Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read.
Start by marking “All the Sad Young Literary Men” as Want to Read:
All the Sad Young Literary Men
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating
Open Preview

All the Sad Young Literary Men

2.89  ·  Rating details ·  1,278 Ratings  ·  260 Reviews
This charming yet scathing portrait of young adulthood at the opening of the twenty-first century charts the lives of Sam, Mark, and Seth on their circuitous paths through sex, love, betrayal, and the writing of books.
Kindle Edition
Published (first published 2008)
More Details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Reader Q&A

To ask other readers questions about All the Sad Young Literary Men, please sign up.

Be the first to ask a question about All the Sad Young Literary Men

This book is not yet featured on Listopia. Add this book to your favorite list »

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  Rating Details
Jun 10, 2008 rated it it was ok  ·  review of another edition
Ha ha ha ha ha. No.

Where to even begin? Sure, there were some funny lines, particularly in the "His Google" chapter, but for the most part this book is terribly flawed. Since Gessen isn't above using charts and bulleted lists in his book, I won't refrain from using them here.

This book:

1. has a complicated relationship with irony. Late in the book, the narrator describes one character's inability to understand what another character is saying. "His English was good but it was not good enough to
Jan 23, 2009 rated it liked it  ·  review of another edition
Shelves: fiction
I wanted to like this book more. Based on the five star system, I have to give it a three. In reality it's a weak three and a half stars, maybe a three point four stars.

The book is about a three (I think, I was thinking of this book about an hour after finishing it, and I was trying to think how many different main characters are there, and I had a hard time thinking if there were three or four, I'm pretty sure it's three though) sad young men. I don't know if I'd call him literary men, but as
Apr 18, 2008 rated it it was ok  ·  review of another edition
I was actually very embarrassed asking where I could find this book in my local Borders, because I'd forgotten the name of the author (which sounds strangely like "keep guessing") and because I find the name of the book, despite its being a Fitzgerald allusion, rather regrettable. So when Frank started reading it to me, we were both surprised and confused to find we actually liked the writing and found Gessen much more talented than his n+1 co-editor Benjamin Kunkel, who'd previously been over-h ...more
Nov 28, 2008 rated it did not like it  ·  review of another edition
Recommends it for: no one, ever
Gessen clearly illustrates everything wrong with his generation of writers: an awkward desire to be vicious, but without the skill or introspection to do any real damage. It's like saying "You're an unmotivated loser for living in your parents basement. I'll be by Friday for dinner. Your mom knows I'm vegan, right?"

Also, all the lady characters are underdeveloped and horribly irritating.
May 23, 2008 rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
as somebody who didn't get any work whatsoever until i changed my email address from to, who can vouch for the knot of humility and vanity and realness and self-mythology and narrow-minded outsider resentment and self-loathing one can find himself in upon graduation--ultra records wouldn't even hire me, ultra fucking records!--i am riding hard for this book. one of the best articulations of this very real problem i know i went through at school, and which i know others ...more
Jun 18, 2008 rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
This book violates pretty much every principle you learned in writing school; it's about hypereducated twentysomethings who don't seem to have jobs or fixed locations, and who primarily engage in speculation about what might have happened between them and their ex-girlfriends. That's not what fiction is about. As we all know, fiction is about characters with cleanly-defined wants pursuing unified actions, just like we all have/do in real life. Fiction is also never about the kind of people who w ...more
Nathan Rostron
The biggest disappointment about this book is not the obvious fact that Gessen could just barely fictionalize three different aspects of himself (obsessive Jew, obsessive Russophile, obsessive politically minded do-gooder smart person) and pass them off as distinct characters, but rather that the novel--about extremely ambitious yet frustrated and self-defeating people--is itself so unambitious. At about 250 pages and with a weird skinny trim size, it's well written but not daring or adventurous ...more
Oct 15, 2010 rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
This book -- expectations for this book weren't so high thanks to so many low-star reviews on here. But, hey, it exceeded expectations. This book -- it's not a novel or a collection of linked stories. It's autofiction in which a consistent authorial presence presents itself in three barely characterized characters, each with more similiarities than differences, each with girlfriends differentiated mostly by their names (this surely intentional undercharacterization interestingly blurs the edges ...more
I enjoyed it more than I expected thanks to all the low star ratings. Confused over-educated twenty-somethings struggling with life and love in the 90s. A least it felt real.
Kristopher Jansma
Another summer reading recommendation from my boss, he billed this one as "literary candy," a description that I whole-heartedly repeat to you all. The strangely-titled book (reference to Fitzgerald, yet again!) follows a group of Harvard students who are swiftly cast out into the real world full of ideas and passion and nonsensical senses of self worth. Gessen does a good job of making these guys lovable, even as you realize that you'd probably hate any one of them if you overheard them bloviat ...more
So since I am a (still) recovering Gawker addict, I had to wait a while to read this. I guess there's supposed to be some kind of unspoken feud between n + 1 and McSweeney's, and since McSweeney's is one of my favorites, I had to let my knee-jerk hate-inclination subside, in order to give this book a fair chance. In fact, I wound up coming full circle, and was really looking forward to finally reading this, assuming it was going to be really smart and good.

Well. It was neither as bad as I'd fea
All the Sad Young Literary Men by Keith Gessen made a big splash when it came out a few years ago. I remember that. I also remember lots of complaints about it being too self-consciously self-conscious. Also self-indulgent. In that odd sense of ruminating on one's suffering that is caused (mostly) by oneself. One's drinking, not committing enough to relationships.

I think all of the above is true. Nonetheless, I really, really enjoyed this book. I found it funny and kind of true and, did I say, f
This is not a bad book. I thought it offered a fairly convincing depiction of what I observe around me most days here in the subways, parks, and especially cafés of Brooklyn, USA. But that's the problem: I would never imagine writing a novel of potential mild interest to so few. The audience that might actually find this book a good, even compelling read, may perhaps only be found in a few forward-thinking but sleepy literary outposts like Trondheim or Aarhus (and I may well be doing these Nordi ...more
Sep 27, 2014 rated it liked it  ·  review of another edition
This book doesn't pass the Bechdel test. That's a dealbreaker for me. Women here are interchangeable placeholders, and many of the women are passed from character to character throughout the book. We're not supposed to be interested in their inner lives.

Much of the prose is nice. I read most of this in one sitting. It's nicely written, but not something I would revisit.

A final note of interest: this book is only six years old, but appears to be written in another age with respect to its curiousi
Josh Friedlander
A novel pretty much designed for me: all of the characters (who are in fact one; thinly disguised autobiographical iterations whom I still had difficulty telling apart by the book's end) are solipsistic, awkward, obsessively bookish young white males who intersperse dating failures and study of obscure history/economics/politics with angst about their direction in life. And in that respect it works. I get a kick out of vicariously living my ideated Brooklyn lifestyle of lit parties, cheap theatr ...more
Nov 28, 2012 rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
Shelves: laughed-out-loud
Ladies and gentlemen, I present to you the intellectual Jonathan Tropper. His debut novel is authored by the scholar's scholar, the Harvard grad's Harvard grad. And while these characters are neither relateable to most people nor very likeable, Gessen does manage to entertain. Truthfully, this book did not deserve four stars. This book was a solid 3.6, maybe even a weak 3.7, but Goodreads does not allow for decimal points, and so I rounded up.

It's an entertaining novel that Gessen has written, a
Jul 27, 2011 rated it did not like it  ·  review of another edition
This book was beyond terrible. I'm truly sorry I bought it, and if I could get my money back in some way, I would. It's incredibly pretentious, but not even in a way where I have to at least grudgingly admit that it's well-written, or funny, or intelligent, or insightful... because this book is none of those things. So on top of NOT being the least bit smart or funny or insightful it's painfully pretentious. It's also banal and flat-out boring. The characters in this book are the same annoying g ...more
I first encountered this book through a review in Slate, and it was of relatively little interest. Cut forward to a long, dismal drive from my sister's high school graduation back to my college. It was Saturday night, the girl I'd been seeing wasn't picking up her phone, and I was staring down the Iowa blacktop listening to a long, unhappy reading from this very book on NPR. I decided to buy a 40.

And remarkably, that's how I felt whenever I read this. It was affecting, but I can say it's only af
Apr 09, 2008 rated it it was ok  ·  review of another edition
Check out the review at the Hipster Book Club.

Basically, it started out making me wanting to hurt the characters and the author for being such snobby little whiners, but by the end...well, I still thought they were snots, but I felt like I understood them better and was more forgiving.
Feb 23, 2011 rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
Someone I follow on Twitter posted a link to someone else’s blog where the author was providing book recommendations for anyone and everyone who commented based on the last five books each person had read. It was an incredible performance—over one hundred people commented, and each recommendation provided was unique and something the guy had read. Intrigued and impressed, I posted my last five and received Keith Gessen’s All the Sad Young Literary Men as a recommendation.

It’s pretty good. There
Eliana Rivero
Con este título tan prometedor, pensé que sería una novela que marcaría una etapa de mi vida o que, por lo menos, tenía muchísimo que ofrecer. No fue así. A pesar de que me resultó entretenido, carece de cohesión para hacerla una gran novela. A mí me enganchó, pero sólo por el hecho de querer terminarlo en un santiamén.

La novela gira en torno a tres personajes: Mark, Sam y Keith. Los tres son unos veinteañeros con esperanzas de hacer grandes cosas, pero, realmente, son unos fracasados. Piensan d
Sep 20, 2012 rated it liked it  ·  review of another edition
Shelves: memoir
Gessen was supposed to be the next big lit star, but the portion of the lit world he was aiming at was nursing the hangover they'd developed with Dave Eggers. Speaking of Eggers, I find some of the slack writing found in Eggers' You Shall Know Our Velocity in the "Sam" portion of ATSYLM that is set in Israel. Certainly if he'd written something that became as trendy as Eggers' A Heartbreaking Work of Staggering Genius his name would be on everyone's tongue. But this book didn't have the power to ...more
May 19, 2008 rated it liked it  ·  review of another edition
I just finished. And sure, I'm still crushing on Keith Gessen pretty hard (this review is for all of you who have suffered through my ecstatic fawning over him these last few days...), but I'm also feeling ambivalent about the book itself.

It seems like a prolonged attempt at reconciling citizenship with sexuality, as though the two things were distinct, and as though each one could justify the ugliness and infelicities of the other. Maybe this picture of that struggle is true (i.e., to life). I
Jul 24, 2008 rated it liked it  ·  review of another edition
Recommends it for: sad young literary men?
I just read Gessen's book and would like to review it with
reasons why my friend Kyle Beachy's debut fiction The Slide:A Novel about pre-9-11 confused college grads is better than Keith Gessen's

1. More colors in the cover.

Anyone can do black and white. Having recently ordered all my books in color order, I have to say there are way too many black and white books. Plus instead of a creepy literary Atlas, we have a flying van.

2. The Slide is a far superior title.

That seems obvious

3. St. Louis is
Sep 24, 2008 rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
Recommends it for: Nerdz
Recommended to Abby by: The Library Shelf.
When I went to the library to rent All We Ever Wanted Was Everything, it wasn't there, and I had to get on the wait list, so I picked All the Sad Young Literary Men up off the "new fiction" shelf because:
a) The title began with the same word.
b) Gawker hates Keith Gessen.
c) I knew some sad young literary men in my days as a sad young literary lady. I guess I still know some now, but they aren't so pathetic, these ones.
d) My brother went to Harvard and was miserable. I had a feeling that the ta
Persephone Abbott
I started this book just when a cold was starting in on me. I thought (as I was feeling already a little bit muddled) I needed an "easy book" to read. I was entertained by the first chapter, and then it seemed as I got better, the book caught the cold that was going around. To inspire my nursing skills I read some of GR's reviews of this book, and one person said, wait until you get to page 150 when it gets better and so in spite of the fact that I really really wanted really really to stop read ...more
Sep 17, 2008 rated it liked it  ·  review of another edition
Shelves: book-club
I have to say, at first this book was entirely confusing to me. Actually, I'm still not even sure how many main characters there were, and what exactly their ties to each other were. The one thing that remains consistent is that they are all very smart, and almost overly educated twenty somethings. Products of Harvard and other Ivy leagues, there lives seem to revolve around obscure authors and incidents of Jewish/Israeli history which they seem to be the only experts in. To me, aside from their ...more
Julie Ehlers
Feb 08, 2011 rated it it was ok  ·  review of another edition
Recommends it for: No one
Shelves: literary-fiction
Ugh. I got about 50 pages into this book and realized I didn't care about any of the characters at all. In fact, I found them all totally insufferable. If it had been an ordinary day, I would've pretty much abandoned the book right then. But I was on jury duty, sitting in an uncomfortable chair in City Hall, with no clear end to the day and no other books with me. So I kept on. Eventually, at about the 150 page mark, I began to care about the characters a little. After jury duty ended, I decided ...more
Nov 30, 2010 rated it it was amazing  ·  review of another edition
Shelves: fiction
This book is one of my favourites. It captures the swirling, nonsensical decision making process of people in their mid-twenties, struggling with the choices that they are being forced to make about growing up, doing the right thing, and being good partners. It is about identity and growth. It is about failure and guilt. It is about looking inside yourself and realizing that you aren't the person you expected to be.

The women in this book struck me as well. None of them are major characters but
Aug 10, 2010 rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
I bought this book because I wanted to read some contemporary fiction, rather than the classics I usually pick up. It had a good cover. And it didn't have "a moment that would change their lives forever", as just about every contemporary novel seems to have, and which I think is a ridiculous idea.

I didn't expect to like it very much. But I did. I liked it a LOT.

All the Sad Young Literary Men really captured a sort of lifestyle. It started in a promising way, as the lives of the characters' did,
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 next »
There are no discussion topics on this book yet. Be the first to start one »
  • Robin and Ruby
  • Perfect Reader
  • Bone Fire
  • Seeing Stars
  • Delta Girls
  • Pinocchio in Venice
  • Getting In
  • Day By Day (Steeple Hill Home Ties, #2)
  • Commuters
  • Long Stay in a Distant Land: A Novel
  • Raising Jake
  • Beyond Seduction (The Red Choo Diaries) (Harlequin Blaze #321)
  • Good Things I Wish You
  • Bill Warrington's Last Chance
  • Internecine
  • Palm Latitudes: A Novel
  • Your Sad Eyes and Unforgettable Mouth
  • Real Life & Liars
Keith Gessen (b. 1975) is editor-in-chief of n+1, a twice-yearly magazine of literature, politics, and culture based in New York City. He graduated from Harvard College and earned his MFA in Creative Writing from Syracuse University in 2004.

Gessen, who was born in Russia, has written about Russia for The Atlantic and the New York Review of Books. In 2005, Dalkey Archive Press published Gessen's tr
More about Keith Gessen...

Share This Book

“She had such control of tone, in her text messages, she was the Edith Wharton of text messaging.” 5 likes
“The sanatorium itself was charming, a group of cabins in the woods, a place for overworked urbanites to feel pleasantly melancholic. A slackertorium.” 0 likes
More quotes…