Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read.
Start by marking “The Gods of Gotham (Timothy Wilde, #1)” as Want to Read:
The Gods of Gotham (Timothy Wilde, #1)
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating
Open Preview

The Gods of Gotham

(Timothy Wilde #1)

3.87  ·  Rating details ·  12,022 ratings  ·  1,862 reviews
1845. New York City forms its first police force. The great potato famine hits Ireland. These two seemingly disparate events will change New York City. Forever.

Timothy Wilde tends bar near the Exchange, fantasizing about the day he has enough money to win the girl of his dreams. But when his dreams literally incinerate in a fire devastating downtown Manhattan, he finds hi
Hardcover, 408 pages
Published March 15th 2012 by Penguin Adult HC/TR (first published 2012)
More Details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Reader Q&A

To ask other readers questions about The Gods of Gotham, please sign up.
Popular Answered Questions
Traci Rauck Have you read The Alienist by Caleb Carr? It is a murder mystery (about a serial killer) but takes place in NYC in that time frame and has a lot of…moreHave you read The Alienist by Caleb Carr? It is a murder mystery (about a serial killer) but takes place in NYC in that time frame and has a lot of historical detail(less)

Community Reviews

Showing 1-30
3.87  · 
Rating details
 ·  12,022 ratings  ·  1,862 reviews

Sort order
(B+) 77% | Good
Notes: It revels in period authenticity, though its heroes’ progressive social attitudes feel too twenty-first century for the era.
Florence (Lefty) MacIntosh
Nov 10, 2013 rated it it was amazing
Recommended to Florence (Lefty) by: Derek Green
Probably it was exactly what I felt like reading right about now, whatever, but I haven’t been this entertained in years. We’re talking quality escapism. A murder mystery featuring the NYPD in its infancy, ‘copper stars’ mainly made up of scrappy, downtrodden Irishmen. “We were all missing bits and pieces.”
A swarm of emigrants gushes ceaselessly onto the South Street docks “the entire block consisted of Irish and dogs and rats sharing the same fleas” - that they’re Catholics makes them all the m
New York City Police Department Application - 1845

1) Can you walk?

2) Are you a Democrat?

If you answered ‘Yes’ to both of these questions: Congratulations! You are now a police officer for the city of New York.

Timothy Wilde was a bartender who was doing well by the standards of 1845. He had saved some money which he planned on using for his dream of purchasing a ferry boat and asking the woman he was in love with to marry him. However, a devastating fire leaves him homeless, unemployed, penniless
Hope, I've discovered, is a sad nuisance. Hope is a horse with a broken leg. ~The Gods of Gotham, Lyndsay Faye
New York City, 1845. Helped by an explosion of combustible saltpeter, a great fire has once again decimated Lower Manhattan, claiming the lives of four fireman and 26 civilians.

Across the Atlantic, a terrible potato blight is beginning to take its toll, and shiploads of desperate, starving Irish pour into the city despised for their race and religion. Despite having traveled so far, wo
3,5 Sterne

Wäre der Start in das Buch für mich etwas besser verlaufen, hätte ich dem ganzen auch getrost 4 Sterne gegeben, allerdings wurde die Geschichte zu Beginn sehr langsam aufgebaut und erzählt, es hat mir einfach etwas lange gedauert bis Spannung aufgebaut wurde. Was ich allerdings hervorragend fand, war, dass ich ziemlich lange im Dunkeln getappt bin was den Mörder angeht und dann Fall an sich fand ich auch sehr gelungen. Der Schreibstil war der Zeit, in der der Roman spielt, angemessen u
This one was...rough. Like, AMAZING. But also rough.

This one deals with a LOT of difficult topics. There's a hell of a lot of anti-Irish sentiment, because it's set in New York in the 1840s, right at the time when there was a huge influx of Irish immigrants due to the Famine. (ETA: Reading it this week with the Cheeto-in-Chief's bullshit Muslim ban was actually kind of a horrifying reminder that there's ALWAYS been an immigrant population that's discriminated against and that the existing popul
3.5 Stars

"I'd known before meeting her that women were capable of writing murder across their eyelids and then sweetly blinking at a fellow, but I'd not seen it. It's pretty daunting, when it's done proper."

It's 1845 New York and the BIG fire has just wiped out part of the city as well as bartender Tim Wilde and his stash of $400 saved over the last ten years (to win over the love of his life).......Now disfigured with nowhere to turn, the good natured Tim reluctantly accepts a job from his mu


New York back in the mid 19th century sounds like a shit hole. Probably no more or less than any other major city at that time but what a melting pot of emotions mixing so many different types of characters with differing ethnic backgrounds into a relatively small space. It's not going to end well!

Although this is what drew me in; I love a bit of historical fiction taking me to a different time and place and even better when I don't know a great deal about that era. This novel layers the atm
Doug Bradshaw
May 31, 2014 rated it really liked it
Unfortunately, things haven't changed much since 1845 except maybe back then it was easier to get drugs like Morphine, hookers were cheap, Catholics disliked Irish and other protestants perhaps a little more than these days. It was also more normal to drink a lot during the day, the political leaders got away with all kinds of bad dealings and politics (wait, maybe that one hasn't changed) and little orphan kids were treated like slaves sometimes in the sex industry...I think I just heard the FB ...more
Jason Pettus
(Reprinted from the Chicago Center for Literature and Photography []. I am the original author of this essay, as well as the owner of CCLaP; it is not being reprinted illegally.)

A couple of years ago, Lyndsay Faye's clever Sherlock Holmes/Jack The Ripper thriller Dust and Shadow made CCLaP's best-of-the-year lists, and with me specifically saying at the time that I was looking forward to a wholly original creation from this engaging, smart author; and now that original creation is
Diane S ☔
Dec 30, 2011 rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
This was a fantastic historical mystery taking place in 1852 New York City. The potato famine has caused hundreds of thousands of Irish immigrants to flock to New York, causing untoward problems between the protestants and the newly arrived Catholics. The Five Point area, 6th district is a poor violent area full of corruption and crime. A new police force, the predecessor to the NYPD is formed, the men wearing the badge are called Copper stars by the residents. Add to that a murderer of children ...more
aPriL does feral sometimes
A vortex of a book! The twists and turns and reveals and dark secrets - I'm spinning! Without reservation, I recommend this book as the best mystery I've read this year! Terrific, well-done, exciting read, despite the horror, death and destruction without a lot of resolution...because it's, you know, New York.

Timothy Wilde, I love you. I want to be your woman. Poor man. I'm a sucker for a guy who is so tough, he's willing to fight 50 men by himself, even though he knows he's going to die, in try
Feb 23, 2016 rated it really liked it
Absolutely BRILLIANT historical fiction! WOW! Faye has and does it all: her language is fluid and melodious; her work's historical accuracy and her attention to detail are downright academic; the characters she creates are multi-dimensional and continue to grow throughout the novel; etc, etc.

The setting is early 19th century antebellum New York City. I've read a bunch of scholarly studies on the era and region, and was absolutely blown-away by all the accurate details Faye managed to explore: w
May 19, 2012 rated it it was amazing
Lyndsay Faye is a remarkable author with a unique talent for interesting plot and rich characters. She enlightens an era of urban history not often relived with grace, candor, and a lyrical prose that effortlessly advances her story while painting a vivid picture of the city's buildings, streets, and inhabitants, even as her unlikely protagonist sketches them in modest charcoal.

"The Gods of Gotham" is impossible to put down once taken up.
Aaron Arnold
May 29, 2012 rated it liked it
A murder mystery set in 1840s New York City, this is something of a cross between Caleb Carr's The Alienist in subject and Dennis Lehane's The Given Day in writing style. Its similarity the Lehane book put me off at first, partly because Faye had the exact same tendency that Lehane did to tell the reader how to feel about everything that was put in front of them. One of my least favorite writer's tics is when they decide that some object just has to serve as a convenient metaphor, and then nothi ...more
Apr 09, 2012 rated it liked it  ·  review of another edition
Shelves: hf, audible, usa, mystery
This is engaging from page one. You feel like you are in NYC, at the middle of the 19th Century. NYC has just formed a police force, due to rampant crime. There is filth and vermin and fires - great to have recently read Triangle: The Fire That Changed America, although that took place 50 years later.

I am listening to the audiobook narrated by Steven Boyer. Every word is clear, even though the speed is rapid. The Irish brogue is just perfect for the time and setting. There is a glossary in the
Feb 03, 2019 rated it it was ok  ·  review of another edition
Shelves: history
War leider absolut nicht meins...
Es ist ganz anders als das was man kennt, irgendwie aber auch nichts Halbes und nichts Ganzes. Historisch interessant aber zäh, dazu Crime Elemente, die zu kurz kommen.
Der Einstieg war schwierig und ich habe ziemlich lange gebraucht um rein zu finden.

Timothy Wilde wird zusammen mit seinem Bruder Valentine Polizist. Der ist korrupt, nimmt Drogen und ist einer der interessantesten Charakter im Buch. Allgemein sind die Figuren vielschichtig und gut gezeichnet. Zu
Mar 20, 2012 rated it really liked it
Once you make it past the late 1940’s-esque cover art---really. Can’t you see that image selling The Gods of Gotham movie starring Barbara Stanwyck, Robert Mitchum, Jennifer Jones, and Van Heflin. The Gods of Gotham…a world torn apart by burning passions! Anyway. As I was implying the cover art is aged at best but the contents? Much better than the cover would have you believe.

My guess is that The Gods of Gotham will most often be compared to The Alienist. Both books are cut from the same cloth
A Girl Has No Name
4 stars!

This book has been lying on my TBR for quite a while; I don't know why it took me such a long time to finally pick it book, as the blurb has been very appealing. I'm a huge fan of historical crime and thriller stories and I was thus very excited about this book. When I finally managed to pick it up, I wasn't decieved.

Lyndsay Faye is a great writer. With the perfect use of an old language and an amazing historical knowledge, she managed to suck me right into the city of New York in 1845.
Jul 15, 2014 rated it it was amazing
Shelves: read-in-2014
So yeah, despite some faults, I really enjoyed this, enough to give it 5 stars.

Faye weaves a wonderful and multi-layered tale in a Gothic setting that is sure to appeal to those who appreciate a good mystery/piece of historical fiction. In addition to an engaging main plot, Faye manages a number of subplots that compliment rather than distract for the primary story line. And while a few of the secondary/supporting characters bordered on cliches, the key characters felt fresh and well-drawn (for
Mar 20, 2012 rated it liked it  ·  review of another edition
The Gods of Gotham by Lyndsay Faye is an interesting read.

"After a fire disseminates a swathe of lower Manhattan, and following years of passionate political dispute, New York City at long last forms an official Police Department. The same summer the great potato famine hits Ireland. These events will change the city of New York forever.

Lyndsay Faye does an amazing job of bringing to life the sense of time and place of 1845 New York City. You certainly get a feel for this city and its people.
Hannah Greendale
Jul 06, 2016 rated it really liked it
A protagonist who grows more likable with every turn of the page, and a mystery more sinister and disturbing with every clue followed.
 Danielle The Book Huntress (Back to the Books)
The Gods of Gotham was an impulse audio read from my trusty library, and it was definitely worth the read. The narrator really took this book where it needed to go. His voices were subtly different for each character. He endows Timothy with the integral mix of hardened cynic and stubborn idealist which defines his persona. For Valentine, Timothy's jaded older brother, his tone is more sardonic and poised, what I would expect of a borderline shady rakish fellow such as Valentine. The narrator als ...more
Willem van den Oever
The Gods of Gotham” could hardly have opened in a more impressive way. Starting off at breakneck speed, the reader is shot back in time to New York, 1845, as a raging fire destroys a large portion of the city. Debris flies through the air, the stench of burning skin lingers in the air and thousands of people are left homeless by the destruction. Amongst those whose life is destroyed in Timothy Wilde. Formerly a barkeeper at a local oyster bar, he discovers his workplace is eaten by the flames, ...more
Sep 12, 2016 rated it it was ok
Shelves: mystery-thriller
The author follows up her engaging debut, Dust and Shadow, with The Gods Of Gotham. The setting is 1845 Manhattan and the early days of the NYPD. Our hero, Timothy Wilde, loses his barkeep job – and almost his life – after a devastating fire. Through political connections – and his brother – - Timothy joins the Police Department. This “intro” taking more than a few pages to get through and a chronic problem I found with this book. For although the detail here – which I can only assume is the fru ...more
Just read the other reviews. Faye's story grabs you from the first sentence and doesn't let go. My only regret is that the library glued down the flaps, covering up part of the map of Manhattan on the inner covers. Timothy Wilde and his brother Val seem a little bigger than life - orphans after fire took their parents lives. Val lives by his wits as Party boss - the Democrats. Wilde is made penniless when southern Manhattan burns to the ground - his savings and his job as bartender up in smoke. ...more
I both read and listened to the audio book. I enjoyed this book a lot. It kept me. Once I got into the storey, I could not put it down. I am looking forward to reading Lindsay Faye's next book. I already have it from the library.

I loved the way she brought the old New York back to life. She really brought home the way the Irish were treated during the potato famine. The Irish part of my family came to New York State during that period. I don't know if they ever lived in New York City. They did
He wasn't in front of me any longer. He was a thousand and a thousand and a thousand miles away. It was a ransomed look. One he'd never before showed me. And since he'd never shown me, I'd never known it was there.

Rep: mc with burn scars, bi side character

I read this book first a year ago, on someone's recommendation, and the Wilde brothers killed me then. Rereading it now, it's even worse. Because you know everything that's going to happen to them, in this book and in later books, and they're
Thomas Edmund
May 11, 2012 rated it really liked it
I hate to sound terribly uneducated, but I'm not a huge fan of 'literary' books that require a dictionary to read, or have such manipulated prose I can barely read them.

Gods of Gotham does have a Flash Dictionary, and the prose is quite poetic, however when it came to this book my concerns were little more than foibles. Sure Gods of Gotham isn't your typically whodunnit thriller, but is stocked well with drama at a good pace.

While at times I was worried the substance would disappear behind the l
Jan 25, 2014 rated it liked it
I expected to like this book much more than I did. The story was good but I felt it was derivative (The TV show "Copper" and the film "The Gangs of New York). The author provides a glossary at the front of the book, but for me it is only half complete. This may be my fault, but I thought I needed to spend too much time with the maps provided on the inside covers. I don't live in New York, but I've been there a few times in my life including to all the places where the story is set and I didn't r ...more
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 next »
topics  posts  views  last activity   
Choice Book Assignment 1 3 May 16, 2018 07:41AM  
What did you think of this book? 5 67 Apr 21, 2016 06:51AM  
Has anyone read this book and what do you think of it? 20 154 Apr 21, 2016 06:50AM  
Change the Title! 1 9 Apr 09, 2016 06:31PM  
Change the Title! 1 5 Apr 09, 2016 06:31PM  
Nothing But Readi...: Faye, Lyndsay; The Gods of Gotham "Relaxed Buddy Read" (Start Date: July 26, 2013) 51 196 Sep 21, 2014 03:16AM  
  • The Bedlam Detective (Sebastian Becker, #2)
  • A Curtain Falls (Simon Ziele, #2)
  • Anatomy of Murder (Crowther and Westerman, #2)
  • The Yard (Scotland Yard's Murder Squad, #1)
  • When Maidens Mourn (Sebastian St. Cyr, #7)
  • Present Darkness (Detective Emmanuel Cooper, #4)
  • The Orphanmaster
  • Good Man Friday (Benjamin January, #12)
  • Murder as a Fine Art (Thomas De Quincey, #1)
  • The Truth of All Things (Archie Lean #1)
  • The School of Night
  • The Death Instinct (Freud, #2)
  • Cut to the Quick (Julian Kestrel Mysteries, #1)
  • The Wandering Arm (Catherine LeVendeur, #3)
  • Letters From a Murderer (Finley Jameson & Joseph Argenti #1)

Other books in the series

Timothy Wilde (3 books)
  • Seven for a Secret (Timothy Wilde, #2)
  • The Fatal Flame (Timothy Wilde, #3)
“Hope, I've discovered, is a sad nuisance. Hope is a horse with a broken leg.” 21 likes
“Nothing is as bad as it seems,' I thought with the last remnants of my dense optimism. It couldn't be. I'd already lost everything once, I'd been ten, and so had countless other people I knew, and they all picked up and kept going. Or they picked up and went in a slightly different direction.” 5 likes
More quotes…