Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read.
Start by marking “Mary Queen of Scotland and The Isles” as Want to Read:
Mary Queen of Scotland and The Isles
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating
Open Preview

Mary Queen of Scotland and The Isles

4.06  ·  Rating details ·  12,676 ratings  ·  595 reviews
Mary, Queen of Scotland and the Isles is the story of a woman born to rule a nation -- and the glorious pageant of love and tragedy that followed in her wake. Mary's beauty inspired poetry -- yet her birthright engendered hideous treachery and terrible, bloody murder. This novel is Margaret George's magnificent recreation of the life of one of history's greatest legends. A ...more
Paperback, 880 pages
Published May 10th 2012 by Pan MacMillan (first published January 1st 1992)
More Details... Edit Details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.
This book is not yet featured on Listopia. Add this book to your favorite list »

Community Reviews

Showing 1-30
Average rating 4.06  · 
Rating details
 ·  12,676 ratings  ·  595 reviews

More filters
Sort order
Start your review of Mary Queen of Scotland and The Isles
I was 17 years old with an honor student's workload. For some reason I decided to take on an 870 page epic. Even for someone who likes to read, any Margaret George book takes real commitment. For most people that commitment becomes effortless and will last a lifetime.

Something happened when I first read this novel. I was lost in it. I devoured it. It's haunted me ever since. I read it again every few years, and visit it like an old friend. The characters are dynamic, genuine, and tortured (somet
Dec 18, 2019 rated it it was amazing  ·  review of another edition
It took almost a year because other books got in the way. Now I am finally done.

This was a wonderfully written piece of historical fiction about one of the most misunderstood monarchs of Scotland.

When you get started on this, make sure that other books don’t get in the way. It is a chunkster that requires time to complete and savour. I’m glad I took the time to finish this one.
Unfortunately, higher-ranking females named Mary didn’t fare quite so well in British history and Mary, Queen of Scots, was no exception. From queen at a few days old, to France, back to Scotland, and then imprisoned and beheaded in England; Margaret George reveals Mary Stuart’s life in, “Mary: Queen of Scotland and the Isles”.

Those readers familiar with George’s novels will find that “Mary” sticks to the usual stylistic format from the author. George begins “Mary” somewhat slowly using a crawl
Rio (Lynne)
First off, you need to be either in the mood for this book or be very interested in Mary Queen of Scots. If I'd picked this up a year ago, I would have skimmed to the end. I visited Scotland in January and hit pretty much every place that Mary had been. I've never been a fan of Mary, but after standing in the rooms where Riccio was murdered, James was born and where Darnley came to his demise, I was ready to read more on Mary. I first tried "Immortal Queen" but lost interest due to the fluff. I ...more
Aug 08, 2011 rated it it was amazing  ·  review of another edition
Well..... I finally finished it. Whew! 870 pages worth. And, you know... I really got immersed in it. There is a family tree at the beginning as well as a couple of maps of England and Scotland with significant castles and cities noted. I consulted them A LOT as I made my way through Mary's life. The author spares no details - when Mary goes outside or looks out her window or eats a meal, we hear about the flower petals and the birdsong and the scents on the breeze and the texture of the clouds ...more
Only if you are a die-hard Mary fan. In no way am I knocking the author or her research (LOVED the auto-bio of Henry VIII), but I lost interest about 1/3 the way through and only finished it by using it as a book to pass the time on the treadmill with . Maybe it is just me, as I love historical fiction and would typically devour a book like this in no time, particularly anything to do with the Tudors.

I just couldn't get into Mary's trials and tribulations, as I found her to be silly, vapid and
Carol Storm
Jan 25, 2012 rated it it was amazing  ·  review of another edition
Margaret George has rescued Mary from the history books and brought her to life as a vibrant, compelling, and astonishingly modern heroine. This Mary talks and thinks like a modern woman, yet her actions are absolutely true to the spirit of the times and the known facts about her life.

Sometimes the language is a bit too modern, as when Mary describes her gorgeous husband Lord Darnley as "looking good enough to eat" during their wedding feast. And the sex scenes leave absolutely nothing to the i
Jun 09, 2016 rated it it was amazing  ·  review of another edition
Mary, Queen of Scots, was the last Roman Catholic ruler of Scotland.
The tale of this beautiful woman, is one of the great tragedies of British history.
Margaret George, in this long book, brings Mary, and the Scotland, France and England of her time to life.
A sympathetic, but not idealistic portrayal of Mary as a woman who was warmhearted , loyal, brave, generous and spirited, but also unable to read character,volatile and impulsive.
The book takes us from Mary's birth, and her coronation as Queen
Only at the end of a life could the pattern be discerned; only then was there a completed weaving to be seen. And hers was this: since the moment of her birth, she had been an inconvenient person, a person who did not fit in, who ruined other people's tidy patterns.

Well written and extremely informative, this was just too long. I would have enjoyed this much more if there were fewer pages of people riding on horses, on their way somewhere. I was also suprised by the romance writing (lots of puls
Aww, man. I wanted to like this book. I just couldn't.

Mary was a drag. I couldn't really relate to her. We got an occasional glimpse into her feelings, but it was always very external. While it's told largely from her perspective (though not in first person), she still feels distant as a human being. We're told she's beautiful. We're told she's athletic. We're told she's a devout Catholic, and that part was pretty solid. Not only did the author establish her religion, but she made it a part of h
James Burns
Mary Queen of Scotland and the Isles is a wonderful Historical novel which captures the essence of Mary and her historical trials and tribulations. After being crowned Queen of Scotland as a baby with her mother as Regent, she was then betrothed to the Dauphin of France and was sent to France to live her betrothed's Family the king and Queen of France. when she was around 18 and Francis I was 17, Francis I ascended to the Throne of France after his father, Henry II was killed while jousting. Mar ...more
Jun 03, 2009 rated it did not like it  ·  review of another edition
Recommends it for: no one
Shelves: england
Ug! I knew it was too good to be true that I should enjoy historical fiction. Remember the old granny in COLD COMFORT FARM that saw something nasty in the woodshed? Well, I know what she saw. She saw page 304 of this damn book! There I was minding my own business halfway thru this not terrible novel when I of a sudden i saw something beyond nasty. I stopped reading just in time but the imagery haunted my eyes the rest of the day. I was completely irritated. Why in the hell would the writer, of n ...more
Oct 04, 2012 rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
I hadn't known too much about the details of Mary, Queen of Scots' life, so this book was really enjoyable and informative. I found myself advocating for Mary, then becoming frustrated with her decision making as she moved toward what I knew was going to be her demise. I was pleased to learn that, of the 200 characters in the book, all of them were real figures in history, so it seems Margaret George is a top notch historical writer. I also enjoyed hearing her (Margaret George) brief analysis o ...more
I am a big fan of Margaret George and have enjoyed the books she has written immensely. Mary Queen of Scots however missed the mark with me. Too often this book degraded into Harlequin romancesque passages. There were times I closed the book to look at the front cover to be certain a shirtless Fabio wasn’t on it. I think I could have over looked that aspect of the book if the rest of it had kept me enraptured. However large amounts of the book outside the bosom heaving love making passages were ...more
Sep 26, 2012 rated it liked it  ·  review of another edition
The life of Mary Queen of Scots is perhaps history's greatest soap opera. It is impossible to make her story dull, although, when reading this novel, I sometimes had the feeling that George was trying her hardest to disprove that fact. True, Mary was a prisoner for twenty years, but did George have to spend what felt like twenty years describing it?

I wish the author had spent less time on the latter half of Mary's life, and more on her years in Scotland, particularly where her relationship with
Mary Queen of Scots led a fascinating life, which is described in captivating detail in George's book. Despite the commitment the length of this book demands, every page held a piece of Scottish history I wanted to understand.

Mary can be a very controversial historical figure. So I imagine writing about her life can create much debate for the author, either representing her in a good or bad light. However, I respected George's interpretation, even more so once reading her notes at the end of the
I want to finish this but I'm struggling. I always find with George's books, there are slow bits inbetween the exciting bits. Even though one of her books is among my favorites (Autobiography of Henry VIII), her work seems to be hit and miss with me because I couldn't finish "Mary, Called Magdalene" and now this one I'm finding the slow bits are more frequent than they should be.

There was also one scene that I thought really wasn't necessary and took the idea of "creative license" too liberally.
Apr 06, 2011 rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
This was a great read! Perfect for the beach, as it was easy to dip in and out of. As an historical fiction junkie, it was super. The story, which I was not very familiar with, was fascinating. Filled with intrigue, betrayal, and the politics of the day, I remained interested most of the time, only losing interest occasionally in scenes filled with intense battle descriptions or the like. Mary had a life marked by much sadness and disappointment, but throughout it all, she kept a sense of almost ...more
Tina Pino
Mar 09, 2014 rated it it was amazing  ·  review of another edition
Shelves: favorites
I went back and forth on whether to give four or five stars. During most of the book, it was like traveling back in time, and having a secret hiding place, watching history unfold through a tiny window, but never actually being inside the room. Although it kept me very interested throughout, it didn't become a page turner for me until about halfway through. I didn't have that breathless magical feeling I get when I finish a five star novel that truly moves me. However, the amount of work that mu ...more
Janet Wertman
I liked it. Didn't love it, but I liked it well enough. I love Margaret George as a writer - her Autobiography of Henry VIII was outstanding. I love long books - Shogun is my favorite book of all time. This one did not quite sing like those, it went on a bit in places, it used a lot of POVs, it slipped a few modern elements into the narrative, but it was a well-told story for people who like the period.
Tabea Vanessa
I DID IT!!!!!! I finished this monater of a book before the year is over! WHOOOOOHOOOOOO
I actually really liked the first 2/3rds of this and it would have been a 4 star read. The last 400 pages dragged on like nothing else though. This story could have been told in 600 pages if you ask me.
But you guys also know that I like fast moving plots so yeah.
Linda Byers
Dec 13, 2019 rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
Her best book.
Review to come
I want to give this book five stars but the fact that it took me nearly 2 years to finish makes me think I shouldn't. a 4.5 perhaps? But I really enjoyed reading this when I was reading it. Margaret George makes, what could have been a dense and sluggish novel, very easy to read! I look forward to reading her take on Elizabeth I and Henry VIII.

(TW: this next section of the review has mentions of rape)

It's interesting to see the way that Mary is portrayed in the different interpretations of her
Tara Chevrestt
Margaret George does a tremendous job bringing to life the times and characters and the drama surrounding the legendary Mary, Queen of Scots. I finally have a lot of questions answered regarding this woman's mysterious history. I like the way this book tells of her entire life, not just her captivity in England in which all she does in other novels is write letters and whine. BUT, once I reached page 500, I had enough, and no offense to Margaret George, I simply cannot stand Mary, Queen of Scots ...more
Aug 15, 2012 rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
After reading and viewing several biographical accounts of Queen Elizabeth I, I became intrigued by the life of Mary Queen of Scots who usually figured as a minor actor in the Virgin Queen's story. In this 870 page tome, Mary is the central figure with Elizabeth the minor, yet incredibly powerful, character who ultimately determines Mary's fate.

Well-researched and well-written, Margaret George depicts in full but not exhausting detail the lifestyle, political and religious climates of not only S
Dec 21, 2008 rated it liked it  ·  review of another edition
If only history courses in school were taught via historical novels.. It's so much easier to remember a period in history when you can become emotionally involved with the characters! I very much enjoyed reading this (long, but definitely a page turner) book, though it lacked a depth that many good novels have. I suppose some depth must be sacrificed in order to stick to the facts as much as possible. I never quite figured out how I felt about Mary, which is part of the point since her true char ...more
Sara Giacalone
Jul 24, 2009 rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
I've had this book for years and for the life of me can't figure out why it took me so long to read it, especially as I enjoyed "The Autobiography of Henry VIII". Once I cracked it open, it took me no time to become hooked and I really enjoyed Margaret George's interpretation of Mary Queen of Scotland. After reading numerous factual books about the time period and the events, it was satisfying to read a more intimate, emotional portrayal of her life and times. Yes, the book is a bit long and has ...more
Rebecca Huston
One of the better novelizations of Mary, Queen of Scots from the cradle to the grave. While this is a -very- long-winded novel, at least the author refrains from the more extravagant silliness that seems to have taken over the historical novel market. For that alone this one deserves a second look. The prose is readable, and the facts more or less in place. The Mary here is foolhardy, more wanting to be loved than involved in politics, but unfortunately, she was born in the wrong time and place. ...more
Oct 14, 2010 rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
Another book of historical goodness! This was the second book I read by George. It was a little daunting to go from the long Autobiography of Henry VIII to another long tale of Queen Mary, but I was eager and excited nonetheless. I really enjoy George's ability to take historical facts and mold them together with fiction to create an account of a life that might be both interesting to history buffs or boring to someone not that interested in history.
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 next »
topics  posts  views  last activity   
Please Add: "Naked Scotland: An American Insider Bares All" 1 2 Feb 22, 2018 12:45PM  
Goodreads Librari...: Add number of pages 8 14 Oct 29, 2017 09:18PM  
Dorothy Dunnett B...: Mary Queen of Scotland and The Isles 1 9 Jun 02, 2017 04:52PM  

Readers also enjoyed

  • Captive Queen: A Novel of Eleanor of Aquitaine
  • I, Elizabeth
  • Time and Chance (Henry II & Eleanor of Aquitaine, #2)
  • Lionheart (Plantagenets #4)
  • The Confessions of Catherine de Medici
  • When Christ and His Saints Slept  (Henry II and Eleanor of Aquitaine, #1)
  • The Lady Elizabeth
  • Devil's Brood  (Henry II & Eleanor of Aquitaine, #3)
  • Henry VIII: The King and His Court
  • The Reckoning  (Welsh Princes, #3)
  • Legacy
  • Here Be Dragons (Welsh Princes, #1)
  • The Last Boleyn
  • Falls the Shadow  (Welsh Princes, #2)
  • The Other Queen (The Plantagenet and Tudor Novels, #15)
  • Jane Boleyn: The True Story of the Infamous Lady Rochford
  • The Secret Diary of Anne Boleyn
  • Lonesome Dove  (Part 1 of 3)
See similar books…
Margaret George is a rolling stone who has lived in many places, beginning her traveling at the age of four when her father joined the U.S. diplomatic service and was posted to a consulate in Taiwan. The family traveled on a freighter named after Ulysses' son Telemachus that took thirty days to reach Taiwan, where they spent two years. Following that they lived in Tel Aviv (right after the 1948 wa ...more

News & Interviews

It’s October, which means it’s the perfect time to scare yourself with a truly unsettling book. But if you’re a casual reader of dread and...
216 likes · 67 comments
“The cure for a broken heart is simple, my lady. A hot bath and a good night's sleep.” 60 likes
“I had a desire to see something besides my own shores, if only to be content to return to them someday. If I wish to live in my native land and love her, it should not be out of ignorance.” 33 likes
More quotes…