certainly wouldn't have read the book. I'm glad I did. It is a slow moving book reminiscent of how it must have felt in the trenches where progress was agonisingly slow. The theme of lies permeates the book, big and little lies that lies are lived around and affected by. The silence of those who fought in the First World War, my grandfather survived the trenches and never spoke a word of it, but the reverberations of those times stay with
...more
I found Helen Dunmore’s The Lie a puzzling book. Certainly it is well written. The main character, Daniel a shell shocked soldier from WWI, is drawn with finesse and art. Puzzling however is the homo-erotic sub theme of the almost “the love that has no name.” Did Daniel really have the hots for his friend? Is the chaste kiss between two soldiers a telling enough point to make a valid raison d’etre for a whole book? I don’t think so.
The scenes from Cornwall run true and deep. The other characters ...more
The scenes from Cornwall run true and deep. The other characters ...more
I didn't finish this one simply because it skipped around so much I couldn't get into it enough. The story was interesting to a point but just not enough. I made it 32% through within a week and a half. I normally don't take that long to read/listen to a book. (Listened via Libby/Overdrive)
...more
I so wanted to love ‘The Lie.’ I have loved her writing for years, ever since curiosity led me to pick up a copy of ‘Burning Bright.’ I was captivated by a story that was a little out of the ordinary, and by words that were used so well, to create such vivid images. I knew then, and the books that followed confirmed, that she was a special author, and author to seek out …..
And I did love ‘The Lie’, but not quite as much as I hoped that I might.
It tells the story of Daniel, who fought in the Grea ...more
And I did love ‘The Lie’, but not quite as much as I hoped that I might.
It tells the story of Daniel, who fought in the Grea ...more
For the centenary marking the outbreak of the Great War, Helen Dunmore has developed one of the few remaining neglected themes: the aftermath of the return from the trenches. Bright working class Cornishman Daniel is already an outsider in that he has spent his childhood playing with the children of a local landowner. Too poor to attend grammar school, he is self taught from secretly borrowing books from the wealthy man's library. Outwardly uninjured but destitute, he is allowed to squat on the
...more
The title of this book can be interpreted in many ways, as revealed by the poignant quotation at the beginning;
'If any question why we died
Tell them, because our fathers lied'.
This beautiful novel is about the aftermath of war particularly for the main protagonists, Dan and Felicia, both doubly bereaved. Dan, the narrator, a 'survivor' of WW1, although physically unharmed was mentally traumatised. Despite this he was clearly a very able and gifted person in many ways and the sense of his missed ...more
'If any question why we died
Tell them, because our fathers lied'.
This beautiful novel is about the aftermath of war particularly for the main protagonists, Dan and Felicia, both doubly bereaved. Dan, the narrator, a 'survivor' of WW1, although physically unharmed was mentally traumatised. Despite this he was clearly a very able and gifted person in many ways and the sense of his missed ...more
Jan 27, 2015
Lisa
rated it
it was ok
·
review of another edition
Recommended to Lisa by:
Naomi (The Writes of Women)
It seems it’s not possible to read The Lie without comparing it to Pat Barker’s Regeneration Trilogy, which I think is one of the finest attempts to render the horror of World War I in fiction. Malcolm Forbes, who reviewed it for The Australian, thought that:
Pat Barker matches her for historical accuracy and the ability to delve deep into the human psyche, but Dunmore’s haunting, lyrical and mesmeric prose to describe carnage and loss elevates her into a different league. (The Weekend Australian ...more
Pat Barker matches her for historical accuracy and the ability to delve deep into the human psyche, but Dunmore’s haunting, lyrical and mesmeric prose to describe carnage and loss elevates her into a different league. (The Weekend Australian ...more
I've read most of Helen Dunmore's novels, but her recent ones haven't bowled me over, this one included. I found it a depressing read. I didn't feel much empathy for Dan and regarded his actions as rather foolish. His relationship with Felicia left me frustrated, urging him to 'just get on with it'! I didn't find his feelings for Frederick particularly convincing either. There is very little plot here and the ending left me feeling 'so what'? It's very well written, as you'd expect from Dunmore
...more
Daniel is a survivor of WWI living with his nightmares and his memories of his seemingly single love of Frederick a childhood friend from a much wealthier family. Daniel has returned to Cornwall and lives on a rundown farm that is near Frederick's old home now owned by his sister Felicity who was briefly married and has a child.
Daniel has haunting flashbacks to the trenches and of the day Frederick dies. This is when the writing is at its best. The sights, sounds and smells of this horrible time ...more
Daniel has haunting flashbacks to the trenches and of the day Frederick dies. This is when the writing is at its best. The sights, sounds and smells of this horrible time ...more
Cornwall, England, 1920. Daniel has returned from the war to his poor hometown. His mother has died, he lost his best friend in the war and he has no where to live. He helps out an elderly woman with her farm and camps out there. When the old woman dies, he takes over the cottage. He is reunited with an old childhood friend and things start to turnaround, a little. Very sad, very profound. Writing was excellent. Very heartfelt.
Hypnotic and haunted. There's a thin narrative, but it's broken up by memory, hallucination and ghosts. A poem of a novel.
...more
I will also do a video review here at my channel: http://www.youtube.com/magicofbooks
"The Lie" by Helen Dunmore takes place in 1920s Cornwall, following Daniel Branwell who has survived the trenches of war. He lives his days in solitude, working on the land, but he cannot forget the horrors that he survived and the best friend that he lost.
First, I won this through Goodreads Giveaways.
I was really hoping this would be a 5-star book. Let me say this: this is not a bad book. If anything, the writi ...more
"The Lie" by Helen Dunmore takes place in 1920s Cornwall, following Daniel Branwell who has survived the trenches of war. He lives his days in solitude, working on the land, but he cannot forget the horrors that he survived and the best friend that he lost.
First, I won this through Goodreads Giveaways.
I was really hoping this would be a 5-star book. Let me say this: this is not a bad book. If anything, the writi ...more
This is her newest and I loved this novel about the Great War. No wonder all the shouting about this author. I have read so many fine novels set during/after the First World War from all sorts of perspectives. Be warned, this is very sad. Dunmore enters the mind of a deeply damaged veteran of the war.
The story is told from the point of view of Daniel Bramwell, home from the war in 1920 and eking out a living on the farm of a woman locally regarded as a witch. He cares for her, buries her when s ...more
The story is told from the point of view of Daniel Bramwell, home from the war in 1920 and eking out a living on the farm of a woman locally regarded as a witch. He cares for her, buries her when s ...more
Another deeply moving book by a writer who never disappoints. Few characters invade this book leaving it clear to concentrate on our hero whose flashbacks to the trenches, the loss of his childhood friend and his torment post war, are at times hard to bear.
Skillfully written this book nevertheless lacks any edge of seat excitement. It is like a beautiful painting, in front of which we stand, stare, wonder and move on.
Skillfully written this book nevertheless lacks any edge of seat excitement. It is like a beautiful painting, in front of which we stand, stare, wonder and move on.
A quite nice, diverting read.
A bit depressing, but nonetheless intriguing for the war pictures the author manages to paint.
Not quite sure about the point of the story. Maybe there is no point. Just the same pointlessness war possesses. Who knows.
Although I find the blurb a bit misleading. The Lie (in my opinion) is not at all the centre of the story. It leads to the end, but the end was inevitable anyhow so ...
A bit depressing, but nonetheless intriguing for the war pictures the author manages to paint.
Not quite sure about the point of the story. Maybe there is no point. Just the same pointlessness war possesses. Who knows.
Although I find the blurb a bit misleading. The Lie (in my opinion) is not at all the centre of the story. It leads to the end, but the end was inevitable anyhow so ...
Beautifully written and a fast read. It might not be in the same league as Pat Barker's Regeneration trilogy about WW1 but I enjoyed it and will watch for further titles from Helen Dunmore. http://izzyreads.com/accomplished-wor...
...more
How a lie can have such consequences. Kept jumping backwards and forwards, so a bit comfusing in places. Not quite as good as other Helen Dunmore I have read.
May 16, 2020
Ape
rated it
liked it
·
review of another edition
Shelves:
england,
history-first-world-war
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it,
click here.
There are no discussion topics on this book yet.
Be the first to start one »
Readers also enjoyed
I was born in December 1952, in Yorkshire, the second of four children. My father was the eldest of twelve, and this extended family has no doubt had a strong influence on my life, as have my own children. In a large family you hear a great many stories. You also come to understand very early that stories hold quite different meanings for different listeners, and can be recast from many viewpoints
...more
Related Articles
Mateo Askaripour is a Brooklyn-based writer whose debut novel, Black Buck—which Colson Whitehead calls a “mesmerizing novel, executing a high...
68 likes · 7 comments
2 trivia questions
More quizzes & trivia...
