Manchester. London. Glasgow. In the summer of 2011, violence erupted in the UK's inner cities, and many blamed gang culture. But is the truth so simple? This book tells the human stories that the media miss: of young men who have fallen through the system, and of one young woman with a vision for change.
Journalist Gavin Knight reports an unflinching frontline view of those on the margins of society and these glimpses are not made of the pretty. Gruelling stuff, this real life, isn't it. Most of the behaviours discussed here are down to social conditioning so it was refreshing to have a look at how the Bostonian System is dealing with similar impacting.
The reader is Siobhan Redmond. 4*
Produced by Jill Waters A Waters Company production for BBC Radio 4.
It's an over-used cliche that non-fiction crime books "grip like a thriller", but this one lives up to it, albeit a gritty, British sink-estate, left-leaning account of gangland Manchester, London and Glasgow. The gangs depicted are a long way from the world of the Krays or the Guy Ritchie fantasies of the big screen. The lives portrayed here are on the lowest rung of the ladder, the hoodies who deal, push and scrabble at the bottom end of the drug food chain trying to find their next fix within the small world of streets they inhabit. While the book tries to take you into this world, and succeeds, I often wondered how much licence the author takes with his material in order to keep the narrative barrelling along, from one gang fight to another. It almost appears exciting and dynamic whereas the life of your average junkie must be one of sheer boredom, misery and squalor, punctuated with bursts of violence, illness and terror. Not that the author doesn't touch on those themes. In fact, it could be argued that the whole background to the story in each of these British cities is nothing else but boredom, misery and squalor, punctuated by extreme violence. How people who are caught up in it survive from day to day is more the focus of Hood Rat, and if dramatic editing and shaping is needed to get the point across and ensure you keep reading, so be it. It certainly kept me reading.
Hood Rat gave an insight into parts of society that I haven't experienced myself and that was valuable, however through most of the book, I couldn't identify the motivation for telling these stories of British gangsters... at times it seemed as if the author was trying to shock the reader, at times it seemed as if he was saying 'look how bad these kids are', and by the conclusion, there seemed to be more of an empathy with them. Personally, I would have found the book more interesting and useful if throughout there had been more of a cohesive point, rather than just a selection of disparate tragic stories.
There are some graphic stories in Hood Rat revolving around the activities of gangs and those who try to stop them, in London, Glasgow and Manchester. A challenging read, put together in a chronological order. Drugs, Prostitution, Pimping it's all included in here. The Author vividly portrays a world where drugs hook adolescents into gangs where they develop a gang mentality where living for the moment and earning respect from other gang members is all they look for. An amazing read if you are a fan of True Crime Genre or anyone interested in the workings of Gangs.
I didn't finish this despite really wanting it to be good and giving it loads of tries before giving up.
The writer clearly knows his onions on crime, Manchester gangs and police procedures, but that doesn't translate into readable prose or give-a-shit-aboutable characters.
It has a bit of a Ross Kemp style too it, like a blokey pub convo where he wants you to be impressed with how hardcore this world is.
It would have been better as non fiction and with less machismo
A true crime book about the violent street gangs in the UK . It begins like a noir and the gang members are trying survive in the hostile universe . Lot of details and case histories : not an easy read. description of the communities in the the problem areas and the police work. But there is an effort to change the situation by the police and politics ; with results according the author.
a page-turner of a tour of the lowest side of british culture. some errors, e.g. west mercia police are not in lancashire, house music isn't rap music. but generally a great work of research, so long as you are happy to read in a novelistic, unverified present tense style. london and manchester sections accorded with what's described in national news media, glasgow section still seemed shocking to me in its dystopia, though also the most hopeful part of the book. i'd love to know how much is new and hos much is traditional - not really addressed other than changing patterns of intoxication.
A new mystery by a writer who compares with Val McDermid, Peter James and Ian Rankin would be a cause for celebration! So let’s start celebrating! The only difference is that the 3 stories in this book are all true. Written in a narrative nonfiction style by crime reporter Gavin Knight we live the lives of crooks and coppers in Manchester, London and Glasgow, follow their actions and their interactions and wait to find out who will live, who will die and who will end up in prison. A must read for all crime fiction fans!
It took me a while to get used to the writing style but once I did, it brought these tragic stories to life. The post-riots afterword in my edition was especially poignant. Tells the horror stories of British inner city ganglands from every perspective, with no glory. Definitely worth a read.
Excellently written account of gang life on the sink estates of Great Britian in the 21st Century. Although quite challenging and even depressing in places it ends with a message of hope for the future of the discarded youth of our inner cities.
Needs to be considered as three books in one. First part about Manchester was gripping after that it tailed off as books written in this style often do and become overburdened with the research that's gone into them. Enjoyable read.
Worst book I have ever written. No great development of the characters. Moves over time spans very rapidly. Only the story of pilgrim is interesting - the book should have surrounded him.