Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Sacrifices Arc #4

Freedom And Not Peace

Rate this book
Fandom: Harry Potter
--------------------------------------------------
AU of GoF, Slytherin!Harry. Training his brother, negotiating with former Death Eaters, juggling responsibility and duty...Harry's life is running away with him, as he struggles to balance.

2226 pages, ebook

First published March 4, 2006

35 people are currently reading
130 people want to read

About the author

Lightning on the Wave

8 books79 followers
Also known as Limyaael.

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
216 (58%)
4 stars
113 (30%)
3 stars
32 (8%)
2 stars
8 (2%)
1 star
2 (<1%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 31 reviews
Profile Image for Julesmarie.
2,504 reviews88 followers
July 13, 2017
This world is becoming increasingly intricate and detailed and fascinating (and marvelous and heartbreaking!). Another reviewer said of the series as a whole she had never read such a well-crafted fantasy world, even compared with Lord of the Rings and the original Harry Potter, and I'm coming to agree more and more with that the further I get in the series. Although, I'd compare it more to the Wheel of Time series by Robert Jordan given that it's the number and depth of the characters that makes it increasingly intricate.

I'm fascinated by how all of these minor characters in canon have evolved and developed in the AU into real, believable, relateable people. We have PoV sections from Narcissa Malfoy, Rufus Scrimgeour, Pansy Parkinson and her mother Hawthorne, Milicent Bulstrode, Professor McGonnagal, Arabella Zabini (Blaise's mother), and others that I can't even remember right now. And they all have things to say that impact Harry and this AU. It's remarkable, fascinating, and unbelievably impressive.

Reading this series has been such an interesting experience. In this book alone I went from wanting to declare it as my new favorite thing I've ever read to hating it and being very, VERY tempted to stop reading not only this story but the whole series. Reading something that can get me so emotionally involved is such an incredible experience, and has been both delightful and draining.

I'm still tempted to declare this as being among my very favorite things I've ever read... Honestly, I know I'm a sap for virutally any version of any Draco and any Harry ending up together, but THIS Draco and THIS Harry are just so spectacularly perfect and beautiful together!

I have to admit, though, that having the author suddenly announce at the beginning of chapter 61 that it turns out she was wrong about the end of book 2 being the darkest chapter she'd ever written and that she expected some people to simply stop reading after that chapter made me feel a little betrayed. The end of book 2 was so tough to read, and I have to be honest that one of the big reasons I'd continued with the series was the assurance that it was all uphill from there. I'm not a good sport when it comes to having characters I love broken or tortured or put into these unimaginably horrific situations. And not since the end of the book 1984, have I read a scene so difficult to get through as that one.

However, I did keep reading (partly because I'm terribly stubborn and refused to stop reading just because of the author note predicting that so many readers would... :P) and I have to say that the ending more than made up for what I'd had to go through with Harry in that graveyard. I've been thinking since about redemption and beauty and how they both seem brighter or more possible after darkness and pain. And the beauty of that last scene was exactly perfect to balance out what came before it. It made accompanying Harry on his journey so far not only seem worth it, but even more special. Fantastically beautifully done.

I am a little leery of what else the author may have in store in the future, but I've now lost any thought of stopping reading. On to story #5!

Favorite Quotes:
If I have to have other voices in my head, they should at least think thoughts I wouldn't have.

"They intended it as a humiliation, yes, a reminder of my 'proper place,' but that doesn't mean I need to take it that way. They can insult me only if I let them."

Lean on our strength when you must, and then stand and go on. There is no shame in this, ever."

He shone joy when he was happy, shone rage when he was angry, and in general acted like a living window on a marvelous land.

And out of the trees came the other unicorns, their legs bending like reeds, their necks bobbing like swans courting, every step light enough to be a dance. They gathered, and then they began to gallop, an enormous, turning circle around Harry and Draco, each one blazing like a stained-glass window with the sun shining through it, gratified and fulfilled and exalted.

"I promise you, I'll be here if you wake or sleep, cry or don't. I'll do anything for you right now, except let you go or leave."

before Draco could even react to him sounding as if he'd put exclamation marks after every single one of his sentences

And all those little things like worrying when Draco was angry and preferring him to most people and not wanting him hurt and being able to dare to kiss him back when I would have run away from anyone else are all right, they're perfectly all right, and oh Merlin I was wrong and this is all right and I can have a future I can have a life I can have love…

Harry took a deep breath. "Thank you," he whispered, one more time. "I'll try to remember. I don't know if I can—" already the sheer clarity of the memories was rushing away from him, obscured by the mask of time and everyday reality, as visions and inspirations tended to be—"but I'll try."

Gryffindors and Slytherins can get along fine, I think. It's just Gryffindors and Malfoys who don't."

He could do this. He could go on.
And some things were not his fault.
Profile Image for Kate.
367 reviews27 followers
February 18, 2014
I managed to read eighty chapters of this godforsaken book without loosing it, but it's the last six that I'm having to push myself through; it's like being dragged over shrapnel. Harry's brain is not fun. His ragged and gaping emotional wounds are pulling me down too and it hurts. The author is a big liar. She said in a previous book her writing wouldn't get any darker, but that was a lie. This is dark dipped in angst, smothered in self-laothing, sprinkled with sad, and topped off with disfigurement. I can see why people would just stop reading her series at this point; it hurts, and most readers only like so much pain in their reading pleasure. I'm a hairsbreadth from crying uncle myself. But I doubt I will. I'll put it aside for a night or so, but I know I'll be back for more. The writing is too brilliant and I find fantasy of this caliber so infrequently I won't be able to stay away.

And I didn't. I finished it. Phew.
Profile Image for Janina.
554 reviews10 followers
April 26, 2013
Even though it's "just" Fanfiction, I consider this series one of the greatest works of fantasy ever written. It goes far beyond the original books in complexity of the world, its characters and the overall story arc. It moves me like few other books do. Some parts are horrible to read and I don't mean the gore that is present in FANP and the later books. It's such a thorough and intelligent description of emotional abuse and what it leads to. Of what a world with magic and magical creatures could really be like. Of the way we grow up and the struggles that come with being a teen and an adult or anything in between. If I could give only one book five stars, this (or one of the series) would be it.
Profile Image for Anna Kļaviņa.
817 reviews206 followers
December 15, 2015
Harry/Draco preslash
Slytherin!Harry
Mentor!Snape
AU

Unbelievably good.

Harry is slowly recovering from his "training". Draco and Connor are slowly growing up. And Snape is growing more attached to Harry, ready to .

Lovely imaginary and characters.

Favourite characters: Rufus, The Malfoys (especially Narcissa), the Parkinsons (Pansy's parents are awesome), Millicent, Minerva, Regulus, Evan and of course Harry and Snape.
Profile Image for Marta Silva.
152 reviews16 followers
September 5, 2016
Although I was upset with Harry a lot of times, obviously since some of the decisions he makes made me want to punch him, I loved it! It was a beautiful story, very long but very beautiful, with extremely sweet moments.
Profile Image for Kate.
270 reviews19 followers
May 13, 2015

Ah, fan fiction. It draws you in with the fully-realized alternate universe, wonderful writing, characters who are distinct from the original versions in interesting ways, thrilling plots, and basically all-around excellence.



Then, in the fourth book (yes, full-length BOOK, of which there are SEVEN), they throw the Harry/Draco slash at you.



And I'm not even mad. Because it developed slowly (it was sort of obviously hinted at in the last book, if not all of the previous ones), it's not the main focus (it's barely even a thing. They kissed like twice in a 700-page book), and most importantly, it makes sense in context. Because so many fanfictions try to shoehorn this shit in, or they write something specifically to focus on the relationship (which is admittedly a completely different genre of fanfiction. I just would have been really disappointed if that was what this series turned into).



I think the gore thing was overstated. So many unnecessary warnings about how intense the last few chapters were. Seriously. They're not that bad. Yes, horrible injuries are sustained and lots of pain is felt, but the description isn't that graphic. I suppose the mere presence of the violence could be gross or uncomfortable or triggering for some people. But I promise, it's not that bad.



I guess my only real criticism is that everyone in this series is more than they seem. Harry, okay, he's the main character and his incredible power is the point. I don't have an issue with that. But if anyone seems weak or you might tend to underestimate them, they're going to surprise you. Is anyone actually just kinda weak and pathetic? I'm just waiting for to have a serious badass moment, because he kinda deserves it.

Profile Image for S.
642 reviews
July 29, 2013
This story holds all the secret untold suspicions and admirations I held reading the original series, and uses them as base-lines for things far far greater than I could ever hope. Every time I come across another aspect of revealing prose and sharp wit, I'm extremely pleased and firm in my decision that yes, Lighting on the Wave is BEST.
The pacing is roaring and ripping, extremely engaging.

*The call of powerful wizards:
*The Necromancer and the Songstress:
*Draco's affections:
*Triwizard Tourniment:
*Magical heirs:
*Walpurgis Night:
*Fawkes:


quotes:
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for Dan.
436 reviews3 followers
December 1, 2024
I was not expecting this to take me two whole months, jeez.

This book is the best so far in terms of character growth—Draco and Connor both finally become characters I like rather than annoying. We get some great worldbuilding especially in terms of Light wizard minhag, and the plot itself obviously goes into overdrive. A lot gorier than I remembered.
Profile Image for Tea and Spite.
415 reviews12 followers
September 30, 2024
This is not quite my favourite TSA story but it's pretty close. The characters and world have come together enough to not be jarring, the writing quality has quite obviously improved, and while there are continued issues with pacing and dropped plots they're mostly made up for by great worldbuilding. The main reason it doesn't get another star is that I just...do not care about the climax.

LotW is still trying to write to the canon beats here and that's just not what makes the series interesting. The violence of the climax comes across as gratuitous rather than enhancing the overall arc of the story and series as a whole. The series is really at its best when it's allowed to flow into its own form with only the occasional mild nod to canon (as it starts to in the next story).
Profile Image for a.
309 reviews1 follower
on-the-train-to-nopeville
October 3, 2016
I want to finish this, I really do. But it's never going to happen.
Profile Image for Alicia.
408 reviews9 followers
August 11, 2021
I can't read this fast enough. I keep trying to skip parts to read faster. Ok, some times people were being dumb, but I love this story anyways. Draco is probably the part that bothers me the most. I just don't get him all the time. I think Snape was totally right about him in the beginning of this book about him needing to be more his own person. But that didn't really get fixed after the aftermath of Snape's actions play out.

I am very happy with how Connor's progressed. He was pretty supportive and is maturing instead of there being another blowout between the twins. I think I would have been pissed if that happened again.

And the end gets so dark. Oh, Harry! I am breaking for you. Please change your mind and go to the Sanctuary.
Profile Image for Jennifer Faythe.
2 reviews
June 26, 2025
I adore this series. I am only reviewing to really just explain to people just how long this series is (not in a bad way!!) all of the books in this series is about 1,000 pages longer than all of the books in the wheel of time series put together. We are talking 12,878 words for this lovely series. And yet somehow I've reread this series already. It's such a good read I genuinely didn't notice the length of time spent with the series but it is just that interesting and entertaining. I hope more people find this series and isn't scared off by the length.
Profile Image for Chalilodimun Angel.
142 reviews4 followers
June 29, 2021
Definitely my favorite book so far! I really really liked it, it was so well-written and Harry is baby. My poor boy… *sigh* I can't wait to read the rest!

I can't believe I read 500k in so little time, so worth it!
Profile Image for Sean Randall.
2,120 reviews54 followers
August 22, 2022
These have totally veered into mega alternate universe land now, the Goblet of Fire itself being a comparatively minor thing in this massive tome of a work. The writing is just so ... moreish. Addictive. Compelling in a poetic sort of a way.
Profile Image for Dominique.
407 reviews53 followers
September 17, 2018
This went from 0 to dark REALLY quickly...

But I am loving this series, and even though they are coming up to over 700000 words per story, I will keep reading it.
Profile Image for Tobe.
818 reviews2 followers
May 4, 2020
Very, very long. Worth it, but reading straight through it can drag at times. I imagine as a serial it works better.
Profile Image for Romi.
7 reviews7 followers
May 16, 2021
De los libros más crudos hasta el momento. Lo peor es que sé que vendrán cosas más sangrientas, pero estoy ansiosa de leerlas porque la calidad lo vale.
Profile Image for gabriella.
89 reviews13 followers
November 16, 2022
so. Good!!! Really like this one, this is where i started taking notes on world building
Profile Image for Oliwia (Diana).
52 reviews
June 28, 2023
i'm unwell, i want to cry and throw up and i don't know if i'll ever recover from this series
4 reviews
July 12, 2024
I like da unicorn :)
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for Menglong Youk.
409 reviews69 followers
May 17, 2016
Finally I can finish this oh-my-God-I-want-to-quit-but-nah book, the longest one I've read so far, 2226 pages of book four in a fanfiction series. Yet, don't underestimate any book just because it's a fanfiction. Although this one bases on the original Harry Potter world, it changes a hell lot of situations and types of characters, and makes them believable and alive to readers. This Harry Potter's head isn't enjoyable to live in since he has tons of problems and responsibilities as if he were an adult. Saving the world, dealing with the abuse from parents (yes, Lily and James are a.holes here) while maintaining a normal teenage life are definitely not fun to experience, but fascinating to see in a safe distance. Many says the book is getting dark since it's tackled serious problems related to abuse and death, but I can handle them pretty well so far. I love how the author elegantly develop the relationship between Harry and Draco in a slow, emotional and supportive ways, not in quick romance cliché. What's more, the complicated relations in this light-and-dark war has built up in a way different from the original series, which makes me feel excited to once again live in my favorite universe, although with nearly entirely different plots.

So, continue to book five which is around 3500 pages. xD
431 reviews
April 19, 2020
I don't think I'm able to write a full review on this book, there was just so much of stuff happening I wouldn't even know what to say!! Here are just some of the thoughts I had while I was reading it:

- EVERYONE WAS DUMB!!! JESUS PEOPLE, USE YOUR BRAINS!!

- Draco not talking to harry at the beginning just didn't make sense, they were both angry because of something completely different and I don't think the book descried it quite well.... Draco wanted to have Harry be his friend but when Harry reached out he exploded....really dumb let me tell you. didn't need to be there. Really made me angry at him more than at Harry because Harry wasn't in love and was just a confused friend...Draco was being a child that wanted contradictory things. STUPID

- just realized Harry is very demisexual! random thought

- Zacharias Smith my FAV! he's hilarious!

- Why did James have to become stupid again?? He was atoning last year?! That's just sad, they could have stayed amicable :(. And then later after Snape's trial, I just felt like James just gave up :(, so sad, I'd have really wanted them to reconcile at least a little bit. I think he could still salvage his family at least on the men's side.

- Someone please explain to me what was Dobby doing the Walpurgis night? I didn't really understand what was happening
26 reviews
January 23, 2016
Simply fantastic.

I am totally engrossed in this series, in a similar way as I was with the original Harry Potter books, the Many Coloured Land series (Julian May) and the Sword of Truth series (Terry Goodkind). I can't stop reading.

I love the intensity, the grand happenings, the relations between the characters, the additions to the wizarding world (rituals, customs).

I'm already on my way in the next one, which is over 25 hours of reading according to my Kindle.
Profile Image for Elena.
494 reviews9 followers
July 5, 2015
Long,long fic with great characters and a good plot and yet I couldn't get as enthusiastic about it as some other readers. She took the setting and made it bigger and wider; the characters in character but all their weaknesses and strengths enhanced and the rituals and history of the wizarding world more complex and bloody than what J K created. Because of these and gave it four starts.
Profile Image for Colleen.
629 reviews2 followers
June 19, 2015
This is a very, very long page-turner to commit to -- and it's in this book that it really starts its massive expansion of scope, ceasing to be an alternative-universe version of the Harry Potter books and becoming its own universe.

I've been informed that I'm kind of an addict to these stories. So, let that be a testimony of quality? :)
Profile Image for sahra reads.
119 reviews15 followers
Read
August 15, 2016
vates harry is/was so important i love my smol magic child.
Profile Image for rixx.
974 reviews57 followers
January 26, 2024
Harry trains his brother. So very repetitive. Each successive book is longer than the last, with not much to show for it. Stopping here on my re-read.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 31 reviews

Can't find what you're looking for?

Get help and learn more about the design.