Winter Be My Shield by Jo Spurrier

Mar 30, 2012 Jill rated it really liked it

Shelves: 2012-debuts

…the blizzard was her shield – without it she would never have come this far.

Sierra has escaped the clutches of the King’s Torturer, Lord Kell and his apprentice, Rasten. For two years she has been imprisoned and abused to break her spirit and her mind. Sierra, a Child of the Black Sun possesses a special gift, a power that feeds off and grows from the sufferings of others. So powerful is her ability, Kell will stop at nothing to bring her back.

After a failed coup ten years ago Prince Cammarian ...more

flag 19 likes · Like · see review

Aug 19, 2015 Lindsay rated it really liked it

I really enjoyed this. It was an emotionally intense piece of the growth of a mage in a group of cultures that have very different ideas of what to do with mages, pretty much none of them good. It's also the first part of a larger novel (and says so right there on the cover, well done!), but feels like a complete book with where the main characters end up. Of course, that's with the luxury of knowing that the full trilogy is already published, I don't imagine I'd be so sanguine if I had to wait I really enjoyed this. It was an emotionally intense piece of the growth of a mage in a group of cultures that have very different ideas of what to do with mages, pretty much none of them good. It's also the first part of a larger novel (and says so right there on the cover, well done!), but feels like a complete book with where the main characters end up. Of course, that's with the luxury of knowing that the full trilogy is already published, I don't imagine I'd be so sanguine if I had to wait a year for the next one :)

Sierra is an extremely powerful type of mage called a Sympath. She is of Ricalan origin, a country that would have culled her as a child because of her talent, but "fortunately" she was identified young by a pair of Blood Mages. A Blood Mage's idea of training is systematized torture, rape and brutal slavery and after several years of imprisonment and being forced to watch frequent ritual torture, Sierra's training is about to begin. The book picks up with Sierra fleeing from the Blood Mages, but in an incredibly hostile frozen wildland that even she has no expectation of surviving.

She navigates between the people of the tribal areas of Ricalan, all of whom have a deep-seated hatred of mages, a pursuing Blood Mage, a group of Ricalan nobles who she falls in with and an invading horde of slave-taking Akharian imperialists.

This is a beautifully realized fantasy world with a rich history and interesting geopolitics. There are three main countries represented and you get background on all three and the reasons for the conflict between them are both varied and realistic. Similarly the characters are also treated with a lot of nuance, even the putative "bad guys". There's growth with most of the characters, and even secondary characters are given enough lea-way to change their minds over time. Another thing that's done very well is introducing point-of-view characters as needed and giving them varying amounts of screen-time, as needed.

The only thing I'd rate it down for is the glacial (hah!) pacing that is so common across epic fantasy books these days. The instinct of writers in this genre is to do all this intense world-building and then to just wallow in it. This does seem to match up with market expectations and I'm sure a generation of epic fantasy readers lap up books like this, but reviews are necessarily subjective, and my first instinct as a reader is to say, "Yes, you're very clever, now get on with it please."
...more

flag 11 likes · Like · see review

Jul 28, 2017 Krystal rated it really liked it

Shelves: light-fantasy, aussie-authors, owned

This was so much more entertaining than I expected it to be! I added it to my shelf waaaaaay back in 2013 and I've picked it up a bunch of times, read a page or two, and decided to pick up something else instead. Finally I forced myself to read it (for an Aussie Readers challenge) and it was so much more captivating than I anticipated!

I find that I'm really easily affected by setting, so the fact that this was all snow and ice was initially off-putting but once I got into it I found I didn't ...more

flag 8 likes · Like · see review

Sep 01, 2014 Shannon (Giraffe Days) rated it really liked it · review of another edition

Shelves: review-copy, fantasy, 2015, australian-women-writers

In the kingdom of Ricalan, winter is a formidable force for many months of the year, as well as a useful ally in this time of invasion and attack. It's not only the settlers from Mesentreia forcing the Ricalani tribes off their land as they've been doing for the last few decades, supported by Ricalan's Mesentreian queen. Now they must also contend with forces from the Akharian Empire to the west. The Empire is also feeling the pinch from Mesentreia and its settler-invaders, and is using Ricalan In the kingdom of Ricalan, winter is a formidable force for many months of the year, as well as a useful ally in this time of invasion and attack. It's not only the settlers from Mesentreia forcing the Ricalani tribes off their land as they've been doing for the last few decades, supported by Ricalan's Mesentreian queen. Now they must also contend with forces from the Akharian Empire to the west. The Empire is also feeling the pinch from Mesentreia and its settler-invaders, and is using Ricalan as a battleground. But the Empire are also slavers, taking every Ricalani civilian after attacking villages, and the Ricalani army is doing little to stop them.

For Sierra, the ongoing battles - both ideological and physical - are merely a backdrop for her own personal hell. In Ricalan, as in Mesentreia, magic is against the law, hunted down, eradicated. Sierra was hidden by her parents until a powerful Akharian Blood Mage, Kell, now working for the king of Ricalan and his mother, comes for her. Sierra's magical gift is fed by the emotions of others, particularly pain and suffering. And Kell, sadistic torturer that he is, has been using her to feed off his victims, store impressive amounts of power, all for him and his apprentice, Rasten. So she was there when Isidro was tortured, brutalised and defeated.

Isidro is foster-brother to the rightful king of Ricalan, Cammarian, the younger son of a minor southern prisoner of Mesentreian blood, Valeria, who was married to the Ricalani queen's brother. The queen chose Cam as her successor, and upon her death his own mother tried to have him killed. Instead, he fled with Isidro, leaving the throne for his older brother, Severian, to take. They have been on the run ever since, falling in with various groups, not staying too long on any one tribe's land lest they wear out their friends' welcome. Until Isidro is captured and then rescued, and Sierra sets herself free. All three of them are being hunted by Rasten and Kell, but it is Sierra who poses both the real danger, and a real hope for salvation.

After a bit of a slow start where I was strangely very confused over the three different nationalities and who was of which country and where the story was even taking place (there is a map but I read it weird, don't know how, and that started the confusion), Winter Be My Shield becomes a deeply engrossing, very interesting, solidly-constructed Fantasy story whose consistently measured pacing is nevertheless gripping due to the oodles of tension and anticipation throughout. I've spent a bit of time, in my summary, trying to provide some context and introduce the three nations, mostly because I had been so confused at first - in retrospect, it's hard to see how I could have been confused, but there you go. Spurrier actually does a very good job of doling out the exposition in manageable bites, at relevant points in the story. You never quite get to the end of understanding of this world, though: for as well-crafted as the world building is, there's always more to learn and reveal, and that helps add to the interest.

I enjoyed this story immensely, once I got into the swing of things and understood what was going on. There are several different 'sides' but only two main perspectives: Sierra and Isidro. Occasionally, Cam and Rasten get to share their perspective, and an Akharian mage called Delphine provides an absorbing Akharian perspective towards the end. The characters are fairly straight-forward, well fleshed-out, and realistically flawed and human. I was expecting Cam to be the main character - he's a typical protagonist, being heir to a kingdom, a fugitive, handsome, charming etc. Blonde, too - that always helps (his mother's blood; the Ricalani are described as being akin to Asian but very tall). So I was pleasantly surprised - and pleased - when it turned out that Isidro was a key protagonist alongside Sierra. Isidro is a more interesting character, more nuanced, and what happens to him - both at the beginning and at the end - adds to this.

Sierra could have been a bit of a formulaic character, but often manages to surprise. It's not the first Fantasy story to feature a character like her, and in some ways this story, and Sierra, reminded me of Kate Elliott's excellent Crown of Stars series. Rasten could be a stand-in for the deliciously evil Hugh, and so on. But I wouldn't go too far with such comparisons: the Children of the Black Sun trilogy stands clearly, solidly on its own feet, engaging with classic fantasy tropes while at the same time bringing new, or refreshed, ones to the genre. The magic system is uncomplicated yet intriguing, and Sierra's untrained ability is fascinating. You also really feel for her - and Rasten before her (a great villain is one you can sympathise with, even if slightly)- when you learn what kind of mage she is, and how much of a blessing her ability could be if Kell hadn't already started warping it for his own ends.

With a steady, slightly slow pace and a wealth of detail, Spurrier brings her wintery world to cold life. There's violence, gore and pain, but also simple pleasures and a complex history in the process of being unlocked, discovered and revealed. By the end of volume one, the stakes have only become immeasurably higher, and Sierra in a wary working relationship, of kinds, with Rasten. Everyone has their own motives, their own plans, which cris-cross messily over each other. I look forward to reading the next two books, Black Sun Light My Way and North Star Guide Me Home, and seeing what happens to these interesting characters in this intriguing world. A well-written, exciting Fantasy that only gets more absorbing the further you read.

My thanks to the publisher for a copy of this book.
...more

flag 4 likes · Like · see review

Jan 08, 2016 Rinn rated it really liked it

Shelves: arc-or-review-copy, reviewed, fantasy, read-2016

I received a copy of this book for free from the publisher, in exchange for an honest review. Also posted on my blog, Rinn Reads.

I have read a lot of fantasy novels in my life; it has pretty much always been one of my favourite genres since as far back as I can remember. Therefore, if I can find a fantasy novel that feels like a breath of fresh air, is unique and original, then I’m happy. Unfortunately, whilst Winter Be My Shield did not quite hit that high note, it was still a good, solid read. I received a copy of this book for free from the publisher, in exchange for an honest review. Also posted on my blog, Rinn Reads.

I have read a lot of fantasy novels in my life; it has pretty much always been one of my favourite genres since as far back as I can remember. Therefore, if I can find a fantasy novel that feels like a breath of fresh air, is unique and original, then I’m happy. Unfortunately, whilst Winter Be My Shield did not quite hit that high note, it was still a good, solid read.

The story follows a girl named Sierra, who until recently was held prisoner and forced to work for a sorcerer named Kell. The reason she was so useful to Kell is because she can use the pain and suffering of others to draw power. The book never really explained how this works; I can only assume that Sierra becomes a conduit of power around those who are suffering or in pain, and others can draw upon that power, as well as drawing upon it herself. Sierra is a bit of a mystery, and for much of the book the reader knows about as much as the characters know about her, which is little. This was both effective in that it kept me reading, wanting to know more, and slightly frustrating in that she was then harder to empathise with.

A quotation on the cover claims that this book will contain ‘villains you will cheer on’, and I can see where the reviewer is coming from. Although Rasten was, quite frankly, disturbing in his thoughts towards and about Sierra, it was also obvious that his mind was twisted by Kell. Occasionally, it was clear that he wanted to be free of his master, and I did want him to succeed in that pursuit, if not others.

By 130 pages in, I had not noted anything that made this fantasy world particularly unique. By 250 pages, I was still waiting for something big to happen. There was a potential romance/relationship which seemed pretty cliche, but then managed to change things round a bit and avoid it. However, it felt like both characters were constantly thinking ‘it couldn’t be love…’, which seemed like foreshadowing. I also had an issue with one of the main male characters, Isidro. We were told that he was, before being captured and tortured, a strong and fierce warrior. However, since he was never shown that way in the book, I had real trouble imagining him as anything but the weak and broken young man he had become. There were also far too many chapters ending ‘And everything went black…’. One of my biggest problems with the book was more edition specific: the font was far too small! Teeny weeny letters…

All in all, I did enjoy Winter Be My Shield. It didn’t feel like a particularly special fantasy novel, not in the way that other series have, but it’s a good, solid fantasy read and I’m interested to see where the second book goes. ...more

flag 4 likes · Like · see review

May 03, 2014 Leonie rated it really liked it

This review forms part of my contribution to the AWWC 2014. I enjoyed this book. It was an excellent taster for what promises to be an excellent series.

Jo Spurrier is a clever writer, and has built a really interesting world. Having said that, this book was clearly a book that sets up the rest of the story, and I did vacillate somewhat over how many stars to give it. I was torn between 3.5 and 4, primarily because I became entwined in the characters enough to want to know what happens to them.

I This review forms part of my contribution to the AWWC 2014. I enjoyed this book. It was an excellent taster for what promises to be an excellent series.

Jo Spurrier is a clever writer, and has built a really interesting world. Having said that, this book was clearly a book that sets up the rest of the story, and I did vacillate somewhat over how many stars to give it. I was torn between 3.5 and 4, primarily because I became entwined in the characters enough to want to know what happens to them.

I rarely bother with tracking down a sequel to a three star book, but this time I will, so for me it's better than three, but came close to not being a four. There was a lot of setting up in this story. The characters were well established, relationships became clear, and the political situation evolved over the course of the book, and in the end, they were the things that made me return to reading the story quite eagerly.

What I would have liked to see, was an earlier explanation of 'the reasons for' all the stuff that was going on. That would probably have made this a four and a half star read for me. As it was, at the beginning, I was wondering where it was all going, (and where all the characters were going because of all the moving around).

I thought that the magic system was interesting, and different enough that it stands out from the crowd of fantasy books a bit, and the issues related to blood magery were stomach churning enough to leave a deep impression. Fortunately from my point of view, they were cleverly implied, rather than graphically written.

That was one of the things that impressed me most. There often needs to be a 'turn off' to distinguish different types of magic systems so that we know who is 'good' and who is 'evil,' but some authors use such graphic detail that it becomes more prominent than the story. Jo Spurrier has skilfully implied horrible nastiness without needing to make it graphic to get her point across. That is a real skill, and for me, that's a huge plus.

I will be reading the sequel/s to this story. ...more

flag 4 likes · Like · see review

Aug 24, 2019 Karina Webster rated it really liked it · review of another edition

Shelves: 2019-favourites

I’m not sure I can summarise this novel better than the queen of fantasy herself, Robin Hobb:

“Unlikely heroes, villains you will cheer for, and cold that eats your bones. Winter Be My Shield will take you to an unforgiving place, but you won’t want to leave it.”

This is definitely a 4.5 star read for me, I found it utterly immersive with an intriguing political landscape and complex characters. I can’t believe this was a debut, the writing is superb and the pacing is great. For the ground and ...more

flag 5 likes · Like · see review

Jan 28, 2014 Peter Greenwell rated it it was ok

I tried my hardest to wade through this book but in the end, it was simply not possible. I'll agree with other reviewers here that the book does possess a lot of originality, but I can't empathise with their enthusiasm for it.

My issues with this book are many - for starters the characters for most of the book, do nothing except wander about in seeming circles from one snow-bound location to the other. There's lots of dialogue, lots of going back and forth, but little of substance happens. ...more

flag 3 likes · Like · see review

Jan 05, 2016 Bibliophile rated it liked it

Solid world building and nuanced characterization make this fantasy novel worth reading. The pacing is slow and there is a lot of trudging through snow and setting up tents, but also some bracing (by which I mean brutal) action scenes. It's not that original, but refreshing all the same. There's the mandatory exiled prince, but he's not the protagonist - his foster brother Isodro is. Isodro is nobel and brave enough for a hero, but he is also disabled and suffering PTSD after enduring torture ...more

flag 3 likes · Like · see review

Feb 23, 2016 Jack Lanigan rated it it was ok

Fine, I think is the word that I'd use to describe this book. Just fine. Nothing harmful or particularly terrible but nothing that really engrossed me either. Probably the weirdest thing was the tonal shifts. Obviously it's going to be a bit dark, what with the whole magic from pain thing, but for the majority of the book it reads more like YA with how many internal monologues there are, and how much so many of the characters elaborate on their plans and feelings.

Then we start talking about ...more

flag 3 likes · Like · see review

Oct 17, 2016 Ari rated it really liked it

Shelves: australian-author

Chiefly a story about Sierra, a sympath - a mage who gathers energy from the pleasure/pain of those around her - after she escapes a powerful mage find of torture and meets up with one of her former Master's victims and his foster brother, who happens to be a prince hunted by his mother and King brother.

Very good, though with a couple of weak points - the biggest of which was that the book ends on a cliffhanger without much resolved - definitely not a stand alone read.

flag 3 likes · Like · see review

Apr 29, 2012 Tsana Dolichva rated it it was amazing

Winter Be My Shield is Jo Spurrier’s debut novel and the first book of Children of the Black Sun trilogy. I was lucky enough to receive an advanced review copy of this book from Harper Voyager.

Set in a country where winter lasts about six months and involves piles of snow (much like the cover depicts), the story follows Sierra, Cam and Isidro. Sierra is a powerful mage but was enslaved by the sadistic Blood Mage Kell and forced to feed him power while he tortured various prisoners. She was Winter Be My Shield is Jo Spurrier’s debut novel and the first book of Children of the Black Sun trilogy. I was lucky enough to receive an advanced review copy of this book from Harper Voyager.

Set in a country where winter lasts about six months and involves piles of snow (much like the cover depicts), the story follows Sierra, Cam and Isidro. Sierra is a powerful mage but was enslaved by the sadistic Blood Mage Kell and forced to feed him power while he tortured various prisoners. She was particularly valuable to Kell because the nature of her magic is such that she gains power when people near her are in pain. You can see how that might be handy to a torturer.

At the start of the novel, she escapes and falls in with other fugitives including the disinherited Prince Cam and his foster brother Isidro who is crippled after suffering torture which Sierra witnessed.

In the country of Riclan, where the action takes place, people with magical abilities are considered tainted and cursed by the gods. Children who show magical talents generally have their powers shackled even then are still considered dangerous and unlucky. Spurrier uses this to great effect to explore ideas of prejudice and discrimination. Despite the fact that Sierra only harms people that are trying to kill her, people are afraid of her and, more interestingly, have difficulty accepting that she isn’t evil. Almost no one offers her any consideration, even after she saves their lives. It’s very frustrating (in a good, well-written way) to see characters make stupid decisions because they’re afraid of her or because they want to profit somehow. It’s also satisfying when it comes back to bite them on the arse.

There are a lot of shades of grey in terms of character in Winter Be My Shield. There are the sympathetic central characters and there is the torturing Bloodmage, Kell. But everyone else is caught somewhere in the middle. The characters that mistrust Sierra and try to hurt her aren’t necessarily bad people (OK some of them are), mostly they’re just acting based on how they’ve been brought up or past bad experiences. Kell’s apprentice, Rasten, is also more complicated than he originally appears to be. He was captured and broken (under torture) by Kell at an early age so how much of what he does is really his fault?

It was delightfully frustrating to watch (and heckle at the page) characters throw away their best hope of not dying (ie Sierra and her magic) out of misguided notions of evil. You know it’s a good book if it evokes such strong reactions.

Spurrier also brought up interesting questions in the way Isidro, the man crippled by torture, was treated. Those closest to him, like his brother Cam, were willing to do a lot to look after him. Other people with less of a connection see him as a useless burden. Of course, he’s sympathetic to the reader, but how much can one really blame the people who want to look out for themselves? Answer: it depends on how they go about it.

It’s been a little while since I read such an involved fantasy novel that wasn’t a sequel and/or by an established author. Winter Be My Shield is a striking debut and I look forward to reading the sequels (and hope it’s not too long a way between them).

5 / 5 stars ...more

flag 2 likes · Like · see review

Jan 13, 2015 Elle rated it did not like it · review of another edition

Shelves: finished-but-tested-will-to-live, dwarf-beards-and-fantastical-things

"Black Sun" count: 95. Gee, what series is this again? I can't remember; better repeat it another BILLION times.

I probably wouldn't have noticed if the rest of the book had been good, but it wasn't at all. I didn't care about a single character; in fact, I was rooting against all of them by the end simply for something interesting/entertaining to happen. They trudge around in snow, whine, call each other infuriating nicknames, yadda yadda. The magic system wasn't interesting enough to save ...more

flag 2 likes · Like · see review

Nov 10, 2017 Nicole Luiken rated it really liked it

Shelves: sf-fantasy, new-to-me-2017

Strong world-building (as a Canadian I can really get into a wintry setting.) A three-sided war with no side that doesn't want to use or kill the heroine leads to hard choices. Ditto for the tortured hero. I will definitely look for book two.

Quibble: I was hoping for more of a climax, but this was more of a character-makes-a-choice ending for book one in a series.

flag 1 like · Like · see review

Aug 04, 2013 Rosa rated it it was amazing

Shelves: wide-reading-logs-school-2013

I choose this book because I was at the public library and decided to give some fantasy a go. Aside from the Hobbit and Lord of the Rings (which I of course enjoyed!) - I have absolutely hated most fantasy when I have previously attempted to read it, mainly because it has seemed so hard to believe and because all fantasy books seem to involve similar themes, namely, dragons, swirly whoosy magic and unlikely heroes rising to defeat a powerful force of evil! I know many people like these types of I choose this book because I was at the public library and decided to give some fantasy a go. Aside from the Hobbit and Lord of the Rings (which I of course enjoyed!) - I have absolutely hated most fantasy when I have previously attempted to read it, mainly because it has seemed so hard to believe and because all fantasy books seem to involve similar themes, namely, dragons, swirly whoosy magic and unlikely heroes rising to defeat a powerful force of evil! I know many people like these types of books but I have just not previously enjoyed them. However, this book may have just changed my mind about the genre. For the first time in a long time, I enjoyed a fantasy novel.

The category this book completes is a fantasy/science fiction book. It was really fascinating and although it took me ages to read I am very glad I did. The book was about a woman named Sierra who escaped from the evil Rasten and Kell who is the King’s torturer. She is on the run in a desolate winter environment with low hopes of survival when she meets two men (Isidro and Cammarian) and their friends who are fugitives, in hiding from the queen who is Cammarian’s mother. She joins them and together they attempt to evade their pursuers while also avoiding the slavers and the battles which rage across their country. It seemed much more believable than some fantasy I’ve read or heard of, and had a believable world (with no fairies or anything of the like!), and with magic that didn’t seem ridiculous. I liked also how it wasn’t all about magic being used to heal or make things appear and disappear, fly or other typical ‘fairy dust’ things. The magic in this book was dark, used as a weapon in battle and was raised through the suffering or happiness of others, which made for a much more interesting and less innocent story. The battle scenes complete with the use of magic were actually very good and well written as I could feel the tension and even though I usually scoff at magic, it’s use was believable and was well described. As I said earlier, I’ll be less reluctant to try fantasy now I’ve read this book. I also enjoyed how this book was set in a rich and extremely well developed world. The book carried a historical element too, although not from one recognizable culture. This helped it seem much more real as did the description of the harsh environment in which the story took place.

A quote I liked from this book was
“Sierra turned her face towards the blizzard. Needles of ice stung her skin and blasted tears from her eyes and strands of black hair lashed around her face, stiff as a whipcord with frost. Huddled deep within her stolen fur she forced her way through the drifts, as the wind howled and shrieked in her ears.”

This quote conveys the harshness of the environment the characters live in and it uses good descriptive language. When I read this quote, I can picture the blizzard and the situation the character is in well. It also seems to portray the overall mood of the book, which was to be honest, rather bleak and a bit depressing. Saying this, I also found parts of the book especially hopeful and fairly dramatic, the drama is another thing reflected in this description.

My favourite character was Sierra. She is a type of mage called a Sympath who draws power from the suffering of others. Contrary to this, she is not a horrible person and does not kill or torture people to gain her strength, unlike her pursuer Rasten who is a complex character but not afraid to kill or maim to get power. I enjoyed reading about her character as she is a unique character with a troubled background but she does not let this stop her from having morals and does not let her powers sway her to become overly twisted and evil. This shows she is very strong in herself and her beliefs. She is also a main character who has her own opinions and ideas and doesn’t let people tell her what to do. I usually make a comment similar to this about the protagonists in novels I read that I enjoy, as I can’t stand a book with a pathetic main character! In general, most of the characters in this novel were pretty strong due to the harsh environment and lives they had grown up with, and they all felt well developed with interesting back stories.

Something this book taught me was that fantasy is not necessarily boring or cheesy. Of course, I already knew this after reading the Hobbit and Lord of the Rings, but some of this genre I have found to be pretty average and repetitive. I am so glad I picked up this book as I have now decided that I will read more of the good fantasy instead of simply rolling my eyes at its mention. Another thing this book taught me, that relates to the first point, is that magic does not always have to be for fairies - a goody good shower of pink and sparkles. This book involves gritty magic that is more of a force of bad than good, and I have enjoyed this much more.

In summary, Winter Be My Shield was a really good book. I couldn’t find time to read, so it took me a while but it was well worth it as it has reintroduced me to the Fantasy genre. I am really glad I picked up this book and want to read the next one. Also, I hear they might be making a movie of this in 2015!

...more

flag 1 like · Like · see review

Feb 11, 2014 K. rated it did not like it · review of another edition

Recommends it for: No one ever

Shelves: 2014, fantasy, setting-fantasy, own-it-kindle, would-not-read-again, australian, war, audience-adult

I was on the struggle bus with this book from pretty much page one. I don't know what it was, but there was just something about it that dragged. I made it about 25% of the way through and seriously considered throwing it on the DNF pile because I was JUST. SO. BORED and it had taken me days to read that far, which never happens. I never felt like I was making any progress with it - you'd turn page after page after page, and my Kindle was all "Nope, you're still only 11% done. LOL."

In addition I was on the struggle bus with this book from pretty much page one. I don't know what it was, but there was just something about it that dragged. I made it about 25% of the way through and seriously considered throwing it on the DNF pile because I was JUST. SO. BORED and it had taken me days to read that far, which never happens. I never felt like I was making any progress with it - you'd turn page after page after page, and my Kindle was all "Nope, you're still only 11% done. LOL."

In addition to the epic drag factor, I struggled a lot with the violence. We're not talking "epic battle" violence here or fight to the death violence. We're talking extended scenes and discussions of rape and torture, and how some characters suffered through this for years. We're talking a man getting slowly skinned and dismembered so that a character can absorb his life force. We're talking about one character who likes to make his (straight) "apprentice"/slave rape other men and who isn't against paedophilia provided the girls don't have a "womanly figure" yet. We're talking about a society that's totally okay with slavery. We're talking bizarre decisions like Isidro being in constant pain thanks to the pulverised bones in his arm that he's told several times won't heal properly and he'll end up unable to use his arm or move his hand, but he (and those around him) refuses to consider amputation because "then I'll be a cripple". DUDE. YOU'RE ALREADY THERE, WITH A SIDE OF CONSTANT PAIN. Your logic is not like our earth logic.

Add in to that the fact that Spurrier has created a world with an incredibly complex society, but there's not nearly enough world building to adequately convey how society works. (Unless, you know, it took place during one of the many sections in which I was basically asleep with my eyes open) Each family unit seems to consist of two husbands and two wives, and the child refers to all of them as their parents. We're told that there are numerous tribes and that some are more powerful than others. But then there are entire countries who refer to the tribes as "barbarians" and operate with a whole different type of society. And there's nowhere near enough explanation of how any of it works.

Basically, about 75% of this book seemed to consist of people wandering about in the snow, making big plans and then having to change said big plans because they were ambushed. Rinse, repeat, add in a fair whack of torture, a little sex and a couple of battles, and you've got yourself a book. ...more

flag 1 like · Like · see review

Feb 21, 2017 Maja Ingrid rated it it was ok

Shelves: fantasy, disappointments

Plot
The book started slow. It took almost a 4th of the book before stuff actually started to happen. The action scenes that came after that were interesting but the rest of the book was dull. It was also lots of chunky info-dump on info dump. Seriously it felt like the first 100 pages was nothing but. Now I don’t mind info-dumps because high fantasy novels do need to exposition, but it gets heavy to handle when there’s more exposition than actual plot in the book. Because bigger parts of the ...more

flag 1 like · Like · see review

Apr 23, 2015 Georgia Claire rated it liked it

Shelves: fantasy

I liked this book, but honestly got so bewildered by who was on what side in their ongoing tussles that it became very difficult to follow any of the machinations. Basically: Isidro and Cam are against literally everyone else, including their own mothers. I think. I don't know, I got really confused. Honestly, the depictions of surviving winter in a perpetually frozen landscape were far more interesting.

One significant nitpick, speaking as a geographer. A major plot point revolves around the ...more

flag 1 like · Like · see review

Sep 29, 2017 Kron rated it it was ok

Shelves: own

Both heavy on characters and world. The characters were fully fleshed, though I did not particularly connect. Isidro was my most favourite character, followed by another that works directly with him but doesn't appear until 75% of the way through the book.

The first third of the book kept me interested - the world fascinated me and the characters interactions with each other. Then a switch flipped and I suddenly no longer cared. There was no upping of stakes, I became disinterested in the story ...more

flag 1 like · Like · see review

Sep 23, 2015 Peter rated it it was ok

2.5/5

Winter Be My Shield is Jo Spurrier's competent debut novel. It's not your average fantasy book, as there's some interesting and unique ideas going on in it. The magic system in particular is a good one. However, this is brought down by bland story-telling and irritating main characters. These problems are off-putting enough that it made it a chore to finish the book, let alone continue on to the rest of the trilogy. It's hard to say if Winter Be My Shield is worth the effort, but each to ...more

flag 1 like · Like · see review

Mar 18, 2013 Renee V rated it really liked it

Shelves: ebook-read, fantasy, owned

A great high fantasy novel from an Australian author. Recommend to lovers of fantasy. I enjoyed this story so much I bought the second one almost as soon as I had finished. (Sadly though I didn't enjoy the second one as much and was frustrated with how the character development happens) The character stories in this one however really drew me in and I'm still looking forward to seeing how it all pan's out for them.

flag 1 like · Like · see review

Jan 06, 2017 Adrielle rated it really liked it

Shelves: fantasy

3.5 - 4 stars
An intriguing world with layered characters. Quite gritty in parts and you can tell that the author is trying to illustrate the violence of the world in a subtle matter. However, dropping a C-bomb in the last 10 pages did not lend any effectiveness, rather, it turned me off. Hence the drop by half a star. I will give the second one a go though.

flag 1 like · Like · see review

Jun 11, 2012 Alison rated it really liked it

Full review to come, but OMG, best fantasy I've read in ages. Think Te good bits of Robert Jordan, JV Jones, Sara Douglas....just darn good story telling, with great characters.

flag 1 like · Like · see review

Nov 10, 2015 Angela marked it as to-read · review of another edition

Shelves: fantasy, kindle

10 November 2015: $1.99 on Kindle

flag 1 like · Like · see review

Jun 30, 2019 Alyssa Grace rated it really liked it

Shelves: fantasy

It was wonderful to read this tale of a devastating blizzard-covered escape on a 37 degree summer day. I can't believe how hard this series is slept on. I've been waiting to read Winter Be My Shield forever, and it was as good as I imagined.

I know I'm seven years late, but hell, you wouldn't understand how much I want to drop everything right now and make a Save Isidro Balorica campaign. I really wonder if Jo Spurrier was answering a challenge to make a character suffer the most humanly possible It was wonderful to read this tale of a devastating blizzard-covered escape on a 37 degree summer day. I can't believe how hard this series is slept on. I've been waiting to read Winter Be My Shield forever, and it was as good as I imagined.

I know I'm seven years late, but hell, you wouldn't understand how much I want to drop everything right now and make a Save Isidro Balorica campaign. I really wonder if Jo Spurrier was answering a challenge to make a character suffer the most humanly possible while deserving nothing but happiness. I mean, come on, he's an orphan with a tragic backstory who gets brutalised over...and over...and over again yet keeps sacrificing everything for his friends, every time you think he's finally gotten some respite.

For fuck's sake, (view spoiler) I actually could not believe what I was reading at certain points, because it was almost comical how much torture this one guy was going through.

Despite the high level of brutality, this book remains readable because it never gets gratuitous, no matter how cruel the scenes depicted. I'm really grateful for that and it gives me hope for the trilogy. Yes, I know this finished several years ago, but please by the Black Sun save everyone. Isidro first of all. But also let Sierra have her happy ending, and Cam have his happy ending, and even Rasten have his happy ending.

There are some nice touches of dark humour if your sense of humour is on the same wavelength as mine. I'm primarily looking at Rasten scenes, of course. And yeah, he's got it so bad for Sierra, I'm a bit scared he'll run off the deep end. The two of them and Isidro make for an interesting telepathy triangle which makes their interactions by far the most interesting.

This also means that Isidro's arc when separated from the rest of the squad is the weakest segment of the book and simply a bore, not least because I find Delphine absolutely grating. Please, for the love of the Black Sun, get the entire Akharian Empire (faux-man Empire, don't try to tell me it's not a budget high fantasy Rome) out of Ricalan. I dislike them more than Kell. ...more

flag Like · see review

Mar 08, 2017 Erin-Claire rated it liked it

This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it, click here. This review is informed by having finished all the series, but I'll just repeat the review in each one.

Overall I'm glad to have read to the end of the third book, I thought the story was worthwhile and well done, the character development definitely improved over the series, and the magic system was pretty original (I would really like to read a series set later in time that explored the magic a lot more).

Warning for spoilers ahead.

Characters:
Sierra – did we ever really get to know her? This review is informed by having finished all the series, but I'll just repeat the review in each one.

Overall I'm glad to have read to the end of the third book, I thought the story was worthwhile and well done, the character development definitely improved over the series, and the magic system was pretty original (I would really like to read a series set later in time that explored the magic a lot more).

Warning for spoilers ahead.

Characters:
Sierra – did we ever really get to know her? Motivations were often a little unclear and seemed more to suit the plot than actually fit her character, and her character moved further and further from the limelight as the series continued. The character development was limited in a way because the reader never really got to know much about any of the characters. While avoiding info-dumping is important, I really wish I could have got a sense of each character’s back story fairly early in the book, because I was still trying to piece together exactly where everyone was from and how they fit together halfway through the third book. Having said that, Rasten's character arc was fantastic and the characterisation of his mental state mostly very believable.

Magic system:
Totally lacking in clarity! A bit like characters – there was an info dump on how magic worked somewhere in I think the third book. This should have been somewhere near the start of the first because it was never completely clear til then. The reader needs to understand the system so it’s not a distraction wondering if you understand it yet.

Torture:
Torture was a central theme of the book. Questionable whether it was perhaps too much, too often. Was it really believable? Especially, is it believable that anyone can put up with that much? The author does a fairly good job of showing the post-traumatic injury done to everyone by the torture, especially in the second and third books. But is it realistic?

Slavery:
I could just about cope with the torture scenes, but the whole depiction of slavery was a bit too much – made me want to throw the book against the room. I don't really enjoy slogging through those 'how much awful can we put the character through before they rise in triumph on the other side' type books (although the redeeming feature here I guess is the lack of rising in triumph...)
I didn't really find the behaviour of the ‘slavers’ group that believable. It felt at times like the author had read the worst accounts of child abuse, torture and slavery and decided that in societies where these things happened, they must happen in their worst form, all the time, to everyone. Real people and societies are much more varied, their motivations and personal convictions clash. I didn’t feel this came through well in the first book in particular.

Disability, acquired injury, trauma:
The way the author deals with the mental and physical trauma and disability acquired through a traumatic incident seems good (although speaking from limited experience or research). At least she doesn’t have them get over it and get better, and especially not within an unrealistic timeframe. Because it’s such a trope of fantasy books, I kind of expected Sierra’s power would actually turn out to be a power to heal, so it was nice to be surprised here (even though her power was never really well explained).

Relationships and romance:
I liked the diversity of relationships, and especially a whole culture where monogamous relationships were not the norm (although it was never quite explained how the family system worked). The development of relationships between the characters, whether romantic or not, was one of the best bits of character development in the books and one of my favourite parts of the books.
...more

flag Like · see review

Jan 13, 2018 Barbara Howe rated it it was amazing

Shelves: spec-fic-deserving-a-reread

What choices can you make when there are no acceptable choices left? That seems to be the question raised in this trilogy.

Once protected by powerful mages, the Ricalani people abandoned magic a century ago, making them ripe for plunder. In a three-way war, the Ricalanis are struggling against cultural obliteration as they are slowly overwhelmed by the conquering Mesentrian’s encroaching settlers, or are carried off as slaves to the neighbouring Ashkarian empire.

The main characters are all, in ...more

flag Like · see review

Sep 05, 2019 Mary rated it it was ok · review of another edition

Shelves: australian-author

This is the first book in the Children of the Black Sun series. Fifteen-year-old Cammarian (Cam) is heir to the Ricalan throne after the death of his aunt, Queen Leandra. Cam had been sent to foster with the Owl Clan and is close friends with Isidro, the son of the clan's chieftain. However Cam's Mesentreian mother Valeria enlists the sorcerous powers of Blood-Mage Kell to prevent the coronation and place Cam's older brother Severian on the throne instead. Cam and Isidro have been on the run ...more

flag Like · see review

May 29, 2017 Julianne rated it liked it

This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it, click here.

flag Like · see review

Nov 17, 2017 Tim Stead rated it really liked it

I enjoyed this book. I always like trying new authors and Jo Spurrier came to hand just as I was looking for something to read. It started out a little low. We are plunged into the middle of a war. The slave-owning Akharian Empire is fighting the Mesentreian rulers of Ricalan and the tribal people of Ricalan, nominally loyal to their Mesentreian rulers are caught in the middle. The story centres on Sierra, an empath of sorts who draws power from pain. She's running away from the Mesentreian ...more

flag Like · see review