The first ever Goosebumps comic adaptation—if you exclude the FBX magazines, which I don’t count as whole books or stories. This was a really solid read for the most part, and I dug the selection of stories. The first two stories had great art styles, both of them being very detailed and semi realistic, the scarecrow going for a hyper realistic feel. Each story was a very accurate adaptation of its book counterpart, which is commendable, and I enjoyed each of them story wise to an extent *coughs* abominable snowman ending *wheezes*. Not a lot to be said for positives, they’re just generally solid adaptations of decent stories and of the two have a great art style. But each story has its flaws. Story One, some of the character were ugly at times. Just flat out ugly. But that’s not the worst thing in this comic collection. Story Two, the characters are hideous at times, like borderline looks-like-a-pile-of-shit. And there’s some really awkward shots in it where the angle is too close to the face, or an expression doesn’t look well, or it’s hard to tell what’s going on like the horse scene and nightmare sequence. And generally, whilst it’s really cool to look at in some frames, the art style can get… iffy. And the third story—FUCK ME SIDEWAYS. Wayyyyyy too cartoony, and I don’t care what folks say, it’s just really kiddish and dork-diary ahh shit, as I call it. Also, the worst of the three is the longest story, and just so happens to have the worst art style and still one of the worst endings to a Goosebumps story, but that issue will be mostly ignored (we’re going off adapting and art style as well as if the story of good or not, which is mostly is). I loved the first two even with their flaws but the art style in the third was just stupid and let alone the story was a drag to get through. Here’s my ratings for each and overall:
The Werewolf of Fever Swamp - 9/10
The Scarecrow Walks at Midnight - 8.5/10
The Abominable Snowman of Pasadena - 5/10
(^ worst than the original book lol)
I’m gonna be generous and give it an 8/10, I like it a bit more than the first one since the art styles are overall better.