i have listened to the radio show but not seen the tv show and wondered how the black community received it. the book does tell of the various thoughts people had of the radio and tv show.
It was difficult to rate this book, in all honesty. The beginning sections are not that bad and the history of the minstrel shows is an unfortunate part of American history; though, it's difficult to judge a different century by the standards of today. Regardless, my main issue with this work is that the writing is dry and incredibly drawn out. Many of the chapters seem to go in circles and it is extremely repetitive at times. The main text is only 255 pages, but, as aformentioned, it's very drawn out in my opinion.
Furthermore, in the preface to this edition, Ely seems incredibly bitter and seems upset that there was not much recognition regarding his chapter on women in the "Amos 'n;Andy" show even though it is one of the shortest chapters in the book and, as the author himself points out, women played a minor role in the show and it was not until much later on that they actually had speaking roles anyway. Then again, if it wasn't for that chapter I wouldn't really know that, ha!
Anyway, like my review, don't like it, doesn't matter. That's my opinion, though.
I have to admit, while growing up Amos 'n' Andy were just objects of derision even though I don't know if any of us had actually ever seen or heard the show. This book ended up being incredibly informative and very fascinating. I still haven't heard nor seen the show, but I definitely found the whole A'n'A phenomenon intriguing.
An even-handed account of what led to the creation of the venerable series, and why it was one of the most popular franchises on radio and TV--until it wasn't. One commentator said that the TV version wouldn't have been found offense if there had been other shows with all-black casts. But A&A was the only depiction of blacks on TV at the time. BTW, you can buy the entire series on Amazon.