511 books
—
1,855 voters
Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read.
Start by marking “Saman” as Want to Read:
Saman
(Saman #1)
by
Saman is a story filtered through the lives of its feisty female protagonists and the enigmatic “hero” Saman. It is at once an exposé of the oppression of plantation workers in South Sumatra, a lyrical quest to understand the place of religion and spirituality in contemporary lives, a playful exploration of female sexuality and a story about love in all its guises, while
...more
Get A Copy
Friend Reviews
To see what your friends thought of this book,
please sign up.
Reader Q&A
To ask other readers questions about
Saman,
please sign up.
Be the first to ask a question about Saman
Community Reviews
Showing 1-30
Start your review of Saman
The story of an Indonesian activist told by a young female Javanese expat living in NYC and working for a human rights NGO. The writing is evocative, even sensual at times, and despite some rough edges it manages to paint a very convincing and fairly tragic picture of poor rural Indonesian communities being exploited and killed under the nose of a numb, corrupt state.
Against this setting, Saman, a former priest, stands up for a small community being violently pressured to sign over their lands ...more
Against this setting, Saman, a former priest, stands up for a small community being violently pressured to sign over their lands ...more
Saman is the story of how a Catholic priest in the world’s most populous Muslim country, Indonesia, becomes a human rights activist called "Saman." Author, journalist Ayu Utami, turns the familiar tale of the crusader for justice on its head by folding Saman's story into that of a group of young women who knew him when they were school girls and he a newly-ordained priest.
Laila is the good girl who always falls for men she cannot have. Shakuntala the dancer who breaks her name in two for an Amer ...more
Laila is the good girl who always falls for men she cannot have. Shakuntala the dancer who breaks her name in two for an Amer ...more
Since I read an article about the author Ayu Utami a few years back, I have wanted to read one of her books for a long time already. She struck me as a very brave and forward-thinking female author in a country dominated by patriarchy. Earlier this year, I finally managed to buy a copy of Saman, even in its original language! Yay! Furthermore, it was the perfect length for me (just over 200 pages).
Well, what can I say now. I think I understand why this book mostly got average ratings. It starte ...more
Well, what can I say now. I think I understand why this book mostly got average ratings. It starte ...more
The first book by an indonesian writer I have ever read.
I have to admit that I'm still a bit puzzled about the meaning and the symbols in it, but as I kept thinking about it and read more about the reactions this book provoced, I realized that it's a very brave book. Sexuality, religious conflicts, the effects the Transmigrasi policy in the 70s, friendship, love, everything is brought up here. It is both, the story of the main characters of the book and their moving fates and a reflection about ...more
I have to admit that I'm still a bit puzzled about the meaning and the symbols in it, but as I kept thinking about it and read more about the reactions this book provoced, I realized that it's a very brave book. Sexuality, religious conflicts, the effects the Transmigrasi policy in the 70s, friendship, love, everything is brought up here. It is both, the story of the main characters of the book and their moving fates and a reflection about ...more
2.5 stars rounded up. Episodes told from alternating and interconnected narratives--beginning with four girls who've remained friends from girlhood--to portray the politicization and radicalization of the eponymous Catholic priest.
I'd been convinced I would give Saman a 4-star rating until I reached the last section with Jasmin ans Samn. That's the point where my rating dropped to 2.5 stars. The first 80% of the novel, however, was fascinating. ...more
I'd been convinced I would give Saman a 4-star rating until I reached the last section with Jasmin ans Samn. That's the point where my rating dropped to 2.5 stars. The first 80% of the novel, however, was fascinating. ...more
Feminism Rocks
Politics Sucks
Love is something personal
Politics Sucks
Love is something personal
Read this as part of my book club assignment. Did not like the book enough to write a serious review.
3 stars for the first 100 pages; 1 star for most everything after that!
There are basically two different stories going on in this book. The first story is centered around Saman, a Catholic priest turned plantation worker rights activist. I really enjoyed his storyline and wish Utami had developed it even further. In this portion of the book, Utami highlights conditions in “transmigration” communities and the heavy hand of oil, rubber, and palm oil industries in Indonesia. We also see Saman explo ...more
There are basically two different stories going on in this book. The first story is centered around Saman, a Catholic priest turned plantation worker rights activist. I really enjoyed his storyline and wish Utami had developed it even further. In this portion of the book, Utami highlights conditions in “transmigration” communities and the heavy hand of oil, rubber, and palm oil industries in Indonesia. We also see Saman explo ...more
Mar 17, 2019
Desca Ang
rated it
really liked it
·
review of another edition
Shelves:
indonesian-writer,
ayu-utami
❝Saman, I have aloerotism. I have sex with my husband, but it’s you I am imagining. He’s been asking why I so often want the lights out. It’s because I’m imagining your face, your body.
Yasmin, I am jealous. You are having sex, I’m not. You’re husband is surely a better lover than I am? I come too fast. But I suppose if I were to get you pregnant, it would mean I am efficient – capable of getting a task done in a short time.
….
Yasmin, Climax! That’s what makes it different. Be frank with me, you ...more
Actual rating: ⭐⭐⭐ and half / 5 stars
Sep 04, 2019
Rick Brose
rated it
really liked it
·
review of another edition
Shelves:
read-harder-2019-challenge
Some translations can feel blocky and stagnant. The translation of Saman retains a flowing, poetic feel to it throughout the book. The novel is an intriguing narrative with complex characters and deep backgrounds. The Indonesian culture and history that is covered within the pages is captivating. It is not a book with a definitive beginning, middle, and end. That did not bother me though. I enjoyed digging into the lives, choices, and motivations of the characters presented.
I read this book to fulfill the "#Own voices/Oceania" task for Read Harder. While I really enjoyed how in-depth the story of Saman and the plantation workers was, I was left feeling like I was missing something. We didn't get a wrap-up to most of the stories that I thought were central to the plot (anything having to do with Laila, Saman's mother's ordeal, etc.). It just ended up being a series of mostly unrelated snippets about repression that were never fleshed out.
...more
The one i like less from the ´Saman trilogy´ of Ayoe Utami. It is sooo pretentious, I think. It tries to keep up the original pace of Saman, but somehow in some parts I think the characters tried too hard it came to the edge of being shallow, instead of deep.
I read this one in highschool, some people found it a bit pretentious. I'm giving it an OK for a clairvoyant narration.
...more
The book started out promising but ultimately fizzled out due to poor character and plot development.
Ayu Utami writings are splendid, this book is no exception. Sadly the plot, basically the romance part, did not grasps my interest. The book is written in three points of view, Laila, Shakuntala, and Saman yet somehow I found it a little bit disconnected from each other. Especially in the chapter where Shakuntala tells the story, mainly she talks about Laila's affair with a certain married man. It has little to no connection to Saman's part of the story. The book's title is Saman, obviously he's
...more
I am not sure what to think. I really wanted to like this more. It is a jumble of some great ideas, sometimes clumsy writing and semi-developed characters. Part of if might have been the awkwardness of the translation (from Indonesian to English to Hungarian), partly the writer's indecisiveness on her priorities. Although the book's title is Saman, it was still marketed as a novel of sexual awakening of four Indonesian women, all of whom are connected to the mysterious Saman. Out of the four wom
...more
While travelling through Bali and Java I was excited to read the work of an Indonesian author. The variety of written structures is engaging, with different characters giving their perspectives at different times and through different mediums (ending in letters and emails). My main criticism is that the story felt rushed and characters were introduced with purpose only for their narratives to not be fully finished. The backdrop of the story is political unrest in Indonesia during the 1980's and
...more
I think maybe a lot of this just went over my head. I loved Saman as a character and I liked the others well enough. I recognized the thread that held them all together as a cast. I appreciate that the book pushed boundaries when published in Indonesia, touching on the cruelty and oppression in famers' lives, repressive sexual attitudes, religion, transmigration and politics, etc. But in the actual reading of it, I thought the whole thing felt disjointed. At one point (about halfway through) I a
...more
Jun 30, 2019
Meg
rated it
really liked it
·
review of another edition
Shelves:
read-harder,
read-harder-2019
I went into reading Saman knowing very little about Indonesia; either its geography or its culture. Saman takes place primarily on the island of Sumatra, and in New York City. I like the wavering timelines and wandering plot lines, which add layers to the surrealism component in Perabumulih. Saman is an interesting mix of theology, morality, sexuality, and survival. My only real complaint was that the book feels unresolved in any way. (There may be more in the series, but not translated to Engli
...more
3.5 stars if that were a think. A nonlinear structure and roaming POV make SAMAN a workout, but each chapter is engrossing in its own right. Set mostly in Indonesia in the second half of the Twentieth Century, I think I’d read SAMAN was originally banned for its sexual content and feminist lens. That’s an interesting tidbit about a novel whose central character is a priest. Surprising and I’d read it again, but not one I’d recommend particularly widely.
Well crafted, fully realised characters with shocking insight into the levels of exploitation in postcolonial societies. There are several parts, especially toward the beginning, that feel white-knuckle and almost as if the author is about to go supernova. It just...doesn't quite happen that way. Not that the latter half is weak, it's just not as satisfying as I'd hoped. But perhaps that's the point.
...more
May 20, 2019
Lekeisha The Booknerd
rated it
liked it
·
review of another edition
Shelves:
ownvoices,
read-harder-2019
*2.5 stars*
Disappointing? Not entirely. When I went into this book, I was wholly excited. Coming out of it had me feeling a little off kilter. I'm all for sexualization, political forces turned upside down,history and feminism. This.... I don't even remember the first quarter of these less than 200 pages. Props to the author for this show of bravado. That is all. ...more
Disappointing? Not entirely. When I went into this book, I was wholly excited. Coming out of it had me feeling a little off kilter. I'm all for sexualization, political forces turned upside down,history and feminism. This.... I don't even remember the first quarter of these less than 200 pages. Props to the author for this show of bravado. That is all. ...more
For the first time ever, I wish I had read this book in a classroom setting. Mainly because I don't feel like I have enough background information about Indonesia's politics and mix of different cultures to really understand it.
...more
I am not sure how to rate this book. I thought the character of Saman (not his real name) was interesting and the early part of his story was the best part of the book. I felt that the book wasn't complete.
...more
The most breathtaking book I have ever read.
It took me places beyond my wildest imagination.
It took me places beyond my wildest imagination.
A page turner
Provocative and lyrical. You'll read it in a single sitting. The character of Saman never stops surprising his family and friends, from Sumatra to NYC ...more
Provocative and lyrical. You'll read it in a single sitting. The character of Saman never stops surprising his family and friends, from Sumatra to NYC ...more
Agree with Lasse's Oct 4 2007 review
...more
An Indonesian woman writes this book. This book has deep meaning. It is not only about women, but the real condition of Indonesia that period. It also shows about human rights.
A very brave story from Ayu Utami in that day when this novel was publish.
| topics | posts | views | last activity | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2015 Reading Chal...: Saman by Ayu Utami | 1 | 22 | Feb 02, 2015 06:02AM | |
| Novel Saman | 1 | 20 | Apr 06, 2014 09:37PM |
Readers also enjoyed
Justina Ayu Utami atau hanya Ayu Utami (lahir di Bogor, Jawa Barat, 21 November 1968) adalah aktivis jurnalis dan novelis Indonesia, ia besar di Jakarta dan menamatkan kuliah di Fakultas Sastra Universitas Indonesia.
Ia pernah menjadi wartawan di majalah Humor, Matra, Forum Keadilan, dan D&R. Tak lama setelah penutupan Tempo, Editor dan Detik pada masa Orde Baru, ia ikut mendirikan Aliansi Jurnalis ...more
Ia pernah menjadi wartawan di majalah Humor, Matra, Forum Keadilan, dan D&R. Tak lama setelah penutupan Tempo, Editor dan Detik pada masa Orde Baru, ia ikut mendirikan Aliansi Jurnalis ...more
Other books in the series
Saman
(3 books)
Related Articles
Danielle Evans was just 26 when she released her short story collection Before You Suffocate Your Own Fool Self in 2010, a multi-award-winning...
16 likes · 1 comments
No trivia or quizzes yet. Add some now »
“Banyak hal dengan mudah terlupakan, seperti kita sama sekali lupa kenapa kita tidak bisa mengingatnya lagi. Sesuatu bisa begitu saja hilang dari ingatan, seperti arwah, seperti mimpi. Kita cuma bisa merasakan jejaknya pada diri kita tanpa bisa mengenalinya lagi. Kita tinggal benci, kita tinggal marah, tinggal takut, tinggal cinta. Kita tak tahu kenapa.”
—
50 likes
“Dunia ini penuh dengan orang jahat yang tidak dihukum. Mereka berkeliaran. Sebagian karena tidak tertangkap, sebagian lagi memang dilindungi, tak tersentuh hukum, atau aparat.”
—
40 likes
More quotes…
