Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read.
Start by marking “Gay New York: Gender, Urban Culture, and the Making of the Gay Male World 1890-1940” as Want to Read:
Gay New York: Gender, Urban Culture, and the Making of the Gay Male World 1890-1940
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating
Open Preview

Gay New York: Gender, Urban Culture, and the Making of the Gay Male World 1890-1940

4.21  ·  Rating details ·  2,573 ratings  ·  107 reviews
The award-winning, field-defining history of gay life in New York City in the early to mid-20th century

Gay New York brilliantly shatters the myth that before the 1960s gay life existed only in the closet, where gay men were isolated, invisible, and self-hating. Drawing on a rich trove of diaries, legal records, and other unpublished documents, George Chauncey constructs a fascinaticentury
...more
Paperback, 496 pages
Published May 19th 1995 by Basic Books (first published May 1994)
More Details... Edit Details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Reader Q&A

To ask other readers questions about Gay New York, please sign up.

Be the first to ask a question about Gay New York

Community Reviews

Showing 1-30
Average rating 4.21  · 
Rating details
 ·  2,573 ratings  ·  107 reviews


More filters
 | 
Sort order
Start your review of Gay New York: Gender, Urban Culture, and the Making of the Gay Male World 1890-1940
Michael
Aug 27, 2018 rated it it was amazing
Shelves: favorites, 2018
My full review, as well as my other thoughts on reading, can be found on my blog.

Written in response to the notion that the 'closet' always has existed for American gay men and lesbians, as well as the concept that gender and sexuality always have been distinct domains of personhood, Chauncey's Gay New York argues that gay people were not isolated, invisible, and self-hating during the first decades of the twentieth century. Instead, the scholar claims, they reterritorialized New York in order to c
...more
Eric
Jul 14, 2010 rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
Shelves: americans, history, lurid
Heterosexuality had not become a precondition of gender normativity in early-twentieth-century working-class culture. Men had to be many things in order to achieve the status of "normal" men, but being "heterosexual" was not one of them.

If many working men thought they demonstrated their sexual virility by taking the "man's part" in sexual encounters with either women or men, normal middle-class men increasingly believed that their virility depended on their exclusive sexual interest in women.

I have my h
...more
Samantha (AK)
Dec 06, 2018 rated it really liked it
Recommends it for: Anyone Interested in Early 20th Century NYC
“Identities are always relational, produced by the ways people affiliate themselves with or differentiate themselves from others -- and are marked as different by others.” [p273]

I broke some personal reading rules with this book. I don’t write in my books (except my cookbooks), but if you flip through my copy of Gay New York, you’ll find notes in the margins and a handful of underlines. It’s big enough, even as a paperback, that I couldn’t reasonably maneuver it and a notebook around my cat,
...more
Amy Wilder
Jan 18, 2010 rated it really liked it
Recommended to Amy Wilder by: Sharon Ullman
This is a big, big book and haven't nearly read it all. It's full of fascinating details that you can just read bits and pieces and be chatting about them for life, like I am. Sometimes you don't have to finish a book for it to change things for you. The vision of New York as it was in 1890-1940 changed forever how I see the struggle for gay rights.

I used to view it as springing suddenly into existence in the 60s on the larger tide of the Civil Rights movement. Stonewall marked a key
...more
Lydia
I read this for research for a queer historical fiction novel I'm writing, and it was interesting.

Chauncey gives a very detailed, thorough, well-researched account of queer meeting places, attitudes and urban culture in New York from the 1800's till 1940 and even slightly beyond that. It was a fascinating social history, although I found parts of it often dragged on or were repeated, I learned a lot and books like this will prove invaluable in my research.

I would also like to add th
...more
Joseph Stieb
Feb 12, 2015 rated it it was amazing
This is one of the more remarkable history books I've read in a while. It is important both in a scholarly sense and to Americans' understanding of their own culture and history. Anyone with a brain knows that there were homosexuals in the past, but for Chauncey to dig up that history with such richness, depth, and clarity is a true achievement.

The basic argument is that a vibrant male gay community formed from the 1890's to the 1920's and began to go into the closet only in the 1930's and 40's
...more
Chris
Nov 28, 2012 rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
Chauncey's history (1994) of the gay world of New York in the early twentieth century is encyclopedic. He did important original research, unlikely to ever be surpassed, mostly through oral interviews. He goes further in synthesizing the data into a convincing theory of the evolution of queer identity from "fairies" whose sexuality is based on behavior, into "gay" and "straight" desire representing the now ubiquitous homosexual/heterosexual divide. The book easily earns a full 5 stars for this work.

...more
Nathaniel
Jul 02, 2017 rated it it was amazing
this book is an encyclopedic, hugely informative, and very accessible — the fact that it took me two years to find the time to finish it is a reflection of how busy the last two years have been for me, not of the quality of the book. aside from being a fascinating and engaging read, it’s also a hugely valuable resource just as a reference, for the breadth of sources Chauncey uses, literary, legal, historical, academic, and otherwise.

also, like, I hate New York City as much as the nex
...more
Elisa Rolle
I was intrigued by this essay since recently some of my preconceptions are starting to fall down and I wanted a book that helped me to rebuild my basis. If I think to a hypothetic “modern” past (more or less pre II World War) I had the idea the gay culture was more or less “underground”, or better, completely hidden. My idea was that, if you were gay (and yes, I know at the time the word gay had a different meaning, but bear with me), you were also probably fated to be unhappily married, or comp ...more
Dan Gorman
Jul 01, 2018 rated it it was amazing
Shelves: favorites, us-history
Contender for the best work of American history from the 1990s. George Chauncey reveals how male gender expression and sexual orientation in early-twentieth-century New York were fluid categories, with a totally different language for homosexuality than we have today. After reading this book, it is impossible to claim, as some conservatives do, that homosexuality is a lifestyle choice or an invention of the mid-1900s. Chauncey's genius is to also convey how rigid gender and sexual terminology — ...more
Ai Miller
Mar 20, 2015 rated it it was amazing
A life-changing book for gay people who think they have no history. Although it focuses almost exclusively on gay men (with good reason, and Chauncey acknowledges that reason,) and only looks at New York City, Chauncey masterfully strips apart dominant narratives about the history of sexuality and explores the nuances of masculinity at the turn of the century. My primary complaint is that communities of color are not as present as they could have been; although Chauncey devotes some space to Bla ...more
Courtney
Nov 18, 2015 rated it really liked it
A dense book about a seldom covered topic, gay/fairy/trade/homosexual/what-have-you men, before the gay rights movement. Chauncey's work is well-written, and a tad long. The length of the book is warranted, and the level of detail provided is impressive---but it's still long. Luckily skipping a chapter that does not particularly interest you will not detract from your reading experience. This is because he is sure to rephrase and refer back (sometimes to previous chapters or mentioned locations ...more
Tyler
Feb 18, 2017 rated it it was amazing
Shelves: history, gay-interest
This well researched, well written, entertaining and well illustrated work does everything its title suggests, helping further establish the link between gays in the 19th century and those today. Of greatest interest is its discussions of how our modern notions of same-sex sexuality emerged from those of the past, and to whom exactly those notions applied.

Together with Strangers: Homosexual Love in the Nineteenth Century, Gay New York provides readers a much completer panorama of gay history than up to now
...more
Nicky
Oct 02, 2017 rated it it was amazing
This book made me hungry for more information. I understand why the author decided to focus on New York and men's experiences, but I really wanted to know about other locations, such as in the west, and about women's experiences. I feel like bisexuality could've been brought up a little bit more as well, but I understand the parameters that Chauncey had to work with in order to write a full narrative about a specific group of people's experiences. It was awesome, but perhaps because I study wome ...more
Kathleen
Dec 20, 2015 rated it it was amazing
"But we should never presume the absence of something before we have looked for it."
Judah
Jun 24, 2019 rated it it was amazing
A must-read for any Gay man or Ally, as it reconstructs a much forgotten chapter in Gay history. Look for the updated edition that was released back in May.
Michael Dipietro
Oct 02, 2019 rated it it was amazing
Excellent and eye opening - a fascinating read. It is very humbling as a gay man to realize the extent to which hegemony has shaped our internal conflicts as a community, across class/race/gender expression. Also, social trends and politics c. 1933 look a lot like 2019 in some startling ways... a bit scary to think about in terms of horrors that might still be in store, but good to recognize we have been here before politically.
Chris
Apr 22, 2014 rated it really liked it
One of those "everything you know is wrong" accounts that will rewrite what you think you know about the early 20th century. While gay people hardly had a walk in the part in the 1910s and 1920s, one would imagine, based on the political and social frameworks of the pre-Stonewall decades, that this would have been the worst time of all to be a member of "the third sex," as they were often called (along with "inverts," suggesting that they weren't so much men interested in men as secret women tra ...more
Joey Diamond
Jun 11, 2013 rated it it was amazing
Holy shit this book is brilliant. I had been putting off reading if for ages because I've read a fair bit of queer history and it often falls for predictable ahistorical projections and appropriations. This is nothing like that. Quite the opposite of books which tromp the old "everything gets better path", this book makes the reader feel that being a man who had sex with men in the 1920s might well have been the most exciting life ever.

Every chapter would have been revelatory to justify a book
...more
Samuel
Oct 28, 2013 rated it really liked it
I first encountered this book as an undergraduate writing my American Studies thesis on "Mormons and Marriage" and my adviser recommended this as a foundation for acquainting myself with "gay history" so that I could address Prop 8 with greater background. Although this study focuses primarily on sexuality rather than marriage, there is a chronology of legislation limiting the overt practice and congregating of gay men in the 1930s, which served as an interesting parallel to anti-polygamy legisl ...more
Oliver Bateman
Mar 29, 2013 rated it it was amazing
Shelves: favorites
Staggeringly, breathtakingly good. What happens when critical theory meets serious outside-the-box primary source scholarship? This. Want to teach your students what can actually be learned from research or how to substantiate meaningful claims or maybe even how to produce a work of such magnitude that it can't come from anywhere save that place deep inside where obsession intersects with love? This book. I'm not a scholar of sex/sexuality/gender, though I'm goodness knows I've written enough ga ...more
Just A. Bean
Jan 17, 2016 rated it it was amazing
This has been called a keystone text of queer history by... almost everyone really, and that's totally justified. It changed the narrative of how we saw ourselves, and is gorgeously researched to boot. I'm really glad I finally got around to reading it (having been using it as an actual door stopper for a few years now).

It is a bit of a door stopper. I mostly read it in twenty-page chunks, because it was so dense, and a little bit dryly written (though also often quite funny). Howeve
...more
Bill Hsu
Dec 10, 2014 rated it it was ok
A lot of fascinating material here. Unfortunately, one has to slog through sentences like this (from p. 66):

The strongest evidence that the relationship between "men" and fairies was represented symbolically as a male-female relationship and that gender behavior rather than homosexual behavior per se was the primary determinant of a man's classification as a fairy was that it enabled other men to engage in sexual activity with the fairies --- and even to express publicly a strong interest/>The
...more
Nelson Minar
Feb 12, 2013 rated it really liked it
This book is a study of gay society in New York from 1890-1940. It's a wonderful piece of social history, completely destroying the myth that there was no gay life before Stonewall. It also pursues one of my favourite themes, exploring the different ways that men express their homosexuality: "straight" men who would occasionally go out and play, gays who tried to pass, pansies who were outrageous. So much of modern gay consciousness and politics is focussed on "we are all alike", it's refreshing ...more
Marta
Nov 02, 2017 rated it it was amazing
Shelves: history, nonfiction
A few things that I appreciated about this:

- the author's adept use of municipal and state records to trace an under-documented group. Its hard to imagine the work that went into combing through these sources. I think he also has a knack for reading the sources for telling details that other people might miss

- his contextualization of gay cultures/subculture in working class and immigrant groups and neighborhoods (his discussion of the prevalence of actively gay men in It
...more
John
Oct 19, 2010 rated it it was amazing
Really fascinating, an analysis of gay culture in New York in the early part of the century, showing how much more prominent it was than we would think today. Chauncey has all kinds of interesting sources, and really does a great job of arguing his thesis that the 'closet' that gay culture came out of in the 70s was created by society in the 30s and 40s as a crackdown on a visible, vibrant gay culture that existed in the 20s and early 30s. Basically he's saying that societal views of sexuality h ...more
Jim
Jul 03, 2013 rated it really liked it
This is a real history book with an 80-page source notes section! It’s a fascinating look at how and why what we know today as gay urban culture came together. In writing about gay people in the fictional present, knowing our past and how that forms us is a crucial exercise in back story. Until I read this book, I never knew how recent (big picture-wise) a recognizable “gay community” was. This book covers a ton of topics, including looking at the police repression of gay men and lesbians and ho ...more
Marti
Feb 07, 2018 rated it really liked it
This book took me months to read, but it was so worth it. I learned a ton. The research that Chauncey did to write this book is fantastic. The footnotes are beautiful things and take up a huge part of the page count. It's the kind of book you read with your finger stuck in the footnotes.

I dropped it to four stars because I did think that it was occasionally repetitive, although if you were looking to use chapters of this book for teaching a class, that would probably work in your ben
...more
Andrea Hickman Walker
I enjoyed this. I don't understand why people feel the need to police other people's sex lives (except in the cases of children, animals and non-consenting adults), so I found a lot of the material in this quite alien. I gather, however, that there are many people who still believe that they have the right to dictate how other people live. In that respect I found this quite an intriguing historical study, showing that things have not always been the same and that the supposed traditions and hist ...more
Shawn Thrasher
Feb 11, 2013 rated it liked it
I totally recognize this as a great piece of scholarship, in depth, well researched. But for me personally, it was a bit too scholarly, and I lost interest about half way through. I wish I could take some sort of seminar or class, with this as the text book. Or a documentary. Or better yet, a movie version (sort of like Mean Girls was"based" on a book about girl bullies). I guess I needed some sort of love story through the ages sort of "hook" which wasn't happening - everything was too impersonal an ...more
« previous 1 3 4 next »
There are no discussion topics on this book yet. Be the first to start one »

Readers also enjoyed

  • Odd Girls and Twilight Lovers: A History of Lesbian Life in Twentieth-Century America
  • Coming Out Under Fire: The History of Gay Men and Women in World War Two
  • The Straight State: Sexuality and Citizenship in Twentieth-Century America
  • Homeward Bound: American Families In The Cold War Era
  • Boots of Leather, Slippers of Gold: The History of a Lesbian Community
  • Transgender History
  • The Origins of the Urban Crisis: Race and Inequality in Postwar Detroit
  • The Gay Metropolis: The Landmark History of Gay Life in America since World War II
  • Secret Historian: The Life and Times of Samuel Steward, Professor, Tattoo Artist, and Sexual Renegade
  • Good Wives, Nasty Wenches, and Anxious Patriarchs: Gender, Race, and Power in Colonial Virginia
  • Stonewall
  • Lies Across America: What Our Historic Sites Get Wrong
  • Stone Butch Blues
  • The Lavender Scare: The Cold War Persecution of Gays and Lesbians in the Federal Government
  • Unapologetic: A Black, Queer, and Feminist Mandate for Radical Movements
  • Trans Liberation: Beyond Pink or Blue
  • Impossible Subjects: Illegal Aliens and the Making of Modern America
  • Manliness and Civilization: A Cultural History of Gender and Race in the United States, 1880-1917
See similar books…
God made them, wrote one man who said his son was homosexual. They did not choose their status. ... It is not a medical matter. ... You know there are quite as many people among them as among your so called 'normal.' ... Let your campagin remove the penal laws which make these 'diseased' people a prey for mackmailers. Give them recognition and let them live their lives.' 2 likes
“Most gay men did not speak out against anti-gay policing so openly, but to take this as evidence that they had internalized anti-gay attitudes is to ignore the strength of the forces arrayed against them, to misinterpret silence as acquiescence, and to construe resistance in the narrowest of terms - as the organization of formal political groups and petitions.” 1 likes
More quotes…