90 books
—
8 voters
Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read.
Start by marking “Triumphs of Experience - The Men of the Harvard Grant Study” as Want to Read:
Triumphs of Experience - The Men of the Harvard Grant Study
by
At a time when many people around the world are living into their tenth decade, the longest longitudinal study of human development ever undertaken offers some welcome news for the new old age: our lives continue to evolve in our later years, and often become more fulfilling than before.
Begun in 1938, the Grant Study of Adult Development charted the physical and emotional ...more
Begun in 1938, the Grant Study of Adult Development charted the physical and emotional ...more
Get A Copy
Hardcover, 457 pages
Published
October 23rd 2012
by Harvard University Press
Friend Reviews
To see what your friends thought of this book,
please sign up.
Reader Q&A
To ask other readers questions about
Triumphs of Experience - The Men of the Harvard Grant Study,
please sign up.
Recent Questions
Community Reviews
Showing 1-30
Start your review of Triumphs of Experience - The Men of the Harvard Grant Study
Here we meet WASP men at work and play, and a little bit in love. Proving the paramount importance of love in a cold climate.
This book reports on the groundbreaking Harvard Grant study of educated American white men's lives and health, begun in 1937, that is still active today. The study tries to define optimal male health not just by gathering physical data from its 200-plus subjects, many of whom are still alive into their nineties, but also by tracking achievements (attainments) that can be m ...more
This book reports on the groundbreaking Harvard Grant study of educated American white men's lives and health, begun in 1937, that is still active today. The study tries to define optimal male health not just by gathering physical data from its 200-plus subjects, many of whom are still alive into their nineties, but also by tracking achievements (attainments) that can be m ...more
This is a fantastic book, but it really has a target audience. If you are a successful, college, male graduate who has choices about what you do and how you live, this book as interesting insight. What decisions that people made at different times in their life ended up being most important.
If you have that opportunity financially, educationally and personally, read this book. If you're not in that position, this book's probably not so interesting. ...more
If you have that opportunity financially, educationally and personally, read this book. If you're not in that position, this book's probably not so interesting. ...more
Vaillant took the helm of the longest-running longitudinal study in American social science when he was a young researcher and the study had already been going for 30 years. Beginning in 1937, the study, funded by a retail magnate to identify key traits in management prospects (with later interest from the Army and tobacco companies), selected 268 Harvard sophomores to track, assuming that they were ideal social and academic paragons, easy to track for the study and likely to give the best of Am
...more
One of those books I am so glad I read. Such a fascinating longitudinal study, the book is written by a former head of this study which analyzed the lives of several hundred Harvard men over the entire course of their lives. I appreciated his insight and analysis of the data. One of the major findings is that what leads to the most fulfillment in life is the quality of a person's relationships. I feel a renewed desire to be kinder and more loving with my family and friends and to prioritize my r
...more
Loving this book. Fascinating, fascinating ...
I was drawn to this book in particular because of the learnings on male development as outlined by Vaillant. But, aside from that, there seems to be a societal attitude that men are privileged and hence require research on their physical well-being but not so much on their long-term emotional well-being. However, increasingly, from many directions, the conclusion that physical well-being, the ability to thrive into old age physically cannot be divorc ...more
I was drawn to this book in particular because of the learnings on male development as outlined by Vaillant. But, aside from that, there seems to be a societal attitude that men are privileged and hence require research on their physical well-being but not so much on their long-term emotional well-being. However, increasingly, from many directions, the conclusion that physical well-being, the ability to thrive into old age physically cannot be divorc ...more
This is such an important work. One of the only longitudinal studies of its kind, this follows a cohort of Harvard men from the ages of 19 to over 90 in a study that spans over 75 years. It is enlightening in so many ways and the style of the author (and study researcher) George Vaillant is so engaging to read. He is about 15 years younger than the study subjects and as they grew and matured, so did he. He came to his own realizations about what adult development means in very concrete terms, an
...more
Phew this was a bit of a slog - really really interesting but not a fast read. Much of what George Vaillant had to say was profound and useful both personally and professionally. At times I needed to reread whole paragraphs to understand his intent as they started off saying one thing but turned into another! That said each of these paragraphs contained pearls worth taking the time to decipher. Of particular interest were the chapters on Alcoholism , Resilience and Adult maturation.
The Grant Stu ...more
The Grant Stu ...more
Vaillant makes use of an extensive set of longitudinal data on Harvard men to determine what leads to enduring fulfillment and joy in their lives. Living through a warm childhood, abstaining from alcoholism and smoking, coping effectively with failure, and permitting love and attachment score high on his list of factors that contribute to beneficial outcomes. This book also depicts several useful misconceptions that the author effectively debunks and several surprising outcomes: for instance, me
...more
I found this book: 1) informative, but not overwhelming; 2) encouraging that growth over time is possible; and 3) relatable, as it shares findings from the study by telling the stories of individuals. This seems like a book that would be nice to revisit in various stages of life.
George Vaillant explains his lifetime work on the Harvard Grant Study that follows many men at Harvard that provides a very interesting longitudinal analysis about a number of factors that lead to a long life, divorce, emotional agility, alcoholism, and more.
The key to a longer, happier life is having loved ones around you, whether that's a spouse, family member, or friend.
A key problem with divorce is alcoholism, which tends to be a genetic factor that can be very difficult to overcome.
There ...more
The key to a longer, happier life is having loved ones around you, whether that's a spouse, family member, or friend.
A key problem with divorce is alcoholism, which tends to be a genetic factor that can be very difficult to overcome.
There ...more
As a 28 year-old man, I acutely feel the impending pressures and complexities of pursuing career consolidation, intimacy, health, generativity (making babies and stuff) amongst others. Triumphs of Experience offers the perfect antidote to the dreaded quarter-/one-third-life crises as it narrates and studies the realities that, "adult development continues long after adolescence, that character is not set in plaster, and that people do change." Vailant pulls data from 70+ years of studying Harvar
...more
Interesting insights based on a longitudinal study of 200+ men for 70 years! Alcoholism is hereditary and the biggest reason for marriages failing. A warm childhood is predictive of success, but a bad childhood can be overcome. Love relationships are what makes us truly happy. People grow and change throughout their lives -- even a life that was devoid until age 50 can still flower into an amazing old-age. All these backed up with scientific regressions plus anecdotal case studies!
This is a fascinating book about a longitudinal study of Harvard undergraduates from 1938 up to the present day. It's interesting to learn how their childhoods, personalities, and habits influence the trajectory of their lives. Highly recommended!
...more
The only lifetime longitudinal study completed on health and happiness in the world....although some insights are outdated, it's still very informative. The conclusion of the study is simply put in the words of John Lennon, "Love is all you need".
...more
Analysis of one of the longest longitudinal studies ever conducted. It tracks over 70 decades of life of a group of Harvard students. A road map looked through the rear mirror, reflecting the possibilities men can achieve (or not achieve) over a lifetime.
"Triumphs of Experience" details the 'cream of the crop,' from college until death, with in-depth interviews of their lifestyle habits and relationships to serve as the gold standard of what to do to live the longest, healthiest and happiest life, and also a few common ways to f-it all up.
I was taken aback by the level of thoughtfulness, thoroughness, and practicality of Vaillant's work. Also thankful that despite pushback, and altering the angle to secure funding (tobacco, alcohol, etc.) to kee ...more
I was taken aback by the level of thoughtfulness, thoroughness, and practicality of Vaillant's work. Also thankful that despite pushback, and altering the angle to secure funding (tobacco, alcohol, etc.) to kee ...more
A detailed and statically heavy look at 268 men over 75 years of life beginning in 1939. Heavy emphasis on relationships and lifestyle. Here is a summary of this 370-page book covering the study:
-Alcoholism was the main cause of divorce between the Grant Study men and their wives.
-Alcoholism strongly correlates with neurosis and depression.
-Alcoholism with associated cigarette smoking was the single greatest contributor to their early morbidity and death.
-Financial success depends on the warmth ...more
-Alcoholism was the main cause of divorce between the Grant Study men and their wives.
-Alcoholism strongly correlates with neurosis and depression.
-Alcoholism with associated cigarette smoking was the single greatest contributor to their early morbidity and death.
-Financial success depends on the warmth ...more
I was initially stoked about this book:
1) very relevant research
2) combined with interesting case studies
3) and some "backstage" stories about running a uniquely long longitudinal study.
Unfortunately as the book went on my enthusiasm waned.
1) Somehow the solid results are underwhelming (alcohol is really really bad...)
2) Case studies got more boring and confusing. Vaillant keeps referring to persons across chapters. However, since the studies are not tremendously memorable (unlike him you spend ...more
1) very relevant research
2) combined with interesting case studies
3) and some "backstage" stories about running a uniquely long longitudinal study.
Unfortunately as the book went on my enthusiasm waned.
1) Somehow the solid results are underwhelming (alcohol is really really bad...)
2) Case studies got more boring and confusing. Vaillant keeps referring to persons across chapters. However, since the studies are not tremendously memorable (unlike him you spend ...more
Triumphs of experience
- based on The Grand study and more longtitude studies
- alcoholism leads to higher chance of divorce and shorter lifespan
- good relationship with siblings, family, (intimate) relationships - to warm relationships, earnings
- love!, solid, bold
- we can change, childhood does not have to determine
- on childhood
- warm childhood -> significant wealth, and satisfaction with life
- brain maturation leads to more intimacy allowance
- Questions
- My behaviour with the opposite sex h ...more
- based on The Grand study and more longtitude studies
- alcoholism leads to higher chance of divorce and shorter lifespan
- good relationship with siblings, family, (intimate) relationships - to warm relationships, earnings
- love!, solid, bold
- we can change, childhood does not have to determine
- on childhood
- warm childhood -> significant wealth, and satisfaction with life
- brain maturation leads to more intimacy allowance
- Questions
- My behaviour with the opposite sex h ...more
Another book read as a favor for a friend--this turned out to be much more interesting than I expected. Somehow Vaillant makes potentially dry, statistical analyses riveting. I couldn't help but apply some of the lessons learned from this prospective study going on 80 years to my own life. I appreciated the author's clinical approach, and yet his own distinct voice, often describing his reactions and attachments to these men whom he knew and studied for decades. I liked the chapter about coping
...more
This feels like the 'capital in the 21st century' for individuals. Vaillant (and all the study leaders before and after him) have followed a small group of people over more than 70 years to search for long term predictions about thriving into old age. The conclusions of the book are not at all surprising, the keys to a happy and meaningful life into old age are:
1. Loving relationships
2. Developing mature coping habits
3. Having a 'warm' childhood
OK - no news there. More interesting to me was th ...more
1. Loving relationships
2. Developing mature coping habits
3. Having a 'warm' childhood
OK - no news there. More interesting to me was th ...more
The psychiatrist George Vaillant (b. 1934) has spent his professional career with the Harvard Grant Study, the longest longitudinal study of human development ever attempted. At publication about 30% of the 268 participants were still alive and in their early 90s. Still, it is unlikely that Vaillant himself will be able to present an absolute postmortem because at publication he was in his late 70s and playfully admitted to a host of bad lifestyle choices.
As an older male, it was encouraging to ...more
As an older male, it was encouraging to ...more
Finally found another great book to be raved about. This book is about the participants of The Harvard Grant Study, a longitudinal study about human development that was conducted in 75 years.
The book talks about the importance of warm childhood for a man's future, and its strong correlation with income and life satisfaction when the participant got old. Loving childhood is a better predictor of success throughout life than family SES!
I also love the book because it tells me about the developmen ...more
The book talks about the importance of warm childhood for a man's future, and its strong correlation with income and life satisfaction when the participant got old. Loving childhood is a better predictor of success throughout life than family SES!
I also love the book because it tells me about the developmen ...more
This book was both academic and approachable. I thoroughly enjoyed the glimpses of the scientific process (proving and disproving hypotheses) and also appreciated the generous and easy to understand conclusions. Each chapter includes a case study or two to make a specific point. These are very helpful in understanding the lessons learned. How amazing that even what seems like such an elite group, selected even for the prospect of future success could end up embodying so much of the foibles of hu
...more
Triumphs of Experience summarizes much of the work of the Grant longitudinal study of Harvard male graduates from 1938 to 1942This well written account can be understood, with much effort, by the lay reader, but it is a slog. Lots of writing justifying the study's methodology and administration, all too the good. Case studies illustrating some of the findings make the more esoteric sections of the book accessible to the general reader. But the book is still a slog. I seldom do not finish a book
...more
Interesting longitudinal study of many lives.
One of the things that was new for me was this idea that even as an older adult, once you're children have left home, there are development steps that you can aim at: e.g. becoming a pillar of a community, creating the next generation leaders. Sure not everybody can do that. And Ive still got a few steps in between. But still. Fascinating to look at lives painted with a life sized brush :)
Ah, and to see that even very late in life, in their fifties an ...more
One of the things that was new for me was this idea that even as an older adult, once you're children have left home, there are development steps that you can aim at: e.g. becoming a pillar of a community, creating the next generation leaders. Sure not everybody can do that. And Ive still got a few steps in between. But still. Fascinating to look at lives painted with a life sized brush :)
Ah, and to see that even very late in life, in their fifties an ...more
https://youtu.be/8KkKuTCFvzI
So I saw this Ted Talk 3 years ago, and decided to get the book with the full research, I have been reading this book on and off for the past 3 years, and finally I was able to finish it.
They discuss the longest ever Research made on Human Life, and the discoveries they have found.
Early Childhood Development is KEY to a Happy and Stable Human Being, and on that Note, Alaa Mahmoud Ghada Shehab I can’t thank you both enough for all the happy childhood memories you creat ...more
So I saw this Ted Talk 3 years ago, and decided to get the book with the full research, I have been reading this book on and off for the past 3 years, and finally I was able to finish it.
They discuss the longest ever Research made on Human Life, and the discoveries they have found.
Early Childhood Development is KEY to a Happy and Stable Human Being, and on that Note, Alaa Mahmoud Ghada Shehab I can’t thank you both enough for all the happy childhood memories you creat ...more
Given how rare it is to have such a thorough longitudinal study, it was interesting for this reason alone. There aren't many works or writings that survey a life from a birds-eye view. I loved the anecdotal bits of seeing how people developed over time, and the researchers' speculations about what made them so.
I'd say that the conclusions were just that though — speculation. Most of the results came from running correlations on every pair of variables and looking at which p-values were significa ...more
I'd say that the conclusions were just that though — speculation. Most of the results came from running correlations on every pair of variables and looking at which p-values were significa ...more
The library required this book back before I was finished with it, and it had been like wading through a long doctoral thesis, complete with references to psychological studies by the obscure and presumed brilliant. Vaillant's analysis of the lives of "the men of the Harvard Grant Study" contained some interesting insights into growth and aging in America, provided by the opportunity to study the lives of a similar cohort of men for nearly seven decades. Unfortunately, I was aging faster than th
...more
Lots of things to think about for myself but I was suprised about how often thought about my kids. How can I provide the best situation to allow my kids to succeed in life? I loved that this was a little think on the science part of his study since I trust so few studies. However, by the end i was thinking, "I get it! Longitudinal studies are important!" But I wanted something to get me thinking and this was great.
...more
There are no discussion topics on this book yet.
Be the first to start one »
Readers also enjoyed
George Eman Vaillant, M.D., born 1934, is an American psychiatrist and Professor at Harvard Medical School and Director of Research for the Department of Psychiatry, Brigham and Women's Hospital.
Vaillant has spent his research career charting adult development and the recovery process of schizophrenia, heroin addiction, alcoholism, and personality disorder. Through 2003, he spent 30 years as Dire ...more
Vaillant has spent his research career charting adult development and the recovery process of schizophrenia, heroin addiction, alcoholism, and personality disorder. Through 2003, he spent 30 years as Dire ...more
News & Interviews
Twists, turns, red herrings, the usual suspects: These books have it all...and more. If you love mysteries and thrillers, get ready for dozens...
126 likes · 31 comments
No trivia or quizzes yet. Add some now »
“Happiness is love. Full stop.”
—
7 likes
“As we’ve gone along, I’ve pointed out that a warm childhood relationship with his mother—not maternal education—was significantly related to a man’s verbal test scores, to high salary, to class rank at Harvard, and to military rank at the end of World War II. At the men’s twenty-fifth reunion, it looked, to my surprise, as though the quality of a man’s relationship with his mother had little effect on overall midlife adjustment. However, forty-five years later, to my surprise again, the data suggested that there was a significant positive correlation between the quality of one’s maternal relationship and the absence of cognitive decline. At age ninety, 33 percent of the men with poor maternal relationships, and only 13 percent of men with warm relationships, suffered from dementia.”
—
4 likes
More quotes…
